Verdict: A 692-page award-winning pirate fantasy that most readers call well paced and never boring, and a vocal minority calls a stroll — the split is entirely about whether you want this much book.
Best for: Readers who loved Pirates of Aletharia, who want character growth given room to happen, and who are happy for a fantasy romance to be genuinely long.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — romance.io rates it explicit open door)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.3/5 — a 4.43 Goodreads average and a Golden Crown Literary Award, against a real minority objection to the pacing)
Tropes: Pirates, dragons, established couple, revenge, found family, sea voyage, sirens, magic-wielding surgeon, sequel romance, epic length.
Goddess of the Sea is book two of Britney Jackson’s Lesbians, Pirates, and Dragons series, a self-published sapphic fantasy romance published in autumn 2024 and a 2025 Golden Crown Literary Award winner, continuing the story of dragon sorcerer Emilia Drakon and Captain Maria Welles after the events of Pirates of Aletharia.
It holds a 4.43 average across 1,101 Goodreads ratings and 139 written reviews, against 4.7 across roughly 618 Amazon ratings. Those are strong numbers and the award is real, but the written reviews contain one of the sharpest disagreements we have seen on a well-rated book, and it is not about the romance or the characters. It is about 692 pages. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.
What Is Goddess of the Sea About?
Sequels to enemies-to-lovers books have a structural problem: the engine that drove book one is spent. Jackson’s answer is to shift from antagonism to partnership and put the pressure outside the relationship — Maria wants her enemies to bleed, Emilia has her own reasons for being on this ship, and the sea supplies the rest. That means this reads as an adventure novel with an established couple at its centre rather than a courtship.
It is also considerably longer than book one, and that length is spent on character growth rather than plot complication. Readers who like the book say so directly: fantastic character growth from both Emilia and Maria is the phrasing, and it comes with the claim that the pacing supports it. Readers who dislike the book are describing the same pages and reaching the opposite conclusion.
What Makes This Sapphic Pirate Fantasy Work
- Character growth with room to happen: Named as the standout by readers who rate it highly, and specifically credited to both leads rather than one.
- A Goldie in its own right: The 2025 Golden Crown Literary Award win follows book one’s, which makes this a two-award series rather than a one-off.
- Established-couple romance: Rarer than it should be. The tension comes from the world rather than from whether they will get together.
- The sea: Sirens, voyages and dragons give a long book somewhere to go, and the setting is the reason readers forgive the length.
- Continuity: Readers who came from book one report the world holding together and the payoffs landing where they were set up.
Book Synopsis
Maria Welles is a pirate captain with a list. What she wants, stated plainly, is to see her enemies bleed — and if she also wants safety for her crew, that is a captain’s obligation rather than a softening. She is not a woman in the process of being redeemed by love, which is a refreshing place for a sequel to start.
Emilia Drakon is a dragon sorcerer, a fugitive, and by this point in the series something more complicated than either. The relationship between the two of them survived book one; what it has to survive now is everything that comes after a story ends — the practical business of two dangerous people sharing a ship, a war, and a set of obligations neither of them can put down.
The sea has its own opinions. Sirens, dragons and the political consequences of the first book’s events all press in, and the crew is a found family with a captain who would burn a great deal to protect it. Across 692 pages the question is not whether Emilia and Maria stay together. It is what the two of them are willing to become in order to survive what is coming, and whether the people around them survive it too.
My Review
The most valuable thing this book does is write an established couple properly. Romance as a genre is built around the getting-together, and sequels usually either invent a contrived rift or reduce the couple to background while a new pairing takes the foreground. Jackson does neither. Emilia and Maria are together, they stay together, and the book finds its tension in what two people who have chosen each other then have to survive. Readers respond to it as character growth, and they credit both women rather than one, which is the sign it is working.
The award matters here too, and not as decoration. Book one won a Golden Crown Literary Award and this one won its own in 2025. Two Goldies across two books is a genuine external signal in a category where external signals are almost entirely absent — nearly every other title on our Kindle Unlimited list has no juried recognition of any kind.
