Mangos and Mistletoe Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A hot, food-rich holiday novella with two Dominican heroines and a real argument about heritage at its centre, held back by two narrators who sound alike and a romance that moves faster than its 150 pages can support.

Best for: Readers who want a short, steamy Christmas read with Bake Off energy, who value Caribbean-Latina representation, and who do not mind a fast, high-friction romance.

Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — explicit open door)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.57 Goodreads average across more than 2,700 ratings, docked for indistinct voices and a rushed arc)

Tropes: Baking competition, grumpy-sunshine, opposites attract, forced proximity, sharing a room, holiday romance, workplace rivals turned partners, heritage clash, Scottish castle, dual first-person POV.

Mangos and Mistletoe by Adriana Herrera is a self-published standalone holiday novella from 2019 — a short, explicit contemporary lesbian romance in which a Dominican pastry chef and a Dominican-American home baker are paired as teammates in a Christmas baking competition at a Scottish castle, and end up sharing a room.

It holds a 3.57 average across more than 2,700 Goodreads ratings, with the book’s admirers including fellow romance author K.J. Charles. Its readers agree on what is good and on what is not, and the split between them is unusually easy to read. Both halves are worth knowing before you start.

What Is Mangos and Mistletoe About?

Mangos and Mistletoe is a holiday novella built on a competition. The Bake Off-style setting gives it a ticking clock, a parade of desserts and a reason for two strangers to be forced together, and the Scottish castle supplies the Christmas atmosphere. But the real engine is cultural: both heroines are Dominican, one born and raised on the island, one raised in New York, and the book takes their different relationships to the same heritage seriously.

Kiskeya Burgos is a driven, guarded pastry chef from the Dominican Republic who needs this win for her career and her visa. Sully Morales is a warm, flirtatious home baker from New York, coming back to the kitchen after years spent caring for family. The story alternates between them in first person, which gives you both sides of every argument — but, as several readers point out, the two voices can be hard to tell apart.

What Makes This Sapphic Holiday Romance Work

  • The heat: The most praised element. Around nine reviewers single out the sex scenes as hot and well written, including some who did not love the rest of the book.
  • The representation: Around nine readers praise the Dominican and Dominican-American perspectives and the way the book lets the two women disagree about what their heritage means.
  • The food: Around six readers love the baking and the Caribbean flavours, and K.J. Charles was among those who praised the food writing.
  • The Bake Off fun: Readers who love the TV show say the competition delivers that energy, and at least one reader returns to it every holiday season.
  • Opposites under one roof: The guarded perfectionist and the bubbly optimist sharing a room is a classic grumpy-sunshine setup, and it gives the novella its friction.

Book Synopsis

Kiskeya Burgos does not do Christmas fun. She does precision, discipline and pastry good enough to win, because winning a televised holiday baking competition could open doors in her career and help her stay in the country. She arrives at a Scottish castle ready to work, and she does not plan on making friends.

The producers have other ideas. Contestants compete in pairs, and Kiskeya’s partner is Sully Morales: a Dominican-American home baker from New York who laughs easily, flirts constantly and is getting back into baking after years of putting everyone else first. Sully is thrilled to be paired with a fellow Dominican. Kiskeya is less thrilled to be paired with someone whose idea of their shared culture looks so different from her own.

They share a kitchen station. They share a room. They clash over flavours, over technique and over who gets to call themselves Dominican, and the arguments start to feel a lot like attraction. As the challenges get harder and the castle gets cosier, the question is whether two women who want such different things from the competition — and from each other — can trust one another long enough to win anything at all.

My Review

The strongest thing here is the specificity. Herrera writes two Dominican women who share a heritage and still misunderstand each other, and that friction gives the novella a texture most holiday romances never reach for. The food is lovingly described, the competition gives it pace, and the setup — a perfectionist and an optimist stuck in one room at Christmas — is a classic for a reason.

Mangos and Mistletoe by Adriana Herrera book cover

The heat is the other draw, and readers agree it is very good. The sex scenes are explicit and frequent for a book this short, and even reviewers who rated it low say they were well written. For a quick holiday read with real spice, it delivers exactly what it promises on that front.

Where it struggles is voice and length, and this is the consistent thread across critical reviews. The single most repeated complaint, from around eight reviewers, is that the two first-person narrators sound the same, so it is easy to lose track of whose chapter you are in. Around seven say the romance moves too fast to feel earned at novella length, and about five found the heroines — Kiskeya especially — judgmental or hard to like, with antagonism that feels contrived. A few wanted more baking and less bedroom, and a few noticed editing slips. Dear Author added a practical objection: one sex scene mid-competition makes no strategic sense.

One expectation to reset: the packaging says cozy foodie holiday novella. K.J. Charles noted it is not really cozy, and readers flag family homophobia and a sharp heritage conflict. If you came for sugar and snow, calibrate; if you came for a spicy, opinionated romance with a holiday backdrop, it is that.

My honest note: A hot, specific, short romance that would have been stronger with more room and more distinct voices. If you need a slow build, it will feel rushed. If you want a quick, steamy Christmas read with two Latina heroines, it is worth an evening.

ElementIn Mangos and Mistletoe
Central relationshipKiskeya Burgos & Sully Morales — a Dominican pastry chef and a Dominican-American home baker, grumpy-sunshine competition partners
Core tropesBaking competition, grumpy-sunshine, opposites attract, forced proximity, sharing a room, holiday romance
SettingA televised Christmas baking competition at a Scottish castle
Heat level4/5 — explicit open door
SeriesStandalone novella, roughly 130–150 pages — HEA with an epilogue
Content notesExplicit sexual content, homophobia and lesbophobia including family non-acceptance, racism and xenophobia, immigration and deportation worries, domestic abuse and death of a parent mentioned (crowd-reported on StoryGraph)

How Spicy Is Mangos and Mistletoe?

A 4/5. I could not get a romance.io reading for this title, so the number comes from the readers, and they are unanimous on this point: StoryGraph users overwhelmingly tag its sexual content graphic, Lair of Books called it super steamy, Bookish Afrolatina gave it full flames, and K.J. Charles described it as high heat. The scenes are open door, explicit and, for a book this short, frequent — one reader wished for fewer of them and more time in the kitchen.

No reviewer I found flags kink content. The thing worth knowing in advance is the family homophobia in the background. If you want another Christmas novella at this temperature, Christmas with Her sits in the same band, and The Christmas Pic is a full-length holiday romance with similar spice.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want a short holiday read with real heat, you love baking competitions and food writing, you value Dominican and Latina representation, and you enjoy a prickly heroine softening fast.

You may want to skip it if: you need two clearly distinct narrators, a fast romance feels unearned to you, abrasive leads put you off, or you wanted a cozy, low-conflict Christmas story.

In short: a spicy, specific Christmas novella with more heat than room to breathe.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)

This is a small, steady seasonal book rather than a phenomenon. It is self-published, so there are no trade reviews, and I found no Reddit or BookTok conversation driving it; it resurfaces every December as readers go looking for holiday romance, and at least one reader treats it as an annual reread. The numbers reflect a book that people like more than love: a 3.57 average across more than 2,700 Goodreads ratings, 3.6 across 760 StoryGraph reviews with a low 2% did-not-finish rate, and 4.1 from 481 Amazon ratings. Dear Author graded it B-, Lair of Books gave it five stars, and Bookish Afrolatina came in at 3.5. The audiobook, narrated by Lacy Laurel and released in December 2020, runs 3 hours 27 minutes; listener reaction is mixed, with complaints that one narrator for two first-person voices is confusing and that the Spanish pronunciation falls short.

Prefer audio? Listen to Mangos and Mistletoe on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The heat and the representation, roughly tied — around nine readers each praise the sex scenes and the Dominican perspectives. The food writing draws about six, and a handful love the Bake Off atmosphere. A few readers single out the family storylines and the way both women grow. StoryGraph readers tag it funny, lighthearted and fast-paced.

What readers argue about and complain about: The narrators, above everything — about eight readers say the two first-person voices are indistinguishable, and some of them still rated it four stars. Second: pace. Around seven feel the romance moves too fast for the emotion to land, and StoryGraph reviewers say the same. Third: around five find the heroines, Kiskeya especially, judgmental or unlikeable. Smaller notes: not enough baking, a thin sense of Scotland, editing slips, and an engagement that happens off the page. The genuine split is the heritage conflict at the heart of the book: some readers call it the emotional core, others find it contrived or uncomfortable, and they divide on whether it is cozy at all.

The standalone question worth asking first: it is complete in itself. There is no series and no cliffhanger, and the epilogue confirms the happy ending. Herrera is better known for her longer romances, and readers who want more of her food-centred writing tend to look there next.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is Mangos and Mistletoe?

It is a novella of roughly 130 to 150 pages, and the audiobook runs 3 hours 27 minutes. Most readers finish it in a sitting or two.

How spicy is Mangos and Mistletoe?

A 4/5. The sex scenes are explicit and open door, and readers agree the heat is one of the book’s main draws.

Is Mangos and Mistletoe a cozy Christmas romance?

Not entirely. It has a holiday setting and a baking competition, but readers note sharp conflict between the heroines, family homophobia and a heritage argument at its centre.

Does Mangos and Mistletoe have a happy ending?

Yes. It ends with an HEA and an epilogue, and it is a standalone with no cliffhanger.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes — narrated by Lacy Laurel and running 3 hours 27 minutes. Listener reactions are mixed, mainly over one narrator voicing both first-person leads.

If You Loved Mangos and Mistletoe, Read These Next

For another short holiday romance at the same heat, Christmas with Her is the closest match, and it carries more emotional weight than its cover suggests. If you want a longer Christmas rom-com with a little more room to breathe, Make You Mine This Christmas runs on fake dating and family chaos. And if it was the kitchen that drew you, The Chef puts food at the heart of a quieter romance.

For more like this, browse our list of grumpy-sunshine sapphic romance or the full Book Reviews collection.

The Bottom Line

Mangos and Mistletoe is a novella with more ideas and more heat than pages. The heritage conflict is genuinely interesting, the food is vivid, and the sex scenes are some of the most praised parts of the book. It is also too short for its emotional arc, narrated by two voices that blur together, and populated by heroines some readers struggle to like. If you want a quick, spicy holiday read with Latina leads, it is a satisfying evening. Check Mangos and Mistletoe on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Mangos and Mistletoe ranks as a steamy, culturally specific indie sapphic holiday novella — hot, flavourful and genuinely opinionated, held back by blurred narrators and a rushed arc, and best approached as a quick spicy read rather than a slow-burn Christmas romance.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ 3.57 average across 2,717 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.6 on StoryGraph, 2% did-not-finish
  • ✓ 4.1 from 481 Amazon ratings
  • ✓ Indistinct voices the loudest complaint

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Grumpy-sunshine friction sparks
  • ✓ Shared room raises the stakes
  • ✓ HEA with an epilogue
  • ✓ Moves too fast for many readers

Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Two Dominican heroines with real texture
  • ✓ Sully’s warmth lands for most
  • ✓ Family storylines add depth
  • ✓ Kiskeya judgmental for some readers

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Food writing vivid and loving
  • ✓ Heat scenes widely praised
  • ✓ Funny and fast-paced on StoryGraph
  • ✓ Two first-person voices sound alike

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Heritage conflict gives real weight
  • ✓ Family acceptance storyline lands
  • ✓ Growth for both leads
  • ✓ Novella length rushes the payoff

Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Explicit, open-door scenes
  • ✓ Readers tag sexual content graphic
  • ✓ Frequent for a short book
  • ✓ Some wanted more kitchen, less bedroom

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Happy ending confirmed
  • ✓ Epilogue shows their future
  • ✓ Standalone, no cliffhanger
  • ✓ Engagement happens off the page

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Short enough for a holiday reread
  • ✓ One reader returns every year
  • ✓ Libro.fm audiobook at 3.5 hours
  • ✓ Audio narration divides listeners

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.