Ask, Tell Review: Is It Worth Reading?
Our review of E.J. Noyes’s forbidden romance between an Army surgeon and her colonel under Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell: intense and emotional, with an infidelity setup that divides readers.
Our review of E.J. Noyes’s forbidden romance between an Army surgeon and her colonel under Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell: intense and emotional, with an infidelity setup that divides readers.
Our evidence-led review of Specifically, You by Jeanine Henning: a warm, low-angst age-gap debut with a moving sister storyline and a slow first half.
An asexual repair tech, a two-hundred-year-old robot and a failing Seattle tea shop. Our evidence-led review of Meredith Katz’s tender sapphic sci-fi novella, and why readers keep wishing it were longer.
Verdict: A tense, steamy small-town romance between a veteran with PTSD and an icy prosecutor from her past, with a heroine readers root for and chemistry that crackles, undercut by a betrayal that a vocal minority feel is forgiven far too easily. Best for: Readers who love ice queens, damaged military heroines and explicit heat, … Read more
Verdict: A tense, gritty military survival romance with one of Radclyffe’s most complex heroines, let down by a love story that declares itself within days and a stateside second half that never matches the siege that opens the book. Best for: Readers who want action and danger first, a damaged military heroine, and Radclyffe’s dependable … Read more
Verdict: A lyrical, comforting hurt/comfort novella: Linnea Worth, an artisan working herself to dust, catches the attention of Iris, a singer and healing attendant at Esk’s Gardens who is determined to make her rest. Readers love the prose, the aether-lit world and the tenderness; a few found the short length left too little shared page … Read more
Our full review of Finding Jessica Lambert by Clare Ashton, the Goldie-winning London celebrity age-gap romance: heat, pacing, ending and what readers say.
Verdict: A sweet, cozy, low-angst novella with welcome Asian and nonbinary representation and a lovable grandmother — but it is short for the burnout story it wants to tell, and readers split over fast pacing and Rae’s attitude to Julie’s career. Best for: Readers who want a quick, warm opposites-attract romance with instalove and hurt/comfort. … Read more
Verdict: A tender, clear-eyed Outer Banks romance about an Army staff sergeant learning to name her PTSD and let a patient nurse love her anyway, held back by a flashback-heavy first half and a romance that several readers say plays second fiddle to the healing story. Best for: Readers who want a character-driven sapphic novel … Read more
Verdict: A hot, emotionally heavier-than-it-looks stud/femme Christmas novella that gives a beloved side character her own story, held back by a length readers keep calling too short and an ending that feels more like a door left open than a door closed. Best for: Readers who already love Zedde’s Like Her world and want Pam’s … Read more