How this list works: these are the lesbian romances readers love most, chosen by popularity on Goodreads, with one line on why each is a must-read and a link to our full review. Looking for our own critics’ ranking with covers, tropes, heat levels and content notes? See the best lesbian romance novels, ranked by our reviews. For the wider sapphic umbrella, see our best sapphic romance books.
These are the 20 most popular lesbian romance books with readers: every one has at least 1,000 Goodreads ratings and an average of 4.18 or higher, which makes them some of the most popular lesbian romance books in the genre. Every heroine is a lesbian, with no awakening arc and no bisexual lead, every story ends happily, and every book has a full review on this site.
How We Picked These Popular Lesbian Romance Books
- Lesbian heroines. Presented as lesbian romance, with no awakening or bisexual heroine. Books under the wider sapphic umbrella are on our sapphic list.
- Romance first, with a central love story and a romantic ending.
- Loved by a lot of readers. At least 1,000 Goodreads ratings, ordered by the average recorded in our review.
- Reviewed in full — the title links to our review.
The 20 Most Popular Lesbian Romance Books
- The Clinch by Nicole Disney — the sports romance where the sport is written as well as the love story: two MMA fighters contracted to fight each other, and an award-winning rivals-to-lovers. (Goodreads 4.43 from 1,475 ratings.)
- Finding Jessica Lambert by Clare Ashton — one of the most acclaimed celebrity romances in lesbian fiction, praised for how tenderly it handles panic attacks and hiding from the world. (Goodreads 4.35 from 3,228 ratings.)
- The Lure of White Oak Lake by Robin Alexander — the comfort read: a lake town full of meddling matchmakers and readers who call it a laugh-out-loud mood lifter. (Goodreads 4.35 from 1,157 ratings.)
- Breaking Character by Lee Winter — the most-recommended Lee Winter romance, with generous characterisation and a closet plot that is never used as a weapon. (Goodreads 4.33 from 10,500 ratings.)
- Coming Home by KJ — a feel-good celebrity romance in Melbourne, loved for its schoolteacher heroine, the child at its centre and its found family. (Goodreads 4.33 from 1,571 ratings.)
- Then & Now by Monica McCallan — a dual-timeline second chance with two of the best-liked leads in the subgenre. (Goodreads 4.30 from 3,270 ratings.)
- Falls From Grace by Ruby Landers — a Goldie-winning debut about a Nashville star in a Vermont winter; readers single out the tension and dialogue. (Goodreads 4.29 from 6,621 ratings.)
- Spindrift by Anna Burke — a warm, funny and genuinely hot butch/femme romance, with a butch-bottom dynamic you rarely see. (Goodreads 4.29 from 1,554 ratings.)
- Hearts in Motion by Miranda MacLeod — two aunts fighting for custody of their nephew: an age-gap romance whose humour carries real grief. (Goodreads 4.29 from 1,300 ratings.)
- Just a Touch Away by Jae — Jae at her most comforting: a 92-day inheritance clause and a long, satisfying ice-queen thaw. (Goodreads 4.28 from 2,265 ratings.)
- Unadulterated Something by MJ Duncan — retired hockey captains from rival countries, and one of the warmest low-angst slow burns in the genre. (Goodreads 4.28 from 1,680 ratings.)
- Who’d Have Thought by G Benson — a Goldie-winning marriage of convenience with one of the best slow burns in sapphic fiction. (Goodreads 4.27 from 6,732 ratings.)
- Just Physical by Jae — a steamier-than-usual Jae romance, praised for its deeply researched multiple sclerosis representation. (Goodreads 4.27 from 2,062 ratings.)
- Thrust by Rachel Spangler — Olympic fencing made thrilling, and ranked by her fans among her best sports books. (Goodreads 4.27 from 1,153 ratings.)
- Tempting Olivia by Clare Ashton — a perfectionist Oxford lawyer and the film star she has always adored: a tender, funny ice-queen slow burn. (Goodreads 4.26 from 5,700 ratings.)
- Sparks Like Ours by Melissa Brayden — sunny, sexy rivals to lovers on the surf circuit, and for many readers the best of the Seven Shores series. (Goodreads 4.24 from 1,903 ratings.)
- Purposefully Accidental by G Benson — a film star in the emergency room of the camp rival she humiliated as a child: funny, tender and low in angst. (Goodreads 4.20 from 4,075 ratings.)
- The Killing Room by Gerri Hill — for readers who want suspense: a serial-killer investigation with a hot cop-and-therapist romance at its heart. (Goodreads 4.20 from 2,076 ratings.)
- Requiem for Immortals by Lee Winter — the darkest pick: a cold, elegant assassin thriller with some of the most praised prose in lesbian fiction. (Goodreads 4.18 from 5,029 ratings.)
- Temptation by Kris Bryant — a light, steamy age-gap nanny romance that readers love for its heroine, the little boy she looks after and the heat. (Goodreads 4.18 from 2,624 ratings.)
Want More?
- Best lesbian romance novels, ranked by our reviews — our critics’ ranking with covers, heat levels and content notes.
- Best sapphic romance books — full entries across the whole umbrella.
- Best lesbian romance across books, film, TV, manga and more.
- Lesbian romance on Kindle Unlimited, verified.
- By trope: enemies to lovers, second chance, friends to lovers, forced proximity.
Ratings are as recorded in each linked review and may have moved since. This post contains links to our reviews; as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
6 thoughts on “The 20 Most Popular Lesbian Romance Books, Loved by Readers”