This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A loud, funny, food-soaked Cuban-American rom-com about two women whose great-grandfathers allegedly stole each other’s pastry recipes — the banter is the main event, and it is very good banter.
Best for: Readers who want an enemies-to-lovers comedy with thirtysomething leads, real cultural specificity, an unambiguous happy ending, and no coming-out plot in sight.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — fully explicit and open-door, but concentrated in the back half)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — a 4.06 Goodreads average earned almost entirely on charm)
Tropes: Enemies-to-lovers, feuding families, second chance, forced proximity, slow burn, femme/femme, romantic comedy, small-business rivals, found-family-by-blood.
Guava Flavored Lies by J.J. Arias is a self-published sapphic romantic comedy set in Miami, in which Sylvie Campos and Lauren Machado — heirs to rival Cuban-American bakeries whose families have accused each other of recipe theft since before either woman was born — spend a season of outdoor food festivals trapped in adjacent booths, trading insults, and slowly running out of reasons to keep hating each other.
It has a 4.06 average across roughly 2,780 Goodreads ratings, it is one of the most-recommended indie sapphic romcoms of the last few years, and readers who love it and readers who are lukewarm on it agree almost entirely on why.
What Is Guava Flavored Lies About?
Guava Flavored Lies is a contemporary lesbian romance and a standalone — no series, no sequel, no cliffhanger. The setup is a pastry war. Generations back, the Campos and Machado great-grandfathers fled Castro’s Cuba, and ever since, each family has insisted the other stole the recipes that built their bakery.
Sylvie and Lauren have inherited that grudge along with the businesses. Both are in their early thirties, both are being groomed to take over, and both spend long hot seasons working outdoor food festivals in booths close enough to hear each other breathe. Nobody gets under Sylvie’s skin like Lauren does. So Sylvie decides to settle it — to dig up proof that the Machados are exactly the thieves her family has always said they were. What she finds instead is a version of the story nobody told her, and a reason to reconsider the girl she almost kissed in high school.
What Makes This Sapphic Rom-Com Work
- The banter: The single most-praised element, by a wide margin. Reviewers describe reading it in stitches; the insult-trading is the book’s engine and its best writing.
- Two women in their thirties: Both leads are out, established, and running businesses. There is no coming-out arc, and readers repeatedly name that as a relief.
- The food: Pastelitos de guayaba, croquetas, cafecito, café con leche. Food is how these families communicate, and it does real narrative work rather than set dressing.
- Own-voices cultural specificity: Arias is a Cuban-American writer from Miami, and the Spanish woven through the dialogue, the music, and the family texture read as lived rather than researched.
- The epilogue: Reviewers single it out as a genuine highlight — a comic payoff that sends you out grinning.
Book Synopsis
Sylvie Campos and Lauren Machado have hated each other since before they were born, which is the only sensible arrangement when your families have spent three generations accusing each other of stealing the pastry recipes that made them. Now both women are in their early thirties and next in line to run their respective Miami bakeries.
That means festival season: long, hot days working outdoor stalls in each other’s immediate vicinity, sniping across the gap. Lauren is infuriating. Lauren is also, inconveniently, the person Sylvie once almost had something with, back in high school, before the family lines hardened for good.
Fed up, Sylvie sets out to prove the Machados are the thieves her relatives always claimed. The trouble is that the archive does not cooperate. What Sylvie uncovers reframes the feud entirely — and once the grudge stops making sense, the heat she has been calling anger turns out to have been something else the whole time. It resolves happily, with an epilogue, and then a second, funnier one.
My Review
This is a book that knows exactly what it is, and what it is is a comedy. The plot is a pretext. The generational recipe feud is thin — several reviewers call it flatly silly — and the mystery Sylvie is chasing resolves without much resistance. None of that is really the point. The point is two women who are extremely good at annoying each other, and Arias writes that with a comic timing most romcoms would kill for.
The cultural writing is the other real achievement, and it is the thing that lifts this above a competent enemies-to-lovers setup. Arias is Cuban-American and from Miami, and it shows in the parts that cannot be faked: the way the families talk over each other, the specific weight of a recipe as inheritance, the Spanish that runs through the dialogue without stopping to translate itself for you. The bakeries are not a quirky backdrop — they are how two immigrant families have held onto something, which is also why the feud has lasted three generations past the point of sense.
Where it wobbles is structure and consistency. The turn from enemies to lovers arrives faster than the buildup earns, which is the most common complaint across Goodreads and StoryGraph alike. Once the romance lands, roughly at the midpoint, the book loses its tension — the bickering that powered the first half has nowhere to go, and the bakery plot is not sturdy enough to carry the second. And there is a persistent note that both women behave younger than their stated ages; readers who came for a thirtysomething romance sometimes found the pettiness read closer to nineteen. Sylvie in particular takes a while to become likeable, though several reviewers note that her early defensiveness makes more sense once you know what she is protecting.
My honest note: Come for the dialogue and the pastelitos, not the plot. This is a hangout book — you are here for the company, and the company is excellent.
| Element | In Guava Flavored Lies |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Sylvie Campos & Lauren Machado — rival bakery heirs, enemies-to-lovers |
| Core tropes | Enemies-to-lovers, feuding families, second chance, forced proximity, slow burn |
| Setting | Miami, Florida — Cuban-American family bakeries and the outdoor food-festival circuit |
| Heat level | 4/5 — fully explicit and open-door, concentrated in the back half |
| Series | Standalone, 340 pages — HEA plus two epilogues |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content; alcohol, a toxic relationship and gaslighting flagged at moderate level by readers |
How Spicy Is Guava Flavored Lies?
A 4/5. I Heart SapphFic files it at “Hot & Steamy” — its top tier, meaning full graphic description — and the publisher blurb promises steam outright. The scenes are unambiguously open-door and detailed when they arrive. What keeps this a 4 rather than a 5 on our scale is distribution: the heat is concentrated after the midpoint rather than running through the book, and there are fewer scenes than in the genre’s most explicit titles.
Reader opinion splits in both directions, which is usually a sign a book has calibrated it about right — some found the later scenes more than they wanted, others wished for more. If you want wall-to-wall explicit, this is milder. If you want closed-door, it is not.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you read romance for dialogue, you want grown women with businesses and opinions rather than a coming-out story, you like your rivals genuinely funny rather than merely hostile, and you want a guaranteed happy ending with no cliffhanger attached.
You may want to skip it if: you need a plot that holds up under pressure, a slow burn that stays slow, or characters who consistently act their age. If a thin premise ruins a comedy for you, this one is thin.
In short: a warm, funny, culturally rich sapphic romcom that is better company than it is a story — and mostly that is enough.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)
Four years on from its June 2022 release, Guava Flavored Lies has settled into a specific role in sapphic reading circles: it is the book people hand over when someone asks for a funny one. There has been no viral moment, no award, no trade review — it is a self-published title that never had a marketing machine behind it — and it has still accumulated around 2,780 Goodreads ratings at a 4.06 average, with a 3.9 on StoryGraph across 337 reviews and a did-not-finish rate of just 3%. That last number is the interesting one: almost nobody bails on this book. Whatever its structural problems, it is extremely easy to keep reading.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The banter, first and always. Reviewers describe laughing out loud, and the insult-trading between Sylvie and Lauren is cited more than any other single element. After that: the chemistry, which reviewers attribute to the leads’ shared history rather than instant attraction; the food writing, which sends a reliable number of readers straight to a Cuban bakery afterward; and the cultural texture, which readers consistently name as authentic rather than decorative. There is also real appreciation for two protagonists in their thirties who are already out — several reviewers say explicitly that a queer romance with no coming-out plot is what they were looking for. And the epilogue has its own small fan club.
What readers argue about and complain about: The enemies-to-lovers turn is too fast — this is the most repeated criticism by some distance. Close behind: the book sags after the midpoint, once the antagonism that powered it resolves and the bakery-feud subplot proves too flimsy to take over. Several readers wanted twenty to forty pages cut. The feud premise itself gets called silly. And there is a recurring note that both women act younger than their thirties, with Sylvie’s early behaviour singled out as grating before it becomes explicable. Separately, one protagonist begins the book already in a relationship, which readers flag — though the consensus is clear that no cheating occurs.
The audiobook is its own conversation. Narrated by Carrie Coello for Tantor Audio and running just under ten hours, it draws the most divided reaction of anything connected to this book. Reviewers describe the delivery as flat in places and strong in others; one rated the audiobook 4/5 while warning about a poor French accent. The sharper criticism concerns Spanish pronunciation, which several listeners found off — a real problem in a book whose whole appeal is cultural authenticity. It is not universal: at least one reviewer reports a Spanish-speaking friend enjoying it. The standard advice in the reviews is to listen to the sample first.
Prefer audio? Listen to Guava Flavored Lies on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Guava Flavored Lies a standalone?
Yes — a complete standalone with no series, no sequel and no cliffhanger. It ends with a happily-ever-after, an epilogue, and a second bonus epilogue that readers consistently call the funniest thing in the book.
How spicy is Guava Flavored Lies?
A 4/5. I Heart SapphFic rates it “Hot & Steamy,” its top tier for fully explicit content. The scenes are open-door and detailed, but they are concentrated in the second half rather than spread throughout.
Does it have a happy ending?
Yes, unambiguously. This is a romantic comedy and it delivers the full romcom resolution, plus two epilogues.
Do I need to speak Spanish to follow it?
No. Spanish runs through the dialogue and the book does not stop to translate itself, but nothing essential is locked behind it — meaning always carries from context.
Is the audiobook worth it?
It depends on your tolerance. Carrie Coello’s narration runs just under ten hours and reviews are genuinely split, with recurring criticism of Spanish pronunciation and some flat delivery. Sample it before you commit.
If You Loved Guava Flavored Lies, Read These Next
If the rivals-with-history dynamic is what you came for, our complete enemies-to-lovers reading list is the fastest way to find more of it. If you want the same antagonism dialled up to something far darker, Bloom Town: Genesis takes the hostility somewhere much more dangerous — though be warned, it ends on a cliffhanger this book would never inflict on you.
For more in this register, browse second chance romance, slow burn, or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
Guava Flavored Lies is a funny, generous, culturally specific sapphic romcom whose plot is an excuse and whose dialogue is a gift. It is not tightly constructed, its second half is softer than its first, and the feud that drives it will not survive much scrutiny. It is also a genuine pleasure to spend time inside, it treats its Cuban-American Miami with real love, and it hands you a happy ending and then two epilogues. Come for the banter and the pastelitos, and it is absolutely worth reading. Check Guava Flavored Lies on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Guava Flavored Lies ranks as a standout indie sapphic romantic comedy — structurally loose but enormously likeable, and one of the best arguments going for what self-published sapphic romance does well.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ 4.06 average across 2,780 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Only a 3% did-not-finish rate
- ✓ Charm carries it a long way
- ✓ Plot is a pretext
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Chemistry built on shared history
- ✓ Second-chance undertow from high school
- ✓ Genuinely funny courtship
- ✓ Enemies-to-lovers turn is rushed
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Two out women in their thirties
- ✓ Family cast is warmly drawn
- ✓ No coming-out plot required
- ✓ Both leads act younger than stated
Writing ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ Best-in-class banter
- ✓ Comic timing throughout
- ✓ Food writing you can taste
- ✓ Second half loses its tension
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Generational immigrant story lands
- ✓ Recipes as inheritance
- ✓ Warm rather than devastating
- ✓ Stakes stay low by design
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Fully explicit, open door
- ✓ Rated Hot and Steamy by I Heart SapphFic
- ✓ Character-specific, not generic
- ✓ Concentrated in the back half
Ending ★★★★★ 4.5/5
- ✓ Unambiguous HEA
- ✓ Epilogue, then a funnier one
- ✓ No cliffhanger, no sequel needed
- ✓ Conflict resolves easily
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Comfort-read energy
- ✓ Banter rewards a second pass
- ✓ Low-stakes and easy to return to
- ✓ Mystery holds nothing back for later