Labyrinth Lost Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A loud, colorful bruja quest with a family worth fighting for and one of the earliest bisexual love triangles in mainstream YA fantasy, held back by a love interest who never gets a real personality and a middle that sags.

Best for: Teen and adult readers who want Latin American magic, sisters and a strange underworld, and who can live with a romance that stays in the back seat and a heroine who is hard work for the first hundred pages.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: YA, kisses only)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5: a 3.71 Goodreads average across about 14,700 ratings, a starred trade review, and a steady pile of readers who wanted more from Rishi and from the middle third)

Tropes: Portal fantasy, witches and family magic, bisexual love triangle, best friends to lovers, reluctant chosen one, quest to save the family, mysterious bad boy, sisters, underworld journey, Brooklyn setting.

Labyrinth Lost is the first book in Zoraida Córdova’s Brooklyn Brujas trilogy, published by Sourcebooks Fire in 2016: a YA fantasy that starts in a Brooklyn house full of altars and dead relatives and then drops its heroine into Los Lagos, an in-between world, after the girl who hates her own magic tries to cast it out and loses her whole family instead.

It sits at 3.71 on Goodreads across roughly 14,700 ratings, and it picked up a starred review from School Library Journal plus warm coverage in the New York Times Book Review and on NPR’s best-of list for 2016. That’s a respectable record for a debut series opener. But the reader reviews are split more sharply than that average suggests, and the split runs along two characters, not along the magic. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Labyrinth Lost About?

This is YA urban fantasy for its first quarter and portal fantasy after that. The Brooklyn chapters are about family obligation: Alex Mortiz comes from a line of brujas and brujos, and her Deathday, the ceremony where a bruja accepts her powers, is meant to be the biggest night of her life. Los Lagos is where the book turns into a quest, with a map, a ticking clock and a run of creatures that want to eat, trick or keep her.

Alex is sixteen, angry and scared. Her father vanished when she was a kid and she blames magic for it, so she’d rather have none. Two people follow her into Los Lagos. Rishi is her best friend from school, a non-magical girl she’s half in love with. Nova is a brujo with a bad reputation who offered to help her get rid of her powers in the first place and clearly wants something for it. The book is told only from Alex’s first-person point of view, which keeps you close to her fear and her guilt but also means Rishi only exists through Alex’s eyes. That turns out to matter.

What Makes This YA Bruja Fantasy Work

  • The family magic: The single most praised thing in the reviews. Readers single out the altars, the dead relatives at the dinner table, the Book of Cantos and a magic system drawn from Latin American and Ecuadorian tradition rather than a generic wizard school.
  • Los Lagos: The underworld is weird in a good way. The comparison readers reach for again and again is Alice in Wonderland, with Pan’s Labyrinth a close second, and the Lambda Literary review called the world-building the place where the book’s beauty lies.
  • The sisters: Alex, Lula and Rose read like real siblings who fight and protect each other. Several reviewers say the family bond is what kept them reading, and it’s what the next two books are built on.
  • Bisexual representation without a coming-out arc: Alex is bisexual and the book doesn’t make that the problem. Reviewers who had wanted a bi heroine doing something other than coming out were the happiest readers in the pile.
  • Speed: On StoryGraph, 39% of readers call the pace fast and 54% medium, and 95% tag it adventurous. The first act moves.

Book Synopsis

Alex Mortiz is an encantrix, the rarest and strongest kind of bruja, and she would give it all back if she could. Magic took her father. Magic makes her family strange in a neighborhood where she’d like to be ordinary. Magic is also about to get a party thrown in its honor, because her Deathday is coming and the whole family, living and dead, is expected to show up.

Alex has a plan. Nova, a brujo with a past nobody in her family likes, tells her there’s a canto that can undo a bruja’s power. She uses it during the ceremony. It doesn’t take her power away. It takes her family. Her mother, her sisters and her ancestors vanish into Los Lagos, a realm between life and death ruled by a creature called the Devourer, and Alex is the only one left on this side of the door.

So she goes in after them. Rishi, who saw too much to be sent home, insists on coming. Nova comes too, because he knows the way and because he has his own reasons for being there. Los Lagos is full of things that talk, bargain and bite, and every stop costs something. Alex has to decide how far she trusts the boy who got her into this, what she feels for the girl who followed her, and whether the power she tried to throw away is the only thing that can bring her family home.

My Review

The best thing about Labyrinth Lost is the house in Brooklyn. The kitchen with consecrated dirt next to the condiments, the bones in velvet pouches, the dead aunts who turn up for the party. Córdova builds a family that already has a whole religion running in the background, and you believe it before anything magical happens on the page. That’s rare in YA fantasy and it’s why the book still gets recommended ten years on.

Labyrinth Lost by Zoraida Córdova book cover

Los Lagos is the second strength and it’s a different kind of fun. It’s a funhouse version of the underworld, with bargains, talking creatures and a few set pieces that are creepier than you’d expect from the cover. StoryGraph readers tag it dark almost a third of the time. I’d call it eerie more than grim, and it’s the part readers compare to Wonderland so often that the comparison has stopped being a compliment and started being a description.

Where it struggles, the reviews agree with each other more than they agree on anything else. The most repeated complaint is Rishi. Readers who were thrilled to get a bi love triangle with a girl in it still say she’s there to be devoted and not much else. One blog reviewer kept waiting for a twist or a reveal about her and got more devotion instead, and a lot of the three-star reviews land on the same point from different angles. Nova, the boy with secrets, gets the layered backstory, and several readers admit they ended up rooting for him for exactly that reason. That’s a problem when the book wants you to root for the girl.

The second complaint is Alex herself, especially early on. She lies to her family, sulks and makes the catastrophic decision the plot needs, and a noticeable group of readers call her bratty or unlikeable. Others say that’s the point and she earns her way out of it. I land closer to the second group, but the first fifty pages ask for patience. The third complaint is pace in the middle: the quest structure turns into stop, creature, escape, repeat, and a few readers say they had trouble picking it back up. Two readers call the climax rushed.

The expectation to reset is the romance. The marketing leans on the bisexual love triangle, and it’s real, but this is a family rescue story with a crush running alongside it. If you came for a sapphic YA romance, calibrate. If you came for brujas and a big strange world, you’re in the right place.

My honest note: A great family and a great underworld, with a romance that’s thinner than its reputation. Read it for Alex’s family and Los Lagos, not for Rishi, and you’ll probably want the sequel.

ElementIn Labyrinth Lost
Central relationshipAlex Mortiz and Rishi, best friends to girlfriends, with Nova as the third point of a bisexual love triangle
Core tropesPortal fantasy, family magic, reluctant chosen one, love triangle, quest to rescue family
SettingBrooklyn, then Los Lagos, a realm between the living and the dead
Heat level1/5: YA, kissing only
SeriesBrooklyn Brujas book 1 of 3: the rescue resolves, the series is complete, books 2 and 3 follow Alex’s sisters
Content notesDeath and violence, animal death, blood, grief, abandonment by a parent; minor mentions of child abuse, self-harm and bullying (StoryGraph reader warnings)

How Spicy Is Labyrinth Lost?

Not at all. This is a YA novel published for ages 14 and up, and romance.io has no entry for it, which is normal for young adult titles because that database catalogs adult romance. What’s on the page, by every reader account I found, is a few kisses and a lot of longing. The age range on the Amazon listing is 14 to 17, and nothing in the reviews suggests anything beyond that.

The thing worth flagging isn’t heat, it’s darkness. StoryGraph readers list death, violence and animal death as graphic, with blood, grief and abandonment at a moderate level, and the underworld chapters have some creepy bodies and bargains in them. If you liked the tone of This Poison Heart or Girl, Serpent, Thorn, both also closed door, this sits in the same band.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want magic rooted in a real culture and a real family, you like portal fantasy with strange creatures and bargains, you’re happy for the romance to be a subplot, and you’re looking for a bisexual heroine whose sexuality isn’t the conflict.

You may want to skip it if: you need the love interest to be as developed as the hero, you get frustrated with heroines who make the bad choice on purpose, you want a romance-led book with a clear HEA as the point, or episodic quest middles make you put a book down.

In short: Come for the brujas and the underworld, and treat the love triangle as a bonus.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

There’s no new viral moment driving this book. Labyrinth Lost is a 2016 title with steady backlist life: around 14,700 Goodreads ratings and nearly 2,900 written reviews, 5,822 StoryGraph reviews, and roughly 1,200 ratings on Amazon. It reached readers the traditional way. School Library Journal gave it a starred review and called it a must-have for teens, the New York Times Book Review called it giddily exciting, Publishers Weekly, Booklist and Kirkus all reviewed it, and the author lists it as an NPR best YA book of 2016. It shows up constantly on Latine and bisexual YA reading lists, and that’s where most new readers seem to find it now.

There’s a full audiobook from Recorded Books, narrated by Almarie Guerra, at 9 hours 28 minutes. I didn’t find enough listener comment on the narration to say whether audio improves the middle, so I won’t claim it does.

Prefer audio? Listen to Labyrinth Lost on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The culture and the family come first, and it isn’t close. The Latin American magic and the sisters are the two things the five-star reviews name every time. The Wonderland comparison is the recurring note on the world, sometimes with Orpheus and Eurydice thrown in. Bisexual readers praise Alex for being bi without that being her storyline. And a smaller group, worth hearing, says Alex’s growth from selfish to brave is the whole point and the early brattiness is earned.

What readers argue about and complain about: Rishi, above everything. Readers keep saying she’s underwritten and exists to support Alex, and a striking number of them prefer Nova as a character even when they wanted the girl to win. Alex’s early behavior is the second theme, with words like bratty, annoying and selfish turning up across several independent reviews. Third: the middle. A cluster of readers say the quest dragged and they had trouble wanting to pick the book back up, and two call the ending rushed or anticlimactic. Fourth, and quieter: a couple of reviewers call it a standard YA quest with familiar beats once you look past the setting. BookPage’s own review noted some awkward passages, which matches what a minority of readers say about the prose. The genuine split is the triangle itself. Some readers call it tired; others say a bi triangle with a girl on one side was exactly what they’d been asking for.

The series question everyone should ask first: Good news here. The trilogy is finished. Labyrinth Lost resolves the rescue plot and settles Alex’s romance, though a late twist sets up the next book. Bruja Born (2018) follows her sister Lula and sits higher on Goodreads at 3.95 across about 4,000 ratings, and Wayward Witch (2020) follows Rose at 3.90 across about 1,900. Both sequels rate better than the opener, which is the useful fact: if book one’s middle loses you but the family hooks you, the series improves. Be aware that Alex isn’t the narrator of books two and three.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Labyrinth Lost a sapphic book?

Partly. Alex is bisexual and the book features a love triangle between her, her best friend Rishi and a boy named Nova, and the romance resolves with a girl. The romance is a subplot to a family rescue quest, though, so don’t expect a romance-led book.

How spicy is Labyrinth Lost?

It’s a 1/5. It’s YA published for ages 14 and up, with kissing only, and romance.io has no listing for it because it isn’t catalogued as adult romance.

Does Labyrinth Lost end on a cliffhanger?

No. The main quest resolves and the romance is settled, but a final twist sets up the sequel. Publishers Weekly noted that twist would leave readers eager for more.

Is the Brooklyn Brujas series complete?

Yes. The trilogy finished with Wayward Witch in 2020. Books two and three each follow a different Mortiz sister, and both rate higher on Goodreads than book one.

Is there a Labyrinth Lost audiobook?

Yes. Recorded Books published it, narrated by Almarie Guerra, with a runtime of 9 hours 28 minutes. It’s available on Libro.fm and Audible.

If You Loved Labyrinth Lost, Read These Next

If the culture-rooted magic was the draw, We Set the Dark on Fire gives you a Latin American inspired world with the sapphic romance moved to the front. If you liked a bisexual heroine with a dangerous power she’s afraid of, Girl, Serpent, Thorn runs the same fear on Persian myth. And if it was the witchy family in a real city, This Poison Heart is the closest match in tone. For more, browse our Latine sapphic books guide or the full book reviews archive.

The Bottom Line

Labyrinth Lost wanted to be Charmed with brujas, and in a lot of ways it gets there. The family is vivid, the underworld is strange and memorable, and Alex’s bisexuality is handled as part of who she is rather than a crisis. The love interest is thin, the heroine takes a while to warm up to, and the quest sags before it finishes. It’s worth it for readers who care most about magic, culture and sisters, and who’ll treat the romance as seasoning. Check Labyrinth Lost on Amazon

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Labyrinth Lost ranks as a landmark bisexual YA bruja fantasy. It’s strongest on family and world-building and weakest on its romantic lead. Read it for the Mortiz family and Los Lagos rather than the love story.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ 3.71 average across 14,742 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ School Library Journal starred review
  • ✓ 3.68 on StoryGraph across 5,822 reviews
  • ✓ Rishi and the middle third drag it down

Romance ★★★☆☆ 2.9/5

  • ✓ Bisexual love triangle, rare in 2016 YA
  • ✓ Resolves with Alex and Rishi together
  • ✓ Nova’s side has the stronger chemistry
  • ✓ Rishi repeatedly called underdeveloped

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ The Mortiz sisters read like real siblings
  • ✓ Nova the most praised supporting character
  • ✓ 67% of StoryGraph readers find them loveable
  • ✓ Alex called bratty in several reviews

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Vivid, specific household magic
  • ✓ Fast first act, 39% call it fast-paced
  • ✓ New York Times called it giddily exciting
  • ✓ BookPage flagged some awkward passages

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

  • ✓ Guilt over the lost family drives the book
  • ✓ Missing father thread lands for readers
  • ✓ Underworld set pieces are eerie
  • ✓ Rushed climax blunts the payoff for some

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ YA, published for ages 14 and up
  • ✓ Kissing only on the page
  • ✓ No romance.io listing, as expected for YA
  • ✓ Dark content outweighs romantic content

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Rescue plot resolves in this book
  • ✓ Romance settled, no romantic cliffhanger
  • ✓ Trilogy complete, sequels rate higher
  • ✓ Two readers call the climax rushed

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ World details reward a second visit
  • ✓ 9 hour 28 minute audiobook available
  • ✓ Sequels pull readers back to the family
  • ✓ Episodic middle discourages a reread

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

1 thought on “Labyrinth Lost Review: Is It Worth Reading?”

Leave a Comment