The Risk Review | S.T. Abby | Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: A 132-page free novella that ends mid-story — and whose readers log rape 409 times at the graphic tier against an author who submitted no warnings at all.

Best for: Readers who want a revenge-thriller heroine more than a romance, and who will start all five installments knowing this one does not end.

Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5 — romance.io’s “Moderate” band)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.5/5 — a genuinely gripping premise and a heroine readers adore, sold as a free sample of a story it cannot finish)

Darkness type: Revenge · Where the darkness sits: Explicit non-consent themes

Tropes: Vigilante heroine · Serial killer · FBI profiler · Revenge · Suspense · Dangerous heroine

Kindle Unlimited: Verified in KU on 21 August 2026, checked on the Amazon product page.

The Risk by S.T. Abby book cover

Two facts about The Risk ought to be on its product page and are not.

The first is that it does not end. It is 132 pages, it is permanently free, and it stops on a hard cliffhanger inside a five-part story that a reading blog describes plainly as one novel sold in five installments. The widely-held belief that you can sample this series risk-free is simply wrong; readers finish it in a sitting and immediately need four more books. Budget for all five, or start with the omnibus.

The second is heavier. S.T. Abby submitted no content warnings to StoryGraph. Readers logged rape 409 times at the graphic tier — the third-largest tag on the book behind only murder at 607 and torture at 424 — plus 124 at moderate and 43 at minor. For a 132-page novella that density is extraordinary. And two tags almost nobody discusses: homophobia at 98 graphic, 67 moderate and 40 minor, and hate crime at 45 graphic. No blurb, blog or list we read across this whole project mentioned either.

Verified in Kindle Unlimited on 21 August 2026 on the individual Amazon product page. Goodreads shows roughly 4.24 across more than 400,000 ratings — we will not quote a precise figure, because three separate readings of the Goodreads page returned three different numbers spanning about 23,000, and the site aggregates 66 editions for this title.

What Is The Risk About?

Lana Myers reads as an ordinary small-town woman. She is a methodical serial killer working through a list — the men who assaulted her and destroyed her life a decade earlier. She also operates under the identity Victoria Evans.

Logan Bennett is an FBI profiler assigned to the string of murders she is committing.

They meet and fall for each other, and neither knows who the other is. He is hunting the killer he is falling in love with; she is falling for the man who will eventually identify her.

It is Mindf*ck book 1 of 5 — The Risk, Sidetracked, Scarlet Angel, All the Lies, Paint It All Red — and each installment picks up immediately where the last one stopped. A single-volume omnibus collects all five at 683 pages, which is the practical recommendation for anyone who does not want to be interrupted four times.

What The Risk Does Differently

The heroine is the killer and readers love her for it. Lana is one of the most enthusiastically praised protagonists we encountered across thirty-two books. Reviewers openly relish her, and a rueful joke about supporting women’s wrongs recurs across a great many reviews. That kind of unqualified affection for a vigilante protagonist is rare.

The premise is the hook and it works. A profiler unknowingly romancing his suspect is a good idea executed with better criminology detail than readers expected, and the Criminal Minds comparisons are earned.

Readers raise the insta-attraction objection and dismiss it in the same sentence. That pattern — naming a flaw and declining to care — recurs often enough here to be a real property of the book’s hold on people.

The ratings climb across the series — roughly 4.24 here, then 4.35, 4.38, 4.50, 4.54, and 4.61 for the omnibus. We would read that as survivorship rather than as evidence the books improve: only readers who continued are rating the later ones.

Content Warnings

Author warning language, paraphrased and unverified. The Goodreads description field carries an author warning covering adult language, vivid depictions of sexual assault and murder, torture, and psychological trauma, with a note that the content may be too much for the easily disturbed reader. We captured this from a description field, not from the book’s own front matter, because Amazon was unreachable to our research tools.

StoryGraph states plainly that this book has no content warnings submitted by the author. Every figure below is reader-submitted.

Heaviest reader-flagged content, StoryGraph graphic tier: murder 607, torture 424, rape 409, violence 361, blood 313, sexual assault 294, death 289, sexual content 261, sexual violence 234, gore 228, injury detail 139, physical abuse 130, kidnapping 127, body horror 109, stalking 106.

Rape: 409 graphic, 124 moderate, 43 minor. In a 132-page book. The description mentions sexual assault; nothing in the marketing prepares a reader for that volume.

The under-flagged finding: homophobia 98 graphic, 67 moderate, 40 minor, and hate crime 45 graphic. These are substantial, consistent across all three severity tiers, and absent from every blurb, blog review and list we consulted. If you are avoiding that content, no other source will tell you it is here.

Pedophilia is flagged 21 at the graphic tier, and a separate community warning database independently lists it as one of only five warnings it gives for this book. Two independent crowd sources agreeing on a tag this severe is worth surfacing.

romance.io warning tags: abuse (23), rape (21), past sexual abuse (17), queerphobia (13). Note that romance.io taggers also register the queerphobia, which corroborates the StoryGraph homophobia cluster.

StoryGraph stores separate records per edition. Every count above is a floor drawn from one record, not a cross-edition total.

My Review

The Risk is the most consequential mislabelling on this page, and the label is the word free.

A permanently free 132-page novella reads as an invitation to try something. This one is a funnel into a five-part story that it stops in the middle of, and the reviews reflect that exactly — the cliffhanger is the defining complaint, and it is structural rather than incidental, because book two picks up mid-scene. Readers describe finishing this book in a sitting and being unable to stop. That is a compliment to the writing and a warning about the commitment.

What earns the affection is Lana. A woman methodically working through the men who destroyed her, written without apology and without a redemption frame, is a protagonist readers respond to with unusual warmth, and the criminology around her is better researched than the format suggests. The premise — the profiler falling for his own suspect — carries the tension the length cannot.

The heat is genuinely secondary. romance.io places this at band 3 of 5, and coverage of the sexual content in the review corpus is noticeably thinner than for anything else on this page. Readers foreground the thriller. If you are borrowing this for romance heat you have the wrong book; if you are borrowing it for a revenge plot, it is one of the better ones here.

What we most want to put on the record is the warning situation, because no other source will. The author submitted nothing to StoryGraph. Readers logged rape as the third-heaviest tag on a 132-page book. And homophobia and hate crime — flagged by around a hundred readers at the graphic tier, corroborated independently by romance.io taggers registering queerphobia — appear in no promotional copy, no blog review and no recommendation list we read. A reader avoiding that content has no way of finding out except by encountering it.

We rate it 3.5. Gripping, short, and honest about none of the three things a prospective reader most needs to know.

How Spicy Is The Risk?

romance.io places it at band 3 of 5, its moderate tier, across 653 ratings — the second-lowest heat band on this page.

Readers describe the explicit scenes as hot and note they arrive early. Beyond that, reader vocabulary about the sexual content is genuinely thin: most reviews foreground the thriller and the revenge plot rather than the romance, and we could not characterise the heat further without inventing detail.

The heavy sexual tags on this book are not heat tags. Rape at 409 graphic and sexual assault at 294 relate to the assault that drives the heroine’s revenge, not to the romance.

We do not assign our own chili count where the author and publisher have not. The band above is romance.io’s crowd measure and is reproduced as theirs.

Who Should Read This Book?

Read it if you want a vigilante thriller with a romance in it rather than the reverse, you like a heroine the book never asks you to forgive, or you are prepared to read all five installments.

Skip it if you want a self-contained book — this one stops mid-story — graphic depictions of sexual assault are a line for you, or homophobic content and hate crime are things you avoid, because they are here at volume and nothing else will tell you so.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

Goodreads: roughly 4.24 across more than 400,000 ratings. We deliberately give no precise figure — three readings of the page returned counts spanning about 23,000, and Goodreads aggregates 66 editions for this title. romance.io: 4.23 across 653.

The cliffhanger is the defining complaint and it is structural: book two picks up immediately, so readers describe finishing book one mid-scene.

Length-versus-price friction recurs. At 132 pages readers finish in a sitting and immediately need four more installments; reviewers frame the series as one novel sold in five parts and advise budgeting accordingly.

Lana is among the most enthusiastically praised protagonists in this whole collection, repeatedly named a favourite character.

The premise draws consistent praise, with comparisons to Criminal Minds and Dexter, and readers credit the criminology detail as better researched than expected.

Insta-attraction is acknowledged as a flaw by readers who then say they did not care — the objection is raised and dismissed in the same breath, repeatedly.

Readers who otherwise loved it repeatedly caution that the violence and assault content is graphic enough to genuinely distress.

Research note: Reddit was unreachable from our research environment and TikTok blocks automated access, so neither is cited here. StoryGraph publishes reader content-warning counts but renders its average rating and did-not-finish rate client-side, so those are marked unavailable rather than guessed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Risk in Kindle Unlimited?

Yes. We verified it on the individual Amazon product page on 21 August 2026. Kindle Unlimited catalogues change without notice, so confirm the KU badge on the product page before borrowing.

Is The Risk a standalone?

No. It is Mindf*ck book 1 of 5 and it ends on a hard cliffhanger. Each installment picks up immediately where the last stopped, and a reading blog describes the series as effectively one book. Order: The Risk, Sidetracked, Scarlet Angel, All the Lies, Paint It All Red. A 683-page omnibus collects all five.

Is The Risk free?

It is a permanently free 132-page novella, which is why readers treat it as a risk-free sample. It is not one — it is the opening of a five-part story that it does not finish.

What are the content warnings for The Risk?

The author submitted no warnings to StoryGraph. The description field carries language about adult content, vivid depictions of sexual assault and murder, torture and psychological trauma. Readers log, at the graphic tier: murder 607, torture 424, rape 409, violence 361, sexual assault 294, sexual violence 234, gore 228, homophobia 98, hate crime 45 and pedophilia 21. The homophobia and hate crime cluster appears in no promotional copy or review we could find.

Is The Risk a romance?

It is a revenge thriller with a romance in it. romance.io places it at band 3 of 5 and reader coverage of the heat is thin; almost all reviews foreground the serial-killer plot.

Is there an audiobook?

An audiobook exists, narrated by Marie Hawkins and TJ Clark for Tantor Media, released about seven years after the ebook. Audiobook availability is separate from Kindle Unlimited ebook access, and we make no claim that the audio is included with a KU borrow.

If You Loved The Risk, Read These Next

All verified in Kindle Unlimited on 21 August 2026.

  • There Are No Saints by Sophie Lark — the other serial-killer romance here, with the roles reversed.
  • Still Beating by Jennifer Hartmann — band 4, and the other book on this page that is more thriller than romance.
  • Nine Minutes by Beth Flynn — band 3, and the other title here readers reclassify out of romance entirely.
  • Nocticadia by Keri Lake — band 4 with the most thorough author warning list on this page.

The Bottom Line

The Risk is gripping, very short, free, and honest about almost nothing a reader needs to know. It stops mid-story inside a five-part series that reads as one novel; its author submitted no content warnings anywhere, while readers logged rape as its third-heaviest tag; and it carries a homophobia and hate-crime cluster that appears in no blurb, blog or list we found across this entire project. What it also has is Lana, one of the most warmly received protagonists in this collection, and a premise that earns its Criminal Minds comparisons. Read it. Start the omnibus, not the novella. And know what is in it first, because nothing else is going to tell you.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

Ranked in the middle of our Dark Romance Kindle Unlimited selection. It gains on a heroine readers adore and on a premise executed with more research than its length suggests. It ranks below the leaders because it is a fragment rather than a book, and because it is the least-disclosed title on this page — no author warnings submitted anywhere, and two heavily reader-flagged content clusters that no other source mentions at all.

The Evidence Scorecard

These scores are derived from named public evidence — rating distributions, crowd tag counts, author-published content warnings and signed reviews — rather than from a full LRR reading of this title. Dimensions the evidence will not carry are marked “not established” instead of guessed.

Heat and spice ★★★☆☆ 3/5

  • ✓ romance.io band 3 of 5, the second-lowest heat band on this page
  • ✓ Readers describe explicit scenes as hot and arriving early
  • ✓ Reader vocabulary about the heat is thin; the thriller dominates coverage
  • ✓ Heavy sexual tags relate to the assault backstory, not to the romance

Darkness ★★★★★ 5/5

  • ✓ romance.io dark-romance tag applied by 22 taggers
  • ✓ Murder 607, torture 424 and rape 409 at graphic tier
  • ✓ Gore 228 and body horror 109 also flagged graphic
  • ✓ Extraordinary tag density for a 132-page novella

Consent framing Not established

  • ✓ Rape flagged 409 graphic, 124 moderate, 43 minor
  • ✓ Content relates to the heroine’s assault backstory rather than to the couple
  • ✓ Author submitted no warnings to StoryGraph for comparison
  • ✓ Insufficient evidence to characterise the central relationship’s consent framing

Romance development ★★★☆☆ 3/5

  • ✓ Insta-attraction acknowledged as a flaw and dismissed by the same readers
  • ✓ Premise gives the relationship built-in dramatic irony
  • ✓ 132 pages leaves little room for development
  • ✓ Heroine praised far more often than the couple is

Plot and pacing ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ 132 pages, finished in a sitting by most readers
  • ✓ Criminology detail credited as better researched than expected
  • ✓ Ends on a hard cliffhanger mid-scene
  • ✓ Comparisons to Criminal Minds and Dexter recur and are earned

Cross-platform reception ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Goodreads roughly 4.24 across more than 400,000 ratings
  • ✓ romance.io 4.23 across 653 ratings
  • ✓ Series ratings climb across installments — a survivorship effect, not improvement

Content warning transparency ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Author submitted no content warnings to StoryGraph
  • ✓ Rape logged 409 graphic against a description mentioning sexual assault
  • ✓ Homophobia 98 and hate crime 45 graphic, absent from every source we read
  • ✓ Pedophilia 21 graphic, corroborated by a second independent crowd database

Standalone readability ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Mindf*ck book 1 of 5, ending on a hard cliffhanger
  • ✓ Each installment resumes immediately where the last stopped
  • ✓ A reading blog describes the series as effectively one book
  • ✓ Free pricing invites a risk-free-sample assumption that is wrong

Affiliate disclosure: the store buttons below are affiliate links (Amazon, Bookshop.org and Audible). As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, and we may also earn a small commission from the other stores, at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Lesbian Romance Reads

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading