Ellie Engle Saves Herself Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A warm, funny middle grade superhero story about a Black girl who can bring things back to life and a crush on her best friend she hasn’t said out loud, held back by powers that get less page time than the cover suggests and a crowded set of themes.

Best for: Readers aged about 9 to 13 (and the adults who buy for them) who want a queer first-crush story inside a gentle superhero plot, and who care more about friendship and self-worth than about action set pieces.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: middle grade, a crush and nothing more)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.9/5: a 4.08 Goodreads average across about 990 ratings and two starred trade reviews, trimmed for a recurring complaint that the magic takes a back seat)

Tropes: Superpower origin story, best-friend crush, queer awakening, sudden fame, friendship growing apart, single-parent home, found family, small town.

Ellie Engle Saves Herself is Leah Johnson’s first book for middle grade readers, published by Disney-Hyperion in May 2023 and now the first book in her Ellie Engle series: a contemporary magical coming-of-age novel set in a small town, where a quiet twelve-year-old who would rather stay in her loud best friend’s shadow wakes up after an earthquake able to raise the dead with a touch.

On Goodreads it holds a 4.08 average across roughly 990 ratings, and StoryGraph readers rate it a little higher at 4.19. The trade reception was stronger still: starred reviews from Kirkus and School Library Journal, a place on Kirkus’s best of 2023 and a Lambda Literary shortlist. The low-star reviews are few, but they agree with each other about one thing, and it’s worth knowing before you hand this to a kid who wants a superhero book.

What Is Ellie Engle Saves Herself About?

It’s middle grade, which means ages 8 to 12 on the publisher’s label, short chapters, a first-person narrator who is twelve, and stakes that are mostly about school, family and friendship. The superpower is real and it matters, but the book uses it the way a lot of good middle grade does: as pressure on a kid who was already working through something else.

Ellie Engle is Black, loves comics, works weekends at an old man’s bakery and lives with her mom, who works long hours since Ellie’s dad moved away. Her best friend Abby Ortega is the bold one, always chasing a way to “make her mark,” and Ellie is happy being the sidekick. She’s also starting to realize her feelings for Abby are more than friendship. The whole book is Ellie’s voice, so you get her jokes, her comic-book frame of reference and her worry, all at the same volume.

What Makes This Sapphic Middle Grade Fantasy Work

  • Ellie’s voice: The single most praised thing in the reviews. Readers call her funny, nerdy, lovable and real, and 92% of StoryGraph reviewers marked the characters as loveable.
  • The crush, handled lightly: Ellie’s feelings for Abby are named and treated as normal, with no coming-out crisis attached. Reviewers who mention it are glad it’s there and glad it doesn’t take over.
  • A power with a cost: Bringing things back to life sounds like a gift until the whole town, then the internet, wants a piece of it. Two Goodreads readers compare the premise to Pushing Daisies, and the comparison fits the book’s mix of sweet and strange.
  • Friendship that changes: The Abby storyline is about a friendship that may not be as equal as Ellie thinks. StoryGraph readers flag “toxic friendship” as a moderate warning, which tells you the book doesn’t let Abby off easy.
  • Grown-up recognition: Two starred trade reviews, a Kirkus best-of slot, a Bank Street star and a Lambda shortlist. For a parent or librarian, that’s a strong signal the book does what it sets out to do.

Book Synopsis

Ellie Engle has a system. She stays in the background, lets Abby do the talking, and spends her free time with comics and her pet fish, or at Mr. Walker’s bakery on the weekends. Seventh grade is coming, Abby has big plans for both of them, and Ellie has a secret she hasn’t even fully told herself: she likes Abby. Like that.

Then a freak earthquake rattles their town, and Ellie wakes up different. When she touches something that has died, it comes back. She tries to keep it quiet, but someone films her using the power, the video spreads, and within days there are reporters outside her house and strangers asking for miracles. A famous pop star wants Ellie to perform her gift on live television. Her mom is scared. Her classmates suddenly know her name. And Abby, who has always wanted to be noticed, has to watch Ellie become the one everybody is looking at.

Ellie has always believed she is the ordinary one. Now she has a power that could help people, a life that has stopped being hers, and a best friend she’s not sure she can trust with how she feels. The question the book keeps asking isn’t whether she can save the world. It’s whether she can stand up for herself.

My Review

The best thing here is Ellie, and it isn’t close. Johnson writes a twelve-year-old who is funny without being a joke machine, anxious without being miserable, and smart about comics in a way that tells you how she sees herself: always the sidekick, never the hero. That frame pays off. The book is built so that the superhero question and the self-worth question turn out to be the same question.

Ellie Engle Saves Herself by Leah Johnson book cover

The second strength is how it treats Abby. A weaker book would make the crush the whole story and Abby the prize. This one lets Ellie slowly notice that a friendship where you’re always the one adjusting isn’t a great friendship. One Goodreads reviewer says outright that Abby would be “dead to me,” and while that’s a bit much, it shows the book lands the point. The queer part is gentle and matter-of-fact. Nobody makes Ellie’s feelings a tragedy, and that’s exactly what a lot of younger readers need.

Where it struggles is the thing the low-star reviews keep coming back to: the powers. More than one reader says Ellie barely uses them, or that it’s really a coming-of-age story with a dash of magic. Another says the book takes on too many themes at once (fame, divorce, grief, ableism, a crush, a changing friendship) and only skims some of them. One reader felt the voice sometimes sounded like an adult trying to talk like a kid. None of these are loud. Only about 4% of Goodreads ratings are one or two stars. But they line up, and they line up on the same gap.

That gap is mostly marketing. The cover and the “saves herself” title promise a superhero romp. What you get is closer to a quiet realistic novel that happens to include resurrection. If your reader wants action, set expectations first. If your reader wants a kid like them who learns her feelings are allowed, you’re in the right place.

My honest note: A big-hearted, very well-voiced middle grade novel that’s more about friendship than fighting. Hand it to the kid who reads for characters, and warn the one who reads for powers.

ElementIn Ellie Engle Saves Herself
Central relationshipEllie Engle and her best friend Abby Ortega: an unspoken first crush inside a friendship that’s shifting
Core tropesSuperpower origin, best-friend crush, sudden fame, friendship growing apart, single-parent home
SettingA small town hit by a freak earthquake, then a media circus
Heat level1/5: middle grade, a crush only
SeriesEllie Engle book 1; resolves on its own. Bree Boyd Is a Legend (2025) follows a friend
Content notesBullying, ableism, death and grief, animal death (and revival), a toxic friendship, homophobia, abandonment by a parent, panic attacks

How Spicy Is Ellie Engle Saves Herself?

It isn’t, and it shouldn’t be. This is a middle grade book for readers aged 8 to 12, so the heat score is a 1/5 by definition. romance.io catalogs adult romance, and I couldn’t get past its bot check from here anyway, so the number comes from the publisher’s age range and what reviewers describe on the page: a crush, some nervous feelings, and no kissing that any reviewer mentions.

The thing to know in advance isn’t romance at all. StoryGraph readers list bullying, ableism and death as the heavier warnings, with animal death and grief close behind, because a book about raising the dead has to deal with the dead. Nothing I found suggests anything graphic for this age group. If you want another gentle sapphic story for younger readers, The Girl from the Sea is a little older and also low heat.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want a queer middle grade book where the crush is normal, you like funny first-person narrators, you care more about friendship than fight scenes, you’re looking for a Black girl hero for a young reader.

You may want to skip it if: you want a superhero book with real action, a lot of themes in one story feels thin to you, a friend who treats the hero badly will make you furious, you need the romance to go somewhere.

In short: It’s a character book wearing a cape, and it’s very good at being a character book.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a book that grown-ups found first. The trade coverage is unusually strong for middle grade: a starred Kirkus review, a starred School Library Journal review calling it “joyful and magical,” a Kirkus best of 2023 pick, an SLJ best book of the year, a Chicago Public Library best-of nod, a Bank Street star and a Lambda Literary shortlist for LGBTQ+ middle grade. Leah Johnson’s site also lists it on the ALA Rainbow List top ten. That’s how it reaches kids: through libraries, teachers and award lists rather than any viral moment. I couldn’t reach Reddit from here, so I can’t say what’s being discussed there.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Ellie, first and most. “Relatable,” “nerdy” and “adorable” keep coming up, and StoryGraph readers pick hopeful (68%) and funny (66%) as the top moods, with 95% saying the character development is strong. The second thing readers name is how warm it is: one calls it a warm hug in a book, another says the writing feels like home. Third, the queer representation for this age group, which adult reviewers single out, one of them in the context of book bans. The Pushing Daisies comparison shows up more than once and it’s a fair shorthand.

