Some love stories you close and move on from. This is not one of them. MATELDA lingers — in its silences, its grief, and the ache of two women learning to stay. This guide is built to help you sit with it: to notice what the book is doing under its surface, and to spark the kind of conversation that lasts longer than the last page.
The first sections are safe to read before you finish. The discussion questions are split into a spoiler-light set and a clearly marked spoiler set — so you can bring the guide to a book club at any stage.
Major themes
Silence & forgiveness
The title says it: in silence we forgive. Nearly every character in this book communicates most in the things they do not say. Matelda weaponises silence; Mia can’t stand it; Sam was destroyed by three years of it. The novel asks whether silence is a wall or a language — and whether forgiveness can be spoken at all.
Grief & inheritance
Mia comes home to bury a father and inherit an empire in the same breath. The book sits in the uncomfortable place where mourning and duty collide, and asks what we owe the dead — and what they had no right to leave us.
Love against duty
“Keep her alive, whatever it costs you.” The central romance grows inside an order, which means every tender moment is also a breach of duty. The tension between what these women are supposed to do and what they feel is the engine of the whole slow burn.
Found family vs. broken family
The Salvatores are blood, and they are fracturing. Sam is family by love and was cut off. Matelda is family by nothing and becomes essential. The book keeps asking which bonds are real: the ones we’re born into, or the ones we choose to stay for.
Symbols & motifs to watch
Jasmine & amber
Matelda’s scent arrives before she does — sweetness laid over something darker. Notice when the jasmine is comforting and when it feels like a warning.
The fountain
The still centre of a house in lockdown. Water that keeps moving while everyone else holds their breath — and the place where the story’s calm finally shatters.
The letter
Gabriel’s words outlive him and reach farther than any order. Watch how a single page reshapes what every character believes they are allowed to feel.
Walls & gates
Protection and imprisonment are the same architecture here. The villa keeps danger out and keeps the characters in — with each other.
“Be afraid. Be afraid — and stay anyway.”
A line worth bringing to the table
Discussion questions
Spoiler-light — safe to discuss at any point in your read.
- The book opens with Mia returning to a home she fought to escape. What makes a place feel like home when you no longer want to belong to it?
- Matelda communicates as much through silence as through speech. Where in your own life is silence a form of care — and where is it a form of control?
- Mia and Sam grew up like sisters and lost three years to silence. What does it take to rebuild a friendship after that kind of distance?
- The Salvatore family kept peace by being loved rather than feared. Is that a strength or a fatal weakness? Can you have both?
- Grief and duty arrive together for Mia. Have you ever had to make big decisions while mourning — and how did one shape the other?
- The age gap and the power imbalance between Mia and Matelda are part of the tension. What makes that dynamic compelling rather than uncomfortable here?
- Everyone in the villa is performing a role. Who do you think is the most honest character — and who is the most hidden?
Haven’t met the Salvatores yet? Every question above is waiting for you inside.
Read MATELDA on Amazon ›Part of the MATELDA universe
Return to the MATELDA: In Silence We Forgive book hub to explore the characters, themes, timeline and reading guide.
Explore more of the world: The Salvatore Dynasty · Family Timeline · Characters
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.