The complaint is length, and it is worth quoting because the disagreement is unusually direct. One reviewer says the pacing was terrible, the dialogue juvenile and boring, and that what should have been a journey is instead a stroll because the leads keep getting distracted by how attractive they find each other — complete with a jab about a favourite tree that turns out not to matter. Against that, a reviewer of the same book says it is paced well and that they were never bored, even in the slower moments. Both of those are honest reports. What separates them is whether you consider 692 pages of two people being in love while things happen around them to be the point or the problem.
The expectation to reset is about what a sequel owes you. If you arrived from Pirates of Aletharia wanting the same enemies-to-lovers charge, calibrate: that engine is spent by design and what replaces it is slower and warmer. If the first book’s length worried you, this one is longer — 692 pages against a book that was already substantial.
My honest note: An award-winning sequel that does the hard thing and writes a couple staying together. If you want an adventure with people you already love, this is a lot of it. If you want propulsion, the minority report is not wrong.
| Element | In Goddess of the Sea |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Emilia Drakon & Captain Maria Welles — dragon sorcerer and pirate captain, now established |
| Core tropes | Pirates, dragons, established couple, revenge, found family, sea voyage, sirens |
| Setting | The seas of Aletharia, after the events of book one, with sirens and dragons in the water |
| Heat level | 4/5 — explicit open door, per romance.io |
| Series | Lesbians, Pirates, and Dragons book 2 — read book one first; both won Golden Crown Literary Awards |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content, graphic violence, revenge and killing, peril at sea, references to past trauma |
How Spicy Is Goddess of the Sea?
A 4/5. romance.io files it as explicit open door, which fits a 692-page adventure novel — the scenes are present and unambiguous but they are not the structure. One of the critical reviews complains that the leads get distracted by how attractive they find each other, which is a backhanded confirmation that the romance is very much on the page.
Nothing in the reviews requires advance warning beyond the general violence of a pirate novel. For the same band with a faster plot, The Rogue Crown by A.K. Mulford is the closer fit, and Woodborn by Heather Nix runs a comparable seafaring found-family structure at a similar explicitness.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you read book one and want more of these two, you like established-couple romance, you want character growth given actual space, and 692 pages sounds like value rather than a warning.
You may want to skip it if: you need a plot that keeps moving, you came for enemies-to-lovers tension and want it sustained, dialogue that leans warm and playful grates on you, or you have not read Pirates of Aletharia.
In short: an award-winning sequel that trades tension for warmth and length, and knows it.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)
This is one of only two books on our Kindle Unlimited list with juried recognition attached — it won a 2025 Golden Crown Literary Award, and its predecessor won one before it. That is the discovery mechanism here as much as anything: the Goldies carry weight in sapphic fiction circles in a way no algorithm does, and they bring readers who would not otherwise browse indie fantasy. Beyond that, the profile is familiar — no trade reviews, no Reddit footprint, no audiobook edition on Libro.fm, and 1,101 Goodreads ratings accumulated steadily since autumn 2024 through Kindle Unlimited and series word of mouth.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Character growth, first and most specifically. The phrasing that recurs is fantastic character growth from both Emilia and Maria — both, not one, which matters in a sequel where the easy option is to develop one lead and park the other. Second, the pacing, which the majority defend explicitly: paced well, never bored, even in the slower moments. That is a reader pre-empting the complaint they know exists. Third, the sea itself — sirens, dragons and voyage structure give the length somewhere to go. And fourth, the award, which reviewers mention as confirmation rather than as news.
What readers argue about and complain about: Pacing, and the disagreement is unusually blunt. The sharpest negative review says the pacing was terrible and the dialogue juvenile and boring, and lands the specific charge that what should be a journey is a stroll because the leads keep getting distracted by finding each other attractive — with a jab about a favourite tree that turns out not to matter to anything. That is a legitimate reading of a 692-page book about an established couple. Second, length in itself: this is longer than book one and book one was not short. Third, and much quieter, expectation — readers who came for the enemies-to-lovers charge of Pirates of Aletharia find that engine deliberately retired. The genuine split is not about quality. Two reviewers describe the same chapters as never boring and as a stroll, and both are telling the truth about their own experience. What decides it is whether you want to spend 692 pages with a couple who have already chosen each other.
The series question everyone should ask first: Do not start here. This is book two and it continues a specific couple’s story rather than starting a new one, so Pirates of Aletharia comes first — it is also on Kindle Unlimited, so the only cost is a borrow slot. Worth knowing before you commit: book one holds a higher Goodreads average than this one, and it is the tighter book. If you read book one and wanted more of the world, this delivers a great deal of it. If you read book one and thought it was slightly long, this is not the sequel for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to read Pirates of Aletharia first?
Yes. Goddess of the Sea continues Emilia and Maria’s story rather than starting a new one, and the payoffs assume book one. Both are on Kindle Unlimited, so reading in order costs nothing but a borrow slot.
How long is Goddess of the Sea?
692 pages, which makes it the longest book on our Kindle Unlimited list. Length is the main thing readers disagree about — the majority say it is well paced, a vocal minority calls it a stroll.
How spicy is Goddess of the Sea?
A 4/5. romance.io rates it explicit open door. The scenes are on the page but this is an adventure novel first, and the explicit content is a component rather than the structure.
Did Goddess of the Sea win an award?
Yes. It won a Golden Crown Literary Award in 2025, following the Goldie won by Pirates of Aletharia. Two juried awards across two books is unusual for a self-published series.
Is Goddess of the Sea an enemies-to-lovers romance?
No. That engine belongs to book one. Emilia and Maria are an established couple here, and the tension comes from the world around them rather than from the relationship.
Is Goddess of the Sea on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes, as is Pirates of Aletharia. It carried the Kindle Unlimited badge on its Amazon listing when we checked in August 2026. Availability changes without notice, so confirm the badge before you borrow.
If You Loved Goddess of the Sea, Read These Next
Three land closest. Pirates of Aletharia is the obvious one and should come first — same couple, tighter book, its own Goldie. Woodborn by Heather Nix runs the same seafaring found-family structure with fated mates and a duet arc. And Of Tides and Snow by Darva Green pairs a pirate captain with a fairytale retelling at a higher heat and half the length. For more in the same band, browse our sapphic romantasy on Kindle Unlimited guide or the full run of book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Goddess of the Sea does the thing sequels usually avoid: it keeps its couple together and finds the story in what they survive next. The character growth is real and credited to both women, the sea setting earns its scale, and a second Golden Crown Literary Award is external validation almost nothing else on our Kindle Unlimited list can claim. Against that: it is 692 pages, the enemies-to-lovers charge that powered book one is deliberately gone, and a minority of readers find the result a stroll rather than a voyage. Worth borrowing if you read book one and want to stay in this world. Check Goddess of the Sea on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Goddess of the Sea ranks as an award-winning sapphic adventure sequel — warm, spacious and genuinely well grown, held back by a length not every reader wants, and best approached as more time with a couple you already love rather than as a new story.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ 4.43 average across 1,101 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4.7 on Amazon across roughly 618 ratings
- ✓ 2025 Golden Crown Literary Award winner
- ✓ Pacing objection is real and specific
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Established couple written as an actual couple
- ✓ Tension moved outside the relationship
- ✓ Both leads develop rather than one
- ✓ Enemies-to-lovers charge deliberately retired
Characters ★★★★☆ 4.4/5
- ✓ Growth credited to Emilia and Maria equally
- ✓ Maria stays hard rather than being softened
- ✓ Crew functions as a real found family
- ✓ Cast assumes book one for full effect
Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Two Goldies across two books
- ✓ Sea setting sustains 692 pages for most readers
- ✓ Majority defend the pacing explicitly
- ✓ Dialogue called juvenile in the sharpest review
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Revenge motive gives Maria a real drive
- ✓ Found-family stakes carry the middle
- ✓ Payoffs land where book one set them up
- ✓ Low jeopardy for the couple themselves
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ romance.io explicit open door band
- ✓ Romance visibly on the page throughout
- ✓ Critics note the leads’ mutual distraction
- ✓ Lower volume than top-band KU titles
Ending ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Resolves its arc without a cliffhanger
- ✓ Series continues from a stable point
- ✓ Complete story in a single borrow
- ✓ Requires book one to land properly
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ 692 pages of world to return to
- ✓ Kindle Unlimited makes re-borrowing free
- ✓ Award pedigree draws repeat readers
- ✓ No audio edition on Libro.fm for a second format
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
