Greta & Valdin Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A very funny, warm Auckland family novel about two queer Māori-Russian-Catalan siblings fumbling toward love, with a voice readers adore and a pile of awards to match, held back by a cast so big and so similarly named that many readers spend the first chapters lost.

Best for: Readers who love character-driven literary comedy, chaotic families and queer twenty-somethings working things out, and who don’t need much plot.

Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5: brief and mostly off the page)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5: a 3.88 Goodreads average across more than 36,000 ratings, a Hubert Church Prize and a Lambda shortlist, trimmed for the confusing cast and thin plot)

Tropes: Sibling dual POV, chaotic family, unrequited crush, found family, academic life, ex in another country, queer coming of age, literary comedy.

Greta & Valdin is Rebecca K Reilly’s debut novel, first published in New Zealand in 2021 and in the US by Simon & Schuster’s Avid Reader Press in 2024: a literary, character-driven comedy set in Auckland, told in alternating chapters by Greta, a broke grad student nursing a crush, and her brother Valdin, still not over the boyfriend who moved to Buenos Aires.

It’s a genuine phenomenon. It has more than 36,000 Goodreads ratings at a 3.88 average and a 4.1 on StoryGraph from nearly 13,000 reviews. It won the Hubert Church Prize for best first book of fiction at the 2022 Ockham New Zealand Book Awards, and it was a finalist for the 2025 Lambda Literary Award in bisexual fiction. Readers mostly laugh their way through it. The ones who don’t usually stop at the family tree.

What Is Greta & Valdin About?

It’s a comic family novel more than a romance, though love drives both halves. Greta and Valdin share a flat, a sense of humor and a sprawling family of Māori, Russian and Catalan roots that is always in each other’s business. The story is about their love lives, but also about being queer and mixed-race in New Zealand, and about the small daily embarrassments of being twenty-something and not sure where you’re going.

For readers here, Greta is the reason to come. She’s queer, stuck on a crush that isn’t going anywhere and drawn to a charming fellow grad student she meets at a party. Valdin’s chapters follow his attempt to get over his ex, which gets harder when work sends him to Argentina. The two voices alternate throughout.

What Makes This Queer Family Comedy Work

  • The humor: StoryGraph’s top mood is funny at 88%, and readers keep calling it laugh-out-loud funny. Reviewers in New Zealand praised how it mixes social commentary with jokes.
  • The family: The eccentric Māori-Russian-Catalan clan is the heart of the book, and readers love how loud and loving it is.
  • Warmth: Readers and critics both point to the tenderness Reilly has for her characters. It’s a kind book.
  • Queer and multiracial life, unforced: Both siblings are queer, and the book treats identity as part of daily life rather than a crisis.
  • Critical weight: A New Zealand bestseller with major awards, and a Lambda finalist when it reached the US.

Book Synopsis

Greta is trying not to let things get her down: not her painfully unrequited crush, not her possibly pointless master’s thesis and not her terrible academic salary. She’d much rather think about the charming grad student she just met at a party and spend time with her friends, a circle of fellow twenty-somethings who are all floundering in their own ways.

Her brother Valdin says he’s fine. It’s been a year since his boyfriend dumped him and moved to Buenos Aires, he has a good flat with Greta and a good job, even if he’s the only Māori person in his office. Then work sends him to Argentina, right into his ex’s orbit, and “fine” stops being an option.

Meanwhile their family won’t leave them alone. Their mother is keeping secrets, relatives keep turning up with opinions, and the siblings keep trying to sort out their hearts in the middle of all of it. Neither of them is sure what they want. Both of them are going to have to figure it out.

My Review

The voice is the whole show. Reilly writes dry, specific, deeply silly observations about family and dating, and they land again and again. You’ll know within ten pages whether this humor is for you, and for most readers it is.

Greta & Valdin by Rebecca K. Reilly book cover

The second strength is how lightly the book carries its identity themes. Greta and Valdin are queer, Māori and Russian, and the book is sharp about racism and belonging, but it never stops to lecture. It just lets them live, and the commentary arrives inside the jokes.

Where it struggles is the cast, and that’s the most repeated complaint even among fans. One four-star reviewer jokes that it has “930 characters” with names that start with the same letters, and that she kept flipping back to the family guide. A Landfall critic noted a level of information overload. A StoryGraph reader calls it confusing because it does everything at once. The second complaint is plot: one reviewer’s headline is essentially that the book gives you nothing to hold on to, and others say not much happens. A third, smaller one is voice: one reader felt the two narrators sound identical. About 7% of Goodreads ratings are one or two stars, and the harshest reviews call it smug or irritating.

The expectation to reset: this isn’t a sapphic romance with a central couple. It’s a family comedy where Greta’s love life is half the story. If you want vibes, wit and warmth, you’ll love it. If you want a romance arc or a strong plot, it may frustrate you.

My honest note: A funny, warm, award-winning queer family novel that rewards patience with its crowded cast. Keep the family tree handy and enjoy the jokes.

ElementIn Greta & Valdin
Central relationshipGreta and her crush and new love interest, alongside Valdin and his ex
Core tropesSibling dual POV, chaotic family, unrequited crush, found family, academic life
SettingAuckland, New Zealand, with a trip to Buenos Aires
Heat level2/5: brief and mostly off the page
SeriesStandalone
Content notesMental illness, panic attacks and racism (graphic, per StoryGraph); homophobia, infidelity, colonisation; minor sexual content

How Spicy Is Greta & Valdin?

Barely. StoryGraph readers list sexual content only as a minor warning, and the book is a comedy about feelings more than bodies. I couldn’t reach romance.io, and as a literary novel it isn’t really catalogued as romance anyway. I’d call it a 2/5.

The heavier warnings are mental illness, panic attacks and racism, which StoryGraph readers mark as graphic, though the book treats them with its usual light touch. For another funny, warm book about twenty-something queer life that leans more into romance, One Last Stop is a good next step.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you love character-driven comedy, big messy families delight you, you want queer and multiracial lives treated as ordinary, you read for voice.

You may want to skip it if: large casts with similar names lose you, you need a strong plot, you want a central sapphic romance, quirky narration grates on you.

In short: A laugh-out-loud queer family novel that’s all voice and very little plot.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This book traveled from a New Zealand university press to a worldwide hit. It was a bestseller at home, won the Hubert Church Prize and the Aotearoa Booksellers’ Choice Award, then was republished by Penguin Random House in the UK and Simon & Schuster in the US in 2024. Its agency says it was a New York Times Editors’ Choice and a Book of the Year for Time and NPR, and it went on to be shortlisted for the Waterstones Debut Prize and the Lambda Literary Awards. That’s an unusual amount of momentum for a small comic novel. I couldn’t reach Reddit from here.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): “Funny” first, by a long way, and “warm” second. Readers adore the family and the siblings’ relationship, and many say they laughed out loud. Critics praised the tenderness Reilly has for her characters and the way she mixes social commentary with humor. 81% of StoryGraph readers say the character development is strong.

What readers argue about and complain about: First, the cast: too many relatives, too many similar names, and a lot of flipping back. Second, plot, or the lack of it. Third, a minority who find the voice too quirky, with one one-star reviewer simply writing “we get it.” Readers broadly split on whether a book this charming needs a plot. Most decide it doesn’t.

The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a standalone. Reilly’s site says she’s working on a second novel.

The US audiobook from Simon & Schuster Audio has a full cast of five narrators, including Natalie Beran and Jackson Bliss, and runs 9 hours and 28 minutes.

Prefer audio? Listen to Greta & Valdin on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Greta & Valdin a sapphic book?

Partly. Greta is queer and half the book follows her crush and new romance with a woman, while Valdin’s half follows his feelings for his ex-boyfriend. It’s a family comedy, not a romance novel.

Why is Greta & Valdin confusing?

Mostly the cast. The family is huge and several names are similar, and many readers say they kept flipping back to the character guide early on.

Has Greta & Valdin won awards?

Yes. It won the Hubert Church Prize for best first book of fiction at the 2022 Ockham New Zealand Book Awards and was a 2025 Lambda Literary Award finalist in bisexual fiction.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. The US edition has five narrators and runs 9 hours and 28 minutes.

If You Loved Greta & Valdin, Read These Next

One Last Stop has the same funny found-family energy with a sapphic romance at the center. Honey Girl is another book about a queer twenty-something adrift and figuring it out. And for a darker but equally family-centered queer novel, Memory Mambo follows a Cuban American lesbian through her family’s competing stories. More on our Indigenous sapphic books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

Greta & Valdin wants to be a funny, loving portrait of a queer, multiracial family in Auckland. The humor is sharp, the family is unforgettable and the warmth is real. The cast is bewildering, the plot is thin and the sapphic romance is only half the story. If you read for voice and laughs, it’s one of the most charming queer novels of recent years. Check Greta & Valdin on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Greta & Valdin ranks as an award-winning queer family comedy. It’s hilarious and warm, held back by an overcrowded cast and little plot. Read it for the voice, not for a romance arc.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ 3.88 average across 36,000+ Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 4.1 on StoryGraph from nearly 13,000
  • ✓ Hubert Church Prize, 2025 Lambda finalist
  • ✓ Confusing cast is the top complaint

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Greta’s crush is sweet and awkward
  • ✓ Two love stories in parallel
  • ✓ Funny rather than swoony
  • ✓ Not a central romance

Characters ★★★★☆ 4.2/5

  • ✓ 81% on StoryGraph say strong development
  • ✓ Beloved, chaotic family
  • ✓ Siblings readers adore
  • ✓ Too many similar names

Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Laugh-out-loud voice
  • ✓ Social commentary inside the jokes
  • ✓ Specific, dry observations
  • ✓ Two narrators sound alike to some

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ Tender toward its characters
  • ✓ Identity handled lightly but sharply
  • ✓ Top moods: funny and emotional
  • ✓ Low stakes overall

Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 2/5

  • ✓ Sexual content a minor warning
  • ✓ Mostly off the page
  • ✓ Comedy over heat
  • ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Both siblings get resolution
  • ✓ Standalone
  • ✓ Warm, satisfying close
  • ✓ Little plot to pay off

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Jokes hold up on a reread
  • ✓ Five-narrator audiobook
  • ✓ Cast clicks on a second pass
  • ✓ Some readers never get past the start

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment