Verdict: A tender, unusually deep celebrity age-gap romance about two anxious women hiding in a London rooftop flat, held back only by a slow first third and a long separation stretch that tests some readers’ patience.
Best for: Readers who want character-driven romance with real interiority, who don’t mind a measured pace, and who like their love stories to take anxiety and fame seriously.
Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5: open door, moderate and woven into the emotional arc)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.3/5: a 4.35 Goodreads average across 3,237 ratings, a 4% StoryGraph DNF rate and a Goldie win, with a pacing complaint that keeps coming back)
Tropes: Celebrity and non-famous, age gap, hurt/comfort, hiding from the world, secret identity, opposites attract, found sanctuary, slow burn, toxic family, second act separation.
Finding Jessica Lambert by Clare Ashton is a self-published standalone contemporary lesbian romance from 2020, set almost entirely in London, in which 24-year-old movie star Jess Lambert bolts from a crowd mid-panic attack and lands in the care of Anna Mayhew, a 39-year-old who has spent five years making her world as small and quiet as possible, and who has no idea who Jess is.
It holds a 4.35 average across 3,237 Goodreads ratings, with 83% of them at four or five stars, and it won the 2021 Golden Crown Literary Society award (the Goldie) for long contemporary romance. It also sits at #3 on our ranked list of the best lesbian romance books. The praise is loud and specific, but so is a smaller group of readers who found the same book slow and frustrating. Both reactions make sense once you know what kind of book this is.
What Is Finding Jessica Lambert About?
This is an age-gap lesbian romance with a celebrity premise, but it reads closer to a quiet, interior novel than a glossy Hollywood rom-com. Readers keep calling it a sapphic Notting Hill, and the setup earns that: a famous woman, an ordinary flat, a person who doesn’t recognise her. What it actually does with that setup is slower and more inward. Most of the first half happens in one place, Anna’s rooftop flat, and the drama is mostly in the two women’s heads.
Jess has everything the job is supposed to give you and is running out of whatever lets her cope with it. She’s warm, funny and kind, and she’s also exhausted, overwhelmed by crowds and fans and close to burning out. Anna, on the other side, has decided the safest life is a tiny, ordered one: her work, one close friend, no surprises. The book moves between both women’s points of view, which matters, because each of them is keeping something back, and you know more than either of them does for a lot of the book.
What Makes This Celebrity Age-Gap Lesbian Romance Work
- The characters: On StoryGraph, 93% of readers say the book has strong character development and 87% call the leads loveable. On Goodreads, readers praise both women’s introspection and say they feel like real, complicated people.
- The anxiety writing: The panic attacks and the way both women manage fear come up again and again in reviews, often from readers who say they recognised themselves. Amazon’s review summary singles out the portrayal of anxiety too.
- A different kind of romance structure: The two get together relatively early, so the tension isn’t really “will they” but “can this last once the truth is out.” Several reviewers name that as what kept the celebrity romance formula feeling fresh.
- Humour in a heavy book: For all the darker material, readers keep mentioning how funny it is. Anna’s best friend Penny gets a lot of the credit, and so does an early back and forth where the two women try to work out whether the other one is queer.
- Two families as mirrors: Jess’s family is loud and loving, Anna’s mother is cold and bigoted. Readers singled out the way Anna finally stands up to her mother as one of the most satisfying moments in the book.
Book Synopsis
Jess Lambert is back in London for the premiere of her latest film, and she can’t buy a coffee without being recognised. She’s young, hugely famous thanks to a superhero franchise, and quietly falling apart. When a wave of panic hits her in the middle of the city, she does the only thing she can think of. She runs.
Anna Mayhew sees a frightened young woman who looks like she’s being chased, and something in her recognises that kind of fear. She steps in, gets Jess away from the crowd, and takes her home to her flat at the top of a London building, a place that has been Anna’s hiding spot for years. Anna doesn’t follow films and has no clue that the stranger on her sofa is one of the most recognisable faces in the world. Jess, who hasn’t been treated like an ordinary person in a long time, decides not to tell her.
Over a few days, the flat becomes a refuge for both of them. Jess gets to be herself, maybe for the first time since she got famous. Anna, who has kept everyone at arm’s length for five years, finds herself laughing again and caring about someone new. But Anna has her own reasons for steering well clear of anything to do with fame, and Jess’s secret can’t stay hidden from the rest of the world forever. The question that hangs over the whole book is what happens to this fragile, lovely thing when real life comes knocking on the door.
My Review
I’ll say it up front: this is one of the most emotionally intelligent romances I’ve read in this corner of the genre. Ashton takes two women who are both scared of the world, for very different reasons, and lets you watch them get a little braver around each other. The rooftop flat works as a sort of pressure chamber, and it gives the first half a closeness that a lot of celebrity romances never get near.
The character work is the real reason to read it. Jess is a lovely creation: kind, a bit awkward, easily overwhelmed and very funny. A number of reviewers, including Smart Bitches, Trashy Books, read her as autistic, and readers who share some of her traits say the social awkwardness and the mimicking rang true. Anna is harder to like at first and more interesting for it. Her routines and walls make sense once you understand what put them there, and the dual POV means you’re never stuck with only one side of a misunderstanding. The writing has a texture you don’t always get in indie romance. One Goodreads reviewer compared it to a home-cooked meal next to fast food, and I think that’s fair.
Where it struggles is pace, and this isn’t just me. A slow start is the most repeated complaint in the reviews, and it shows up even in the five-star ones. One four-star reader almost gave up at 20% and says it only clicked after 30%. Another five-star reader called the pace “glacial” before deciding it was the whole point. StoryGraph has 28% of readers marking it slow-paced. The second complaint is the separation in the back half. Once the secret comes out, Anna reacts badly, the two spend a long stretch apart, and several readers felt the book lost its spark there. One reader also wanted Anna to apologise to Jess directly. Third, and quieter: a few low-star readers say it runs too long.
One expectation to reset. The blurb sounds like a breezy Notting Hill riff, and some readers went in expecting exactly that and came out disappointed. It’s really a book about anxiety, trauma, fame and family that happens to be a romance, and plenty of readers say it reads more like literary fiction. If the cute celebrity premise is what drew you, expect something heavier and slower. If you were worried it might be fluff, relax, it’s anything but.
My honest note: A beautifully observed, character-first romance that rewards patience and punishes impatience. If you need a story to move quickly, you’ll feel the first third. If you can settle into its pace, it’s one of the most moving books in the genre.
| Element | In Finding Jessica Lambert |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Jess Lambert (24) & Anna Mayhew (39): young movie star and reclusive Londoner, a 15-year age gap |
| Core tropes | Celebrity and non-famous, age gap, hurt/comfort, secret identity, hiding from the world, opposites attract |
| Setting | Contemporary London, mostly Anna’s rooftop flat, with a later stretch on a film set |
| Heat level | 3/5: open door, moderate, emotional rather than frequent |
| Series | Standalone with an HEA. No prior books needed |
| Content notes | Panic attacks and anxiety disorder, stalking (past and present), PTSD, burnout, emotional abuse and homophobia from a parent, racism, sexual content |
How Spicy Is Finding Jessica Lambert?
I’d put it at 3/5. romance.io lists the book, but I couldn’t load its steam rating on this pass, so this number comes from the reader evidence instead. I Heart SapphFic rates it “Medium,” with sex scenes that use mildly graphic description, and that matches what most reviewers describe. The door is open, the scenes are there, and they grow out of the emotional closeness rather than driving the plot. Several of the readers who loved the book single out the love scenes as a highlight.
It’s worth knowing that the heat divides people. Some readers call the scenes very sexy, while at least two low-star reviewers say they were rushed, too few or tame. Nobody I found flags any specific kink or consent concern. If you want this same level of heat with a famous lead, Breaking Character and Purposefully Accidental both sit in the same open-door band.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you read romance for the characters more than the plot, you like an age gap handled with care, you want anxiety and mental health written with real understanding, and you’re happy to spend a lot of time inside two women’s heads.
You may want to skip it if: a slow first third will lose you, a long separation in the back half ruins a romance for you, you want frequent, high-heat scenes, or you were hoping for a light, fast Hollywood rom-com.
In short: a deep, warm, slow-moving love story that gives back exactly as much patience as you bring to it.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
There’s no viral moment behind this book, and there doesn’t need to be one. My searches turned up no Reddit threads driving it, and as a self-published title it has no Publishers Weekly or Kirkus coverage. What it has is six years of steady word of mouth inside the lesfic community. It won the 2021 Goldie for long contemporary romance, LezReviewBooks gave it 5+ stars and put it on its best of 2020 list, and the Goodreads count keeps ticking up, from 3,228 ratings when we first reviewed it last month to 3,237 now. StoryGraph has it at 4.18 from 615 reviews, and Amazon at 4.7 from about 2,000 ratings. It’s also in Kindle Unlimited.
The audiobook is a big part of that. Gabrielle Baker narrates it for Tantor, and the recording runs 14 hours and came out in August 2021. LezReviewBooks put it first on its best sapphic audiobooks of 2021 list and called her performance of the feelings and accents “spot-on.” A couple of listeners had small quibbles, but the narration is mostly praised, and at least one reader says some scenes landed even better on audio.
Prefer audio? Listen to Finding Jessica Lambert on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The characters, first and by a distance. “Layered” and “three-dimensional” come up again and again, and StoryGraph’s numbers back it up, with 82% of readers calling it character-driven. Then the depiction of anxiety, which a lot of readers say they recognised from their own lives. The chemistry gets steady praise, especially in the first act on the rooftop. Readers enjoy the humour and Penny, the best friend. And more than one reviewer says the writing feels richer and more textured than most romance, which is where the “closer to literary fiction” comparison comes from.
What readers argue about and complain about: Pace, above everything. The slow start shows up in reviews at every star level, including from readers who ended up loving it, and almost three in ten StoryGraph readers mark it slow-paced. Second is the separation. After the secret comes out, Anna’s reaction struck several readers as out of proportion, the two leads spend a long section apart, and a three-star reader felt the lying that split them up never really got resolved. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books’ reviewer stopped at about 57% for exactly these reasons, saying she found little chemistry and saw the reveal coming. Third is length. A few low-star readers say it would have worked better as a novella, and one wanted tighter editing. Beyond that, the heat splits readers (some found it tame), and one one-star reviewer was uncomfortable with the 15-year gap. These are real complaints, but they’re about taste, not craft. StoryGraph’s DNF rate is only 4%, which is low next to most books I’ve checked recently.
The standalone question worth asking first: This is a complete standalone with a happy ending, and you don’t need to have read anything else first. If you want more Clare Ashton afterwards, Tempting Olivia is the easy next step, with a 4.26 Goodreads average across about 5,700 ratings. After Mrs Hamilton, her darker, earlier Goldie winner, sits lower at 3.95, so treat that one as a different kind of read rather than more of the same.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Finding Jessica Lambert a standalone?
Yes. It’s a complete standalone with a happy ending for Jess and Anna, and it doesn’t connect to any of Clare Ashton’s other books, so you can start here.
How old are Jess and Anna in Finding Jessica Lambert?
Jess is 24 and Anna is 39, a 15-year age gap. Most readers say it’s handled with care, though at least one reviewer found the gap uncomfortable.
How spicy is Finding Jessica Lambert?
About a 3/5. It’s open door with a moderate number of scenes, rated Medium by I Heart SapphFic. Some readers find the scenes very sexy and a few find them too tame.
Is Finding Jessica Lambert slow?
At the start, yes. The slow first third is the most common complaint, and about 28% of StoryGraph readers call it slow-paced. Many readers say it clicks around the 30% mark and pays off.
Is there a Finding Jessica Lambert audiobook?
Yes. Gabrielle Baker narrates it for Tantor, it runs about 14 hours and it was released in August 2021. Listeners mostly praise her performance, especially the accents.
Did Finding Jessica Lambert win any awards?
Yes. It won the 2021 Golden Crown Literary Society award (the Goldie) in the long contemporary romance category.
If You Loved Finding Jessica Lambert, Read These Next
If it was the famous-woman-meets-ordinary-woman setup that got you, Jae’s Damage Control runs a Hollywood actress and her publicist through the same fear of exposure at a similar heat level. For another actress who has to manage a public image while falling for someone, Lee Winter’s Breaking Character adds more bite and a fake relationship. And if you want more of Ashton’s warmth, Tempting Olivia is the obvious next read.
For more like this, browse our celebrity lesbian romance list, the age-gap lesbian romance collection, our literary and character-driven fiction shelf, or the full Book Reviews archive.
The Bottom Line
Finding Jessica Lambert sets out to be a celebrity romance that takes its characters seriously, and it pulls that off. The two leads are rich and believable, the anxiety writing is some of the best in the genre, and the rooftop first act is warm, funny and quietly romantic. It also starts slowly, loses some momentum during a long separation, and runs longer than a few readers wanted. If you read for character and don’t mind taking your time, it’s an easy recommendation and a deserved award winner. Check Finding Jessica Lambert on Amazon
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Finding Jessica Lambert ranks as a top-tier, character-first celebrity age-gap romance. Its strengths are deep characters and some of the best anxiety writing in the genre. It’s held back by a slow first third and a long separation, and it’s best read for the two women rather than the premise.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ 4.35 average across 3,237 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4% DNF rate on StoryGraph
- ✓ 2021 Goldie winner, long contemporary romance
- ✓ Slow start named at every star level
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Rooftop first act full of warmth
- ✓ Together early, tension is staying together
- ✓ Strong chemistry praised across reviews
- ✓ Long separation drains momentum for some
Characters ★★★★★ 4.6/5
- ✓ 93% on StoryGraph say strong development
- ✓ 87% of StoryGraph readers find leads loveable
- ✓ Jess widely read as autistic, written with care
- ✓ Anna’s overreaction frustrates several readers
Writing ★★★★☆ 4.4/5
- ✓ Textured prose readers compare to literary fiction
- ✓ Humour lands inside heavy material
- ✓ Dual POV used well
- ✓ Some find the interiority repetitive
Emotional Impact ★★★★★ 4.5/5
- ✓ Anxiety written from real understanding
- ✓ 75% of StoryGraph readers tag it emotional
- ✓ Anna standing up to her mother lands
- ✓ Unresolved apology leaves a sour note for some
Heat Level ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Open door, moderate scenes
- ✓ Rated Medium by I Heart SapphFic
- ✓ Grows from emotional closeness
- ✓ Split between sexy and too tame
Ending ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Complete standalone with an HEA
- ✓ Both women finish braver than they started
- ✓ Family thread gets real closure
- ✓ Reunion feels quick after the long split
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Rooftop chapters reward a revisit
- ✓ 14-hour Gabrielle Baker audiobook as second pass
- ✓ Kindle Unlimited makes rereading easy
- ✓ Slow first third discourages a quick reread
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
2 thoughts on “Finding Jessica Lambert Review: Is It Worth Reading?”