MATELDA: In Silence We Forgive Review | Jossef S. | Is It Worth Reading?

An ice-cold survivor and the grieving heir who hates her — trapped together in a crumbling mafia empire where every silence is a weapon and desire is the deadliest liability of all.

If you love enemies-to-lovers tension, dangerous age-gap dynamics, and atmospheric slow burns where love is a liability, MATELDA: In Silence We Forgive by Jossef S. belongs on your shelf. It pairs forty-year-old Matelda — a woman who survived eighteen years of a monster by turning silence into armor — with twenty-four-year-old Mia Salvatore, who returns from exile to run her dead father’s empire and finds herself locked down with the one person she swore to destroy.

Our take: This is a moody, literary mafia romance that trades on tension and atmosphere rather than pace. Readers praise the layered characters, cinematic writing, and genuinely earned slow burn; the honest caveats are a deliberate, unhurried tempo and heavy, dark themes that won’t suit everyone.

The Evidence Scorecard

Here’s what real readers across Amazon and Goodreads consistently say about MATELDA — the praise and the honest criticism, sourced from reader reviews.

★★★★½ Writing & Voice

Evidence:

• ✓ Reviewers repeatedly call the prose “beautifully written,” “moody,” and “almost cinematic” — atmosphere is the book’s signature strength.
• ✓ Readers praise the “layers upon layers of intricate descriptions” that chronicle the action in vivid color.
• ✓ The literary, sensory style (jasmine, spring rain, marble villas) gives the mafia world a distinctive, immersive texture.
• ✓ A minority find the dense, descriptive style slower going than a typical genre romance.

★★★★½ Dialogue & Banter

Evidence:

• ✓ Readers say “the dialogue feels so realistic,” grounding the high-stakes world in believable exchanges.
• ✓ The tension “lives in the pauses” — much of the power is in what the two women withhold from each other.
• ✓ Lines like “be afraid and stay anyway” are quoted by readers as emotional high points.
• ✓ Those wanting light, playful banter should note this is charged restraint, not quippy repartee.

★★★★½ Chemistry & Romance

Evidence:

• ✓ The enemies-to-lovers arc is praised as a true “dark-to-light progression” where resentment slowly fractures into fierce devotion.
• ✓ Readers loved the “hallway collision” tension — every glance becomes a dangerous, loaded dance.
• ✓ The power imbalance (survivor vs. heir) makes the pull between Mia and Matelda feel genuinely combustible.
• ✓ A few readers wished for a more explicit reconciliation beat; the transformation is quiet rather than confrontational.

★★★★☆ Heat

Evidence:

• ✓ Billed as an agonizing slow burn — the physical tension builds to “unbearable” before it ignites.
• ✓ Reviewers call the intimacy “engaging and sexy,” high-voltage but never gratuitous.
• ✓ The heat is inseparable from the danger, which readers found heightened the spice.
• ✓ Readers wanting instant or frequent explicit scenes should know the burn is deliberately delayed.

★★★★½ Emotion & Depth

Evidence:

• ✓ Readers describe it as “emotional and deeply moving,” exploring identity, trauma, and forgiveness with real sensitivity.
• ✓ The theme of loving “the daughter without betraying the ghost of the father” gives the conflict genuine moral weight.
• ✓ Many felt “completely hooked,” thinking about the characters long after finishing.
• ✓ The heavy emotional and trauma content is immersive but demanding — not a light read.

★★★★☆ Pacing

Evidence:

• ✓ Readers say the story “moves at a good pace and is easy to follow” despite its literary density.
• ✓ The mafia stakes — shifting alliances, territory wars, a near-fatal ambush — keep suspense high alongside the romance.
• ✓ The slow burn is praised for not rushing; the payoff hits harder because the cost is felt.
• ✓ At 436 pages with an atmospheric style, some readers found stretches that ask for patience.

★★★★½ Ending

Evidence:

• ✓ The book delivers a guaranteed HEA that readers found beautiful and romantic — “they kiss for the first time” after a life-saving sacrifice.
• ✓ Reviewers praise “twists you won’t see coming” that pay off the buildup.
• ✓ The resolution feels earned given everything the two women survive.
• ✓ Several readers ended wanting more of this world — hungry for a sequel rather than dissatisfied.

★★★★☆ Re-read & Comfort Value

Evidence:

• ✓ Readers call it “a refreshing read” that stood out from the usual sapphic offerings — memorable enough to revisit.
• ✓ The layered prose rewards a second read, where earlier silences take on new meaning.
• ✓ Fans of the leads (“I love Mia and Matelda so much”) return for the characters.
• ✓ Its dark, heavy themes make it a more intense than cozy comfort re-read.

Quick Facts

Author	Jossef S.
Published	March 23, 2026
Length	436 pages
Tropes	Enemies to lovers, age gap, forced proximity, slow burn, mafia
Heat level	High (slow-burn build)
Standalone?	Yes — standalone with a guaranteed HEA
HEA?	Yes — earned happy ending

You’ll Love This If…

• ✓ You crave enemies-to-lovers tension that smolders across an entire book.
• ✓ Dangerous age-gap dynamics between two powerful women are your catnip.
• ✓ You want a moody, literary, cinematic take on mafia romance.
• ✓ You love a survivor heroine whose silence is her armor.
• ✓ You need real stakes — where love is a genuine liability.

Avoid If…

• You want a fast, plot-driven read — this is slow and atmospheric by design.
• You’re sensitive to organized-crime violence and heavy emotional trauma.
• Large age gaps in romance aren’t for you (Matelda 40 / Mia 24).
• You prefer overt declarations to restrained, silence-heavy tension.

Book Synopsis

Mia Salvatore never wanted to return to the sun-drenched villa of her childhood. Three years of self-imposed exile — driven by pride and a burning hatred for her father’s beautiful, untouchable companion — end abruptly when Gabriel Salvatore dies. Mia comes home to step into his role as the Architect of a crumbling criminal empire, only to find herself trapped in a high-stakes security lockdown with her ultimate enemy: Matelda.

Matelda is marble and stillness, a woman who survived eighteen years under a monster by weaponizing silence. She never expected the fierce, grieving daughter to breach her defenses. As a high-voltage attraction ignites amid spring rain and jasmine, every hallway collision becomes a dangerous dance where exposure is a death sentence. In an underworld tearing itself apart, the two women must face an impossible question: can you love the daughter without betraying the ghost of the father?

My Review

What sets MATELDA apart from the crowded sapphic-romance field is atmosphere. Jossef S. writes the mafia villa like a character in its own right — marble and jasmine, spring rain and locked doors — and the result is a book you inhabit rather than simply read. The tension doesn’t come from gunfire (though there is danger); it comes from two women sharing rooms they can’t leave, saying almost nothing, and feeling everything.

The central pairing is the draw. Matelda’s silence-as-armor and Mia’s grief-fueled fury make for a genuinely combustible enemies-to-lovers dynamic, and the age gap — Matelda at forty, Mia at twenty-four — adds a layer of power and vulnerability that the story takes seriously rather than treating as titillation. Readers consistently single out how “layered” and “complicated” both women feel, and I agree: their slow thaw is the best thing here.

My honest caveats mirror the reader consensus. The prose is dense and unhurried, so if you want a brisk, plot-forward romance, this deliberate literary pace may test your patience. And the themes are heavy — organized crime, stylized violence, inherited trauma — so it’s an intense rather than cozy read. Go in expecting a moody slow burn, not a light one.

But the payoff earns its buildup. When the walls finally come down — after a life-or-death sacrifice that several readers called unforgettable — the HEA lands with real weight because you’ve felt the cost of every step toward it. It’s a confident, distinctive debut-series opener that leaves you wanting the next book.

Romance Profile

Pairing	Matelda (survivor, 40) × Mia Salvatore (grieving heir, 24)
Central trope	Enemies to lovers + age gap + forced proximity (mafia)
Burn speed	Agonizing slow burn
Heat	High — high-voltage and dangerous
Conflict	Grief, inherited power, survival, and forbidden desire

Emotional Profile

• ✓ The slow dismantling of walls two women built to survive.
• ✓ Grief tangled with forbidden, dangerous desire.
• ✓ The ache of longing held in silence and stolen glances.
• ✓ Hard-won catharsis when love finally outweighs fear.

Content Warnings

• Organized crime and stylized violence (including a shooting).
• Grief, loss of a parent, and inherited trauma.
• Large age-gap relationship (40 / 24).
• Heavy emotional themes; on-page intimacy (slow-burn, high heat).

Book DNA

Vibe	Moody, literary, cinematic, dangerous
Setting	A sun-drenched Italian mafia villa in lockdown
Pace	Slow burn with high-suspense stakes
Comps	Dark sapphic mafia romance; literary age-gap WLW fiction
Best for	Readers who want atmosphere, real stakes, and a hard-won HEA

Similar Books You Might Enjoy

• A Game of Romance and Ruin by Ruby Roe — for readers who love a dangerous, high-stakes sapphic slow burn.
• The Runway Affair by C.L. Smoke — high-tension enemies-adjacent workplace romance.
• Baggage by Cass Morgan — emotionally heavy contemporary sapphic romance.
• The Anchor by Tessa Vidal — an ice-queen, forced-proximity slow burn.
• More sapphic slow-burn picks — our full curated guide.

For more like this, browse our full guide to Sapphic Second Chance Romance Books, and if the age-gap dynamic drew you in, don’t miss our Age-Gap Lesbian Romance roundup.

About the Author

Jossef S. is a distinctive voice in atmospheric sapphic fiction, specializing in stories where the intensity of the landscape matches the complexity of the heart. Known for lyrical prose, forbidden longing, ice-queen archetypes, and age-gap, enemies-to-lovers arcs, Jossef explores “the space between” — the silences that hold more weight than words. MATELDA opens the Matelda series.

Read more Jossef S. reviews →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is MATELDA: In Silence We Forgive a standalone?

Yes. It’s a standalone sapphic romance with a guaranteed HEA, and it opens the Matelda series.

Does MATELDA have a happy ending?

Yes. Despite the dark, high-stakes world, the book delivers a guaranteed, earned happy ever after.

How steamy is MATELDA?

It’s a high-heat slow burn. The physical tension builds to “unbearable” before igniting; intimacy is charged but never gratuitous.

What tropes does MATELDA include?

Enemies to lovers, age gap, forced proximity, slow burn, and mafia romance — all set in a criminal underworld.

How big is the age gap?

Significant — Matelda is forty and Mia is twenty-four, a roughly sixteen-year gap that the story treats with real depth.

Is MATELDA more romance or more mafia thriller?

It’s a romance at its core, but the mafia setting provides genuine suspense, danger, and stakes throughout.

Is there a lot of violence?

There is stylized organized-crime violence, including a shooting, plus heavy emotional and trauma themes.

Who will enjoy MATELDA the most?

Readers who love moody, literary, atmospheric sapphic romance with enemies-to-lovers tension and real stakes.

Final Verdict

MATELDA: In Silence We Forgive is a moody, literary sapphic mafia romance that turns silence into its sharpest weapon. The enemies-to-lovers slow burn between Matelda and Mia is layered and combustible, the atmosphere is cinematic, and the hard-won HEA lands with real weight — though the deliberate pace and heavy themes ask for patience. A distinctive, immersive series opener for readers who want their romance dangerous. 4.4 / 5.

Where to Buy

Buy MATELDA on Amazon

Note: This is a plain, non-affiliate link — we don’t earn a commission from your purchase.