Magic for Liars Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A sharp, bitter detective noir set inside a California school for teenage mages, with a narrator whose self-deception is the real mystery, held back by a lead most readers find hard to like and very little sapphic content for a book on sapphic lists.

Best for: Readers who want adult mystery with magic, a messy first-person investigator and sister drama, and who aren’t looking for an F/F romance.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: little to no on-page romance heat)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.3/5: a 3.62 Goodreads average across about 37,000 ratings, a Locus Award shortlisting, and a heroine only 27% of StoryGraph readers find loveable)

Tropes: Magic school murder, private investigator, estranged twins, noir narrator, unreliable self-image, outsider in a magical world, campus mystery, sibling rivalry, secrets and lies, standalone.

Magic for Liars is Sarah Gailey’s first full-length novel, published by Tor in June 2019: a contemporary fantasy mystery about a non-magical private investigator who takes a murder case at the magical academy where her estranged twin sister teaches.

It sits at 3.62 on Goodreads across roughly 37,000 ratings and 3.66 on StoryGraph across more than 15,000 reviews. Publishers Weekly called it clever and fast-paced, and it was a 2020 Locus Award finalist for best first novel. It appears on our list of lesbian mystery audiobooks for its queer representation and its investigation, not for a central F/F romance, and that distinction matters a lot here. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.

What Is Magic for Liars About?

This is detective noir in a magic-school setting. The school is a high school for young mages in the Bay Area, full of teenagers using magic for exactly the petty things teenagers would use it for. The genre is the hard-drinking PI story, and the magic mostly serves to make Ivy feel left out.

Ivy Gamble is a private investigator who usually photographs cheating spouses. She was born without magic and has always said she didn’t want it. Her twin sister Tabitha got the magic, the school and the life Ivy tells herself she doesn’t envy. The book is narrated by Ivy in first person, and it’s built so that you see everyone through her suspicion, her resentment and her lies to herself. That narrative choice is the book’s best idea and the reason so many readers dislike her.

What Makes This Magic-School Noir Work

  • The premise: A murder at a Hogwarts-style school, solved by an outsider who resents the whole system. Reviewers keep describing it as Veronica Mars meets Harry Potter, and that pitch is what drew most readers in.
  • Ivy’s voice: A noir narrator who lies to the reader because she’s lying to herself. Fans call her one of the most interesting unlikeable heroines they’ve read.
  • The twins: Ivy and Tabitha’s broken relationship is the emotional center. Readers with sisters say it hit uncomfortably close.
  • Realistic teens: Readers like that the magical students are petty, horny and self-absorbed in believable ways, and that the school is queer-inclusive.
  • Audio: Xe Sands narrates, and the first-person noir voice is a natural fit for listening.

Book Synopsis

Ivy Gamble makes a living catching people in lies: cheating husbands, insurance frauds, people who said they were somewhere they weren’t. She drinks too much, sleeps badly, and hasn’t really spoken to her twin sister in years. Tabitha has magic. Ivy doesn’t. That’s been the shape of their lives since they were kids.

Then the headmaster of the Osthorne Academy for Young Mages hires Ivy to look into a death on campus, a teacher killed in a way nobody can explain. The school’s magical investigators have no answers. Ivy is cheap, discreet and, the headmaster hopes, easy to manage. She also happens to be the sister of one of the faculty.

So Ivy moves into a world she’s spent her life pretending not to want. She interviews teenagers who can bend reality and teachers who keep their secrets behind wards. She starts to like who people think she is here. And the closer she gets to the truth about the murder, the harder it becomes to tell the truth about herself, to Tabitha or to anyone else.

My Review

Ivy is the best thing in the book and the biggest problem with it, and I mean that as praise. Gailey writes a narrator whose bitterness bleeds into every observation, so that you slowly realize the person you can trust least is the one telling the story. When it works, it’s sharp and sad. You watch Ivy want something she’ll never have and lie about it on every page.

Magic for Liars by Sarah Gailey book cover

The setting is the second strength. The school feels like a real high school with magic bolted on, not a fantasy castle: teenagers using spells for gossip and pranks, staff politics, a library that’s slightly creepy. Shelf Awareness said the book riffs lovingly on the magic-school trope, and that’s fair.

Where it struggles, the reviews mostly point at Ivy. Only 27% of StoryGraph readers call the characters loveable, which is very low, and the Goodreads complaints are specific: self-pity, wallowing, a narrator some readers just wanted to shake. The second complaint is the mystery. Several readers guessed the solution early, and a cluster call the whole thing predictable or forgettable. Third, a couple of readers found the teen drama and the tone melodramatic.

The expectation to reset, for readers of this site, is the sapphic content. Ivy’s own romantic thread is with a man. The queer content is a pair of background teens and a lesbian couple tied to the central crime, and at least one reader warns that the most prominent sapphic relationship in the book sits at the heart of the murder plot. If you came for F/F romance, this isn’t it. If you came for a queer-inclusive magical mystery with a damaged detective, you’re in the right place.

My honest note: A clever, sour, very readable noir that’s more about envy than magic. Read it for Ivy and Tabitha, and don’t expect a sapphic love story.

ElementIn Magic for Liars
Central relationshipIvy Gamble and her estranged twin Tabitha; Ivy’s own romance is M/F, with sapphic characters in supporting roles
Core tropesMagic school murder, private investigator, estranged twins, noir narrator, outsider in a magical world
SettingOsthorne Academy for Young Mages, a magical high school in the San Francisco Bay Area
Heat level1/5: little to no on-page romance heat
SeriesStandalone
Content notesAbortion, body horror and cancer; death of a parent, alcoholism, blood; minor adult and minor relationship, eating disorder; death of a queer character (StoryGraph and reader warnings)

How Spicy Is Magic for Liars?

Not spicy. This is a mystery shelved as fantasy, it isn’t catalogued on romance.io as a romance, and by reader accounts the romantic content is limited to Ivy’s attraction to a colleague and some teenage relationships at the school. I’d call it a 1.

The things worth flagging are content, not heat. StoryGraph readers list abortion, body horror and cancer as graphic, and a teacher and student relationship comes up as a minor warning. If you’re after magic and murder with a real F/F romance, A Restless Truth is the better pick, and An Education in Malice gives you a dark academic setting with sapphic tension front and center.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you like noir narrators who lie to themselves, magic schools appeal to you but you’re tired of chosen ones, sister stories hit you hard, and you’re happy with a mystery that’s more character study than puzzle.

You may want to skip it if: you need a likeable lead, you want a twisty mystery you can’t solve, you’re looking for sapphic romance, or abortion and cancer are hard content for you.

In short: A smart magical noir about jealousy, not a sapphic book in any central sense.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This book had a big launch and a long tail. It came out from Tor in 2019 with placements on Goodreads’ hottest summer books and most popular sci-fi and fantasy lists, and it still pulls readers in through the Veronica Mars meets Harry Potter pitch. It has about 37,000 Goodreads ratings and 5,450 written reviews, and close to 16,000 on StoryGraph. It was a Locus Award finalist for best first novel in 2020. Gailey’s later books, like The Echo Wife, also send readers back to it.

The audiobook from Macmillan Audio is narrated by Xe Sands and runs 9 hours 7 minutes.

Prefer audio? Listen to Magic for Liars on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The concept and the narrator. Fans love a messy, hard-drinking PI walking into a magic school, and they love that Ivy is unlikeable on purpose. The sister relationship is the emotional hook, and several reviewers say it reminded them painfully of their own siblings. Queer readers appreciate a magic school that’s realistically queer and diverse. A few readers compare the atmosphere to Tana French.

What readers argue about and complain about: Ivy, above everything. The self-pity and the constant envy wear a lot of readers down, and the 27% loveable score on StoryGraph is one of the lowest I’ve seen on our lists. Second: the mystery itself, which several readers solved early and others found forgettable. Third: tone, with a couple of readers calling it melodramatic. Fourth, from a sapphic-reader angle: one reviewer points out that the book’s two queer couples are minor teens and a lesbian pair at the center of the crime, and flags it as a representation concern. The real split is Ivy herself. Half the readers think her unlikeability is the point; the other half think it’s a reason to stop reading.

The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone. The mystery is solved in this book and there’s no sequel, though some readers have asked for one. If you liked Gailey’s voice, The Echo Wife is a darker, adult thriller, and their YA novel When We Were Magic follows a group of queer teen witches.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Magic for Liars a sapphic book?

Not centrally. The narrator Ivy’s romantic thread is with a man. The book includes queer students and a lesbian couple connected to the murder, which is why it appears on queer mystery lists, but there is no central F/F romance.

How spicy is Magic for Liars?

It’s a 1/5. There’s very little romance on the page and nothing explicit. The heavier content is abortion, cancer and body horror.

Is Magic for Liars YA?

No. It’s an adult novel narrated by a grown private investigator, even though it’s set in a high school for young mages.

Is Magic for Liars a standalone?

Yes. The mystery resolves in this book and there’s no sequel.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Macmillan Audio published it, narrated by Xe Sands, with a runtime of 9 hours 7 minutes. It’s available on Libro.fm and Audible.

If You Loved Magic for Liars, Read These Next

For magic, murder and a real F/F romance, A Restless Truth puts a murder on an ocean liner and two women at the center of it. If the dark academic setting was the draw, An Education in Malice gives you a gothic college and a sapphic rivalry. And if you want classic lesbian detective noir without the magic, Murder at the Nightwood Bar is the foundational example. For more, browse our lesbian mystery and thriller audiobooks guide or the full book reviews archive.

The Bottom Line

Magic for Liars set out to drop a bitter, non-magical PI into a school full of mages and see what broke, and it delivers a sharp character study. Ivy’s voice is memorable, the sister story hurts, and the school feels real. The heroine is hard to like, the mystery is guessable, and for sapphic readers the queer content is thin and tied to the crime. It’s worth it for readers who want smart magical noir and a complicated narrator, not a love story. Check Magic for Liars on Amazon

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Magic for Liars ranks as a clever queer-inclusive magical noir. It’s strongest on its narrator and its sister story and weakest on likeability and sapphic content. Read it for the mystery and Ivy rather than for romance.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ 3.62 average across 36,984 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.66 on StoryGraph across 15,699 reviews
  • ✓ 2020 Locus Award finalist, best first novel
  • ✓ Only 27% find the characters loveable

Romance ★★☆☆☆ 2/5

  • ✓ Ivy’s own romance is M/F
  • ✓ Queer teens in background roles
  • ✓ Lesbian couple tied to the crime
  • ✓ No central sapphic relationship

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Ivy a memorable unreliable narrator
  • ✓ Twin relationship hits hard
  • ✓ Teens feel realistically petty
  • ✓ Self-pity wears many readers down

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Publishers Weekly called it clever and fast-paced
  • ✓ Strong noir voice
  • ✓ 90% of StoryGraph readers tag it mysterious
  • ✓ Melodramatic for a few readers

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Envy and grief land
  • ✓ Sister story painfully relatable
  • ✓ Dark tone, 58% tag it dark
  • ✓ Hard to care about Ivy for some

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Little romance on the page
  • ✓ Nothing explicit
  • ✓ Not catalogued as romance
  • ✓ Heavier content is medical and violent

Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Mystery solved in one book
  • ✓ No sequel
  • ✓ Emotional payoff for the twins
  • ✓ Several readers guessed the killer

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 2.9/5

  • ✓ Narration rewards a second look
  • ✓ 9 hour 7 minute audiobook
  • ✓ Fans enjoy spotting Ivy’s lies
  • ✓ Solved mystery limits a reread

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment