The Holiday Detour Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A Christmas Eve road-trip romance between a stressed Jewish lesbian and a kind genderqueer pig farmer, with a premise readers were excited about, let down by a heroine who repeatedly misgenders the love interest, uncertain humor and a romance that arrives very late.

Best for: Readers who want a quick, quirky holiday road trip with Jewish and genderqueer leads, and who can tolerate a main character whose growth is the point of the book.

Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5: low, by reader reports)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (2.8/5: a 3.06 Goodreads average across about 120 ratings and 2.75 on StoryGraph, with genderqueer readers among its sharpest critics)

Tropes: Road trip, holiday romance, stranded on Christmas Eve, opposites attract, forced proximity, scheming ex, city girl and farmer, F/NB romance.

The Holiday Detour is Jane Kolven’s 2020 debut from Bold Strokes Books: a contemporary sapphic holiday road-trip romance, where a Jewish lesbian whose car breaks down in Indiana on Christmas Eve accepts a ride from Charlie, a genderqueer pig farmer, and everything that can go wrong on the way home does.

The premise drew readers in, and several reviews say so in their first line. The results are rough: a 3.06 Goodreads average across about 120 ratings, nearly a third of them one or two stars, and 2.75 on StoryGraph from 39. The most pointed criticism comes from genderqueer readers themselves, and it’s the thing to understand before you pick it up.

What Is The Holiday Detour About?

It’s a holiday romance built on a road trip, so the structure is a string of mishaps over a few days: breakdowns, accidents, an ex causing trouble and a snowbound, empty Chicago Loop. The tone aims for light and quirky, closer to a Christmas movie than a serious romance.

Dana Gottfried is a stressed-out Jewish lesbian who has just quit her job and wants to get home to her grandmother. Charlie is a pig farmer who doesn’t identify as male or female, and who stops to help when Dana is stranded. The story is told from Dana’s point of view, which matters a lot: the reader sees Charlie through Dana’s assumptions, mistakes and all.

What Readers Liked About This Holiday Road Trip

  • The premise: A Jewish heroine at Christmas and a genderqueer farmer love interest is a combination readers rarely see, and many picked it up for that alone.
  • Charlie: The love interest’s kindness and humor are what Dana falls for, and readers who liked the book liked Charlie most.
  • Quick and light: Reviewers call it a fast page-turner, and StoryGraph’s few mood votes all include lighthearted.
  • A journey of self-knowledge: The most positive reviews read Dana’s arc as personal growth, with a lot of time spent inside her head.
  • Holiday chaos: If you enjoy cheesy Christmas movies, several readers say that’s exactly the vibe.

Book Synopsis

Dana Gottfried has just walked out of her job, and all she wants is to get home to her grandmother for the holidays. Then her car dies in the middle of Indiana on Christmas Eve, and she’s stuck with nowhere to go.

Charlie, a pig farmer who happens by, offers help. Charlie doesn’t identify as male or female, has an easy sense of humor and seems to be the kindest person Dana has met in a long time. Against her better judgment, Dana accepts a ride.

The road home is anything but straight. Car trouble, accidents, a scheming ex-girlfriend and a snowy Chicago turned ghost town all get in the way. Somewhere along the route, Dana starts to realize that Charlie might be the best thing that has happened to her in years, if she can get out of her own way.

My Review

The idea is lovely, and that’s what keeps coming up in reviews. A Jewish lesbian stranded at Christmas, rescued by a genderqueer farmer: there’s a warm, funny book in that pitch, and readers wanted it badly. Charlie, when the book lets them shine, is easy to like.

The Holiday Detour by Jane Kolven book cover

There’s a gentle self-discovery story here too. The most positive reviewers say Dana is quirky and that the book gives a real inside view of her processing big life changes, and that’s a fair reading of its intentions.

Where it struggles, and this is the dominant complaint, is in how Dana treats Charlie. Reviewers warn that the main character misgenders Charlie, and a minor character does too. A genderqueer sapphic reviewer on Goodreads calls it very difficult to review for that reason, and a genderqueer reader on StoryGraph quit about a quarter in and says she can’t recommend it. Another says the main character simply isn’t a good person. The second problem is tone: two separate reviewers say they couldn’t tell which scenes were meant to be funny, and one calls the dialogue the weakest part of the book. Third, readers expecting a cute holiday romance found that it arrives late, after a lot of chaos crammed into a few days. Nearly a third of Goodreads ratings are one or two stars.

The gap here is between the marketing and the experience. The book sells a cozy F/NB holiday romance, and for many readers, especially nonbinary and genderqueer ones, the experience is spending most of the book with a heroine who gets the love interest’s identity wrong. If you can treat that as the arc Dana has to grow through, you may enjoy the ride. If that’s exactly what you read queer romance to avoid, skip it.

My honest note: A great premise undermined by its own narrator. Readers looking for affirming F/NB representation should look elsewhere.

ElementIn The Holiday Detour
Central relationshipDana Gottfried, a stressed Jewish lesbian, and Charlie, a genderqueer pig farmer
Core tropesRoad trip, holiday romance, stranded on Christmas Eve, forced proximity, scheming ex
SettingIndiana and Chicago over Christmas
Heat level2/5: low, by reader reports
SeriesStandalone; HEA
Content notesMisgendering by the main character and a minor character, car accident, memories of a parent’s death

How Spicy Is The Holiday Detour?

Low. I couldn’t reach romance.io, and StoryGraph has no content warnings listed, so the 2/5 is my estimate from reviews, which focus on the road trip and say the romance only comes together late in the book. None of the reviews I read describe explicit scenes.

The thing to flag isn’t sex. It’s misgendering, which reviewers list as the main content warning, along with a car accident and recalled parental loss. For a nonbinary-lead romance that readers describe as affirming, and much hotter, try Love & Other Disasters.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you love Christmas-movie chaos, you want a Jewish heroine at the holidays, a quick read appeals, you can treat a heroine’s mistakes as her arc.

You may want to skip it if: misgendering on the page is a dealbreaker, you want clear, sharp humor, you want the romance early, you’re looking for affirming nonbinary representation.

In short: A charming idea that many of its intended readers found hurtful.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a small debut from Bold Strokes, published in September 2020 (one reviewer wonders if the publisher released it early so it wouldn’t get lost in the holiday rush). It has a modest footprint: about 120 Goodreads ratings and 39 on StoryGraph. I found no trade coverage and couldn’t reach Reddit. It turns up on lists like our nonbinary sapphic books page because F/NB holiday romances are rare, and that rarity is a big part of why readers pick it up.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The premise, Charlie’s kindness and the holiday road-trip energy. A four-star reader enjoyed Dana’s journey of self-knowledge; others describe it as a quick page-turner with a cheesy Christmas-film feel, which some mean as praise.

What readers argue about and complain about: First and loudest, misgendering. Genderqueer readers report being hurt by how Dana treats Charlie, and one abandoned the book because of it. Second, tone: readers couldn’t tell if scenes were meant to be funny, and found some reactions oversized and conversations odd. Third, structure: too much crammed into a few days, and the romance arriving late. The real split is whether Dana’s misgendering reads as a character flaw the book takes seriously or as something the book itself gets wrong. Genderqueer reviewers mostly read it the second way.

The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a standalone holiday romance with a happy ending. Kolven has since written other sapphic romances, so this debut isn’t the last word on her work.

I couldn’t find an audiobook edition.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Holiday Detour a sapphic romance?

Yes. It’s a romance between Dana, a lesbian, and Charlie, who is genderqueer. It ends happily.

Does The Holiday Detour have misgendering?

Yes. Reviewers warn that the main character and a minor character misgender Charlie, and it’s the most common complaint from genderqueer readers.

How spicy is The Holiday Detour?

Low, about a 2/5. Reviewers say the romance comes together late, and none describe explicit scenes.

Is there an audiobook?

Not that I could find.

If You Loved The Holiday Detour, Read These Next

For a nonbinary lead written with care, Love & Other Disasters is the stronger pick. If it’s holiday chaos you want, The Holiday Trap and My Fake Holiday Date are both warmer, steamier seasonal reads. More on our nonbinary sapphic books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

The Holiday Detour wanted to be a cozy, funny holiday road trip with representation you rarely see. The premise is great, Charlie is kind and the pages turn quickly. The heroine misgenders the love interest, the humor misfires and the romance arrives late. Unless you’re very forgiving of a narrator’s mistakes, there are better F/NB holiday romances to read. Check The Holiday Detour on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, The Holiday Detour ranks as a well-intended but flawed holiday debut. It has a fresh premise and a kind love interest, held back by misgendering and uneven tone. Read it for the idea only if you know what you’re getting into.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 2.8/5

  • ✓ 3.06 average across about 120 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 2.75 on StoryGraph from 39
  • ✓ Nearly a third of ratings at one or two stars
  • ✓ Genderqueer readers among the harshest critics

Romance ★★★☆☆ 2.7/5

  • ✓ Charlie is kind and funny
  • ✓ Road trip forces them together
  • ✓ HEA
  • ✓ Romance arrives late

Characters ★★★☆☆ 2.5/5

  • ✓ Charlie is the reader favorite
  • ✓ Dana gets a growth arc
  • ✓ Jewish heroine at Christmas
  • ✓ Dana called not a good person by some

Writing ★★★☆☆ 2.6/5

  • ✓ Quick, easy read
  • ✓ Christmas-movie energy
  • ✓ Humor often unclear
  • ✓ Dialogue called weak

Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 2.8/5

  • ✓ Grandmother and family give it heart
  • ✓ Self-discovery for Dana
  • ✓ Lighthearted mood
  • ✓ Misgendering hurts some readers

Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 2/5

  • ✓ Low heat
  • ✓ Romance develops late
  • ✓ No explicit scenes in reviews
  • ✓ Estimate, not a romance.io band

Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ HEA
  • ✓ Standalone, no cliffhanger
  • ✓ Road trip reaches home
  • ✓ Comes after a crowded plot

Re-read Value ★★☆☆☆ 2.4/5

  • ✓ Short seasonal read
  • ✓ Charlie draws some back
  • ✓ No audiobook
  • ✓ Few readers want a second pass

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment