Always a Love Song Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Always a Love Song by Charley Clarke book cover

Verdict: An emotional, angst-rich second chance: five years after leaving for stardom, pop star Bridget Callahan comes home after a broken engagement and faces Alex, the bar owner she left behind. Readers praise the heartache, consistent characters and the slow understanding of why Bridget left; others found Alex maddeningly stubborn and the then/now structure choppy. … Read more

Some Part of Me Is You Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Some Part of Me Is You by Adrienne Marsh book cover

Verdict: A hidden Kindle Unlimited gem: Ali, guitarist in her brother’s Chicago indie band, spends a summer opening for pop-country megastar Kristen Nichols — and falls for her. Readers love the slow burn, the real music-making detail and the characters; the main complaints are clunky sentences and too much uncommunicated pining. Best for: Readers who … Read more

Hammers, Strings, and Beautiful Things Review: Worth It?

Hammers, Strings, and Beautiful Things by Morgan Lee Miller book cover

Verdict: A raw, heavier-than-advertised music romance: 24-year-old songwriter Blair Bennett opens for pop superstar Reagan Moore’s tour while spiralling after her grandfather’s death. Readers praise the writing, music detail and intense chemistry; many struggled with how unlikable and self-destructive Blair is for most of the book. Best for: Readers who can handle a messy, grieving … Read more

The Popstar’s Cowgirl Review: Is It Worth Reading?

The Popstar's Cowgirl by A. Goswami book cover

Verdict: A spicy, polarising age-gap romance between a protective Texas rancher and the pop star who wants to shoot a music video on her land. Fans of the author call it funny, hot and heartfelt; a large share of critical reviewers believe it reads as AI-generated and cite inconsistencies, typos and flat characters. Best for: … Read more

I Kissed Her First Review: Is It Worth Reading?

I Kissed Her First by Betty Cayouette book cover

Verdict: A sweet, food-filled new adult debut: an aspiring chef lands a job cooking for her favourite pop star on a European tour, and a friendship turns into more. Readers love the travel, the food writing and the surprising emotional depth around grief; critics found the characters immature, the chemistry thin and too much told … Read more

Irregular Heartbeat Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Irregular Heartbeat by Chris Zett book cover

Verdict: A solid, low-angst medical slow burn: after nearly a decade as a professional drummer, Diana Petrell returns to her ER residency under an aloof attending, Dr. Emily Barnes. Readers praise the balance of medicine and romance and a couple who communicate; others found it pleasant but bland, with a slightly incomplete ending. Best for: … Read more

Because You Can Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Because You Can by Leigh Landry book cover

Verdict: A sweet, zero-spice twist on “the other woman”: a cat-rescue coordinator plots revenge on her cheating boyfriend with the closeted country singer he’s also dating, and they fall for each other. Readers love the premise, the pets and the supporting cast; several wanted more time together before the “I love yous” and less of … Read more

Lacey Lassiter Is Not a Lesbian Review: Worth Reading?

Lacey Lassiter Is Not a Lesbian by Mabel Ballard book cover

Verdict: A breezy debut rom-com in which a last-minute mix-up casts a rising queer TV actress as a tightly managed pop star’s love interest in a music video — and the internet goes wild. Readers who wanted short and sweet got exactly that; others found the leads childish for their age and the chemistry thin. … Read more

I Kissed a Girl Review: Is It Worth Reading?

I Kissed a Girl by Jennet Alexander book cover

Verdict: A kisses-only, horror-movie-set romance between a closeted B-list scream queen and the special effects makeup artist who has long crushed on her. Readers praise the Jewish and bi rep and the gory behind-the-scenes detail; many say the chemistry fell flat and the book tried to do too much. Best for: Horror-movie fans who want … Read more