What Is She Drives Me Crazy About?
She Drives Me Crazy is a young adult rom-com before it is anything else, and it wears its influences openly: 10 Things I Hate About You, She’s All That, the whole 1990s high-school canon, restaged with two girls. Roaring Brook lists it at ages 12 to 18 and grades 7 to 9, and the register matches — StoryGraph readers mark it 84% lighthearted, 67% funny and 3% tense. It is fast, too: 56% of readers call the pace fast and the book runs 304 pages. Scottie narrates in first person and alone — no dual POV, which matters more than it sounds, because the book’s central problem is that Scottie is wrong about someone and you are stuck inside her being wrong. Irene Abraham is the head cheerleader, Indian American, and introduced through Scottie’s contempt before anything else. Watching that read collapse is the engine of the novel.What Makes This Sapphic YA Rom-Com Work
- Irene: The most-praised element by a wide margin. Readers arrive expecting a mean-girl cheerleader and get someone driven, funny and defended — she argues cheerleading is a sport and she is right — and reviewers routinely say she steals the book from its own narrator.
- The dialogue: Kirkus calls it a page-turner of quippy dialogue and emotional authenticity, and readers agree; the banter is what people quote when they hand this book to someone.
- The healing plot: Scottie’s slow reckoning with what her relationship with Tally actually was is the emotional spine, and it is handled without turning the ex into a cartoon. This is the part adult readers keep saying they did not expect from a YA rom-com.
- The conflict discipline: The third-act problem is real, necessary and resolved by two people talking. Readers who came braced for a manufactured breakup say so with relief.
- The supporting cast: Danielle, Honey-Belle and the rest are given personalities rather than functions, and 96% of StoryGraph readers flag the cast as diverse.
Book Synopsis
Scottie Zajac’s season opens with the worst possible night. Her team loses to her ex-girlfriend’s, in public, and on the way out of the lot she reverses into the car belonging to Irene Abraham — head cheerleader, longtime irritant, and the last person on earth Scottie wants to owe anything to. The repairs will take weeks. Neither of them has another way to school. Out of the carpool comes an idea Scottie is not proud of. If she covers the cost of Irene’s car, Irene will pretend to be her girlfriend until the district championship. Scottie gets to be visibly, enviably fine in front of Tally. Irene gets her car back. Nobody has to mean anything by it. What Scottie has not accounted for is that Irene is not the person she has spent two years assuming she is, that a fake relationship conducted in a small Southern high school is not a private arrangement, and that the thing she is still carrying from her last relationship is not jealousy. The performance keeps working. The trouble is how little of it either of them is performing.My Review
This is the most professionally built sapphic YA romance I have reviewed, and you can feel what a real editorial process buys. The dialogue snaps, the pacing never sags, the supporting cast is populated rather than sketched, and the emotional arc — Scottie figuring out that being wronged did not make her right — is structured rather than announced. Four trade outlets reviewed it positively and Booklist starred it, and unlike most of what gets reviewed here, that shows on the page.
Irene is the achievement. The book sets her up as a stock antagonist and then makes the reader do exactly what Scottie does — revise, apologise internally, fall for her. Readers name her as their favourite character far more often than the narrator, which in a first-person novel is either a flaw or a deliberate design. Here it is design. The ex is handled well too: Tally is not a villain, she is someone Scottie was not good with, which is harder and truer to write.
Where it struggles is the premise, and this is not a fringe complaint — it is the single most repeated criticism in the negative reviews. Scottie does not ask Irene to fake-date her; she leverages a car she damaged into a public relationship that outs Irene to their entire school, for Scottie’s benefit. Once the feelings turn real, readers say, the book stops examining the transaction. Around that sits a dispute about the label: the marketing says enemies-to-lovers, and a large group of readers argue only Scottie is anyone’s enemy. Two independent blog reviewers I read say the label fits — this one really does split.
Smaller complaints recur too: Scottie’s narration reads as judgmental to a meaningful minority, the word “lesbian” is barely used despite both leads being lesbians, and the basketball is thinner than a sports romance implies.
One expectation to reset: this is a middle-school-shelf YA romance — ages 12 to 18, grade 7 to 9, closed door. Adults read and love it, and the reviews are full of them. But if you found this book through the sapphic-romance recommendation pipeline expecting anything in the register of Tryst Six Venom, which runs a comparable high-school rivalry, you are about to read a very different book.
My honest note: A genuinely excellent rom-com with a first act you have to be willing to forgive, on behalf of a narrator the book fully intends you to judge. If a heroine behaving badly and never quite being called out for the worst of it will spoil a book for you, this will spoil; if you can hold that open, it earns nearly everything else.
| Element | In She Drives Me Crazy |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Scottie Zajac & Irene Abraham — basketball player and head cheerleader, fake dating on a paid arrangement |
| Core tropes | Fake dating, enemies-to-lovers, rivals-to-lovers, sports romance, forced proximity, toxic-ex recovery |
| Setting | A Christmas-named Southern small town and its high school, home of the Fighting Reindeer |
| Heat level | 1/5 — closed door, no on-page sex; published for ages 12 to 18 |
| Series | Standalone — complete arc, HEA, no sequel |
| Content notes | Toxic relationship, bullying and homophobia, lesbophobia, being outed, underage drinking, a car accident, brief drug use |
How Spicy Is She Drives Me Crazy?
A 1/5, and worth stating plainly because the sapphic-romance recommendation lists this book appears on rarely mention it. There is no romance.io entry at all — that database indexes adult romance, and this is a young adult novel published for ages 12 and up. What is on the page is kissing and longing. Readers describe the physical content as minimal and the emotional content as the point, and one reviewer went looking for something sensual-but-not-explicit and reported it is not there. Nothing else needs flagging in advance beyond the content notes above — no reviewer I found raises anything more explicit than teenage making out. If you want a comparable low-heat sapphic read, This Is How You Lose the Time War sits in the same 1/5 band and Portrait of a Lady on Fire one step up, though both are considerably more adult in register.Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want a fast funny rom-com you can finish in an afternoon, you like a love interest who outshines the narrator, you want the toxic-ex recovery arc taken seriously, and closed-door romance is a feature rather than a limitation for you. You may want to skip it if: a protagonist coercing someone into being outed is a line for you, you need the enemies in enemies-to-lovers to be mutual, you want a sports romance with actual sport in it, or you have no patience for a judgmental narrator in first person. In short: an expertly made teen rom-com with an ethical knot at its centre that it charms its way past rather than untying.What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)
Five years on, this book is a fixture rather than a moment. It has no current viral cycle and does not need one, and the evidence is unusually concrete: it places in the top three of multiple crowd-compiled sapphic recommendation tallies on Reddit, and turns up across r/wlwbooks, r/YAlit and r/actuallesbians in cover-love threads, fan art and reading logs rather than promotional posts. Institutionally it is the best-credentialed book reviewed on this site: a Booklist star, Publishers Weekly calling it a satisfyingly feminist rom-com mash-up, School Library Journal’s verdict of a breath of fresh air, a Kirkus recommendation, a Goodreads Choice Award nomination and IndieBound bestseller status. Quindlen self-published Her Name in the Sky in 2014 and sold more than 30,000 copies on word of mouth before traditional publishing picked her up, and her 2026 novel This Must Be the Place is sending a new wave of readers back through the backlist. Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Irene, first and most consistently — readers describe falling for her at the same rate Scottie does, and she is named as the favourite character far more often than the narrator is. Then the humour: “laughing in every chapter” is close to a stock phrase here. The healthy-communication modelling gets named explicitly as a reason people hand it to teenagers. The toxic-ex arc draws the most emotional responses, particularly from adult readers who did not expect it. And the 1990s rom-com scaffolding reads as a feature — School Library Journal reaches for She’s All That and 10 Things I Hate About You, and readers do the same unprompted. What readers argue about and complain about: The bribe, above everything. The recurring charge is that Scottie uses a damaged car as leverage to put Irene in a public fake relationship that outs her, and that the book lets the transaction dissolve into romance without answering for it. Second, and closely related: whether “enemies-to-lovers” describes this at all, since many readers argue the animosity is one-directional. This one genuinely divides — blog reviewers tend to say the label fits. Third: Scottie herself, whom a real minority find judgmental for long enough to sour the book. Beyond that: the near-absence of the word “lesbian,” underdeveloped basketball for a sports romance, heavy Christmas theming, dated pop-culture references, and an unresolved thread around Charlotte. The audiobook, narrated by Piper Goodeve across seven hours and four minutes, draws no comparable complaints. The standalone question worth asking first: this is a true standalone with a complete arc and an HEA, and nothing else is required. Quindlen’s other books are separate stories rather than sequels, though This Must Be the Place (2026) is a companion to her debut Her Name in the Sky, which remains her highest-rated book at 4.26. If this one works for you, that is where readers go next.Frequently Asked Questions
Is She Drives Me Crazy spicy?
No. It is a closed-door young adult romance published for ages 12 to 18, with kissing and no on-page sex. Readers consistently describe the physical content as minimal and the emotional content as the focus.Is She Drives Me Crazy a standalone?
Yes. It resolves fully, delivers a happily-ever-after for Scottie and Irene, and has no sequel. Kelly Quindlen’s other novels are separate stories, not continuations.Is She Drives Me Crazy really enemies-to-lovers?
It is disputed. The marketing says so and several reviewers agree, but a large group of readers argue the hostility runs one way — Scottie dislikes Irene, and Irene is largely reacting to that. Expect a rivalry rather than mutual loathing.Is the fake-dating setup problematic?
It is the book’s most-argued element. Scottie leverages a car she damaged to get Irene into a public fake relationship that effectively outs her, and critics say the novel never fully reckons with that once the feelings turn real. Readers who can read it as a flawed teenager making a bad call generally do not mind.Is there an audiobook of She Drives Me Crazy?
Yes — narrated by Piper Goodeve and running seven hours and four minutes. Unlike many dual-cast YA audiobooks, the narration draws no significant complaints in listener reviews.If You Loved She Drives Me Crazy, Read These Next
If what worked was the low-angst engine — no manufactured breakup, conflict resolved by two people talking — Outdrawn runs the same machinery in an adult workplace setting. If it was the high-school rivalry and you want it with real teeth and adult heat, Tryst Six Venom is the same premise turned all the way up. And Roaring Brook sold this book to fans of Casey McQuiston for a reason: One Last Stop has the same warmth and found-family instinct with a decade added to the characters. For more in this register, browse our complete enemies-to-lovers reading list or the full Book Reviews collection.Why It Made Our Lists
She Drives Me Crazy is featured on our Enemies-to-Lovers Lesbian Romance guide.
The Bottom Line
She Drives Me Crazy is the most polished book on this site’s shelf and the one with the sharpest argument attached to it. The dialogue is genuinely funny, Irene is one of the best love interests in sapphic YA, and the recovery-from-a-toxic-relationship arc is handled with more care than the cover promises. It is also built on a coercive bargain it never squarely addresses, narrated by a girl a real share of readers cannot stand, and sold on a label half its audience disputes. Whether that matters depends on how much you need a rom-com premise to hold up under pressure — but as craft, very little in the subgenre is better made. Check She Drives Me Crazy on Amazon →The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, She Drives Me Crazy ranks as a benchmark sapphic YA rom-com — expertly built, warmly funny and trade-endorsed, compromised by a premise it charms past rather than resolves, and best approached for Irene and the dialogue rather than for the rivalry it advertises.The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 3.92 average across 84,000 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Booklist star plus three positive trade reviews
- ✓ Goodreads Choice Award nominee
- ✓ Premise objection never fully answered
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Banter carries the whole middle
- ✓ Fake dating turns real without whiplash
- ✓ No manufactured third-act breakup
- ✓ Hostility runs one direction only
Characters ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ 89% rate character development strong
- ✓ Irene outshines her own narrator
- ✓ Toxic ex written as person, not villain
- ✓ 10% file the leads as complicated
Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Kirkus praises the quippy dialogue
- ✓ Prose casual, conversational, readable
- ✓ Pacing never sags across 304 pages
- ✓ Pop-culture references already dated
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ 48% of readers mark it emotional
- ✓ Toxic-ex recovery arc lands hardest
- ✓ Family and friend group given weight
- ✓ Only 3% of readers found it tense
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ Closed door, no on-page sex
- ✓ Published for ages 12 to 18
- ✓ No romance.io entry exists
- ✓ Readers wanting sensuality report none
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Complete standalone arc and HEA
- ✓ Conflict resolved by conversation
- ✓ Championship and romance land together
- ✓ Charlotte thread closes without consequence
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Readers report immediate rereads
- ✓ Seven-hour audiobook is an easy revisit
- ✓ Top-three fixture on sapphic rec lists
- ✓ Heavy Christmas theming dates the mood
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
15 thoughts on “She Drives Me Crazy Review — Is It Worth Reading?”