You Should See Me in a Crown Review — Is It Worth Reading?

Updated on October 8, 2026

This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: A warm, funny, genuinely joyful Black sapphic prom rom-com with one of the best anxious narrators in YA, undercut by a premise nobody quite believes and conflicts that resolve too easily.

Best for: Readers who want a low-stakes-feeling, high-heart YA romance where a Black queer girl gets to win, and who will forgive a school that treats prom like a national election.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — kisses only, closed door)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5 — a 4.06 Goodreads average with more four-star ratings than five)

Tropes: Rivals-to-lovers, new girl in town, forced proximity, competition plot, closeted heroine, forced outing, found family, sick sibling, small-town scrutiny, HEA.

You Should See Me in a Crown is Leah Johnson’s debut novel, a standalone contemporary young adult romance published by Scholastic Press on 2 June 2020, set in the fictional small town of Campbell, Indiana, where prom is treated as a civic institution, and built on the collision between Liz Lighty — Black, queer, broke, anxious and desperate to leave — and Amanda “Mack” McCarthy, the new girl who turns out to be running for the same crown and the same scholarship money.

It holds a 4.06 average across 43,585 Goodreads ratings and a 4.13 on StoryGraph across 20,736 reviews, it was a 2021 Stonewall Honor Book, and it was the first young adult title Reese’s Book Club ever selected, in August 2020. But the ratings curve has a distinctive shape: 44% of Goodreads ratings are four stars and only 33% are five, which is the profile of a book that is widely liked rather than widely adored. The reason for that gap is remarkably consistent across reviews, and one starred trade reviewer named it too. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is You Should See Me in a Crown About?

This is contemporary young adult romance in the rom-com register — not issue fiction, despite what its content list implies. That distinction matters, because the book is carrying grief, chronic illness, poverty, racism and a forced outing while still committing to being funny, and the rom-com framing is what lets it do that. 69% of StoryGraph readers mark it lighthearted and 68% mark it hopeful, which is not a profile you would predict from the plot summary.

Liz is introduced by what she lacks: money for Pennington College, a mother who is still alive, a body that does not panic on her, and any intention of being seen. What she assumes — and what the book methodically dismantles — is that being visible is the same as being unsafe. The novel is narrated in the first person and, unusually for the subgenre, in the present tense, which keeps the reader inside Liz’s anxiety in real time rather than at the safe distance of retrospect. Each week of the prom-queen campaign is introduced by screenshots from Campbell Confidential, the school’s gossip app, and that device is doing more than decoration: it is how the town’s surveillance gets onto the page.

What Makes This Sapphic YA Rom-Com Work

• Liz’s voice: The most-praised element by a distance. The Horn Book called the first-person narration snarky and readers agree; 88% of StoryGraph readers report strong character development and 92% call the cast loveable.
• Black queer joy as the actual point: Readers return again and again to the fact that a Black sapphic protagonist is allowed a light, funny, winning story rather than a trauma narrative, and they name it as the reason the book mattered to them.
• The anxiety writing: Panic attacks are logged by StoryGraph readers at the graphic tier, and they are written from inside rather than described from outside — readers with anxiety consistently single this out as accurate.
• The friendship arc: Liz and Jordan, the estranged best friend who becomes prom king, draws nearly as much comment as the romance, and it is where the novel’s emotional weight actually sits.
• Pacing: School Library Journal called the pacing perfect and 35% of StoryGraph readers mark the book fast — a high figure for a 336-page contemporary, and the reason it works as a one-sitting read.

Book Synopsis

Liz Lighty has one plan and it has exactly one step: get the scholarship, go to Pennington College, play in the orchestra, become a doctor, and never think about Campbell, Indiana again. When the scholarship falls through, the only money left in reach is the town’s other institution — the prom-queen scholarship, awarded through a weeks-long popularity contest that Campbell takes more seriously than anything else it does.

Running means being looked at, which is the one thing Liz has organised her whole life around avoiding. She is Black in a mostly white school, queer in a town that has not been asked to have an opinion about it, poor among people who are not, and prone to panic attacks that arrive without warning. She enters anyway, because her brother Robbie needs her to and because there is no other door.

Then Mack turns up: new, funny, disarming, and — it emerges — a rival candidate. The campaign throws them together constantly, and what starts as reluctant alliance turns into something Liz cannot afford to have noticed. The question the book spends its second half on is not whether she can win. It is what she is willing to be seen doing in order to, and who gets to decide when a girl comes out.

My Review

Liz Lighty is the reason this book works and I want to say that first. Johnson writes an anxious narrator without making anxiety her personality — Liz is funny, competitive, occasionally petty, and entirely aware of how ridiculous her own catastrophising is, which is a much harder balance than sad-and-sympathetic. The present-tense narration keeps you in the panic rather than beside it, and Kirkus starred the book on the strength of exactly this, calling it the queer prom romance you did not know you needed.

The second strength is a structural decision that gets less credit than it deserves. This is a book about a Black queer girl in a hostile small town that refuses to be a book about suffering. The racism is there, the homophobia is there, the poverty is there, and the register stays comic — 51% of StoryGraph readers mark it funny and only 3% mark it sad. Holding those two things at once is genuinely difficult, and it is why so many readers describe this as the book they wished they had at sixteen. The forced outing in act three is the one place the comedy drops out, and Johnson handles it without turning the novel into a different genre.

Where it struggles is the premise, and this is the dominant complaint rather than a private objection of mine. Nobody believes the prom. The scale of the money, the school’s dedicated gossip app, the town’s investment, the suggestion that a prom-queen title carries weight with colleges — readers call this unrealistic more often than they say anything else about the book, and Kirkus, in its starred review, wrote the same thing: the hullabaloo around prom seems far-fetched. Two secondary problems come with it. The conflicts resolve too easily — the rupture with Jordan is patched with an apology that readers say could not plausibly cover it, and the student body’s change of heart arrives with very little groundwork — and Mack is underbuilt, so a romance readers enjoy is one they also describe as insta-love, with several saying they never understood what the two of them saw in each other. There is one further note worth carrying, and it comes from the same starred review: Kirkus observed that the supporting characters appear white by default, which is a fair criticism of a book otherwise praised for its representation.

The expectation worth resetting is what “YA romance” buys you here. This is closed door and the relationship is a subplot inside a competition story rather than the engine of the book; the friendship and the family get more page time than the courtship does. If the Reese’s pick and the prom cover made you expect a light confection, calibrate slightly — there is a dead parent, a sibling with sickle cell anaemia, and a forced outing in here. If the content list made you brace, relax: it is a genuinely happy book and it ends the way you want it to.

My honest note: A four-star heroine in a three-star plot, rescued by charm and by how much it matters that this story gets to be fun. If implausible stakes ruin a book for you, the prom will ruin this one. If you can accept the premise as a comic device, Liz is worth every page.

Element	In You Should See Me in a Crown
Central relationship	Liz Lighty & Amanda “Mack” McCarthy — closeted overachiever and disarming new girl, rival prom-queen candidates
Core tropes	Rivals-to-lovers, new girl in town, forced proximity, competition plot, forced outing, found family
Setting	Campbell, Indiana — a small, affluent, mostly white town where prom is a civic event
Heat level	1/5 — kisses only, closed door
Series	Standalone debut — complete arc and an HEA, no sequel
Content notes	Homophobia, racism, panic attacks and anxiety, forced outing, bullying, parental death in the past, a sibling with sickle cell anaemia, hospital scenes, needles

How Spicy Is You Should See Me in a Crown?

A 1/5, and the sourcing needs stating: romance.io has no entry for this book. That absence is informative rather than a gap in the research — romance.io indexes adult genre romance, and this is a young adult title, so it is not being catalogued there at all. The number comes from two other places: the publisher’s stated audience, which runs from Publishers Weekly‘s ages 12 and up through Kirkus‘s 14 to 18, and reader reports, which describe kissing and nothing further. No reviewer and no content-warning listing flags sexual content of any kind.

The element worth flagging in advance is not heat — it is the forced outing, which arrives late and is the book’s real wound. StoryGraph readers log homophobia, racism and panic attacks at the graphic tier, and a reader who has been outed against their will should know that scene is coming. Nothing beyond that is flagged. For the same band on this site, She Drives Me Crazy and Hani and Ishu’s Guide to Fake Dating both sit at 1/5 and are the closest YA neighbours we have reviewed.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want a Black sapphic protagonist who gets a fun story instead of a hard one, you read YA for voice above plot, you want anxiety representation written from the inside, and you enjoy a competition structure with a countdown.

You may want to skip it if: implausible stakes pull you out of a story, you need a love interest with a fully drawn interior life, conflicts that resolve inside a chapter frustrate you, or you want the romance to be the main plot rather than a thread inside one.

In short: a terrific narrator in a premise you have to agree not to interrogate.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)

Six years on, this is one of the most-read sapphic YA debuts of its decade, and the discovery story explains why: it was the first young adult title Reese’s Book Club ever picked, in August 2020, ten weeks after publication and in the middle of a summer when a lot of people were reading at home. That, plus a 2021 Stonewall Honor and a place on TIME‘s 100 Best YA Books list, put it in front of an audience far wider than YA sapphic romance usually reaches — 43,585 Goodreads ratings and 20,736 StoryGraph reviews are enormous numbers for this shelf. It also means a large share of the reviews come from readers outside the book’s core audience, which is worth remembering when you read the complaints.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Black queer joy comes first and comes up most, and readers name it explicitly as the thing that was missing before — a sapphic protagonist of colour in a story that is allowed to be light. Second is Liz herself: her voice, her growth, and specifically the anxiety representation, which readers with anxiety describe as one of the more accurate depictions in YA. Third is the romance, described most often as precious, adorable and wholesome; readers who love it love its softness rather than its tension. Fourth is the family and friendship material — Liz’s grandparents, her brother Robbie, and the Jordan arc all draw more praise than the courtship does, and 97% of StoryGraph readers mark the cast diverse. Fifth is that it feels cinematic: the phrase “this should be a movie” appears constantly. The trade reviews converge on the same two things, voice and pacing, with Kirkus the only starred review among them. The minority view worth flagging, because it cuts against the main complaint, comes from readers who argue the prom’s absurd scale is deliberate comic exaggeration — the same register as a teen movie, and no more meant literally than one.

What readers argue about and complain about: The premise, above everything. The complaint has a specific mechanism rather than being a vague grumble: readers do not object to a prom-queen plot, they object to the scholarship money, the school’s dedicated gossip platform, and the claim that colleges would care, all of which make Campbell feel like nowhere real. This is the single most reliable dissent theme because it appears in reader reviews and in the starred Kirkus review alike. Second is that conflicts resolve too easily — the Jordan rupture is repaired with an apology reviewers say could not cover it, and the student body’s late change of heart arrives with almost no groundwork. Third is the romance being underbuilt: several readers describe it as insta-love and say Mack never acquires enough interiority to justify the ending, which is a real problem in a book sold as a romance. Fourth is overstuffing — poverty, grief, racism, chronic illness, anxiety and school politics is a lot for 336 pages, and readers who wanted more of Robbie or the grandparents are asking for depth the page count could not give. Fifth, from Kirkus rather than from readers, is that the supporting cast reads as white by default. The genuine split is over the ratings curve itself: with 44% at four stars against 33% at five, this is a book most people finish happy and few people call a favourite, and whether that reads as a disappointment or as a perfectly good time is mostly a question of what you wanted from it.

The standalone question worth asking first: It is a complete standalone with a full HEA and no sequel — nothing further is required or planned. If it works for you, Johnson’s second novel Rise to the Sun (2021) is the natural next step, a dual-POV sapphic romance set at a music festival; it is rated a little lower on Goodreads than this one and readers describe it as quieter and sadder, so go in expecting a shift in register rather than more of the same. Her middle-grade series Ellie Engle Saves Herself is a different audience entirely.

The audiobook is narrated by Alaska Jackson and runs 7 hours 18 minutes from Scholastic Audio, released the same day as the hardcover, and it suits the book — Liz’s present-tense narration is written to be heard, and the runtime makes it an easy single-weekend listen.

Prefer audio? Listen to You Should See Me in a Crown on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does You Should See Me in a Crown have a happy ending?

Yes, a full HEA in the YA register. Liz and Mack reconcile and end the book together, and the crown lands where readers want it to; nothing is left hanging and there is no sequel to wait for.

How spicy is You Should See Me in a Crown?

A 1/5 — kissing only, closed door. The publisher’s ranges run from ages 12 and up to 14 to 18, and no reviewer or content-warning listing flags sexual content of any kind.

Is there a forced outing in the book?

Yes, and it is the central wound of the final act rather than a passing incident. If that is something you need to avoid, this is the content note that matters most in the book.

Was You Should See Me in a Crown a Reese’s Book Club pick?

Yes — the club’s first young adult selection ever, in August 2020. It is also a 2021 Stonewall Honor Book, which is an honour citation rather than the Stonewall Book Award itself.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Alaska Jackson narrates the Scholastic Audio edition, which runs 7 hours 18 minutes and was released alongside the hardcover on 2 June 2020.

Is it a standalone or part of a series?

A standalone. Leah Johnson’s later novel Rise to the Sun is unrelated, set at a music festival with a different cast, so you can read this one and stop.

If You Loved You Should See Me in a Crown, Read These Next

Try She Drives Me Crazy for the same trope engine at the same heat — sapphic high-school rivals thrown together by a scheme neither of them controls; Hani and Ishu’s Guide to Fake Dating for a queer girl of colour negotiating visibility in a mostly white school, with a sharper edge on the racism; and Last Night at the Telegraph Club for the same coming-out arc handled with far more weight, if you want the serious version. More in Contemporary Lesbian Romance and across our Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

You Should See Me in a Crown set out to give a Black queer girl a rom-com instead of a hardship story, and three things carry it: a narrator whose voice earned the book its only starred trade review, an anxiety portrayal readers with anxiety vouch for, and a comic register it holds even while carrying grief, racism and a forced outing. Three things hold it back: a prom premise almost nobody finds credible, conflicts that resolve faster than they were built, and a love interest too lightly drawn to anchor the romance she is supposed to. If you need plausibility you will fight this book for 336 pages; if you want to spend a weekend with a girl who deserves to win and does, it is a very easy yes. Check You Should See Me in a Crown on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

We rank You Should See Me in a Crown at 3.8/5 — a landmark of joyful Black sapphic YA, carried by its narrator rather than by its plot.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ 4.06 average across 43,585 Goodreads ratings
• ✓ 2021 Stonewall Honor Book and a starred Kirkus review
• ✓ First young adult pick in Reese’s Book Club history
• ✓ 44% four-star against 33% five-star ratings

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

• ✓ Rivals-to-lovers setup pays off at the crowning
• ✓ Readers describe it as wholesome and precious
• ✓ Coming out is handled without punishing the heroine
• ✓ Frequently called insta-love; Mack stays underwritten

Characters ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ 92% of StoryGraph readers call the cast loveable
• ✓ 88% report strong character development
• ✓ Jordan and Robbie carry real emotional weight
• ✓ Kirkus notes supporting characters read as white by default

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

• ✓ First-person present tense keeps the anxiety immediate
• ✓ The Horn Book singles out the snarky narration
• ✓ Campbell Confidential screenshots structure the campaign weeks
• ✓ Comic exaggeration strains the setting’s credibility

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ 68% of StoryGraph readers mark it hopeful, 54% inspiring
• ✓ 51% mark it funny and only 3% mark it sad
• ✓ The outing scene lands hard against the comic register
• ✓ Heavier threads resolve too quickly to fully land

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

• ✓ Kissing only, entirely closed door
• ✓ Publisher ranges run from ages 12 up to 14 to 18
• ✓ No romance.io entry, since it is not adult romance
• ✓ No content listing flags sexual content at all

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

• ✓ Full HEA with the crowning scene readers wanted
• ✓ Liz chooses visibility on her own terms
• ✓ No cliffhanger and no sequel required
• ✓ Widely described as predictable and too convenient

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ Short, fast and built as a comfort read
• ✓ 35% of StoryGraph readers mark the pace fast
• ✓ A standard recommendation for readers new to sapphic YA
• ✓ Plot holds few surprises the second time

Affiliate disclosure: the store buttons below are affiliate links (Amazon, Bookshop.org, Libro.fm and Audible). As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, and we may also earn a small commission from the other stores, at no extra cost to you.