Sapphic romance has exploded in popularity over the last few years, and Amazon is packed with options ranging from breezy YA rom-coms to literary coming-of-age novels. Here are three standout titles that consistently earn strong ratings and passionate reader followings, each with an editorial review and a summary of what everyday readers are saying.
Some Girls Do by Jennifer Dugan
The Premise
After being forced to transfer schools for being openly gay, elite track athlete Morgan falls for Ruby, a closeted beauty-pageant contestant with a passion for restoring old cars. Both girls are on very different timelines when it comes to living openly, and the story follows how their romance survives that gap.
Editorial Review
This one has real critical pedigree behind it. School Library Journal praised how the novel portrays serious issues alongside the adrenaline rush of first love, while Kirkus Reviews called it a complex and poignant queer romance. Bestselling YA authors Becky Albertalli and Casey McQuiston both blurbed the book warmly, and it picked up honors including a spot on the ALA Rainbow Book List and YALSA’s Best Fiction for Young Adults list.
What Readers Say
With a 4.5-star average across roughly 2,700 ratings, this is a reader favorite. Customers describe it as engaging from start to finish, praising the heartfelt portrayal of teenage queer relationships and well-developed characters. Several reviewers say it made them feel truly seen, and many finished it in a single sitting.
Sunburn by Chloe Michelle Howarth
The Premise
Set in a conservative Irish village in the early 1990s, this coming-of-age novel follows Lucy as an all-consuming love for her friend Susannah forces her to choose between the safe, expected life laid out for her and the terrifying, honest one she actually wants.
Editorial Review
Sunburn arrived with serious literary buzz, shortlisted for the Nero Book Award for Debut Fiction and the British Book Awards’ Discover Award, among other honors. Harper’s Bazaar described it as a novel that burns with the intensity and yearning of first love, and it’s frequently compared to Call Me By Your Name for its atmospheric, slow-building tension.
What Readers Say
Holding a 4.5-star average from around 2,800 ratings, Sunburn’s reviews highlight its beautiful, sharp prose and the vivid emotional pull between the two leads. Several readers mention being completely hooked despite a deliberately slow pace, though a handful found the tone more melancholy than expected. Overall, it’s described as an intense, memorable read that lingers well after the last page.
Like First Love, Again by J.J. Arias
The Premise
A second-chance, friends-to-lovers romance about Tori, a guarded real estate broker, and Mia, her childhood best friend and secret first love, who reenters her life fourteen years later while grieving and rebuilding herself.
Editorial Review
Author Alexis Daria called it an emotionally propulsive sapphic romance with heat and heart, praising how it balances humor with a thoughtful handling of grief and loss within the classic friends-to-lovers arc.
What Readers Say
This title boasts a 4.6-star average from over 2,600 ratings, one of the strongest showings of the three. Reviewers consistently praise the chemistry between the two leads and the way the book handles heavier themes like grief, mental health, and queer self-discovery without losing its warmth or humor. Many readers specifically called out the avoidance of common romance-genre frustrations as a major strength, and multiple reviewers said it was their introduction to sapphic romance as a genre.
Leave a Reply