What readers argue about and complain about: First, the magic. The most common complaint in the low-star reviews is that Ellie hardly uses her powers, or that the premise promises more than the book delivers. Second, scope: one reader felt it took on too many themes and couldn’t go deep on any. Third, voice: a minority finds Ellie’s narration sounds older than twelve, though most readers say the opposite. The Abby question splits people. Some think the book is too soft on her, others think watching Ellie slowly see the problem is the point.

The series question everyone should ask first: Ellie’s story wraps up here, so there’s no cliffhanger to worry about. The sequel, Bree Boyd Is a Legend, came out in March 2025 and moves the spotlight to Ellie’s friend Bree, who gets her own powers after a lightning strike. Kirkus called it “a charming tale of personal growth.” If your reader loves Ellie, she’s still around, but it’s Bree’s book.

The audiobook is narrated by Rocky Anicette, and the edition I found runs 6 hours and 17 minutes, a good length for a car trip or a family listen.

Prefer audio? Listen to Ellie Engle Saves Herself on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ellie Engle Saves Herself a sapphic book?

Yes. Ellie has a crush on her best friend Abby, and the book treats it as a normal part of growing up. There’s no romance plot beyond the crush, which fits the middle grade age range.

What age is Ellie Engle Saves Herself for?

The publisher lists it for ages 8 to 12, grades 3 to 7. Ellie is twelve, and the heavier topics are bullying, grief, death and a friendship that turns unkind.

Is Ellie Engle Saves Herself part of a series?

Yes. It’s book 1 of the Ellie Engle series, but it stands alone. The second book, Bree Boyd Is a Legend, came out in March 2025 and follows Ellie’s friend Bree.

Does Ellie use her powers a lot?

Less than some readers expect. The power drives the plot, but much of the book is about friendship, fame and family, and that’s the most common complaint in the low-star reviews.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Rocky Anicette narrates, and the edition on Libro.fm runs about 6 hours and 17 minutes.

If You Loved Ellie Engle Saves Herself, Read These Next

For the author’s YA side, You Should See Me in a Crown is Leah Johnson’s prom-queen romance for older teens, with the same funny, big-hearted voice. The Girl from the Sea is a gentle graphic novel about a first crush with a magical twist, aimed a few years older. And Labyrinth Lost is the next step up: a YA story where a girl’s magic and her feelings for her best friend collide. More picks for this age group are on our sapphic middle grade books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

Ellie Engle Saves Herself sets out to tell a superhero story about a kid who doesn’t think she deserves to be the hero. The voice works, the crush is handled with care, and the friendship plot has real teeth. The magic is thinner than the cover suggests, the theme list is long, and a reader hungry for action may drift. For a young reader who wants to see a girl like her figure out that her feelings and her space in the world both count, it’s an easy recommendation. Check Ellie Engle Saves Herself on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Ellie Engle Saves Herself ranks as a top-shelf queer middle grade novel. It’s carried by its narrator and its honest friendship story. It’s best read as a coming-of-age book with magic in it, not as a superhero adventure.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ 4.08 average across about 990 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 4.19 on StoryGraph from 435 reviews
  • ✓ Starred by Kirkus and School Library Journal
  • ✓ Low-star reviews say the powers are underused

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ First crush named and treated as normal
  • ✓ No coming-out crisis attached
  • ✓ Fits the 8 to 12 age range
  • ✓ Crush stays a crush, no romance arc

Characters ★★★★☆ 4.4/5

  • ✓ Ellie is the most praised thing in reviews
  • ✓ 95% of StoryGraph readers say strong development
  • ✓ Abby written with real flaws
  • ✓ Some readers find side characters thin

Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Funny, warm first-person voice
  • ✓ Short chapters suit younger readers
  • ✓ Comic-book frame carries the theme
  • ✓ A minority hears an adult behind the voice

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4.2/5

  • ✓ Self-worth story lands with readers
  • ✓ Grief and an absent parent handled gently
  • ✓ Top StoryGraph moods: hopeful and funny
  • ✓ Many themes, some only skimmed

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Middle grade, ages 8 to 12
  • ✓ A crush and nothing more
  • ✓ No kissing reported by reviewers
  • ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ Ellie’s arc resolves in this book
  • ✓ No cliffhanger
  • ✓ Sequel moves on to Bree
  • ✓ Friendship thread wraps up quickly for some

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Voice holds up on a second read
  • ✓ 6 hour 17 minute audiobook for family listening
  • ✓ Sequel keeps the world open
  • ✓ Readers wanting action may not return

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

3 thoughts on “Ellie Engle Saves Herself Review: Is It Worth Reading?”

Leave a Comment