This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A brother’s-best-friend college baseball romance where the baseball is a hat the hero wears. Very readable, very popular, and one of the clearest cases on our shelf of a book sold on a sport it does not depict.
Best for: Readers who want a shy heroine, a confident hero, campus setting and high heat with no third-act break-up.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — “Explicit open door” on romance.io)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5 — 3.75 on Goodreads across 19,529 ratings, 3.73 on StoryGraph, 4.1 from 8,395 on Amazon)
This is an LRR evidence review. We have not read the book text. Everything below is assembled from Goodreads, StoryGraph, romance.io, Amazon’s own review corpus, the author’s channels and named book blogs — and where the evidence stops, we say so rather than filling the gap.
Homerun Proposal opens Maren Moore’s Orleans University series and sits on our Kindle Unlimited sports guide. Lane Collins is a senior, the team captain and a pitcher. Hallie is a freshman, his younger brother’s best friend, and by her own description a nerd who would rather stay in.
A listing correction: this is college, not professional
Orleans University is a college programme in Louisiana, not an MLB analogue. If you filtered our guide for professional baseball and landed here, that was our error and it is corrected.
How much baseball is actually in Homerun Proposal?
Essentially none that anyone describes.
The most thorough blog review we found reports no gameplay, no practice, no team scenes, no season, no draft and no injury — the baseball is “character backdrop” because Lane is captain and pitcher. Another blogger notes that the one sport-adjacent thread, tension with his father about his baseball career, is “resolved off page almost as an afterthought”. A targeted sweep of Goodreads reviews for mentions of a game, the field, the season, the clubhouse or an injury came back empty.
romance.io agrees on the weighting: baseball is tagged four times against six for athlete hero and six for college. The strongest positive reader statement we could find is generic: “best friends brother, baseball, him ‘teaching’ her things” — baseball as one item in a trope list.
Our measurement makes the gap unusually stark. Of the book’s 606 US written Amazon reviews, baseball is named in 277 — 45.7%, the fourth-highest sport-name rate on our entire shelf — while a game is mentioned in 11, or 1.8%. That is a twenty-five-to-one ratio, the widest we have measured. Nearly half of all readers reach for the word “baseball” when describing this book, and almost none of them can point to a game.
Our grade: SPORTS-LABELED with LOW on-page sport — unchanged, and this is close to the archetype of the band.
Book synopsis
Hallie arrives at Orleans University knowing exactly one person: her best friend’s older brother, who is the campus’s baseball star and entirely off limits. He appoints himself her guide to being nineteen. It goes where brother’s-best-friend books go, with a virgin-heroine arc and a friends-with-benefits stage on the way.
My review
Popular and middling-rated, which is a specific combination: 19,529 Goodreads ratings at 3.75, StoryGraph 3.73 with a 3% did-not-finish rate. Blogs range from a five-star “hit it out of the park” to a three-star verdict calling it formulaic with “unexpectedly hot smut”.
Two things it does well by reader account: consent and pacing in the physical relationship, which one blog singles out, and a grand-gesture ending readers enjoy. Two things it does less well: originality, and any use at all of the sport on the cover.
Worth noting for readers who avoid the trope: romance.io taggers apply no third-act break-up twice, which on this shelf is a selling point rather than a spoiler.
Is Homerun Proposal on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes, verified on 22 August 2026 by reading the Kindle format swatch on the book’s own Amazon product page. Enrolment changes without notice.
Does the author publish content warnings?
No public warning set found. The author’s own page for this book carries no warning block, romance.io lists none, and StoryGraph’s panel would not load.
Reader-sourced only, labelled as such: explicit on-page sex and a virginity-loss arc; one blogger flags “VERY SPICY MOMENTS”; several Goodreads readers mention period-related scenes.
Ending, cliffhanger and series position
HEA: yes, with a grand gesture and a dual-point-of-view close. Cliffhanger: no. Readers describe it as full circle. Orleans University book 1 of a connected series — Catching Feelings, Walkoff Wedding and Rookie Mistake follow different couples.
Audiobook
An audiobook exists, narrated by Alex Kydd and Sarah McEwan for Podium Entertainment, running 10 hours 22 minutes. Whether audio is included with Kindle Unlimited is UNKNOWN — no Read and Listen for Free language was reachable.
What readers are actually saying (August 2026)
Enjoyed, rarely loved, and described almost entirely in trope terms. Reddit: UNKNOWN / NOT ACCESSIBLE — blocked from our research environment, nothing substituted.
Frequently asked questions
Is Homerun Proposal on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes as of 22 August 2026, verified on the book’s own Amazon product page.
Is it college or professional baseball?
College. Orleans University in Louisiana. Our guide previously listed it as professional and that has been corrected.
How much baseball is in Homerun Proposal?
Almost none. Baseball is named in 45.7% of the book’s 606 Amazon reviews — the fourth-highest rate on our shelf — but a game in only 1.8%. No blogger describes gameplay, practice, the season or an injury.
Is there a third-act break-up?
romance.io taggers say no, applying the no-third-act-break-up tag twice.
Does it have a happily ever after or a cliffhanger?
HEA with a grand gesture, no cliffhanger.
Does the author publish content warnings?
No public warning set was found on her site or the listing.
If you loved Homerun Proposal, read these next
For college baseball with the sport genuinely on the page, The Dugout is the book on our shelf with the highest measured competition content. For professional baseball with a full ensemble, Caught Up.
The bottom line
A perfectly enjoyable campus romance whose sport exists on the cover and in the reader vocabulary and almost nowhere else. If you came to our guide for baseball, keep scrolling to the CORE SPORT band.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 3.75 Goodreads from 19,529 ratings
- ✓ 3.73 StoryGraph, 3% did-not-finish
- ✓ 4.1 Amazon from 8,395
- ✓ Blog range from three to five stars
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Brother’s-best-friend with a real proximity engine
- ✓ Consent and pacing praised by one blog
- ✓ No third-act break-up, reader-tagged
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Shy-heroine and confident-captain pairing
- ✓ Virgin-heroine arc tagged six times
- ✓ Formulaic by one blogger’s account
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Funny, hopeful, lighthearted, medium-paced on StoryGraph
- ✓ Grand-gesture ending readers enjoy
- ✓ One blog notes it “could use some more editing”
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Father-son career tension is the only weight
- ✓ Resolved off page, per a reviewer
- ✓ No author warning set
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Band 4 of 5, “Explicit open door”
- ✓ One blogger flags “VERY SPICY MOMENTS”
- ✓ Described as unexpectedly hot by a three-star review
Ending ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ HEA with a grand gesture and dual POV close
- ✓ No cliffhanger
- ✓ Readers call it full circle
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Four-book connected series
- ✓ Widest sport-name-to-game gap we have measured
- ✓ Nothing sporting to return to
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.
Leave a Reply