This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A warm, funny, genuinely moving YA novel about queer community and a complicated family legacy, undercut by a back half that rushes and a romance that plays second fiddle to the bar.
Best for: Readers who want found family, grief and queer joy more than a slow-building love story, and who can forgive a self-absorbed eighteen-year-old narrator long enough to watch her grow up.
Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — glimpses and kisses)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.7/5 — a 3.91 Goodreads average across roughly 775 ratings, pulled down by a thin romance and a rushed second half)
Tropes: Found family, saving the queer bar, coming of age, grief and legacy, wrong-foot-to-truce, small-town football culture, the coach’s daughter, coming out, queer elders, interconnected standalone.
This Must Be the Place by Kelly Quindlen is a standalone sapphic YA novel from Roaring Brook Press, set over one summer in a football-obsessed small town in Alabama — where freshly out eighteen-year-old Louisa Wade inherits a struggling gay bar from her late great-uncle, and where the girl she keeps colliding with is the daughter of the man who wants it torn down.
It holds a 3.91 average across roughly 775 Goodreads ratings, a 4.0 on StoryGraph, trade reviews from Kirkus and Publishers Weekly, and a Junior Library Guild selection. The response is warm and steady — but the complaints that surface keep circling the same two things. Both are worth knowing before you start.
What Is This Must Be the Place About?
This Must Be the Place is a contemporary coming-of-age novel first and a romance second, and it is marketed accurately on that front — the publisher’s own copy leads with queer joy and found family, not with the love story. The setting is Rustin, Alabama, a college town where football is civic religion, which means the book’s central conflict is not girl-versus-girl but a queer bar versus a town that would rather remember its hometown hero without the inconvenient parts.
Louisa Wade arrives with nothing the job requires: no business experience, no real relationship with the great-uncle who left her the bar, and a very eighteen-year-old certainty about who the good guys are. Aubrey Calhoun, the sharp-tongued, popular daughter of Rustin University’s new head football coach, starts as an obstacle. Louisa narrates in first person throughout, which buys a funny, acerbic voice and costs depth wherever she is not looking.
What Makes This Sapphic YA Coming-of-Age Story Work
- The Frisky Cricket and its people: The bar’s community is the most consistently praised element by a distance. “Found family” turns up in more reader reviews than any other phrase, and the bar’s regulars are at the center of that praise.
- A complicated dead man: Uncle George — football legend, secret bar owner, not a simple hero — is the book’s most interesting idea. Readers repeatedly single out the question of how to remember a flawed person, and one calls the refusal to sanctify him refreshing.
- Humor next to heartbreak: Readers name the mix of laugh-out-loud moments and grief as Quindlen’s signature; StoryGraph tags it emotional (94%), hopeful (60%) and funny (25%).
- Returning faces: Hannah and Baker from Her Name in the Sky reappear as adults, now the queer elders they never had themselves. For longtime Quindlen readers this is the most emotional thread in the book.
- A readable length: At 288 pages it is a fast read — 35% of StoryGraph readers call the pace fast, and only 2% did not finish.
Book Synopsis
Louisa Wade has just graduated, just come out, and just learned that her great-uncle George — Rustin, Alabama’s favorite son, a man whose football career the whole town still talks about — left her something in his will. It is not money. It is The Frisky Cricket, a struggling, beloved gay bar that George apparently owned for years without most of his own family knowing it existed.
Louisa spends the summer in Rustin and decides almost immediately that the bar is going to stay open. Nobody else is quite so sure. George’s grumpy ex-partner, Hatch, would rather sell. The bar is barely solvent, the regulars are wary of a teenager with big convictions, and most of the town would prefer that George be remembered as a gridiron hero, full stop.
Then there is Aubrey Calhoun, the coach’s daughter, who is pretty, popular and quick with a cutting remark, and who gets on Louisa’s nerves from their first meeting. A wary truce turns into late nights and confidences neither of them expected to share. But Aubrey’s father has plans for the land the Frisky Cricket stands on: a new athletic facility that would honor George’s football career and quietly erase everything else about him. Louisa has to work out how far she will go to fight for a man she barely knew — and whether winning that fight is worth what it might cost the people she is starting to care about.
My Review
What this book does best is make a place feel like it matters. The Frisky Cricket is not a backdrop; it is a character with a history, a clientele and a threat hanging over it, and Quindlen writes the regulars with enough affection that by the midpoint you are invested in a bar you have never been to. The premise is strong, and the book uses it to ask a real question about legacy rather than just staging a save-the-venue plot.
The second strength is the adults. Hatch, Louisa’s father, and George himself — seen only through what he left behind — are drawn in more shades than a YA novel usually bothers with, and one reader who rated it 3.5 stars says outright that they were more nuanced than Louisa. The return of Hannah and Baker from Her Name in the Sky gives the book a quiet, generational weight: two women who had to come out with no support are now the support. For longtime readers, that is the emotional core.
Where it struggles is structure. The most repeated complaint, even in positive reviews, is that it is too short for what it attempts: one reader says the pace turns blistering after a strong opening and wanted another 50 to 100 pages, another says the relationships with Louisa’s father and grandparents never get enough room for the ending to fully land, and a third found the turn from friction to feelings with Aubrey rushed. The second is Louisa herself — self-absorbed and black-and-white, grating to some, realistic to others. Third, even a five-star reviewer calls the villains caricatures.
One expectation to reset: this is marketed as a YA romance “sizzling with chemistry,” and on the page it is a coming-of-age novel with a romance in it. One enthusiastic reader warns plainly that it is not a romance; Publishers Weekly calls the chemistry somewhat spare. If the love story is what drew you, calibrate. If you came for community and grief, it is right on target.
My honest note: A big-hearted book about why queer spaces matter, told a little too fast. If you need the romance at the center, you may feel short-changed. If you want to find a family in a bar in Alabama for a summer, this is the place.
| Element | In This Must Be the Place |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Louisa Wade & Aubrey Calhoun — freshly out bar heir and the football coach’s sharp-tongued daughter, wrong-foot-to-truce |
| Core tropes | Found family, saving the queer bar, coming of age, grief and legacy, coach’s daughter, queer elders |
| Setting | Rustin, Alabama — a football-obsessed college town, and The Frisky Cricket, its struggling gay bar |
| Heat level | 1/5 — glimpses and kisses |
| Series | Standalone, sharing a world with Her Name in the Sky — reading that first is optional |
| Content notes | Homophobia, grief and the death of a family member, outing, deadnaming, alcohol and underage drinking, a fire, cancer, racism |
How Spicy Is This Must Be the Place?
A 1/5. romance.io lists it at its lowest steam band, “glimpses and kisses,” and that matches both the publisher’s 14-to-18 reading age and what readers describe: kissing, late-night talks and a mutual coming-out scene that one reviewer says had them grinning in a coffee shop. There are no sex scenes. This is a closed-door YA novel, and the score is a description, not a criticism.
The thing worth flagging is not spice but intensity of a different kind: StoryGraph readers list graphic homophobia, grief and outing as the major content notes, and one reader thought it sketchy that adults helped the eighteen-year-olds get around drinking laws. Beyond that, no reviewer flags anything unexpected. If you want the same closed-door register, Quindlen’s own She Drives Me Crazy and Jennifer Dugan’s Girls Like Us both sit at 1/5.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: found family is your favorite trope, you want a book about why queer spaces matter, you have read Her Name in the Sky and want to see Hannah and Baker grown up, and you like grief handled with humor.
You may want to skip it if: you need the romance to be the main event, a self-righteous teenage narrator wears you out, you want slow, fully developed family arcs, or you prefer antagonists with more than one dimension.
In short: a generous, emotional community story with a sweet but secondary romance, told at a speed that leaves some of its best threads underfed.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
There is no viral moment to report, and I could not check Reddit or BookTok from here, so I cannot say whether it has an organic social footprint. What it has instead is a full trade launch: a Kirkus review calling it a love letter to the queer communities of the South, a Publishers Weekly review, a Junior Library Guild selection, and author blurbs from Becky Albertalli, Julian Winters, Kit Rosewater and Jen St. Jude on the Amazon listing. Many early reviews came through NetGalley, and ratings have built steadily since — plus a 4.5 from 47 Amazon ratings, which runs high as usual. The author’s name is doing much of the work: She Drives Me Crazy sits at 3.92 across 84,600 Goodreads ratings, and at least one reviewer says her name on the cover is all it takes.
The audiobook arrived the same day as the hardcover from Macmillan Audio, narrated by Piper Goodeve and running 8 hours 47 minutes. Kirkus reviewed the audio separately and praised how Goodeve captures Louisa’s conflicted feelings and differentiates the cast; at least one listener says they would happily hear her read YA sapphic romance indefinitely.
Prefer audio? Listen to This Must Be the Place on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The community, first and most consistently — “found family” is the recurring phrase, and one reader lists the safe spaces, the pride parties and the bar’s mechanical bull as exactly what they loved. Then the emotion: StoryGraph readers tag it emotional at 94%, and multiple reviewers report crying. Then Uncle George’s complicated legacy, and the full-circle return of Hannah and Baker. StoryGraph readers are also unusually positive about character work — 87% say it has strong character development and 83% call the cast lovable — which is notable, because Louisa’s personality is also one of the main complaints.
What readers argue about and complain about: Length and pacing, above everything. Readers who liked the book still say it needed more room: a back half that races, family relationships that stay sketched, and an Aubrey turn that outpaces its setup. Louisa is the second theme — self-absorbed, bratty, seeing the world in black and white — and here opinion genuinely divides between readers who find her grating and those who say that is the point of her arc. Third: the villains and some of the parents read as caricatures, which is interesting, because Kirkus says the opposite about the supporting cast. Fourth, the romance itself — Publishers Weekly finds the chemistry spare, and readers call it sweet but secondary. At least one Her Name in the Sky fan also found Hannah and Baker thinner than hoped.
The standalone question worth asking first: it is complete in one volume, and the Frisky Cricket plot resolves by the end. You do not need to have read Her Name in the Sky, though readers who have get more out of the Hannah and Baker scenes. If you want more Quindlen afterwards, Her Name in the Sky is her highest-rated book at 4.26 across 17,500 Goodreads ratings and She Drives Me Crazy is the most-read at 3.92, a much lighter rom-com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is This Must Be the Place a romance?
Partly. It is a YA coming-of-age novel with a sapphic romance running through it, and the bar, the community and Louisa’s grief take up more of the page than the love story. Publishers Weekly calls the chemistry somewhat spare, and at least one reader warns plainly that it is not a romance.
How spicy is This Must Be the Place?
A 1/5. romance.io rates it “glimpses and kisses,” its lowest band, and the publisher lists it for ages 14 to 18. There are kisses and emotional intimacy, but no sex scenes.
Do I need to read Her Name in the Sky first?
No. This Must Be the Place is a standalone, but Hannah and Baker from Her Name in the Sky appear as adults, and readers who know them get more from those scenes. One reviewer felt the book never quite settles how much it expects you to know about them.
Is there an audiobook?
Yes. Macmillan Audio released it on May 26, 2026, narrated by Piper Goodeve and running 8 hours 47 minutes. Kirkus praised the narration for capturing Louisa’s conflicted feelings and giving the supporting cast distinct voices.
What are the content warnings?
StoryGraph readers flag homophobia, grief and outing as the major ones, with death, alcohol and a fire as moderate, and cancer, deadnaming and racism as minor. The book also depicts underage drinking.
If You Loved This Must Be the Place, Read These Next
Readers coming from Quindlen’s backlist land most often on She Drives Me Crazy, which puts the romance at the center and swaps the grief for a rivals rom-com. For a YA story about a queer teen taking on her small town’s biggest institution, You Should See Me in a Crown runs the same underdog engine through prom instead of a bar. And if the character-first, slightly older YA voice is what you liked, Girls Like Us follows a first-year relationship with the same closed-door heat. For another book where a lesbian bar is the heart of the story, see our guide to books like Last Night at the Telegraph Club.
For more in this register, browse our lesbian YA books guide or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
This Must Be the Place has a heart bigger than its page count. The Frisky Cricket is a genuinely lovable setting, Uncle George’s complicated legacy gives it a real question to chew on, and the return of Hannah and Baker lands with quiet force. It is also rushed in its second half, thin on romance for a book sold on chemistry, and willing to let its villains stay flat. Whether that trade works depends on what you came for — but the reader who wants found family, queer history and a good cry will get a complete, hopeful book in under 300 pages. Check This Must Be the Place on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, This Must Be the Place ranks as a big-hearted traditionally published sapphic YA community novel — emotionally generous and funny, held back by pacing and a secondary romance, and best approached for the found family rather than the love story.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ 3.91 average across 775 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Only 2% did-not-finish on StoryGraph
- ✓ Kirkus, PW and a JLG selection
- ✓ Too short for everything it attempts
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Sweet, banter-driven moments land
- ✓ Mutual coming-out scene a highlight
- ✓ Coach’s-daughter stakes add tension
- ✓ PW calls the chemistry spare
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 87% of StoryGraph readers cite strong development
- ✓ Hatch, George and Dad drawn in shades
- ✓ Hannah and Baker return as elders
- ✓ Louisa divides; villains read as caricatures
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Acerbic first-person voice praised by PW
- ✓ Humor sits comfortably beside grief
- ✓ Southern setting detail Kirkus singles out
- ✓ Back half races past its material
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Tagged emotional by 94% on StoryGraph
- ✓ Multiple readers report crying
- ✓ Queer legacy question genuinely resonates
- ✓ Family arcs too sketched to fully pay off
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ romance.io: glimpses and kisses
- ✓ Publisher reading age 14 to 18
- ✓ Closed door throughout
- ✓ Heavier on homophobia than on heat
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Complete standalone, nothing left hanging
- ✓ Tagged hopeful by 60% on StoryGraph
- ✓ Frisky Cricket plot closes in one volume
- ✓ At least one reader disliked the wrap-up
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Short enough for an easy return
- ✓ Audiobook is a strong second pass
- ✓ Sends readers back to Her Name in the Sky
- ✓ Underfed threads limit the payoff
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.