Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire Review — Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: The only book on our dragon shelf where the dragon negotiates — a genuinely original conception of the creature, attached to a twist five readers guessed at the thirty-percent mark.

Best for: Readers who want dragons thought about properly rather than deployed, who are happy in young-adult territory with longing instead of heat, and who will forgive a talky middle.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — young adult, longing only; romance.io has no entry for this book at all)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.70 Goodreads average across only 186 ratings, three years after a traditionally published debut)

Tropes: Dragon negotiation, dragontongue heroine, hostage rescue, forgiveness arc, family dysfunction, young adult fantasy, found family, standalone, longing, mountain-pass setting.

Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire by Erica Hollis is a standalone sapphic fantasy published by Entangled Teen in June 2023, set in and around the town of Morwassen’s Pass, where dragons are natural fauna who eat gold and gems, and where Lotte Meer — a dragontongue, someone who can speak with them — is hired alongside the sharp-tongued Maryse Basvaan to deal with a dragon extorting tribute from the pass.

It has a 3.70 average across 186 Goodreads ratings and a 4.0 across 26 on Amazon, and those numbers are the story as much as the book is. Three years after a traditionally published young-adult debut, there is no trade review anywhere, no Reddit footprint at all, no romance.io entry, and the author has published nothing since. This is a book with a genuinely good idea in it that essentially nobody read.

What Is Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire About?

This is young-adult fantasy in the older sense — a world with rules, a job to do, and a romance that stays at the level of longing throughout. Entangled Teen list it for readers of fourteen and up, and the register matches that. What lifts it out of the ordinary is the worldbuilding premise: dragons here are not a magical force or a mount, they are fauna. They come in sizes, they have individual personalities, they eat precious metal and gemstones because that is what their bodies run on, and the ones who speak use “we” rather than “I”. A reviewer for Fresh Fiction put it well — they cannot spend the gold, so hoarding it is simply rational.

Lotte Meer is sixteen and a dragontongue, which makes her useful and, in the way of small towns, slightly suspect. Maryse Basvaan deals in precious and magical goods and has a brother who captains the City Guard, which will matter. The job is a dragon that has been taxing everyone who uses the mountain pass, and the twist — which we will not spoil, though five readers say you will see it coming — is that the dragon has a reason and a hostage, and the hostage is Lotte’s mother.

What Makes This Young Adult Dragon Fantasy Work

• The dragons are actually thought about: the single most-praised element, named by three independent reviewers including the one professional critic who covered it. One reader says every dragon is unique and you will remember every single one, which is not a claim you can make about most dragon books.
• The premise is negotiation, not slaughter: as one reader put it, a quest that turned into a question. Almost nothing else in this category does that.
• Queerness is simply present: three separate readers name it approvingly and one says specifically that it does not read as a box being ticked.
• Family dysfunction handled seriously: two readers name the family plotting as a strength, and it carries more of the book than the synopsis suggests.
• It resolves: a genuine standalone with a bittersweet, satisfying ending, and two readers wishing there were more of it.

Book Synopsis

Morwassen’s Pass is the way through, and someone has started charging for it. Not a bandit — a dragon, sitting on the road and requiring tribute from everyone who wants to cross, in the currency dragons care about. The town cannot route around it and cannot fight it, which leaves talking, and talking to dragons is a specialised skill.

Lotte Meer has that skill. She is sixteen, she is a dragontongue, and being able to speak with something everyone else regards as weather has never made her life easier. She takes the job because it is a job. Maryse Basvaan takes it because she trades in exactly the sort of goods a dragon might be persuaded to accept, and because her family has interests in the pass staying open.

What they find at the top is not a monster with a grudge but a negotiator with a position — and a captive, whose identity turns the job from a commercial problem into something Lotte cannot walk away from. Working out what the dragon actually wants means working out what it has been told, by whom, and how long ago, and the answer is older than either of them.

My Review

The dragons are the reason to read this, and I want to be precise about why. Most fantasy treats a dragon as either a weapon system or a personality in a large body. Hollis treats them as animals with a biology — creatures whose bodies need metal, whose hoarding is therefore a metabolic fact rather than a character flaw, and whose speech uses a first-person plural that quietly tells you they do not experience themselves as individuals the way we do. That is worldbuilding doing actual work, and the one professional reviewer who covered this book and the readers who liked it converge on the same verdict: this is where the value is.

The premise follows from it. A dragon that can be reasoned with produces a quest that turns into a question, which is a genuinely different shape from the sixty other dragon books published that year. The queerness is unremarked in the way readers keep saying they want and rarely get, and the family material — Lotte’s mother, Maryse’s brother in the City Guard, obligations neither of them chose — carries more weight than the cover implies.

Where it struggles is that the plot cannot keep the secret it is built around. Five independent reviewers say they worked out the central reveal at roughly the thirty-percent mark, and one of them is a four-and-a-half-star review — so this is a structural observation rather than a grudge. Once you know, the middle act has nowhere to go, and three more readers name what fills it instead: dialogue. One says there are pretty much no descriptions; another that people talk a lot, a lot, a lot. Three readers separately find the romance underdeveloped, with characters jumping between scenes from “she hates me” to intimacy, and declarations arriving inside about a month.

The sharpest criticism comes from a two-and-a-half-star reader and it is worth quoting the substance of, because it is a fair objection to the emotional arc. Lotte forgives someone who betrayed her, lied to her face repeatedly, and bears responsibility for her losing the use of her dominant arm — and the reviewer’s point is not that forgiveness is wrong but that every time Lotte approaches a healthy boundary, the writing frames setting it as the mistake. For a young-adult book, that is a modelling problem worth naming. Two other readers note that Maryse’s arc simply does not finish.

Two expectations to reset. The comparison titles on the cover are Abigail Owen and Samantha Shannon, which sets an adult-romantasy expectation this book does not meet: it is young adult and there is no spice at all, only longing. And in the other direction, one reader who arrived for dragons reports far more family dynamics and municipal politics than the synopsis led her to expect — two readers actually wanted more dragons, which is an odd complaint about the thing the book does best. Be aware, too, that the graphic content is more than the fourteen-plus rating implies: StoryGraph’s crowd flags death, gore and injury as graphic, and one reader in her twenties found herself wincing.

My honest note: A better idea than book. If you care about dragons as a design problem, the conception here is worth the evening on its own. If you need the plot to surprise you or the romance to be built, you will spend the second half waiting.

How Spicy Is Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire?

A 1/5, and this is one of the cases where the absence of a rating tells you something. romance.io — the database this site normally quotes — has no entry for this book at all, which is what happens when a title is catalogued as young-adult fantasy rather than as adult romance. So the number comes from the publisher’s stated age range, fourteen and up, and from readers, one of whom puts it exactly: not a spicy book, but definitely some longing.

Nothing here needs flagging for content in the romance, then. What does need flagging is the violence, because the fourteen-plus rating undersells it — StoryGraph’s crowd rates death, gore and injury as graphic, and one adult reader reports cringing at the descriptive gore and concluding that the book would otherwise have been pitched younger. If you want low-heat sapphic dragon fantasy for adults instead, The Bloodless Princes and Brighter than Scale, Swifter than Flame both sit in the same register with more craft behind them.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want dragons conceived as creatures rather than as plot devices, you read young adult happily, you like a quest that resolves through conversation, and unremarked queerness is what you are looking for.

You may want to skip it if: you need a twist you cannot see coming, you want a romance built scene by scene, dialogue-heavy books with little description lose you, or you were expecting the adult romantasy the cover comparisons imply.

In short: the best dragon-design in the category, in a book that gives its own game away at thirty percent.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

The most important thing to report about this book’s reception is how little of it there is. Three years after publication by a real imprint, a search of Reddit for the title returns zero results — not a thin footprint, nothing at all, and we verified the search was working by running a comparison title in the same session that returned eleven threads. There is no TikTok content. There is no Publishers Weekly, Kirkus, Library Journal, Booklist or School Library Journal review, and that last absence is genuinely notable for an Entangled Teen title. Nothing from The Lesbrary, The Lesbian Review, LezReviewBooks or Lambda Literary. The entire editorial coverage of this book is one favourable Fresh Fiction review from August 2023 and a handful of blog posts, plus a bare listing in an LGBTQ Reads roundup of queer dragon fantasy. Its Amazon sales rank sits above 1.3 million. What it has instead is 186 Goodreads ratings accumulated slowly, an audiobook from Recorded Books, and an author who has not published since.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The dragons, first and by a distance — three independent voices including the Fresh Fiction critic name the conception specifically, one saying every dragon is unique and memorable, another appreciating that a creature which cannot spend gold hoarding it is simply rational. Then the negotiation premise: a quest that turns into a question. Then the representation, named by three readers, one saying explicitly that the queerness is not just there to cover a base. Two more name the family dysfunction as the emotional core. StoryGraph’s crowd rates the book 100% adventurous, 76% loveable and 76% diverse, with 69% saying the character development is strong — good numbers on a small sample.

What readers argue about and complain about: The twist, above everything. Five independent reviewers say they solved it at around the thirty-percent mark, including one who rated the book four and a half stars, and one two-star reader who states the figure exactly. Once it is out, the middle has nothing to carry it. Second, and related: three readers find the book dialogue-heavy at the expense of description and setting — one saying there are pretty much no descriptions, another that the characters talk a great deal. Third, the romance, named by three as underdeveloped: characters skip between scenes from hostility to intimacy, and declarations arrive after about a month. Fourth, and the most substantive single objection, one reader argues that the forgiveness arc actively models bad boundaries in a book written for teenagers — Lotte forgives repeated betrayal and a permanent injury, and each time she approaches a limit the narrative treats the limit as the error. Two readers say Maryse’s arc never finishes. And there is one genuine oddity: two readers wanted more dragons, which is a complaint about the element everyone else names as the book’s strength. One outlier reviewer objected to a nonbinary character’s pronouns; nobody else echoes it and several readers praise the same representation, so it is a single hostile voice rather than a theme.

The standalone question worth asking first: it is a genuine standalone and it resolves — readers describe the ending as bittersweet and satisfying, and one as leaving a bright new beginning. Two readers actively wished it were a series, which is the nicest complaint a book can attract. There is no sequel and none is coming as far as anyone can tell. Where a reader goes next is the awkward part, and it is worth saying honestly rather than inventing a recommendation: Hollis’s only other rated title sits at 2.60 across five ratings, and another has no ratings at all. Neither is a defensible next step. Send yourself sideways to another author rather than to this backlist.

The audiobook is narrated by Justis Bolding, runs 13 hours 54 minutes, and was published by Recorded Books in September 2023. We could not find any substantive listener commentary on the narration — one retailer displays a very low rating with no stated sample size behind it, which is not worth quoting in either direction.

Prefer audio? Listen to Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire a standalone?

Yes. It resolves completely, readers describe the ending as bittersweet and satisfying, and there is no sequel — the author has published nothing since 2023.

How spicy is Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire?

A 1/5. It is a young adult title published by Entangled Teen for readers of fourteen and up, and there is nothing explicit on the page — one reader sums it up as not spicy but definitely some longing. romance.io has no entry for it at all.

Is it suitable for teenagers?

Mostly, with one caveat. It is marketed at fourteen and up and the romance is chaste, but StoryGraph’s crowd rates death, gore and injury as graphic, and one adult reader found the gore more descriptive than she expected.

Is Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire on Kindle Unlimited?

No. It is available to buy (check today’s price on Amazon) and carries no Kindle Unlimited badge.

Is the twist really that predictable?

Five independent reviewers say they worked it out at around the thirty-percent mark, and one of them still rated the book four and a half stars. Treat it as a book to read for its dragons rather than for its plot.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes — narrated by Justis Bolding, running 13 hours 54 minutes, published by Recorded Books in September 2023.

If You Loved Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire, Read These Next

If it was the dragon-as-creature conception you enjoyed, The Bloodless Princes has the best-written dragon on our shelf in a similarly short book. If you want the same low-heat register with a bond at the centre, The Priory of the Orange Tree is the enormous version of that idea. And if you have aged out of the young-adult register and want the same premise with adult stakes and real heat, The Blood-Born Dragon is where to go.

For more in this register, browse our guide to dragon sapphic romantasy or the full Book Reviews collection.

The Bottom Line

Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire contains the best idea about dragons in this entire category. Making them fauna with a metabolism, giving them a collective first person, and building a plot around talking one down instead of killing it is genuinely original, and the people who read this book noticed. It is also a mystery that unmasks itself a third of the way through, a talky middle with almost no description in it, a romance assembled between scenes, and a forgiveness arc that models something unfortunate for the teenage readership it was written for. Three years on it has no trade reviews, no Reddit presence and 186 ratings, which is a shame for the idea if not for the execution. Read it for the dragons. Check Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Hearts Forged in Dragon Fire ranks as an inventive but under-read young adult sapphic dragon fantasy — original in its worldbuilding and warm in its queerness, held back by a transparent plot and an underbuilt romance, and best approached for how it thinks about dragons rather than for what happens to them.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

• ✓ 3.70 Goodreads average across 186 ratings
• ✓ Dragon conception is genuinely original
• ✓ No trade coverage and no Reddit footprint at all
• ✓ Five readers solved the twist at 30%

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3/5

• ✓ Queerness is unremarked and welcome
• ✓ Longing is written with real restraint
• ✓ Two women, no triangle, no man
• ✓ Skips from hostility to intimacy between scenes

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

• ✓ Every dragon individually characterised
• ✓ Lotte’s dragontongue isolation is well drawn
• ✓ Family obligations carry real weight
• ✓ Maryse’s arc never finishes

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

• ✓ Dragon biology thought through properly
• ✓ Negotiation premise sustains the first half
• ✓ 61% rate the pace medium
• ✓ Three readers say it is nearly all dialogue

Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

• ✓ Bittersweet ending readers name as satisfying
• ✓ Family dysfunction handled seriously
• ✓ A hostage twist with real stakes attached
• ✓ Forgiveness arc frames boundaries as the error

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

• ✓ Young adult, fourteen and up
• ✓ Longing rather than heat
• ✓ Nothing explicit on the page
• ✓ No romance.io entry exists for it

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

• ✓ Resolves completely as a standalone
• ✓ Bittersweet and earned
• ✓ Two readers wished for more
• ✓ Predictable by the halfway mark

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

• ✓ Dragon worldbuilding rewards a second look
• ✓ Recorded Books audiobook at nearly 14 hours
• ✓ Short enough to revisit
• ✓ The twist does not survive knowing it

Affiliate disclosure: the store buttons below are affiliate links (Amazon, Bookshop.org, Libro.fm and Audible). As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, and we may also earn a small commission from the other stores, at no extra cost to you.