This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A well-researched, low-angst London hospital romance between an ice-queen surgeon and an ex-army trauma chief, let down by chemistry that many readers never feel and a fraud plot that wraps up too easily.
Best for: Readers who love medical settings and workplace banter, who prefer adult conflict to miscommunication, and who are happy with a gentle romance rather than a combustible one.
Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5 — open door, a small number of scenes)
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.74 Goodreads average across about 880 ratings, docked for muted chemistry and a rushed resolution)
Tropes: Ice queen, workplace rivals to lovers, enemies to lovers, opposites attract, doctors, military veteran, hospital fraud mystery, interracial couple, no third-act breakup, low angst.
Major Surgery by Lola Keeley is a standalone contemporary lesbian romance from Ylva, published in 2019 and the author’s second novel — a workplace romance set in a West London hospital, where a rule-bound surgeon is passed over for promotion in favour of a brash former army surgeon, and the two rivals stumble on a fraud that forces them to work together.
It holds a 3.74 average across about 880 Goodreads ratings, earned a B from Smart Bitches, Trashy Books and an enthusiastic write-up from The Lesbian Review. Readers agree on what it does well and on what it does not, and the two lists are worth reading side by side before you start.
What Is Major Surgery About?
Major Surgery is a hospital romance with a mystery running through it. The setting is the heart of the book: St Sophia’s is a busy London hospital with real procedures, real politics and plenty of medical detail, and the plot runs on both clinical cases and a financial fraud the leads uncover. It is low-angst by design — the conflict comes from outside the relationship rather than from the two women sabotaging it.
Dr Veronica Mallick is methodical, protocol-driven and famously cold, a surgeon who expected a promotion to go to her protégé. Major Cassie Taylor is the outsider who got it: an ex-army surgeon, blunt and unorthodox, newly in charge of trauma and still carrying what she saw in the military. The author has said the pairing was partly inspired by a fan-favourite couple from the BBC hospital drama Holby City, and the ice-queen-and-maverick dynamic will feel familiar to anyone who knows it.
What Makes This Sapphic Medical Romance Work
- The hospital: The most praised element. Around seven reviewers single out the authentic, well-researched British hospital setting, and several say the medical scenes show rather than tell.
- The banter: Around six readers, along with Smart Bitches and The Lesbian Review, enjoy the sharp, dry dialogue between two very smart women.
- The ice-queen thaw: Veronica’s slow softening is a recurring pleasure for readers who come to medical lesbian romance for exactly that.
- Grown-up conflict: Several readers praise the absence of a third-act breakup and the way the leads handle problems like adults.
- The cast: Readers note the interracial couple and the book’s attention to racism in the workplace, and StoryGraph reviewers repeatedly tag it as having a diverse cast.
Book Synopsis
Dr Veronica Mallick has built her career at St Sophia’s on doing everything correctly. She follows protocol, she expects others to do the same, and she had every reason to believe the new Head of Trauma post would go to someone she trained. Instead the hospital hands it to an outsider.
Major Cassie Taylor has spent years as an army surgeon, operating in conditions most civilian doctors never see. She is quick, blunt and allergic to paperwork, and she has come home carrying more than she lets on. Her arrival at St Sophia’s lands like a grenade in Veronica’s carefully ordered world, and the two clash from their first meeting over how medicine should be practised.
Then the numbers start not adding up. Money is going missing somewhere inside the hospital, patients and staff could be at risk, and the only two people who seem to notice are the two who can barely stand to be in the same room. Working the problem means trusting each other — and the more time they spend digging, the harder it becomes to remember why they were supposed to be enemies.
My Review
The setting is the strongest thing about this book. Keeley clearly did her research, and St Sophia’s feels like a real, overstretched London hospital — the rotas, the hierarchies, the clinical decisions, the politics. Readers who love medical romance for the medicine are well served, and the injured-soldier storyline gives Cassie’s military past a real place in the plot.
The dialogue is the other genuine pleasure. Veronica and Cassie are both clever and sharp-tongued, and their sparring is fun to read. The book also deserves credit for its maturity: the relationship is not derailed by a manufactured misunderstanding, and readers who are tired of third-act breakups appreciate that.
Where it struggles is the romance itself, and this is the single most repeated complaint in the reviews. Around fourteen readers say they never felt the chemistry between the leads — the banter works, but the spark does not. About as many say the fraud plot and the climax resolve too quickly and too easily. Around five feel the medical storylines crowd out the love story, about as many say the enemies phase ends almost before it starts, and a similar number found the jargon or UK hospital terminology hard to follow. Readers who loved Keeley’s debut, The Music and the Mirror, often say this one does not reach the same heights. Pacing divides readers in both directions: some found it slow, others found the shift to attraction too sudden.
One expectation to reset: the pitch promises enemies to lovers and two sexy doctors. Readers find a brief rivalry, a gentle romance and a book that is as much medical drama as love story. If you came for fireworks, calibrate; if you came for a calm, competent workplace romance with good banter, it delivers.
My honest note: A well-made, well-researched hospital romance with a spark that many readers missed. If chemistry is everything to you, look elsewhere. If you want a low-angst medical romance with two smart women and no breakup drama, it is a comfortable read.
| Element | In Major Surgery |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Dr Veronica Mallick & Major Cassie Taylor — ice-queen surgeon and ex-army trauma chief, workplace rivals to lovers |
| Core tropes | Ice queen, workplace rivals, opposites attract, military veteran, hospital fraud mystery, low angst |
| Setting | St Sophia’s, a hospital in West London |
| Heat level | 3/5 — open door, a small number of scenes |
| Series | Standalone — resolved romance, no third-act breakup, no cliffhanger |
| Content notes | Medical content and medical trauma, death, military trauma and loss, racism, heavy drinking, sexual content, misogyny (crowd-reported on StoryGraph and in reviews) |
How Spicy Is Major Surgery?
A 3/5. I could not get a romance.io reading for this title, so the number comes from readers. The intimacy is on the page — Smart Bitches called the sex scenes great, and StoryGraph readers describe it as steamy or as having minor spice — but there are not many scenes, and one Goodreads reviewer called the intimate scene forgettable. Most of the book is banter and medicine rather than heat.
No reviewer I found flags kink content. If you want hospital romance at the same open-door level, Surgeon and Irregular Heartbeat sit in the same band.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you love a detailed medical setting, you enjoy ice-queen heroines and sharp workplace banter, you prefer couples who solve problems together, and you like a mystery subplot in your romance.
You may want to skip it if: you need strong chemistry above all, medical jargon wears on you, you want a long and bitter enemies phase, or a too-easy resolution spoils a plot for you.
In short: a competent, low-angst hospital romance whose setting is stronger than its spark.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
This is a modest backlist title from a small press, and its readership reflects that. I found no trade reviews, no Reddit thread and no BookTok trend; what it has is a steady trickle of ratings over the years and two good blog reviews. The numbers: a 3.74 average across about 880 Goodreads ratings, with 29% at three stars; 3.5 across 55 StoryGraph reviews with a 3% did-not-finish rate; and 4.4 from 274 Amazon ratings. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it a B, praising the thawing ice queen and the sex scenes, and The Lesbian Review had no complaints at all. Ylva’s own coverage notes the book drew on the Holby City pairing fans call “Berena”. The audiobook, from Tantor, is narrated by Gabrielle Baker and runs 8 hours 21 minutes; listener reaction is mixed, with several saying the two leads sound too alike.
Prefer audio? Listen to Major Surgery on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The hospital setting, first — around seven readers praise how authentic and well researched it feels. Then the banter, named by about six. The ice-queen thaw has its fans, as does Cassie’s military backstory. Several readers appreciate the interracial couple and the attention to workplace racism, and around four praise the adult conflict and lack of a third-act breakup. StoryGraph readers tag it hopeful and lighthearted, and a handful call it a comfort read.
What readers argue about and complain about: Chemistry and the ending, roughly tied. About fourteen readers say they never felt a spark between Veronica and Cassie, and about as many say the fraud plot and climax are resolved too fast or too easily. Behind those: the medical plot dominates (around five), the jargon and UK hospital terms confuse non-British readers (around five), the enemies phase is too short (around five), and the book is weaker than Keeley’s debut (around five, though a couple of readers prefer this one). A few found the villain over the top, and two flagged editing slips. The genuine split is pacing — some readers found it slow until the leads got together, while others thought the shift from rivals to romance happened far too fast.
The standalone question worth asking first: it is complete. There is no series, the romance resolves without a third-act breakup, and there is no cliffhanger. If you want more of Keeley’s ice queens, her debut The Music and the Mirror is the book readers most often say they prefer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Major Surgery enemies to lovers?
Only briefly. Veronica and Cassie start as workplace rivals, but readers consistently say the enemies phase ends early and the book becomes a gentle, low-angst romance.
How spicy is Major Surgery?
A 3/5. The sex scenes are open door but few, and most of the book is banter and medical drama.
Does Major Surgery have a third-act breakup?
No. Readers specifically praise the lack of a breakup — the conflict comes from a hospital fraud rather than from the relationship.
Is Major Surgery a standalone?
Yes. It is a complete standalone with a resolved romance and no cliffhanger.
Is there an audiobook?
Yes — narrated by Gabrielle Baker for Tantor, running 8 hours 21 minutes. Some listeners found the two leads’ voices too similar.
If You Loved Major Surgery, Read These Next
For another hospital romance at the same heat, Surgeon is short, briskly plotted and adds an age gap. If you want to stay on the wards with a different couple, Irregular Heartbeat is another open-door medical romance from our list. And for Keeley at what many readers consider her best, The Music and the Mirror swaps the operating theatre for a ballet company and turns up the ice.
For more like this, browse our list of lesbian medical romance books or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
Major Surgery is a book that knows its setting better than its couple. The hospital is vivid and convincing, the banter is sharp, and the grown-up approach to conflict is a relief. It is also a romance many readers never quite feel, a rivalry that ends too soon, and a fraud plot that ties itself up too neatly. If you want a calm, competent medical romance with two clever women, it is a pleasant read. Check Major Surgery on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Major Surgery ranks as a solid small-press sapphic medical romance — well researched, witty and refreshingly low-angst, held back by muted chemistry and a rushed resolution, and best approached for the hospital and the banter rather than the heat between the leads.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ 3.74 average across 878 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 3.5 on StoryGraph, 3% did-not-finish
- ✓ B grade from Smart Bitches
- ✓ Muted chemistry the top complaint
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Banter between the leads lands
- ✓ No third-act breakup
- ✓ Ice-queen thaw has its fans
- ✓ Around fourteen readers felt no spark
Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Cassie’s military past adds depth
- ✓ Veronica a classic ice queen
- ✓ Interracial couple and diverse cast
- ✓ Backstories left underexplored
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Hospital detail praised as authentic
- ✓ Sharp, dry dialogue
- ✓ Shows rather than tells in surgery
- ✓ Jargon confuses some readers
Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Military trauma handled with care
- ✓ Injured soldier storyline lands
- ✓ Workplace racism addressed
- ✓ Low stakes in the romance
Heat Level ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Open-door intimacy
- ✓ Smart Bitches calls the scenes great
- ✓ Few scenes overall
- ✓ One reader found them forgettable
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ Romance resolves, no cliffhanger
- ✓ No third-act breakup
- ✓ Standalone with no homework
- ✓ Fraud plot resolved too easily
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Comfort-read for medical romance fans
- ✓ Libro.fm audiobook available
- ✓ Banter rewards a second look
- ✓ Weak chemistry discourages a return
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.