Thaw Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A sweet, short F/F romance with a biromantic asexual heroine written by an ace author, and for a lot of ace readers it was the first time they saw themselves in a romance, held back by a love interest whose depths are told more than shown and an ending some ace readers object to strongly.

Best for: Readers who want a quiet, low-heat sapphic romance about an introvert and a glamorous ice queen, and who want ace representation at the center rather than in the margins.

Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5: low heat, mostly kissing, with sex negotiated rather than dwelt on)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.3/5: a 3.56 Goodreads average across about 435 ratings, warm praise for the ace rep, and a small but serious objection to how the book resolves the question of sex)

Tropes: Ice queen, opposites attract, librarian and supermodel, asexual heroine, bisexual love interest, coming out as ace, celebrity romance, slow trust, secrets, interconnected standalone.

Thaw is the second book in Elyse Springer’s Seasons of Love series, first published by Riptide in April 2017: a short contemporary sapphic romance in which a shy, biromantic asexual librarian dances with a famous model at a charity auction and then has to work out how to tell her what she does and doesn’t want.

It sits at 3.56 on Goodreads across roughly 435 ratings and 3.41 on StoryGraph across about 190 reviews, which is a small footprint for a book that a lot of ace readers name as important to them. Foreword Reviews called it passionate and raw. The reviews split sharply, and not along the usual lines of pace or prose. They split on what the book says about asexuality. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Thaw About?

This is a contemporary romance with a celebrity twist and a quiet center. Abby has a library job, a small circle of friends and a settled life. Gabrielle Levesque has magazine covers, a public nickname and a team of people managing her image. The glamour gives the book its fairy-tale shape; the real story is about whether someone like Abby can be loved as she is.

Abby is biromantic and asexual, and her fear is simple: that anyone she falls for will leave once they find out sex isn’t something she wants. Gabrielle is biracial and bisexual, known as the Ice Queen for how cold she is in public, and she has secrets of her own that her career depends on keeping. The book stays mostly with Abby, which makes the ace experience vivid and makes Gabrielle harder to know. That trade-off decides how a lot of readers feel about it.

What Makes This Ace Sapphic Romance Work

  • Abby: The most praised thing in the book by a distance. Ace readers describe recognizing their own worries on the page, and several reviewers note with real relief that the author is ace herself.
  • Coming out as ace to a partner: The anxiety of that conversation is the engine of the book, and NetGalley reviewers singled out how carefully it’s balanced against the lighter parts.
  • The ice queen thaw: Readers who love the trope get what they came for. Gabrielle softening around Abby, and only Abby, is the payoff several reviews mention.
  • A comfortable read: Reviewers keep calling it sweet, cute and quick. At around 226 pages it’s a one or two sitting book.
  • Representation on both sides: An ace heroine and a bisexual biracial love interest in a 2017 indie romance was rare, and readers who found it then still recommend it for that reason.

Book Synopsis

Abby likes her life. She likes her library, her apartment and the people she trusts, and she likes that it’s quiet. A friend drags her to a high-profile charity auction, and she ends up on the dance floor with one of the most beautiful women she has ever seen. It’s a lovely night that she assumes will stay a lovely night.

Then Gabrielle Levesque calls. The supermodel the press calls the Ice Queen wants a date, and then another. In public Gabrielle is distant and polished. With Abby she laughs, talks about books and theater, and lets the mask slip. Abby is falling for her, and that’s exactly the problem.

Abby is asexual. She knows what she feels for Gabrielle is real, and she knows it doesn’t include the kind of desire Gabrielle probably expects. Every date brings the conversation closer, and every time she puts it off, the fear gets bigger. Gabrielle isn’t telling everything either: there are things in her life and career that could fall apart if they came out. The question is whether two people this different can be honest with each other before their secrets decide for them.

My Review

Abby is why this book still gets passed around. Her fear isn’t dramatic, it’s ordinary, and that’s what makes it land: the dread of a conversation she’s had before and lost. Springer writes that dread from the inside, and for readers who have lived it, that’s worth more than any plot twist.

Thaw by Elyse Springer book cover

The romance has a nice shape, too. The opening dance is a good meet-cute, and the early dates have real warmth. When Gabrielle drops the Ice Queen act with Abby, the book is at its best.

Where it struggles, there are two separate problems, and they come from different readers. The first is Gabrielle. A reader who otherwise liked Abby says the book keeps insisting Gabrielle has hidden depths without ever showing what they are, and that Abby forgives her too easily for things like tracking down Abby’s address. Others describe the love story as a bit surface-level. A couple of readers mention skimming when the two leads weren’t together, and one found the city setting generic.

The second problem is bigger, and you should know about it before you buy. A small number of readers, at least one with a whole document of notes, object to how the book resolves the sex question. Their reading is that the asexual heroine ends up having sex she doesn’t want in order to keep the relationship, and that the book presents this as a healthy compromise. Other ace readers loved the same book and felt seen by it. I can’t settle that for you. It’s a real split, and if consent and compromise in ace relationships is something you feel strongly about, read a few reviews from both sides first.

My honest note: Important representation in a sweet, slight package, with an ending that won’t sit right with every ace reader. Read it for Abby, and go in knowing where the debate is.

ElementIn Thaw
Central relationshipAbby, a biromantic asexual librarian, and Gabrielle Levesque, a bisexual biracial supermodel known as the Ice Queen
Core tropesIce queen, opposites attract, celebrity romance, coming out as ace, secrets
SettingNew York, between a quiet library life and the fashion world
Heat level2/5: low heat, mostly kissing, with sex negotiated rather than dwelt on
SeriesSeasons of Love book 2 of 4: interconnected standalone, ends with the couple together
Content notesSex negotiated by an asexual character, which some readers find uncomfortable; fear of rejection for being ace; secrets that threaten a career (from reader reviews; StoryGraph lists no warnings yet)

How Spicy Is Thaw?

Not very. I couldn’t get romance.io’s page to load past its bot check, and StoryGraph has no content warnings for this book yet, so this comes from readers. One reviewer rated it one flame out of five, and another joked that ace romances are full of kissing because the intimacy has to go somewhere. That matches what the reviews describe: affection, kissing and a lot of talking about sex rather than detailed scenes. I’d call it a 2.

The thing worth flagging isn’t heat, it’s the negotiation. How Abby and Gabrielle handle sex is the most argued-about part of the book, and some ace readers find it distressing. If you want a low-heat sapphic romance with ace representation and a different approach, Perfect Rhythm and Kiss Me, Maybe are both on the site.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you’ve been looking for an asexual heroine in a sapphic romance, you like the ice queen trope, you want a short, sweet read, and you’re happy with low heat.

You may want to skip it if: you want a love interest with fully drawn depths, you dislike leads who forgive too easily, you want a setting with a strong sense of place, or you feel strongly that an ace character shouldn’t compromise on sex to keep a partner.

In short: A comforting book for many ace readers and a frustrating one for some, so check which camp you’re likely in.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a quiet book with a loyal readership. It has about 435 Goodreads ratings and 123 written reviews, roughly 190 on StoryGraph, and no recent surge driving new readers to it. What keeps it alive is word of mouth inside ace reading circles: one reviewer picked it up after a Smart Bitches, Trashy Books podcast episode about ace and aro characters in romance, and it shows up on ace-spectrum reading lists like ours. Trade coverage is limited to Foreword Reviews, which praised it, and a Publishers Weekly catalog listing. I didn’t find a Libro.fm audiobook for it, and I found no listener discussion that suggests an audio edition is widely read.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Representation, first and last. The most enthusiastic reviews are from ace readers who say they finally found a character who felt the way they do, and several mention that it matters to them that the author is ace. After that, readers praise the sweetness, the ice queen softening, and the fact that it’s an easy, quick read. A few readers say they started the series out of order and it didn’t matter.

What readers argue about and complain about: The resolution of the sex question, above everything, even though it comes from a minority. The readers who object do so strongly, and their objection is specific: that the book’s message is that ace people should have sex they don’t want to keep a relationship. The second theme is Gabrielle, who several readers found underwritten, with her depth asserted rather than shown. Third: a thin feel overall, with readers calling the love story surface-level and admitting to skimming the scenes without both leads. One reader also found the New York setting generic. The genuine split is the ace representation itself, which some readers call the best they’ve read and others call harmful. Both groups include ace readers.

The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone. The romance resolves with the couple together and there’s no cliffhanger. Seasons of Love has four books, and Abby appears briefly in the first one, Whiteout, but readers who started with Thaw say they didn’t miss anything. On Goodreads the series averages 3.56 across about 1,168 ratings, so this book sits right at the series’ average.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Thaw a lesbian romance?

It’s a sapphic romance between Abby, who is biromantic and asexual, and Gabrielle, who is bisexual. Neither lead is described as a lesbian, but it’s an F/F romance with a happy ending.

How spicy is Thaw?

About a 2/5. It’s mostly kissing and affection, with sex discussed and negotiated rather than described at length. One reviewer rated it one flame out of five.

Is the asexual representation in Thaw good?

Readers disagree. Many ace readers, and the author is ace, say it’s the first time they saw themselves in a romance. A smaller group objects that the book treats an ace character having unwanted sex as a healthy compromise.

Do I need to read Whiteout first?

No. Thaw is book two of Seasons of Love, but each book follows a different couple, and readers who started here say it works on its own.

Is there a Thaw audiobook?

I didn’t find one on Libro.fm. Check Audible for the current listing.

If You Loved Thaw, Read These Next

For another ace-spectrum sapphic romance with more page time for both leads, try Perfect Rhythm, where a pop star and a small-town nurse work out the same questions. Kiss Me, Maybe gives you a gray-ace lead with a contemporary rom-com setup. And if the celebrity side was the draw, Tempted by the Actress runs the famous-woman, ordinary-woman pairing. For more, browse our ace-spectrum sapphic books guide or the full book reviews archive.

The Bottom Line

Thaw set out to put an asexual woman at the center of a sapphic love story, and for many readers that alone makes it matter. Abby is believable, the ice queen trope is satisfying, and it’s a quick, kind read. Gabrielle stays out of focus, the romance runs thin, and the way the book handles sex divides its own target audience. It’s worth it for readers looking for ace representation who are open to a debate about it. Check Thaw on Amazon

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Thaw ranks as a short, important ace sapphic romance. It’s strongest on Abby’s point of view and weakest on its love interest and its contested resolution. Read it for the representation rather than the glamour.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ 3.56 average across 435 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.41 on StoryGraph across about 190 reviews
  • ✓ Ace representation the main draw
  • ✓ Contested resolution of the sex question

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Good meet-cute on the dance floor
  • ✓ Ice queen softens only for Abby
  • ✓ Some readers call it surface-level
  • ✓ Abby forgives too easily for one reader

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Abby widely praised as relatable
  • ✓ Bisexual biracial love interest
  • ✓ Gabrielle told more than shown
  • ✓ Thin supporting cast

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Sweet, quick, easy to read
  • ✓ Foreword Reviews called it passionate and raw
  • ✓ Readers skim scenes without both leads
  • ✓ Setting called generic by one reader

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Fear of rejection lands for ace readers
  • ✓ Many say they felt seen
  • ✓ Low external stakes
  • ✓ Some ace readers left uncomfortable

Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 2/5

  • ✓ Mostly kissing and affection
  • ✓ One reviewer rated it one flame of five
  • ✓ Sex negotiated rather than detailed
  • ✓ No romance.io band available

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Couple ends together
  • ✓ No cliffhanger
  • ✓ Stands alone in the series
  • ✓ Resolution is the most disputed part

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3/5

  • ✓ Short enough to revisit easily
  • ✓ Comfort read for its fans
  • ✓ No audiobook found on Libro.fm
  • ✓ Thin romance limits a reread

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment