This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A sharp, fast YA premise — magical dueling as a spectator sport, a revenge plot aimed at a rival’s father, two Chinese American leads — held back by a world readers found paper-thin and a romance that runs out of pages before it resolves.
Best for: Teen and adult readers who want a quick, one-sitting sapphic fantasy built on sports-movie structure and family drama, and who can live without a mapped magic system or a clearly defined happy ending.
Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — YA, no romance.io steam rating; readers report kissing and nothing beyond it)
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.61 Goodreads average across 221 ratings, with worldbuilding the complaint that will not go away)
Tropes: Rivals-to-lovers, revenge plot, secret agenda, forbidden love, magical tournament, sports rivalry, dual POV, controlling parent, grief, found connection.
To the Death by Andrea Tang is a standalone young adult sapphic fantasy published by G.P. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers in February 2026, set in a contemporary, magic-aware New York where arcane duels fill arenas — and where Samantha Chan has spent four years engineering a fight that will ruin Tamsin Blackwood, the daughter of the man she blames for her brother’s death.
It sits at a 3.61 average across 221 Goodreads ratings, with a starred Publishers Weekly review, a positive Kirkus notice and Booklist and School Library Journal quotes behind it. The professionals and the readers do not agree, though, and that gap is the most useful part of the story here. Both halves of it are worth understanding before you start.
What Is To the Death About?
To the Death is YA contemporary fantasy with a thriller engine and a romance running through the middle. The magic is public knowledge, the duels draw crowds and reporters, and the circuit runs on press conferences, prize money and reputations — Amazon files it under teen LGBTQ+ romance and romantic thrillers, and romance.io’s handful of taggers reach for “sports”. That sporting frame is the real genre signal: this is a fight-camp story, with training, scouting and pre-bout theatre, more than it is a quest or a court intrigue.
Samantha Chan is 18, Chinese American, and working as the second to Lysander Rook, the undefeated star of the circuit. What she lacks is an ending — her brother Jamie died four years ago and nobody else still thinks about it. Tamsin Blackwood, also 18 and of Chinese and Irish descent, has talent to spare and no life of her own; her father Mateus, a retired legend, coaches her and treats her as his legacy. The book alternates first-person chapters between them, which lets you watch Sam’s con from the inside while Tamsin walks straight into it.
What Makes This YA Sapphic Fantasy Romance Work
- The premise: Magical dueling as a professional sport is the most-praised element in the reviews, and readers repeatedly call the concept unique or innovative even when they are marking the execution down.
- Speed: StoryGraph readers tag it fast-paced by a clear majority, and reviewers call it a slump-buster and a one-sitting read.
- The secret at the centre: Sam befriending the girl she is meant to destroy gives the book a forbidden-love tension that at least one reader argues describes the book better than the rivalry the cover promises.
- The family material: Grief and an emotionally abusive father are what readers single out as the book’s real weight, and trade reviewers praise the same thing.
- Representation: Two Chinese American leads in a queer YA fantasy — 97% of StoryGraph reviewers mark the cast as diverse.
Book Synopsis
Four years after her brother died in an illegal underground duel, Samantha Chan still knows exactly who is responsible. Mateus Blackwood is untouchable — retired, celebrated, still the biggest name the sport has — but he has a daughter on the circuit, and Sam has put herself next to the one fighter who might beat her. As second to the brash, undefeated Lysander Rook, she sets up the bout of the season and waits.
Tamsin Blackwood accepts the challenge because she needs the money. Everything in her life runs through her father: her training, her schedule, her press, her sense of what she is worth. A big enough win would buy her a way out, and Rook is the biggest name she could possibly beat. She has no idea the girl who brokered the bout has been waiting four years for it.
Then Sam’s plan requires getting close. What begins as reconnaissance — learning Tamsin’s habits, her weaknesses, the cracks between her and her father — turns into the first real friendship either of them has had, and then into something neither of them expected. The duel is coming, the press is waiting, and Sam has to decide whether the revenge she has built her life around is still worth what it will cost the girl on the other side of the arena.
My Review
The idea here is excellent, and I want to say that first. Treating spellcasting as a combat sport — seconds, press conferences, a circuit with legends and upstarts — is a genuinely fresh frame for YA fantasy, and pinning a revenge plot to it gives the whole book a countdown. Tang keeps things moving; this is a short book, around 300 pages, and it reads like one.
The second strength is the family story underneath the fights. Mateus Blackwood’s hold over his daughter is the most emotionally specific thing in the book, and Sam’s grief is written as a thing that has hardened into a plan rather than something she is processing. Publishers Weekly calls it an exploration of corruption, emotional abuse and grief, and readers who liked it most name the same themes. StoryGraph users call it character-driven by a wide margin, and 82% say the character development is strong.
Where it struggles is the world, and this is not a stray complaint — it is the most repeated criticism in the reviews by a distance. Nearly half of the thirty Goodreads reviews I read raise it: no sense of how magic works, what it is used for outside the arena, how the duels are governed, or what a second actually does. Several readers say the fight scenes, which should be the showpiece, reduce to someone throwing a spell and someone else blocking it. Around that sit the structural notes — the book is too short for what it is attempting, the two first-person voices blur once the leads meet, and at least one reader finds Mateus a cartoon villain.
One expectation to reset: the cover and the marketing sell a rivals-to-lovers duel to the death. Readers report something quieter — a one-sided secret, closer to forbidden love and slow burn than to mutual rivalry, and a romance that at least two reviewers say is still unsettled on the final page. If a rivalry is what drew you, calibrate; if you wanted a girl torn between love and a grudge, that is exactly what this is.
My honest note: A four-star concept delivered at three-star depth, carried by pace and family drama. If thin worldbuilding kills a fantasy for you, this will frustrate you. If you want a fast, emotionally pointed YA read with a great hook, it earns its evening.
| Element | In To the Death |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Samantha Chan & Tamsin Blackwood — a grieving schemer and the rival’s daughter she means to ruin |
| Core tropes | Revenge plot, secret agenda, rivals-to-lovers, forbidden love, magical tournament, controlling parent |
| Setting | A contemporary New York where magical dueling is a professional spectator sport |
| Heat level | 1/5 — YA, kissing only by reader accounts |
| Series | Standalone — no sequel announced; readers split on whether the romance resolves |
| Content notes | Violence, emotional and parental abuse, toxic relationship dynamics, death of a sibling and grief, minor addiction and body horror |
How Spicy Is To the Death?
A 1/5. romance.io does list the book, but with no steam rating at all — only four users have rated it there — and Amazon gives a reading age of 14 and up. Reader reports fill the gap: reviewers who discuss the romance talk about attraction, tension and a kiss, and nobody I found describes anything beyond that. This is a YA romance in the most literal sense, and the heat is not what anyone is reading it for.
The element worth naming in advance is emotional rather than sexual. StoryGraph users flag a toxic relationship dynamic, and at least one reviewer notes how much anger sits between the two leads in the second half. If you want other sapphic YA at the same closed-door band, The Dead and the Dark and Youngblood both sit at 1/5.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want a high-concept hook executed at speed, you like revenge plots where the avenger’s heart gets in the way, you read YA for family drama and grief as much as romance, and you are happy with a short book you can finish in a sitting.
You may want to skip it if: you need a magic system with rules and a world that exists beyond the arena, you want a fully developed slow burn, you need a romance that closes with a clear happy ending, or you wanted a genuine two-sided rivalry.
In short: a great premise and a strong family spine, delivered in a book that many readers wish were longer.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
This is a traditionally published YA release with the trade coverage to match, and that coverage is where most of its visibility comes from. The Amazon editorial block carries a starred Publishers Weekly review, Kirkus, Booklist and School Library Journal, plus Kobo naming it a best young adult book of February. Beyond that it has been quiet: 221 Goodreads ratings seven months after release, a much smaller Amazon footprint of 11 ratings, and no viral moment in the reader reviews. I could not check TikTok or Reddit from here, so I cannot report on either. The audiobook is a full production from Penguin Random House Audio, narrated by Mirai and Jo Yuan and running nine hours — two narrators for a dual-POV book.
Prefer audio? Listen to To the Death on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The dueling premise, first and most consistently — “unique” and “innovative” are the words readers reach for, and at least one reader compares it to a YA An Unkindness of Magicians. Then the pace: readers call it quick, snappy and a slump-buster. The sapphic romance gets “cute” more than anything else, and several readers say they would happily read a sequel just to spend more time with Sam and Tamsin. Lysander Rook is a surprise favourite — one reviewer calls him the most interesting character in the book, and another wants a spinoff about him. The grief material draws genuine praise.
What readers argue about and complain about: Worldbuilding, above everything. Readers want to know how spells are made, what magic does outside a duel, how the circuit is regulated and what a second is for, and the book does not say — so the fights read, as one reviewer puts it, like MMA with spell names. What makes this notable is that Kirkus praises the opposite, crediting “dynamic depictions of arcane magic” with fleshing out the world, and none of the trade quotes mention the gap readers keep naming. Length is the second theme: short, rushed, and “I wanted more” appears across three- and four-star reviews alike. Third: the romance, which readers call underdeveloped, with an insta-love feel to Sam abandoning a four-year plan after a few conversations. Beyond that, two reviewers found the narrative voices too similar, and individual readers flag a cartoonish villain and a late turn in Tamsin’s behaviour that was hard to follow. StoryGraph’s 6% did-not-finish rate is moderate — lower than the 9% I flagged on Her Spell That Binds Me.
The standalone question worth asking first: this is a single volume with no sequel announced, and the revenge plot concludes. The romance is where readers split — at least two say it ends open, with the leads not yet together, while others describe a neat ending. If you need a defined happy ending, go in expecting a hopeful maybe. For more Tang, Rebelwing sits at 3.75 on Goodreads; her most-read book, These Deadly Prophecies, sits lower at 3.39 across about 3,400 ratings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is To the Death a standalone?
Yes. It is published as a single volume and no sequel has been announced as of September 2026. Several readers say they would like one, mostly to see more of the romance.
Does To the Death have a happy ending for the couple?
A hopeful one rather than a definite one. The revenge plot resolves, but at least two reviewers say the romance is left open, with the two leads not clearly together on the last page.
How spicy is To the Death?
A 1/5. It is YA for ages 14 and up, romance.io gives it no steam rating, and readers describe attraction and kissing only.
Is it really enemies-to-lovers?
Only partly. The hostility is mostly one-sided, because Tamsin does not know Sam’s plan, so readers describe it as closer to forbidden love and slow burn than a true mutual rivalry.
Is there an audiobook?
Yes. Penguin Random House Audio released it alongside the print edition, narrated by Mirai and Jo Yuan, with a running time of about nine hours.
If You Loved To the Death, Read These Next
For the closest match, Crier’s War runs the same engine — a girl who means to destroy the one she falls for — with a much deeper world. If the arena and the sports-movie structure were the draw, Home Field Advantage puts a sapphic YA romance inside a real competitive season. And for another Publishers Weekly-starred sapphic YA with a supernatural edge, Youngblood is the next stop.
For more in this register, browse our enemies-to-lovers reading list, the enemies-to-lovers archive, or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
To the Death is a book whose hook outruns its build. The dueling circuit is a terrific premise, the revenge-meets-attraction setup gives it real tension, and the grief and parental abuse give it weight. It is also thinly built, too short for its own ambitions, and light on the romance it sells — a world with no rules, a relationship with no room, and, for some readers, an ending that leaves the couple unsettled. Whether that trade is worth it depends on what you read fantasy for; the reader who wants a fast, emotionally sharp YA story with a great concept will get an evening’s worth, and the reader who wants a lived-in magic world will not. Check To the Death on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, To the Death ranks as a high-concept YA sapphic fantasy — fast and emotionally pointed, held back by thin worldbuilding and a short page count, and best approached for the revenge plot and the family drama rather than the magic or the romance.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ 3.61 average across 221 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Starred Publishers Weekly review
- ✓ Dueling premise praised nearly everywhere
- ✓ Worldbuilding the dominant reader complaint
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Secret-agenda tension works
- ✓ “Cute” is the recurring reader word
- ✓ PW praises the steadily growing attraction
- ✓ Underdeveloped and left open at the end
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ 82% on StoryGraph say strong development
- ✓ Sam’s grief-driven obsession stays consistent
- ✓ Rook a surprise reader favourite
- ✓ Voices blur and the father flattens
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ PW credits confident prose
- ✓ Fast-paced for 58% of StoryGraph readers
- ✓ Easy, one-sitting readability
- ✓ Fight scenes vague on the page
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Grief for Jamie drives everything
- ✓ Emotional abuse from Mateus lands
- ✓ “Emotional” tagged by 47% on StoryGraph
- ✓ Too short for the themes to deepen
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ YA, reading age 14 and up
- ✓ No romance.io steam rating
- ✓ Readers report kissing only
- ✓ Toxic-relationship dynamic flagged on StoryGraph
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Revenge plot concludes
- ✓ Standalone with no sequel required
- ✓ Some readers call it neat
- ✓ Romance left open for at least two reviewers
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Nine-hour dual-narrator audiobook
- ✓ Short enough to revisit easily
- ✓ Readers want more of these characters
- ✓ Thin world gives little to rediscover
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.