One Solstice Night Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A tiny, sugar-sweet winter novella about a hopeless witch and a lonely shapeshifter that does exactly what it promises in one sitting, held back by how little room it leaves for the romance to grow and a plot readers call simple and predictable.

Best for: Readers who want a cozy, closed-door sapphic fairy tale to read on a December evening, and who are happy with charm over depth.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: closed door and sweet)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.6/5: a 3.85 Goodreads average across about 160 ratings, from a small and mostly fond readership that also calls it slight)

Tropes: Hapless witch, shapeshifter love interest, outcast in a small town, winter solstice, fairy-tale retelling feel, insta-attraction, talking cat, holiday romance.

One Solstice Night is a 2011 novella by Elora Bishop and the first of her three Benevolence Tales: a short, cozy sapphic fantasy romance set in a snowbound mountain village, where a witch who keeps getting chased out of towns is hired to cast one spell a year and falls for the shapeshifter the town has shut out.

The original novella holds a 3.85 Goodreads average across about 160 ratings, and StoryGraph readers land close at 3.91. Those are small numbers, and there’s a reason: the author later folded all three Benevolence Tales into a single book, Under Her Spell, published under another pen name, Bridget Essex, and that’s where most new readers meet Isabella and Emily now. The reviews of this standalone are warm but short, and the same few words keep coming up. Both the fondness and the shrug are worth hearing.

What Is One Solstice Night About?

It’s a cozy fantasy novella, closer to a fairy tale than to a modern romantasy. There’s a village, a snowy forest, a winter festival and a monster at the edges, and the magic runs on charm rather than rules. The small town matters: Benevolence is lovely if you belong, and the story is partly about who doesn’t.

Isabella Fox is a self-described mediocre witch whose spells go sideways often enough that she’s been run out of town more than once. One reviewer reads her as a witch with something like attention trouble, which fits how the book plays her mistakes for warmth rather than shame. Emily is a shapeshifter who lives alone in the mountains because the town won’t have her. Isabella narrates, so you see Emily through Isabella’s curiosity, and the whole thing moves at the speed of one long winter night.

What Makes This Cozy Sapphic Witch Novella Work

  • The mood: Snow, a festival and a village that glows. Readers who loved it mostly loved this, and StoryGraph’s handful of mood votes all land on funny, hopeful and lighthearted.
  • A heroine who isn’t good at her job: Isabella’s mediocrity is the running joke and the heart of the book. Reviewers find her easy to like because she keeps trying.
  • The outcast love interest: Emily being shut out of the town’s celebrations gives the romance a small, real stake. It’s the closest thing the story has to an argument.
  • Unapologetic queer romance: One longtime reader remembers this as some of the first lesbian romance she read where nobody had to die or be punished for it, and that’s part of why it has kept fans for more than a decade.
  • A talking cat: It comes up in reviews more than you’d think. If that’s a selling point for you, it’s here.

Book Synopsis

Isabella Fox has run out of second chances. Her spells have a way of going wrong, and the last town that hired her sent her off with torches. So when the mountain village of Benevolence offers her the post of village magicmaker, with just one spell to cast each year, it feels like the job even she can’t ruin.

Benevolence is getting ready for the Winter Solstice, and everyone is invited to the celebration except Emily, a shapeshifter who lives alone up in the mountains and keeps her distance from the people who keep their distance from her. Isabella doesn’t know what to make of her until the two of them cross paths in the snowy woods, and something between them catches.

But the one spell Isabella was hired to cast matters more than anyone told her. The town’s protection isn’t as complete as it looks, something dangerous waits beyond the treeline, and the longest night of the year is coming fast. Isabella has never managed to get a spell right when it counted. She’s about to find out whether this time is different, and whether the woman everyone else has turned away will be standing next to her when she tries.

My Review

What this does well, it does very well: it builds a place you’d want to spend a December night in. Benevolence is all lanterns and snow, the festival feels like a real tradition, and Isabella’s voice is light and self-mocking without tipping into slapstick. It reads like a fairy tale told by someone who loves fairy tales, and one reviewer calls it exactly that: a charming fairy tale built on traditional stories.

One Solstice Night by Elora Bishop book cover

The second strength is how gentle it is about Emily’s exclusion. The book doesn’t turn it into a lecture. Emily is simply not welcome, Isabella notices, and that noticing is how the romance starts. For a short story, it’s a smart engine: the outsider witch and the outcast shifter find each other, and the town’s blind spot becomes part of the danger.

The weak point is size. This is a novella, and a short one (one reviewer who reread it says it’s shorter than the two books that follow), so the romance runs on attraction at first sight and a single night. Readers who liked it call it a “simple tale, simply told,” which is praise, but readers who didn’t say the same thing with a frown. The words that recur are “predictable,” “sweet” and “quick.” The one blunt dissent on Goodreads calls it a two for her, and suggests it gets five stars because sapphic readers were starved for options when it came out. About 9% of its Goodreads ratings are one or two stars, which is not a lot, but there’s a clear theme among them.

So set expectations by format. If you want a full novel’s worth of longing, this isn’t it, and you’d be better off with Under Her Spell, which collects all three Benevolence Tales so the relationship gets room to grow. If you want a cup-of-tea read with a happy ending and some snow on it, this delivers in an hour or two.

My honest note: A sweet little winter story that’s more postcard than novel. Read it as a holiday treat, and if you fall for Isabella, get the collection.

ElementIn One Solstice Night
Central relationshipIsabella Fox, a hapless witch for hire, and Emily, a shapeshifter the town has shut out
Core tropesHapless witch, shapeshifter love interest, outcast, winter festival, insta-attraction, talking cat
SettingBenevolence, a snowbound magical mountain village, at the Winter Solstice
Heat level1/5: closed door and sweet
SeriesBenevolence Tales book 1; HEA; collected with books 2 and 3 in Under Her Spell
Content notesMob violence against a witch (mentioned, handled lightly), exclusion and prejudice against a shapeshifter, a monster threat; StoryGraph lists no warnings yet

How Spicy Is One Solstice Night?

A 1/5. I couldn’t get past romance.io’s bot check from here, so this comes from what readers report: reviewers call the novella “sweet,” and a reviewer of the Under Her Spell collection says plainly there’s no spice. One reader of the collection even thinks it reads more like a young teen book. It’s a closed-door love story with a kiss-and-hold-hands level of romance.

The only thing worth flagging is that Isabella’s backstory includes being chased out of towns by angry mobs, and there’s a dangerous creature in the second half. Reviewers say both are handled lightly, and StoryGraph has no warnings listed at all. If you want something in the same gentle register, The Cybernetic Tea Shop is another short, sweet, low-heat sapphic novella.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want a cozy holiday read, you like fairy-tale fantasy with snow and a village, you prefer closed-door romance, you can finish a novella in one sitting and be happy.

You may want to skip it if: you need a slow-burn relationship with room to breathe, predictable plots bore you, you want open-door heat, you’d rather buy one book than track down a short standalone.

In short: Charming and slight, and it knows it.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a quiet backlist title, and the discourse is quiet to match. There are about 160 Goodreads ratings and 19 written reviews on the original novella, plus about 40 ratings on StoryGraph. I found no trade reviews, and I couldn’t reach Reddit from here. A couple of book bloggers covered it around its release. What keeps it alive is the author’s later career: the Benevolence Tales were reissued in 2017 as Under Her Spell by Bridget Essex, a pen name with a much bigger readership, and that collection has its own audiobook narrated by Rose Clearwater. So most people reading Isabella and Emily now are reading them there.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): “Sweet” and “charming” are the recurring words. Readers praise the fairy-tale feel, Isabella’s hapless charm, the winter atmosphere and the happy ending. A longtime fan who reread it says the magic of the first read came partly from how rare unapologetic lesbian romance was in 2011, and that it still holds up as a “delicate sugary confection.” Another reader who’d read the author’s other work says this one feels “just right” where her others felt rushed.

What readers argue about and complain about: First, length. Most of the reviews I read mention how short it is, and for some that’s the whole problem. Second, predictability: even readers who rated it four stars say you can see the ending coming. Third, depth: the romance moves fast, and the one sharply negative review argues its high ratings say more about how few sapphic books were available then than about the book. Readers don’t really split on what it is. They split on whether a small, sweet thing is enough.

The series question everyone should ask first: The novella ends happily, with no cliffhanger. The story continues in One Imbolc Gloaming, where Isabella and Emily visit a haunted abbey, and then a third tale. All three are now collected in Under Her Spell, which runs about 268 pages and holds a 3.88 Goodreads average across about 240 ratings, almost the same score as the novella. If you’re starting fresh, the collection is the easier buy and gives the couple more time together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is One Solstice Night a lesbian romance?

Yes. It’s a short romance between Isabella, a witch, and Emily, a shapeshifter, with a happy ending. It’s closed door and sweet.

Is One Solstice Night the same as Under Her Spell?

Partly. Under Her Spell, published under the pen name Bridget Essex, collects One Solstice Night and the two Benevolence Tales that follow it in one book of about 268 pages.

How spicy is One Solstice Night?

It’s a 1/5. Reviewers describe it as sweet, and a reviewer of the collection says there’s no spice at all.

How long is One Solstice Night?

It’s a short novella you can read in one sitting. A reviewer who reread it says it’s shorter than the two tales that follow.

Is there an audiobook?

Not for the standalone that I could find. The Under Her Spell collection has an audiobook narrated by Rose Clearwater.

If You Loved One Solstice Night, Read These Next

For another witch who’s better at heart than at spells, The Honey Witch is warmer and longer, with open-door scenes. Payback’s a Witch swaps winter for autumn but keeps the hidden magical town and the happy ending. And if the short, gentle format is what you liked, The Cybernetic Tea Shop is a quiet sapphic novella of about the same size. There are more on our sapphic witch romance books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

One Solstice Night wants to be a winter fairy tale with two women at the center, and that’s what it is. The atmosphere is lovely, Isabella is easy to root for, and the happy ending lands. The romance is quick, the plot is predictable, and it’s over almost as soon as it starts. If you want a cozy hour on a cold night, it’s a pleasant one, and if you want more, the collected edition is where to go. Check One Solstice Night on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, One Solstice Night ranks as a pleasant backlist cozy novella. It’s warm and well set, held back by its size. Read it as a seasonal treat rather than a full romance.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ 3.85 average across about 160 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.91 on StoryGraph from 38 ratings
  • ✓ Fond, steady readership since 2011
  • ✓ Readers repeatedly call it slight

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Outsider witch meets outcast shifter
  • ✓ Exclusion gives the romance a stake
  • ✓ Sweet HEA
  • ✓ Attraction moves fast in a short space

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Isabella’s hapless charm is well liked
  • ✓ Emily gets a clear reason to be guarded
  • ✓ Talking cat is a reader favorite
  • ✓ Little room for either lead to develop

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Fairy-tale voice suits the story
  • ✓ Light, self-mocking narration
  • ✓ Reads in one sitting
  • ✓ Called simple and predictable

Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Exclusion theme handled gently
  • ✓ Danger adds some tension late
  • ✓ Warm, hopeful mood throughout
  • ✓ Stakes stay low

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Closed door
  • ✓ Reviewers call it sweet
  • ✓ Collection reviewer reports no spice
  • ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism

Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Clear happy ending
  • ✓ No cliffhanger
  • ✓ Story continues in two more tales
  • ✓ Ending is easy to see coming

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Readers return to it each winter
  • ✓ Short enough for a seasonal reread
  • ✓ Collection adds an audiobook option
  • ✓ Novelty fades on a second read for some

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment