Each of Us a Desert Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A gorgeous, strange YA fantasy about a girl who carries her village’s confessions across the desert, with a sapphic love story that grows out of hostility, held back by a slow pace that a lot of readers couldn’t push through and a second half that loses some of them.

Best for: Readers who love lyrical prose, allegory and slow, thoughtful fantasy, and who are happy for the romance to be one part of a story about faith, guilt and storytelling.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: YA, longing and kisses)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.6/5: a 3.83 Goodreads average across about 1,570 ratings, strong trade reviews, and more than half of StoryGraph readers calling it slow)

Tropes: Enemies to lovers, journey across a desert, chosen role she didn’t want, religious doubt, stories as magic, forced proximity, sapphic slow burn, monsters at night, found voice, standalone.

Each of Us a Desert is Mark Oshiro’s second novel, published by Tor Teen in September 2020: a YA fantasy set in a post-apocalyptic desert where a village storyteller absorbs everyone’s confessions and gives them to a god, until a journey with the one girl who hates her makes her question what she’s been carrying.

It sits at 3.83 on Goodreads across roughly 1,570 ratings and 3.88 on StoryGraph across almost 900 reviews. Kirkus, Publishers Weekly, Booklist and School Library Journal all reviewed it, and it made NPR’s best books list for 2020. Readers agree about the writing more than they agree about anything else. They disagree, sharply, about whether the pace is worth it. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Each of Us a Desert About?

This is literary YA fantasy that leans toward allegory. The world is a desert after some kind of collapse, with a Mexican-inspired culture, a lot of Spanish on the page and a single god, Solís, who keeps the desert from swallowing the people. Magic here is made of stories: told, taken, carried and released.

Xochitl is the cuentista of her village. Since she was a child, people have come to her to unload their secrets, and she takes the stories into herself and gives them to Solís so the village can be clean. She’s lonely, tired and full of things that aren’t hers. Emilia is a girl from the same village with her own reasons to resent the cuentista, and she can’t stand Xochitl. The whole book is told by Xochitl to Solís, almost as a prayer. One reader compared reading it to overhearing a confession, and that’s the right image.

What Makes This Sapphic YA Fantasy Work

  • The prose: The most praised thing in the reviews by a distance. Readers call it beautiful, lyrical and unlike anything else they’ve read, and even the people who quit say they loved the writing.
  • The premise: A girl who has to hold other people’s sins inside her is a strong, original idea, and the book uses it to talk about guilt, faith and what we owe each other.
  • Xochitl and Emilia: Their relationship starts in real hostility. Readers who loved the book single out the moment Xochitl feels something that belongs to her alone, after years of carrying everyone else’s feelings.
  • Latinx and queer identity: The cast is entirely Latinx, queerness is normal in the world, and several Latinx queer readers say the book meant a great deal to them.
  • Audio: School Library Journal praised Frankie Corzo’s narration, and the audiobook is a natural fit for a book written as a spoken confession.

Book Synopsis

Xochitl was eight when she became the cuentista of her village. Ever since, she’s spent her days listening to people’s secrets: their cruelties, their fears, the things they’d never say aloud to anyone else. She takes the stories into her body, carries them out into the desert, and gives them to Solís, who cleanses the village so it can go on. It’s a holy job. It’s also lonely, and the stories don’t always leave when she lets them go.

Xochitl wants someone to share her life with. What she gets is Emilia, a sharp-tongued girl from her village who resents Xochitl and everything she stands for. Then something goes wrong at home, and the two of them are forced to set out across the desert together.

The desert is dangerous by day and worse at night, when terrible things rise out of the sand. Every village they pass through has its own stories and its own fears, and some of them don’t line up with what Xochitl was taught. The longer she travels with Emilia, the more she begins to doubt the role she was given and the god she gave everything to. The question is what’s left of her if she stops carrying everyone else’s sins.

My Review

The writing is the reason this book exists in readers’ heads at all. Oshiro writes Xochitl’s voice like a hymn, addressed to a god she’s starting to doubt, and some of the lines about wanting something for yourself after a lifetime of holding other people’s pain are the best in the book. It’s the kind of prose that makes readers copy passages into notebooks, and a lot of them did.

Each of Us a Desert by Mark Oshiro book cover

The premise is the second strength. Turning confession into a physical burden is a clever idea, and it gives the romance a real foundation: Emilia is the first person Xochitl wants for herself and not for the village. The relationship moves from hostility to trust to something more, slowly, and it’s the warmest thing in a cold, harsh book.

Where it struggles, almost everyone agrees on the same thing: pace. On StoryGraph, 54% of readers call it slow, and only 1% call it fast. That’s unusually lopsided. On Goodreads, one reader called it ten days of slow torture, another took a month to finish, and another quit a quarter of the way in because they couldn’t get a fix on who Xochitl was. The second complaint is related: the book is long, around 432 pages, and has few natural stopping points, which one reader said made it hard to pick back up. Third, a smaller group loved the first half and lost interest in the second, and a few found the allegory confusing or felt the blurb sold them a different book.

The expectation to reset is the romance. The marketing talks about two girls falling in love on a dangerous journey, and that’s in there, but this is mainly a book about faith and stories. If you came for a sapphic adventure romance, calibrate. If you came for something literary and haunting, you’ll probably find more than you expected.

My honest note: Beautiful and demanding, with a romance that rewards patience. If slow books lose you, try the audiobook first, or try something else.

ElementIn Each of Us a Desert
Central relationshipXochitl, the village cuentista, and Emilia, a village girl who resents her, enemies to lovers
Core tropesDesert journey, enemies to lovers, religious doubt, stories as magic, forced proximity
SettingA post-apocalyptic, Mexican-inspired desert watched over by the god Solís
Heat level1/5: YA, longing and kisses
SeriesStandalone, complete in one book
Content notesGore, death and violence; animal cruelty and animal death; vomiting; minor alcoholism, infidelity and domestic abuse (StoryGraph reader warnings)

How Spicy Is Each of Us a Desert?

Not spicy. It’s YA from Tor Teen, romance.io doesn’t catalog it as an adult romance, and by every reader account the romance is longing, closeness and kisses. One reader quoted the moment Xochitl first feels desire that belongs to her, and that’s about as heated as it gets. I’d call it a 1.

The thing to flag is darkness, not heat. Kirkus called it often gory, and StoryGraph readers list gore, death and violence as graphic, with animal cruelty at a moderate level. If you liked the tone of Girl, Serpent, Thorn or Labyrinth Lost, this is darker but sits in the same closed-door band.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: beautiful sentences matter more to you than plot speed, you like allegory and books about faith and doubt, you want a fully Latinx queer cast, and a slow enemies-to-lovers arc is a plus.

You may want to skip it if: slow pacing makes you quit, you want a clear, action-driven adventure, you need short chapters and frequent breaks, or gore and animal cruelty are hard limits.

In short: One of the best-written books on our list, and one of the hardest to finish.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a well-reviewed literary YA novel with a modest, steady readership: about 1,570 Goodreads ratings and 456 written reviews, and close to 900 on StoryGraph. It reached readers through the trade press and through Oshiro’s existing audience from their debut, Anger Is a Gift, and their online review work. Kirkus called it intricate and allegorical, and it showed up on NPR’s best books of 2020. It’s also a regular on Latinx and queer YA reading lists, which is where most new readers seem to find it now.

The audiobook from Macmillan Audio is narrated by Frankie Corzo and runs 12 hours 30 minutes. School Library Journal described her narration as almost lyrical, which suits a book that’s written to be heard.

Prefer audio? Listen to Each of Us a Desert on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The writing, first and last. “Beautiful” is the recurring word, followed by “lyrical” and “unlike anything.” Latinx and queer readers say the book felt like it was written for them. Readers praise the originality of the premise, and one compared it to Rivers Solomon’s The Deep, another book about carrying a community’s memories. And the people who finished it often say the ending and acknowledgments made them cry.

What readers argue about and complain about: Pace, above everything. More than half of StoryGraph readers call it slow, and the low-star Goodreads reviews are dominated by people who wanted it to move. Second: structure, with long sections and few natural breaks that make it hard to pick up and put down. Third: the second half, which a group of readers found weaker than the first. Fourth: confusion, with a couple of readers calling the allegory hard to follow and one saying the back-cover copy promised a different book. The real split is whether the slowness is a feature. For one group it’s meditative and earned; for the other it’s a slog.

The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone. The story resolves in this book and there’s no sequel to wait for. If you liked Oshiro’s voice, their debut Anger Is a Gift is a contemporary YA novel about police violence, a very different book in tone, and they’ve since written middle grade as well.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Each of Us a Desert a sapphic book?

Yes. The central relationship is between Xochitl and Emilia, two girls who start out hostile and grow close during their journey. The romance is a major thread, but the book is mostly about faith, guilt and storytelling.

How spicy is Each of Us a Desert?

It’s a 1/5. It’s YA from Tor Teen, and the romance is longing and kisses. The darker content is violence and gore rather than anything sexual.

Is Each of Us a Desert slow?

Yes, for most readers. 54% of StoryGraph readers call it slow and only 1% call it fast, and slowness is the most common complaint in low-star reviews.

Is Each of Us a Desert a standalone?

Yes. It’s a complete story in one book with no sequel.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Macmillan Audio published it, narrated by Frankie Corzo, with a runtime of 12 hours 30 minutes. It’s available on Libro.fm and Audible.

If You Loved Each of Us a Desert, Read These Next

If the Latin American inspired world and the sapphic heart were the draw, We Set the Dark on Fire gives you both with a faster, more political plot. If you liked a heroine carrying something dangerous inside her, Girl, Serpent, Thorn runs that idea through Persian myth. And for brujas and a strange journey through another world, Labyrinth Lost is lighter and quicker. For more, browse our Latine sapphic books guide or the full book reviews archive.

The Bottom Line

Each of Us a Desert set out to write a fantasy about the weight of other people’s stories, and it does that with real beauty. The prose is exceptional, the premise is original, and the slow-growing romance gives the book its warmth. It’s slow, long and hard to pick back up, and some readers lose the thread in the second half. It’s worth it for readers who love language and allegory and who’ll trade momentum for depth. Check Each of Us a Desert on Amazon

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Each of Us a Desert ranks as a lyrical, literary sapphic YA fantasy. It’s strongest on prose and premise and weakest on pace. Read it for the writing and Xochitl’s voice rather than for adventure or romance.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ 3.83 average across 1,572 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.88 on StoryGraph across 887 reviews
  • ✓ Kirkus, PW, Booklist and SLJ reviewed it
  • ✓ 54% of StoryGraph readers call it slow

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Enemies to lovers built slowly
  • ✓ Emilia the first thing Xochitl wants for herself
  • ✓ Warmest thread in a harsh book
  • ✓ A secondary thread to faith and guilt

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Xochitl’s voice praised as distinctive
  • ✓ Fully Latinx queer cast
  • ✓ 68% of StoryGraph readers find them loveable
  • ✓ Some readers never got a sense of Xochitl

Writing ★★★★☆ 4.3/5

  • ✓ Beautiful is the recurring word
  • ✓ Written as a prayer to Solís
  • ✓ Kirkus called it intricate and allegorical
  • ✓ Long sections with few breaks

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ Guilt and faith themes land hard
  • ✓ Readers cried at the ending
  • ✓ Desire as something of her own
  • ✓ Slowness dulls it for many

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ YA from Tor Teen
  • ✓ Longing and kisses only
  • ✓ Not catalogued as adult romance
  • ✓ Darkness comes from gore, not heat

Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Story resolves in one book
  • ✓ No sequel needed
  • ✓ Readers moved by the close
  • ✓ Second half weaker for a group of readers

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Prose rewards rereading
  • ✓ 12 hour 30 minute audiobook
  • ✓ Quotable passages
  • ✓ Slow pace discourages a return

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment