Specifically, You Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Specifically, You by Jeanine Henning book cover

Our evidence-led review of Specifically, You by Jeanine Henning: a warm, low-angst age-gap debut with a moving sister storyline and a slow first half.

Homegrown Magic Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Homegrown Magic by Jamie Pacton and Rebecca Podos book cover

A cozy F/NB greenhouse romance with a sweet childhood-crush reunion and real heat, held back by secrecy-driven plotting and a villain family many readers found antisemitic.

We Set the Dark on Fire Review: Is It Worth Reading?

We Set the Dark on Fire by Tehlor Kay Mejia book cover

Tehlor Kay Mejia’s YA sapphic dystopia pairs sharp border politics with a forbidden romance between two wives of the same man. Here’s what 21,000 Goodreads ratings and the trade reviews say, and why you’ll want the sequel ready.

The Abyss Surrounds Us Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Abyss Surrounds Us by Emily Skrutskie book cover

Emily Skrutskie’s YA debut pairs pirates, bioengineered sea monsters and a captor and captive romance that takes consent seriously. Here’s why readers love it, and why most of them wish it were longer.

Trial by Fire Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Trial by Fire by Carsen Taite book cover

A prosecutor and a public defender clash over an arson murder in a courtroom drawn by a former defense lawyer, let down by a rushed romance. Our evidence review of Carsen Taite’s Trial by Fire.

It Should Be a Crime Review: Is It Worth Reading?

It Should Be a Crime by Carsen Taite book cover

A courtroom-accurate debut with a hot opening and a murder case readers love, held back by a romance the trial keeps interrupting. Our evidence review of Carsen Taite’s It Should Be a Crime.

Scatter Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Scatter by Molly J. Bragg book cover

Molly J. Bragg’s Scatter strands a deputy U.S. Marshal thirty years in the past with the superhero she has loved since childhood. A big-hearted sapphic time travel romance with lumpy pacing.

Iron & Velvet Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Iron and Velvet by Alexis Hall book cover

A funny, queer urban fantasy mystery set in supernatural London, with a half-fae detective worth meeting, held back by a slow, info-heavy start and a romance that plays second fiddle to the case.

The Power of Mercy Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Power of Mercy by Fiona Zedde book cover

Fiona Zedde’s Black lesbian superhero novella pairs a shape-shifting vigilante with a murder that hits far too close to home. It’s dark, gritty and absorbing, held back by a short page count that leaves the mystery and the romance underfed.