Verdict: A warm, steamy cooking-show romance with a nonbinary lead written with real care and chemistry that works from the first spilled dish, held back by a slow first half and leads some readers found a little thin.
Best for: Readers who want a sex-positive queer romance with low drama and very little miscommunication, and who don’t mind that the competition sometimes sits in the background.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5: open door and explicit, by reader accounts)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.7/5: a 3.79 Goodreads average across about 21,000 ratings, warm trade coverage, and a recurring complaint that the first 40% drags)
Tropes: Rivals to lovers, reality TV competition, secret relationship, cooking romance, opposites attract, nonbinary love interest, bisexual heroine, starting over after divorce, found family, fling with an end date.
Love & Other Disasters is Anita Kelly’s debut and the first Nashville Love book, published by Forever in January 2022: a contemporary queer romance set on a televised cooking competition, where a recently divorced, broke and famously clumsy home cook falls for the first openly nonbinary contestant in the show’s history.
It sits at 3.79 on Goodreads across roughly 21,000 ratings, with a 3.9 on StoryGraph across more than 11,000 reviews. Publishers Weekly called it a sweet debut, and it turned up on Booklist’s best romance debuts and BookPage’s best romance lists for its year. But the reviews have a clear shape: people love the couple and the tone, and a solid group wanted the book to get moving sooner. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.
What Is Love & Other Disasters About?
This is a contemporary romantic comedy with a reality-TV frame. Think a MasterChef-style competition, with the cooking challenges, eliminations and on-set rules setting the pace of the relationship. The competition gives the book a built-in clock and a reason to keep things quiet, and it’s why so much of the romance happens in stolen time between tapings.
Dahlia Woodson is a bisexual woman whose marriage just ended and whose bank balance is close to zero, and she’s on the show to prove to herself she can still do something well. London Parker is nonbinary and pansexual, a serious cook who came to win and who’s carrying the weight of being the first openly nonbinary person the show has cast. Dahlia lacks confidence; London has more than enough focus for both of them. The book alternates between them, so you get both sides of the attraction and both sets of worries.
What Makes This Queer Cooking Romance Work
- London: The most praised thing in the book. Nonbinary readers in particular say London felt real, not like a lesson, and several call it the representation they’d been waiting for in a mainstream romance.
- Chemistry from the first meeting: Readers who rated it four stars and up keep coming back to how well the two leads spark, and Publishers Weekly said the same thing in nearly the same words.
- Low drama: A recurring compliment is that the book doesn’t lean on miscommunication. The conflict comes from the show and from the characters’ own baggage.
- Tone: StoryGraph readers tag it lighthearted (78%) and funny (67%), and 92% call the characters loveable. It reads as a comfort book.
- The food: Fans of Food Network and The Great British Bake Off say the cooking scenes made them hungry, and that the dishes do some of the emotional work.
Book Synopsis
Dahlia Woodson can dice an onion like a pro and do almost nothing else right. Her marriage is over, her savings are gone, and a spot on Chef’s Special, the country’s favorite cooking competition, is the one big swing she has left. She arrives determined, nervous and prone to knocking things over.
London Parker arrives with a plan. They want to win, and they want to show that a nonbinary cook can be on national TV without it being the story. The last thing they need is the clumsy, chatty contestant at the next station, who keeps making them laugh at exactly the wrong moments.
The two of them are rivals on paper and allies in practice. They help each other out, they flirt, and then they start something they agree has to stay off camera and has to end when the competition does. Every challenge brings someone closer to elimination. Dahlia has to decide whether she can trust herself again after a marriage that left her doubting everything, and London has to decide whether letting someone in is worth the risk of losing focus. The question isn’t only who’ll win the show. It’s whether what they’ve built in the kitchen can survive when the cameras stop.
My Review
London is the reason to read this. Kelly writes a nonbinary lead whose identity is part of the story without becoming the plot, and the book shows the specific tiredness of being a first on national TV without turning London into a symbol. When London is careful, it’s because they’ve had to be. When they let go, it’s earned.
The second strength is how kind the romance is. Dahlia and London are good to each other. There’s no big lie, no manufactured breakup over a misheard phone call, and the sex scenes are frank and warm. A few reviewers specifically call it sex positive, and they mean it as the main compliment. If you want a romance where two adults talk to each other, this delivers.
Where it struggles, the reviews mostly agree. The most repeated complaint is pacing, and it’s very specific: the first forty percent or so. More than one reader who ended up loving it says they nearly gave up early, and a few did. A second, smaller group finds the leads a bit generic, especially Dahlia, whose main trait for a while is being a mess. Third, and this one comes up more than you’d think: one particular bedroom moment involving a toe. Several reviewers mention it, some laughing and some cringing, and at least one says it ruined the rest of the book for them. It’s a single scene. Decide for yourself.
The expectation to reset is the competition. If you’re coming for a cooking-show plot with twists and rival drama, it’s quieter than that. The show is the setting and the clock, not the main event. One reader wanted more cooking; another said the cooking got in the way of the romance. If the romance is what you want, you’re in the right place. If you wanted Top Chef with kissing, calibrate.
My honest note: A big-hearted debut with a lead you’ll remember and a slow first act you’ll have to push through. Give it to page 150 before you decide.
| Element | In Love & Other Disasters |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Dahlia Woodson and London Parker, bisexual heroine and nonbinary pansexual love interest, rivals to lovers |
| Core tropes | Reality TV competition, secret relationship, opposites attract, starting over after divorce, fling with an end date |
| Setting | The set of Chef’s Special, a televised amateur cooking competition |
| Heat level | 4/5: open door and explicit, by reader accounts |
| Series | Nashville Love book 1: standalone romance with a happy ending; later books follow other couples |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content, transphobia and misgendering, homophobia, dysphoria, alcohol, divorce and job loss, minor cooking injuries and blood (StoryGraph and reader warnings) |
How Spicy Is Love & Other Disasters?
Quite spicy for a rom-com. I couldn’t get romance.io’s page to load past its bot check, so this number comes from readers and from StoryGraph instead, and they’re consistent: the sex scenes are open door, explicit and frequent enough that StoryGraph readers rate sexual content as graphic. Reviewers who loved it describe it as steamy, and a Reddit review on r/RomanceBooks talks about the tension and the steam rising together. I’d put it at a 4.
The one thing worth knowing in advance is the toe scene, which is a running joke in the reviews at this point. Beyond that, no reviewer flags anything you wouldn’t expect in a contemporary open-door romance. If you liked the heat in Satisfaction Guaranteed or Delilah Green Doesn’t Care, you’ll be comfortable here.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want nonbinary representation written from the inside, you like low-angst romance where adults communicate, you enjoy food and competition settings, and open-door scenes are a plus for you.
You may want to skip it if: slow openings make you quit, you want the cooking competition to drive the plot, you need sharply drawn heroines from page one, or you’d rather your romance stayed closed door.
In short: Stay for London and the kindness, and be patient with the first third.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
This isn’t a book having a moment right now. It had its moment in 2022, when it came out from Forever with a big list of romance authors behind it and landed on Booklist’s best romance debuts, BookPage’s best romance list and Women’s Health’s romance picks. Publishers Weekly reviewed it warmly and Shelf Awareness praised the character work and the balance between the romance and the show. Since then it’s kept selling as a backlist pick and as the entry point to Kelly’s books: roughly 21,000 Goodreads ratings, 11,500 StoryGraph reviews and more than 1,000 ratings on Amazon, where it sits at 4.3.
The audiobook is from Hachette Audio, narrated by Lindsey Dorcus, and runs 10 hours 38 minutes.
Prefer audio? Listen to Love & Other Disasters on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Representation first. Nonbinary and bisexual readers say they saw themselves, and the happiest reviews are the ones that say the book felt written for them. The chemistry comes second, then the low-drama approach, with “no miscommunication” turning up as a compliment over and over. The food scenes are a reliable bonus for anyone who watches cooking TV. And a group of readers who struggled early say the second half won them back completely.
What readers argue about and complain about: Pacing, above everything. The slow first stretch is the most repeated criticism, often from people who still gave it four stars. Second: thin characterization. Some readers found Dahlia and London generic and never got a firm grip on them, which sits oddly against StoryGraph’s 92% loveable score and suggests it’s a matter of taste. Third: the toe scene, which some readers find funny, some find unbearable, and nobody forgets. Fourth, from single voices rather than a crowd: one advance reader objected to an all-white main cast, one wanted the cooking show to matter more, and one picked at small writing choices like a character’s name and some slang. The real split is the competition itself, which some want front and center and others are happy to see in the background.
The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone. The romance resolves with a happy ending and there’s no cliffhanger. Nashville Love continues with Something Wild & Wonderful (2023), a different couple on a hiking trail, and How You Get the Girl (2024), a sapphic basketball romance we’ve reviewed here, which loops back to characters from this book. You don’t need either to enjoy this one, but if Kelly’s warmth works for you, the third book is where a lot of readers say it all clicked.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Love & Other Disasters a lesbian romance?
It’s a queer romance between a bisexual woman, Dahlia, and a nonbinary pansexual love interest, London. It sits comfortably on sapphic and nonbinary reading lists, but neither lead identifies as a lesbian.
How spicy is Love & Other Disasters?
About a 4/5. The scenes are open door and explicit, and StoryGraph readers rate the sexual content as graphic. One scene involving a toe gets mentioned in a lot of reviews.
Is Love & Other Disasters a standalone?
Yes. It’s book one of Nashville Love, but each book follows a different couple and this one ends with a happy ending and no cliffhanger.
Is there a Love & Other Disasters audiobook?
Yes. Hachette Audio published it, narrated by Lindsey Dorcus, with a runtime of 10 hours 38 minutes. It’s available on Libro.fm and Audible.
Is the book slow?
The first part is, according to a lot of readers. The most common complaint is that the opening 40% or so drags, and many of those same readers say the second half made up for it.
If You Loved Love & Other Disasters, Read These Next
If a food setting is your thing, Guava Flavored Lies swaps the TV kitchen for rival bakeries with more heat and more banter. For Kelly’s voice with a sapphic couple, How You Get the Girl is the obvious next step. And if it was the sex-positive tone you loved, Satisfaction Guaranteed is in the same open-door, big-hearted band. For more, browse our nonbinary sapphic books guide or the full book reviews archive.
The Bottom Line
Love & Other Disasters set out to put a nonbinary lead at the center of a mainstream rom-com, and it does that with care. London is memorable, the chemistry works, and the romance is refreshingly free of fake drama. The opening is slow, the leads read thin for some people, and the cooking competition is more backdrop than plot. It’s worth it for readers who want warmth, open-door heat and good representation, and who’ll give it a hundred pages to get going. Check Love & Other Disasters on Amazon
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Love & Other Disasters ranks as a big-hearted queer cooking-show rom-com. It’s strongest on representation and chemistry and weakest on pacing. Read it for London and the relationship rather than the competition.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ 3.79 average across 21,164 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 3.9 on StoryGraph across 11,562 reviews
- ✓ Booklist best romance debuts pick
- ✓ Slow first 40% is the top complaint
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Chemistry praised by readers and trade
- ✓ Little to no miscommunication
- ✓ Secret fling gives it tension
- ✓ Some found the leads generic
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ London the most praised element
- ✓ 92% of StoryGraph readers find them loveable
- ✓ 78% say strong character development
- ✓ Dahlia reads thin to several readers
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Warm, funny, 67% tag it funny
- ✓ Food scenes are vivid and specific
- ✓ Shelf Awareness praised the balance
- ✓ Pacing drags early on
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Divorce and starting over land
- ✓ Being the first nonbinary contestant hits
- ✓ Second half wins readers back
- ✓ Low stakes for some readers
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Open door and explicit
- ✓ StoryGraph rates sexual content graphic
- ✓ Readers describe it as steamy
- ✓ The toe scene divides readers
Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Happy ending for the couple
- ✓ No cliffhanger
- ✓ Stands alone in the series
- ✓ Competition payoff lighter than the romance
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Comfort-read tone, 78% lighthearted
- ✓ 10 hour 38 minute audiobook
- ✓ Series books revisit the cast
- ✓ Slow opening discourages a reread
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

2 thoughts on “Love & Other Disasters Review: Is It Worth Reading?”