The Priory of the Orange Tree Review | Samantha Shannon | Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: A complete 848-page feminist epic with dragons, a queen and a mage at its centre and no sequel required, let down by a first half that explains and a last act that sprints.

Best for: Readers who want one enormous standalone secondary world with women in power treated as unremarkable, and who would rather have detail than pace.

Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5 — romance.io’s “behind closed doors”; sex happens, none of it is described)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.9/5 — a 4.16 Goodreads average across 297,651 ratings, with a pacing complaint even its starred review makes)

Tropes: Forbidden love, queen and bodyguard, secret identity, multiple POV, dragons, arranged marriage, class difference, slow burn, chosen family, complete standalone.

The Priory of the Orange Tree is Samantha Shannon’s fifth novel, a standalone high fantasy published by Bloomsbury on 26 February 2019, set across three mutually hostile regions of a world built out of the Saint George legend, and built on the collision between Ead Duryan — a lady-in-waiting who is secretly a mage sent to protect a queen who does not know she needs protecting — and Sabran the Ninth, whose unbroken female bloodline is supposedly the only thing keeping a dragon-god chained.

It holds a 4.16 average across 297,651 Goodreads ratings and a 4.24 across 96,990 StoryGraph reviews, making it by far the most-read book on our sapphic fiction list, and it was a Lambda Literary Award finalist for LGBTQ Speculative Fiction in 2020. The averages sit on top of a structural complaint that recurs with unusual consistency and that Kirkus, in an otherwise starred review, made first. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is The Priory of the Orange Tree About?

This is doorstop epic fantasy rather than fantasy romance, and the distinction matters more here than almost anywhere else on this list. The novel runs five viewpoints across three cultures that each believe a different version of the same history: a Protestant-shaped West that venerates a knight, an East where dragons are gods and riders are chosen, and a South whose mages know what actually happened. That religious disagreement is the plot — not a backdrop for it — and the book’s real subject is which version of a founding story a society is willing to let go of.

Ead is introduced through concealment: a foreigner at court, tolerated rather than trusted, quietly warding a bedchamber every night for a woman who thinks her own body is the kingdom’s defence. Sabran is introduced through duty — a queen who has been told since childhood that her only real function is to produce a daughter, and who is being pressed into a marriage to do it. The romance grows out of that setup rather than being dropped into it, which is why it works, and why it takes several hundred pages.

What Makes This Sapphic Epic Fantasy Work

• The scale: The most-praised element by a distance. 98% of StoryGraph readers mark the book adventurous, the highest score of any title on our list, and the three-culture structure is what earns it.
• Women in power as unremarkable: Readers describe it as the feminist successor to The Lord of the Rings so often it has become a formula, and the point stands — queens, mages and dragonriders are women, and the book never pauses to be impressed with itself about it.
• Queerness without fuss: The world simply does not police it. Readers who are tired of homophobia being the engine of every sapphic plot name this repeatedly as the reason they finished 848 pages.
• Niclays Roos: The least likeable viewpoint and the one readers most often single out as the best-written — a bitter, self-pitying alchemist whose arc is the novel’s most surprising.
• It is genuinely standalone: A complete epic in one volume with an HEA and no cliffhanger, which in this genre is rare enough to be a selling point on its own.

Book Synopsis

For a thousand years the House of Berethnet has ruled Inys on a single promise: as long as the queen’s line continues, the Nameless One stays bound. Sabran the Ninth is unmarried, childless, and increasingly the subject of assassination attempts. Her court wants a husband found and an heir produced before something happens to her.

Ead Duryan has spent eight years in that court as a minor lady-in-waiting from the South. She is in fact a mage of the Priory of the Orange Tree, sent to keep Sabran alive, and she has been protecting the queen with a magic Inys considers heresy while pretending to be nobody. Across the sea in Seiiki, a young woman named Tané has trained her whole life to ride a dragon and does one reckless thing on the eve of the selection. In the same city, a disgraced Ménite alchemist is being kept alive by a warlord who wants something he cannot deliver.

The wyrms are waking. The question the novel spends its second half on is which of the three religions is telling the truth about how they were stopped last time — and what happens to a queen whose entire legitimacy rests on the version that is wrong.

My Review

The ambition is the reason to read this, and it is worth being precise about what Shannon actually pulled off. She built three complete cultures with incompatible theologies, gave each of them a viewpoint character who believes their own version sincerely, and then resolved the whole thing in one volume without a sequel hook. Very few contemporary epic fantasies even attempt a self-contained arc at this scale. The Inysh court, the Seiikinese dragonriders and the Priory itself all feel like they were designed separately and then made to collide, which is the hardest kind of worldbuilding to fake.

The second strength is the way the romance is built out of the politics rather than beside them. Ead is guarding Sabran under false pretences, using a magic Sabran’s church would burn her for, in service of an order Sabran has never heard of. Everything tender between them is also a lie of omission, and the novel is patient enough to let that accumulate for hundreds of pages before it pays. The result is one of the few sapphic pairings in epic fantasy where the obstacle is genuinely structural rather than a misunderstanding, and where the resolution requires the queen to give up the story she was raised on.

Where it struggles is pacing, and this is the dominant complaint rather than a personal impatience — Kirkus starred the book and still noted that Shannon may favour detailed explication over keeping a steady pace, which is a polite version of what thousands of readers say. The mechanism has two halves. First, a great deal of the worldbuilding arrives as characters thinking history at themselves rather than as dramatised scene, which reads as dry across the first three hundred pages. Second, and more damaging, the ending compresses: after several hundred pages of measured accumulation, the confrontation the entire book has been arranged around resolves in a rush, and a large share of the three-star reviews are specifically about that mismatch. A related complaint worth taking seriously is that the apocalyptic framing produces surprisingly few consequences — the stakes are announced as world-ending and land smaller.

The expectation worth resetting is what kind of book this is. It appears on sapphic romance lists constantly, and the relationship genuinely matters, but it is one of five strands and the novel is an epic first. Only 8% of StoryGraph readers call it character-driven, against 24% who call it plot-driven and 67% a mix — that is a fair description of the experience. If the length worries you, be realistic: 848 pages and 33% of readers calling the pace slow is a real commitment. If you were worried the queerness would be incidental, relax — it is central and it ends happily.

My honest note: A magnificent piece of worldbuilding with an editing problem at both ends, rescued by the fact that it finishes. If you want one complete feminist epic rather than a trilogy, this is the book; if you need every page to earn its place, you will find a hundred that do not.

Element	In The Priory of the Orange Tree
Central relationship	Ead Duryan & Queen Sabran the Ninth — a disguised mage and the queen she was sent to protect
Core tropes	Forbidden love, queen and protector, secret identity, slow burn, arranged marriage pressure, multiple POV
Setting	Inys and Virtudom in the West, Seiiki in the East, and the Priory in the South — a world built from the Saint George legend
Heat level	2/5 — romance.io’s “behind closed doors”; sex occurs and is never described
Series	Standalone with a complete arc and an HEA — A Day of Fallen Night (2023) is a prequel, not a sequel; no further books announced
Content notes	Miscarriage, infertility and reproductive coercion, child loss, death and graphic violence, religious persecution, plague and body horror, alcoholism, depression and suicidal ideation, incest mentioned

How Spicy Is The Priory of the Orange Tree?

A 2/5. romance.io files it as “behind closed doors”, and readers in the book’s own Goodreads Q&A put it more precisely: people have sex, you know it has happened, and the act itself is never described. The most physically explicit passage in 848 pages is one character seeing another undressed, handled non-graphically. StoryGraph’s community warnings agree, logging sexual content only at the minor tier — below miscarriage, death and violence, all of which sit in the graphic tier.

The element worth flagging in advance is reproductive coercion, which Shannon lists in her own content notes and which runs through the whole Berethnet premise: a queen whose worth is measured by her ability to produce a daughter, with miscarriage and infertility on the page. No reviewer flags anything beyond that. For the same restrained band on this site, Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea and A Memory Called Empire both sit at 2/5 — secondary-world stories where the relationship is real and the door stays closed.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want one enormous complete epic rather than a trilogy, you enjoy competing religions treated as a genuine puzzle, you like a world where women holding power needs no explanation, and you read for immersion rather than momentum.

You may want to skip it if: 848 pages is a commitment you resent, worldbuilding delivered as interior monologue bores you, a compressed climax after a slow build will annoy you, or you want the romance to be the main event.

In short: the biggest and most self-sufficient book on this list, and the one that most needed a firmer editor.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

Seven years on, this is the volume title on our sapphic fiction list — 297,651 Goodreads ratings and 96,990 StoryGraph reviews, more than double the next book — and its position is odd: enormously read, very lightly decorated. Its single genuine genre-award credential is a 2020 Lambda Literary Award finalist slot in LGBTQ Speculative Fiction, which it lost to The Deep, plus a Goodreads Choice nomination in 2019. It does not appear in the Locus, Ignyte, BSFA, Hugo, Nebula or World Fantasy listings at all. What drives it instead is BookTok and word of mouth, and the recommendation is almost always phrased the same way: the standalone feminist epic with dragons. The world has since expanded backwards rather than forwards — A Day of Fallen Night (2023) is a full-length prequel set five hundred years earlier, and Among the Burning Flowers is a short illustrated prequel. No sequel and no screen adaptation has been announced anywhere we could verify, so treat any claim of a Priory series in development as unsourced.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Scale and layering come first and come up most — three cultures, three theologies, and readers repeatedly using the word intricate. Second is the feminist framing, and specifically that women in authority are unremarkable within the world rather than a point being made at the reader. Third is the handling of queerness: no persecution plot, no fetishisation, and a substantial number of readers say that alone is why they finished a book this long. Fourth is Niclays Roos, who draws more comment than either lead — a genuinely unpleasant man whose arc readers describe as the most affecting thing in the novel. Fifth is the prose, which readers compare to George R. R. Martin for density. Sixth, and often first in the actual recommendation, is that it is one book. The minority view worth flagging cuts against the length complaint: a real contingent argues the slow accumulation is the pleasure, that this is a book to live in rather than to finish, and that readers treating it as a plot delivery mechanism are reading it wrong.

What readers argue about and complain about: Length that is not earned, above everything. The mechanism is that a large share of those 848 pages is court detail and description rather than plot movement, so readers finish feeling the page count was arbitrary rather than necessary. The second theme is the one professionals corroborate and it is really a consequence of the first: information is doled out at a crawl for three hundred pages and then the climax and resolution are compressed into the final stretch, so the confrontation the book was built toward reads anticlimactic. Kirkus said the polite version — that Shannon may favour detailed explication over keeping a steady pace — while starring the book. Third is infodumping specifically through interior monologue, with characters thinking history at themselves instead of the history being dramatised. Fourth: several reversals are followed by long explanatory passages, which readers read as retrofitting rather than payoff. Fifth, least frequent but sharp, is that the apocalyptic stakes produce very few consequences — a world-ending threat that kills remarkably few people the reader cares about. The genuine split is over whether the density is immersion or padding, and there is no reconciling it: 33% of StoryGraph readers call the pace slow and 7% call it fast, and both groups are describing the same chapters.

The standalone question worth asking first: This is a genuine standalone with a complete arc and a happy ending, and it needs nothing else — which is the main reason people recommend it. If you want more of the world afterwards, the direction of travel is backwards: A Day of Fallen Night is a prequel set five centuries earlier with a different cast, and it rates comparably on Goodreads rather than dropping off, so it is a real recommendation rather than a courtesy. Be aware that it is another 800-page volume, and that reading it will not give you more of Ead and Sabran.

The audiobook is narrated by Liyah Summers and runs 25 hours 52 minutes, and it is an Audible Studios exclusive — there is no Libro.fm edition of the novel. If you search that shop you will find a third-party “summary and analysis” product using the same title; it is not the book.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Priory of the Orange Tree a standalone?

Yes. It resolves completely in one volume with a happy ending and no cliffhanger. A Day of Fallen Night (2023) is a prequel set five hundred years earlier, not a sequel, and no further books have been announced.

How explicit is it?

A 2/5. romance.io files it as “behind closed doors”. Characters do have sex and none of it is described; the most physical passage in the book is one woman seeing another undressed. StoryGraph logs sexual content at the minor tier only.

Is the sapphic romance the main plot?

No, though it is central to one of five viewpoints and it resolves happily. This is an epic fantasy with a load-bearing sapphic relationship inside it rather than a fantasy romance.

Is it worth 848 pages?

That is exactly the argument. A third of StoryGraph readers call the pace slow, and the loudest complaint is that the first half explains while the last act rushes. Readers who want to live in a world rather than be pulled through one tend to say yes.

Did it win any awards?

It was a finalist for the 2020 Lambda Literary Award in LGBTQ Speculative Fiction, losing to The Deep, and a 2019 Goodreads Choice nominee. Despite its readership it does not appear in the Hugo, Nebula, Locus, World Fantasy or BSFA listings.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes — Liyah Summers narrates a 25 hour 52 minute Audible Studios exclusive. It is not stocked by Libro.fm, and the similarly titled listing there is an unofficial summary product rather than the novel.

If You Loved The Priory of the Orange Tree, Read These Next

Try The Jasmine Throne for the same appetite for enormous secondary-world politics with a sapphic pair at the centre and a stronger central dynamic; A Memory Called Empire for court intrigue where competing versions of a founding story are again the plot; and Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea for the opposite scale — the same closed-door warmth in a book you can finish in an evening. More across our Book Reviews and on our sapphic fiction list.

The Bottom Line

The Priory of the Orange Tree set out to write a complete feminist epic in a single volume, and three things carry it: three fully realised cultures whose religions genuinely contradict each other, a world where women in power need no justification and queerness needs no defence, and an ending that actually ends. Three things hold it back: several hundred pages that explain rather than dramatise, a climax compressed after a very long build, and apocalyptic stakes that cost the cast surprisingly little. If you want one enormous fantasy you will never need a sequel for, it is worth the commitment. Check The Priory of the Orange Tree on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

We rank The Priory of the Orange Tree at 3.9/5 — the most ambitious standalone on this list, with an editing problem at both ends that its own starred review noticed.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

• ✓ 4.16 average across 297,651 Goodreads ratings
• ✓ Starred by Kirkus, and a 2020 Lambda finalist
• ✓ 4.24 on StoryGraph across 96,990 reviews
• ✓ Kirkus itself flags explication over pace

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ Obstacle is structural, not a misunderstanding
• ✓ Ead’s deception gives the slow burn real weight
• ✓ Resolves in a clear, earned happy ending
• ✓ One strand of five, and closed door throughout

Characters ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

• ✓ 83% of StoryGraph readers report strong development
• ✓ Niclays Roos is the most-praised arc in the book
• ✓ 76% find the cast loveable across five viewpoints
• ✓ Only 8% experience it as character-driven

Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ Starred by Kirkus with a “GET IT” verdict
• ✓ Three cultures built with separate internal logic
• ✓ Prose density compared to Martin by readers
• ✓ Worldbuilding often delivered as interior monologue

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ 98% of StoryGraph readers mark it adventurous
• ✓ Sabran’s reproductive coercion arc genuinely lands
• ✓ Niclays draws the strongest reader reactions
• ✓ Only 48% mark it emotional, low for 848 pages

Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 2/5

• ✓ romance.io files it as behind closed doors
• ✓ Sex occurs and is never described
• ✓ StoryGraph logs sexual content at minor tier only
• ✓ Readers wanting on-page heat will not find any

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

• ✓ A complete epic resolution in a single volume
• ✓ Clear HEA for Ead and Sabran
• ✓ No cliffhanger and no sequel required
• ✓ Widely described as rushed after a long build

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

• ✓ Dense enough to reward a second pass
• ✓ Reads differently once the true history is known
• ✓ The prequel sends readers back to it
• ✓ 848 pages is a long re-entry cost

Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.