Truth and Measure Review — Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: A slow-burn ice-queen workplace romance with the best-drawn fashion tyrant in sapphic fiction, undercut by an ending that is really a page break.

Best for: Readers who want a burn measured in hundreds of pages, who care more about pining and dialogue than about how explicit the sex is, and who can accept that the payoff sits in book two.

Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — explicit open door)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.1/5 — a 4.33 Goodreads average across 5,572 ratings, docked because book one stops mid-story)

Tropes: Age gap, ice queen, boss and employee, slow burn, workplace romance, pregnancy, queer awakening, forced proximity, caretaking, class difference.

Truth and Measure by Roslyn Sinclair is the first half of the two-book Carlisle series, a contemporary sapphic romance set at Du Jour, a New York fashion magazine, where Jules Moretti — twenty-five, newly single, hyper-competent — spends her working life anticipating Vivian Carlisle, an editor-in-chief some seventeen years her senior who is midway through a divorce and about to learn she is pregnant.

It carries a 4.33 average across 5,572 Goodreads ratings and a 4.13 across 1,167 StoryGraph reviews, and it arrives with a history: it is a rewrite of a 2013 Devil Wears Prada fanfic with 661,854 hits and 12,566 kudos on Archive of Our Own. What the aggregate hides is that nearly every critical review objects to one structural decision. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Truth and Measure About?

Truth and Measure is a contemporary age-gap romance and an office romance, and both labels come with machinery the book uses. The gap — reviewers put it at sixteen or seventeen years, Vivian in her early forties against Jules at twenty-five — sets the terms of who has money, who has authority, and who may want anything out loud. The workplace half is what most boss-and-assistant romances skip: Vivian signs Jules’s paycheck, and the book treats that as a problem, not a flavour.

Jules arrives with competence and nothing else — no career yet, an aspiring writer paying rent by managing someone else’s calendar. Vivian arrives assuming everyone is replaceable, including the assistant who reads her before she speaks. romance.io files the book as third person and readers place the narration with Jules, so you get Vivian entirely through what she says and does — which is why the moments she slips land so hard.

What Makes This Sapphic Ice Queen Workplace Romance Work

• Vivian Carlisle: The most-praised element by a distance. Readers do not call her a good ice queen, they call her the benchmark — the name that surfaces first when a sapphic books subreddit is asked for one.
• The banter: Amazon’s own review summary leads with it and reviewers repeatedly report laughing out loud. Dialogue is where this book does its characterisation.
• The length of the burn: At around 120,000 words this is a genuine slow burn, and readers who like the form say the wait is what makes it work.
• The supporting cast: Independent reviewers single out the secondary characters as actual characters, both noting this is unusual in the subgenre.
• Abby Craden’s narration: The audiobook has a following of its own. Listeners describe re-listening repeatedly, and more than one blog review says it improves on the page.

Book Synopsis

Jules Moretti has the kind of job people call a foot in the door and then decline to explain. She is assistant to Vivian Carlisle, who runs Du Jour, and the work is knowing what Vivian wants before she says it, absorbing what happens when she gets it wrong, and going home too tired to write the fiction that was meant to be the point. She is broke, newly single, and better at the job than she wants to admit.

Vivian is in the middle of a divorce she is handling by ignoring it. Her marriage is ending, her magazine is not, and she has arranged her life so the second cancels the first. Then a piece of bad timing turns into a pregnancy and the arrangement stops working. Nobody in her life is positioned to help — no friend without an angle, no family without an opinion — except the assistant who already knows her schedule, her moods and her coffee order.

So Jules helps. The help is practical at first and then it is not: appointments, apartments, the domestic intimacies no job description covers. Neither woman will name it, and both have reasons not to — the paycheck, the age difference, the fact that Vivian has never once described herself as interested in women. The question is not whether they want each other. It is what either will give up to say so.

My Review

Vivian Carlisle is the reason this book has 5,572 Goodreads ratings and a reputation, and I want to say so first. Ice queens are the most over-attempted character in sapphic romance, and most are cold for one act and then stop. Vivian does not. Her cruelty is precise, funny and entirely consistent with a woman who built a life on being the most competent person in the room, and the thaw arrives in units so small you can miss it.

The second real strength is the dialogue. Sinclair writes scenes in which two people say almost nothing true to each other and everything true underneath it, and does it for 120,000 words without the trick going stale. Amazon’s review summary leads on hilarious banter, and that is what readers are there for. The supporting cast benefits too: the friends and colleagues have their own jokes and agendas, rarer than it should be.

Where it struggles is the ending, and this is not a personal gripe — it is the single most repeated criticism in the reviews. Book one does not resolve. Readers describe being left short of even a happy-for-now, one saying plainly that the couple is still in flux on the last page. The blurb does say this is part one of two, but the effect is that the payoff you spent 120,000 words earning costs a second purchase. Around it sit smaller complaints: several readers find the first two-thirds underdeveloped as romance, and more than one says the turn arrives faster than the buildup earned.

One expectation to reset. This is sold as steamy, and it is explicit — romance.io bands it 4/5, “explicit open door” — but not the wall-to-wall heat that word usually signals here. LezReviewBooks noted the scenes are less explicit than Sinclair’s earlier books and read more as sustained edging than scorching, and some readers complain the sex is told rather than shown. If you came for tension, this delivers. If you came for volume, calibrate.

The last thing worth knowing is what this book was: a rewrite of Telanu’s 2013 Devil Wears Prada fanfic — 271,584 words, 661,854 hits — with the leads renamed. Most readers stop noticing within fifty pages. A few cannot unsee it; one says knowing Vivian was written as Meryl Streep made her hard to picture. It also explains the audience it had on release day.

My honest note: The best ice queen in the genre, in a book that ends a hundred pages early. If you can buy both halves at once, this is a five-star read; if you can only buy one, know you are buying the setup.

Element	In Truth and Measure
Central relationship	Jules Moretti & Vivian Carlisle — a twenty-five-year-old assistant and her editor-in-chief, roughly seventeen years apart
Core tropes	Age gap, ice queen, boss and employee, slow burn, pregnancy, queer awakening, caretaking
Setting	Du Jour, a New York fashion magazine, and the apartments and hospital rooms around it
Heat level	4/5 — explicit open door
Series	The Carlisle Series book 1 of 2 — no HEA here; the arc completes in Above All Things
Content notes	Pregnancy and medical content, explicit sexual content, workplace power imbalance, divorce and infidelity, sexism, alcohol, brief discussion of abortion, lesbophobia and biphobia

How Spicy Is Truth and Measure?

A 4/5. romance.io bands the steam level “explicit open door,” one step below the top rating it reserves for books where the sex is graphic and constant. That matches reader reports: the scenes are on the page and not brief, but they arrive late and are outnumbered by the wanting. I Heart SapphFic files it as hot and steamy, which lands in the same place.

The element worth naming in advance is the power imbalance, because the book does not hide from it. Vivian is Jules’s employer when the attraction starts, and both Smart Bitches, Trashy Books and the Lesbrary flagged the ethics rather than waving them through — Smart Bitches concluded it works because Jules keeps her agency and the characters address it. No reviewer I found flags kink content beyond that. If you want this heat band elsewhere, Boss of Her and Hotel Queens sit in the same one.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you read ice-queen romance for the thaw rather than the resolution, you have patience for a burn measured in hundreds of pages, you want dialogue doing the heavy lifting, and you will buy two books to get one ending.

You may want to skip it if: an unresolved ending ruins a book for you, you want the romance established well before the midpoint, you need explicit heat throughout rather than late, or you would rather not read a romance where one woman signs the other’s paycheck.

In short: the best-drawn ice queen in sapphic romance, in a book that sells you the first half of her story.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

There is a live reason this book is moving right now. On 21 August 2026 an updated edition appeared under Lucky Opal Press with a new cover, a new ISBN and a 478-page Kindle file, replacing the 2022 Ylva Publishing edition Ylva still lists; Above All Things got the same treatment plus a new short story, and the reissue already has a new-covers thread on r/LesbianBookClub. Both books are in Kindle Unlimited as I write. What it does not have is trade coverage — no Kirkus, Publishers Weekly, Library Journal or Booklist review of either volume, and neither Carlisle book appears on the 2026 Golden Crown finalist list, though Sinclair is a finalist there for another novel. Discovery has been reader-driven, and the biggest vector is audio: Tantor Audio’s edition, narrated by Abby Craden, runs 12 hours and 7 minutes and holds a 4.7 average across 1,853 Amazon ratings.

Prefer audio? Listen to Truth and Measure on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Vivian, first and by a distance. “Ice queen” is the recurring phrase and the framing is superlative rather than descriptive — readers call her the ultimate, the one they reach for when asked for a recommendation, and one TikTok creator calls her the queen mother of the archetype. Then the banter, repeatedly described as laugh-out-loud. Then the burn itself: StoryGraph readers mark it emotional at 70% and funny at 43%, and 61% call it character driven. Re-reading is unusually common — several reviewers report five or more passes, one returns every two or three months — and Craden’s narration is much of why; two blog reviews credit her with improving on the text.

What readers argue about and complain about: The ending, above everything. Book one stops without an HEA and, by several accounts, without even a happy-for-now; LezReviewBooks says outright you need book two for the story to feel complete, and the Lesbrary describes it as cutting off mid-duology. Second: pacing. The recurring note is that the first two-thirds are underdeveloped as romance, and 28% of StoryGraph readers mark the pace slow. Third, and connected: the turn is abrupt — one reviewer describes Jules’s feelings changing from one moment to the next, others wanted more groundwork before the physical. Beyond that, a minority reads Vivian’s cruelty as emotional abuse rather than archetype, the lowest-rated reviews say the thaw never convinced them, some find the sex told rather than shown, and one flags how closely the setup resembles Lee Winter’s The Brutal Truth — noting, fairly, that Winter edited this one. StoryGraph readers also split on the cast: 54% say it is not diverse.

The series question everyone should ask first: two books, both published in 2022, both finished, and you need both. Above All Things carries a 4.50 average across 4,393 Goodreads ratings — higher than book one — completes the arc, delivers the HEA, and in its 2026 edition adds a short story. There is no third book and none is needed. The instruction is simple: treat the pair as one novel sold in two parts and buy them together, because stopping after book one is the reliable way to have a bad time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Truth and Measure end on a cliffhanger?

Effectively, yes. Book one closes without a happily-ever-after and, by many reader accounts, without a happy-for-now either. Above All Things picks up immediately and completes the arc.

How spicy is Truth and Measure?

A 4/5. romance.io bands it “explicit open door,” one step below its top rating. The sex is graphic and on the page, but it arrives late and there is less of it than in Sinclair’s earlier novels.

Is the Carlisle series finished?

Yes. Two books, both published in 2022, and Above All Things completes the story with an HEA. Updated editions of both appeared in August 2026, and book two’s adds a short story.

Is Truth and Measure really a Devil Wears Prada fanfic?

In origin, yes. It rewrites Telanu’s 2013 Archive of Our Own story, which runs 271,584 words and has drawn 661,854 hits. Names and details changed, and most readers say it stands on its own.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes — narrated by Abby Craden for Tantor Audio, running 12 hours and 7 minutes, released in December 2022. It holds a 4.7 average across 1,853 Amazon ratings, and readers routinely say the narration improves it.

If You Loved Truth and Measure, Read These Next

Readers comparing this to other ice-queen romances land most often on The Brutal Truth, which runs the same frozen-executive-and-younger-woman engine and which one reviewer found almost too close a match — Lee Winter edited this one too. For the age gap and the institutional power, The Headmistress does it inside a boarding school at the same heat band, and Assistant to the CEO keeps the assistant-and-boss setup a heat band higher. For more in this register, browse our age-gap lesbian romance reading list or the full Book Reviews collection.

The Bottom Line

Truth and Measure sets out to make you want something for a very long time, and succeeds better than almost anything in the genre. Vivian Carlisle is the best-realised ice queen in sapphic romance, the dialogue is funny, and the supporting cast earns its pages. It is also slow to become a romance, abrupt when it turns, and — the complaint that dominates the rest — only half a story, with the resolution sold separately. Whether that trade is worth it comes down to one question: can you buy both books? If you can, this is a five-star weekend. If not, wait. Check Truth and Measure on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Truth and Measure ranks as a benchmark sapphic ice-queen workplace romance — unmatched at slow-burn tension and character work, held back by an ending that is really a page break, and best approached as the first half of one book sold in two parts.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

• ✓ 4.33 average across 5,572 Goodreads ratings
• ✓ 4.13 on StoryGraph from 1,167 reviews
• ✓ Ice queen work near-unanimously praised
• ✓ Book one resolves nothing on its own

Romance ★★★★☆ 4.2/5

• ✓ Pining sustained across 120,000 words
• ✓ Power imbalance addressed, not ignored
• ✓ No miscommunication, no third-act breakup
• ✓ The turn arrives abruptly when it comes

Characters ★★★★★ 4.5/5

• ✓ Vivian is the genre’s benchmark ice queen
• ✓ 70% on StoryGraph report strong development
• ✓ Secondary cast named as unusually well drawn
• ✓ 54% say the cast is not diverse

Writing ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

• ✓ Banter leads Amazon’s own review summary
• ✓ Dialogue carries the characterisation
• ✓ No editing complaints anywhere in the reviews
• ✓ Some readers find the sex told, not shown

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4.3/5

• ✓ 70% of StoryGraph readers mark it emotional
• ✓ The pregnancy gives the thaw real stakes
• ✓ Pining and angst singled out repeatedly
• ✓ Stops before the payoff lands

Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ romance.io bands it explicit open door
• ✓ Graphic and on the page, not fade to black
• ✓ Tension outweighs frequency
• ✓ Less explicit than Sinclair’s earlier books

Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

• ✓ Setup and stakes land before the break
• ✓ Above All Things completes the arc
• ✓ Sequel rated higher at 4.50 across 4,393 ratings
• ✓ No HEA here, and arguably no HFN

Re-read Value ★★★★★ 4.6/5

• ✓ Multiple readers report five or more passes
• ✓ One reviewer returns every two to three months
• ✓ Craden’s audiobook is a strong second pass
• ✓ 120,000 words is a long way back in

Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.