D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding Review | Chencia C. Higgins | Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: A fast, funny fake-engagement romance with two Black sapphic leads who actually communicate and a coming-out arc taken seriously, undercut by a reality-show premise the book never makes work.

Best for: Readers who want high heat and low angst, adults who talk to each other instead of manufacturing a third-act breakup, and a butch-femme dynamic written with obvious pleasure.

Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — romance.io’s “explicit open door”)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.7/5 — a 3.96 Goodreads average across 8,450 ratings, with a very specific craft complaint)

Tropes: Fake engagement, fake dating to real, forced proximity, reality television, coming out, butch femme, curvy heroine, insta-love, dual first-person POV, HEA with epilogue.

D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding is Chencia C. Higgins’s sapphic contemporary romance, a standalone published by Carina Adores on 25 January 2022, set over six weeks in and around Houston, and built on the collision between D’Vaughn Miller — closeted, curvy, and quietly desperate for a reason to finally tell her mother — and Kris Zavala, an Afro-Latinx influencer with a reputation, when a reality show pairs them off and gives them six weeks to convince their families they are engaged.

It holds a 3.96 average across 8,450 Goodreads ratings and a 3.99 across 5,747 StoryGraph reviews, and the New York Times named it to its first dedicated best-romance list in 2022, in the contemporaries category. The averages sit on top of a split that is refreshingly precise: readers agree almost entirely about the couple and disagree almost entirely about the premise around them. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding About?

This is contemporary romance in the fake-dating mode with a reality-television frame, and the frame is doing two jobs at once. Mechanically it supplies the forced proximity and the ticking clock — six weeks, a hundred thousand dollars, a wedding that has to look real. Emotionally it supplies something better: a closeted woman gets a socially acceptable excuse to come out to a mother who will not take it well, which is a genuinely clever use of a premise most books deploy for farce.

D’Vaughn is introduced through avoidance: thirty, working a job she does not love, and still performing a version of herself for a conservative Christian mother she has never told the truth. Kris is introduced through momentum — visible, confident, out, with an online reputation as someone who does not stay. The novel runs in dual first person, present tense, and it is punctuated by reality-show confessional interstitials the book calls Jitter Cam, which let each woman narrate to camera what she will not say to the other.

What Makes This Sapphic Fake-Engagement Romance Work

• Two Black sapphic leads at the centre: The most-cited reason readers picked it up and the most-cited reason they recommend it. It is not incidental and it is not decorative.
• Adults who communicate: There is no third-act miscommunication, and readers name this constantly — when something goes wrong, the two of them talk about it like people.
• 93% loveability: That is StoryGraph’s figure for this cast, the second-highest on our entire sapphic fiction list, and it is the clearest number in the book’s favour.
• The Jitter Cam device: Confessional interstitials that mimic actually watching the show, and the one structural choice everyone agrees works.
• The coming-out arc: D’Vaughn’s anger at her mother is not minimised or resolved with a hug, and readers who have had that conversation say so.

Book Synopsis

D’Vaughn Miller is thirty, closeted, and out of excuses. Her mother is devout, her family is close, and every year she does not say anything makes saying it harder. So when she is cast on Instant I Do — a reality show that pairs strangers and gives them six weeks to plan a wedding and convince their families the engagement is real — she says yes partly for the hundred thousand dollars and mostly because it gives her a reason.

Kris Zavala is on the show for the money and the exposure. She is out, she is charming, she is good at this, and she has never once had to explain herself to anyone. The rules are simple: six weeks, cameras, a wedding at the end, and if the families believe it, they split the prize.

What neither of them planned for is that the performance is easier than expected and the pretending is harder. The question the book spends its second half on is not whether they will fall for each other — that happens fast and everybody knows it. It is what D’Vaughn is actually going to say to her mother when the cameras are off, and whether Kris is someone who stays.

My Review

The best decision in this book is that the coming-out plot is the real plot. Fake dating usually exists to generate farce; here it exists to give a frightened woman a structure she can hide behind while she does the hardest thing in her life. D’Vaughn’s relationship with her mother is written without softening — the anger is allowed to be justified, the reconciliation is not automatic, and the book never pretends that a warm family can absorb this easily. That gives a light, fast romance an actual spine.

The second strength is that these two women behave like adults. There is no manufactured misunderstanding, no third-act breakup engineered to fill pages, and no scene where one of them overhears half a conversation and storms off. When something is wrong they say so. Readers name this more often than anything else in the five-star reviews, and it is worth understanding why: in a subgenre that runs almost entirely on avoidable conflict, a couple who communicate is genuinely restful. It is also why 93% of StoryGraph readers call this cast loveable.

Where it struggles is the premise, and this is the dominant complaint rather than my own pedantry — it is raised independently by the Lesbrary and by several review blogs, which moves it from reader grumbling to a craft problem. The reality-show logistics do not hold up: readers cannot track when the cameras are rolling, so scenes that should be performance read as private and vice versa, and a cameraman established as living in D’Vaughn’s house simply disappears from the narrative. Stacked on that is the stakes problem, which is the dominant three-star note: the show promises jeopardy — a hundred thousand dollars, a deceived family, a forced timeline — and then every obstacle dissolves on contact. One reader summarised the whole book as things working out for the characters too easily, and that is fair. A third recurring objection is that the falling-in-love is asserted rather than built; the phrase is insta-love, and the six-week clock does not fully excuse it. There is also a specific and pointed complaint from Spanish-speaking readers that Kris’s Spanish contains errors, which matters in a book whose Afro-Latinx representation is part of the pitch.

The expectation worth resetting is angst. If you come to fake dating for the ache — the pining, the near-misses, the moment it all falls apart — this book does not have much of it, and one reviewer put it exactly right in saying she prefers her romance with broken hearts before they get mended. Calibrate for comfort rather than tension. On the other hand, if you have been avoiding fake-dating books because the third act always makes you want to throw them, this is the one that does not.

My honest note: A genuinely warm romance with a smart emotional core sitting inside a premise that does not survive scrutiny. If you can treat the reality show as a delivery mechanism rather than a setting, this is a fast, hot, unusually kind book; if the logistics bother you once, they will bother you for three hundred pages.

Element	In D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding
Central relationship	D’Vaughn Miller & Kris Zavala — a closeted femme and an out Afro-Latinx influencer, paired by a reality show
Core tropes	Fake engagement, fake dating to real, forced proximity, reality television, coming out, butch femme
Setting	Houston, Texas, over the six-week run of a fictional reality show called Instant I Do
Heat level	4/5 — romance.io’s “explicit open door”
Series	Standalone — complete, with an epilogue set one year later
Content notes	Homophobia and lesbophobia, religious bigotry, racism, coming out to an unsupportive parent, parental rejection, body image and a weight-loss backstory, explicit sexual content, heavy profanity

How Spicy Is D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding?

A 4/5. romance.io files it as “explicit open door”, and StoryGraph’s community warnings put sexual content at the top of the graphic tier, above homophobia. Reviewers describe it as hot throughout rather than saving everything for one scene, and the butch-femme dynamic is written with real specificity — readers name it as a draw rather than as a content note. Carina Adores marketed it as a flirty lesbian romantic comedy, and on heat the marketing is honest.

The element worth flagging in advance is a body-image thread rather than anything sexual. Smart Bitches, which graded the book a B plus, made the sharpest version of the point: Kris’s history as a formerly fat person surfaces sporadically without ever being explored, which keeps a book with a curvy heroine from being fully fat-positive. No reviewer flags any kink. For the same explicit band on this site, Delilah Green Doesn’t Care and Hotel Queens also sit at 4/5.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want Black sapphic leads front and centre, you are tired of manufactured miscommunication, you like a butch-femme dynamic written with pleasure, and you want heat without angst.

You may want to skip it if: a premise that does not hold together will nag at you, low stakes bore you, insta-love is a dealbreaker, or you read fake dating specifically for the pining.

In short: the kindest romance on this list, wrapped in the least convincing premise.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

Four years on, this book’s reception has an unusual shape: real mainstream recognition, no awards, and a small but very warm readership. The New York Times named it to its first dedicated best-romance list for 2022, in the contemporaries category selected by romance columnist Olivia Waite, and it picked up a Today Show mention. It was not a Lambda Literary finalist and not a GCLS Goldie finalist. With 8,450 Goodreads ratings it is one of the smaller readerships on our sapphic fiction list, which matters when you read the reviews — the sample is enthusiastic rather than representative. Higgins has not written a sequel; her next sapphic release was A Little Kissing Between Friends in 2024. No adaptation has been announced.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Black sapphic leads come first and come up most, usually phrased as a demand for more of exactly this. Second, and stated with real relief, is the absence of the miscommunication trope — readers repeatedly note that the two women communicate as partners and that there is no big conflict engineered for the final act. Third is that it is a low-angst comfort read; the recurring image is finishing it with a stupid grin. Fourth is pace and humour: 52% of StoryGraph readers call it fast, the highest figure on our list, and 73% mark it funny. Fifth is the Jitter Cam structure, which readers enjoy as a formal joke that also does character work. Sixth is that the coming-out arc is taken seriously, including D’Vaughn’s anger. Seventh is the heat. The minority view worth flagging cuts against the stakes complaint: a real contingent argue that a book about a Black queer woman coming out to a devout mother does not need manufactured jeopardy on top, and that readers asking for more drama are asking for a worse book.

What readers argue about and complain about: Low stakes, above everything, and it is the dominant three-star note rather than a one-star one — the reality-show premise promises a prize, a deceived family and a deadline, and then every obstacle resolves without cost. Second, and the sharper craft objection, is that the reality-television logistics simply do not hold: readers cannot tell when filming is happening, private scenes read as unwatched when they should not be, and a cameraman established early vanishes from the book. This one is raised independently by the Lesbrary and by review blogs, which is why it carries more weight than a typical reader grumble. Third is insta-love — the six-week frame is not quite enough to justify how quickly the feelings arrive, and readers wanted more development and a little more ache. Fourth is telling rather than showing, with a slice of readers reporting they never felt the connection and that not much actually happens. Fifth, specific and pointed: Spanish-language errors in a book whose Afro-Latinx representation is central. A sixth thread, raised by Smart Bitches, is that D’Vaughn’s doubt persists until roughly the ninety per cent mark, which strains belief in the happy ending. StoryGraph adds one number worth noting against the enthusiasm: 14% of readers say there is no strong character development.

The standalone question worth asking first: It is a complete standalone with an HEA and an epilogue set a year later, which Smart Bitches specifically credits for reassuring readers about the couple’s stability — useful if the late-book doubt bothers you. There is no sequel and none announced. If it works for you, Higgins’s A Little Kissing Between Friends (2024) is the natural next stop, and the honest framing is that it is a different register rather than more of the same premise. Her wider catalogue is largely m/f, so the sapphic list is short.

The audiobook is narrated by Rebecca Lee and runs 8 hours 47 minutes from Dreamscape Media — note that it arrived five months after the print edition, so early reviews do not discuss it. It is the shortest listen on our list, which suits a book whose main virtue is momentum.

Prefer audio? Listen to D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding have a happy ending?

Yes, with a full HEA and an epilogue set one year later that shows the couple settled. If you worry about how late in the book D’Vaughn’s doubts persist, the epilogue exists to answer exactly that.

How explicit is it?

A 4/5. romance.io files it as “explicit open door” and StoryGraph puts sexual content at the top of the graphic tier. Reviewers describe it as hot throughout rather than concentrated in one scene.

Is there a third-act breakup?

No, and it is the single most-praised thing about the book. There is no manufactured miscommunication; the leads talk to each other when something goes wrong.

Is it part of a series?

No. It is a complete standalone with no sequel written or announced. Higgins’s next sapphic novel was A Little Kissing Between Friends in 2024.

How heavy is the coming-out storyline?

Substantial. D’Vaughn is coming out to a devout, unsupportive mother, her anger about it is not minimised, and the reconciliation is not automatic. It is the emotional core rather than a subplot.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Rebecca Lee narrates the Dreamscape Media edition at 8 hours 47 minutes, released five months after the print version.

If You Loved D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding, Read These Next

Try Delilah Green Doesn’t Care for the same explicit heat with a great deal more family friction; Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea if what you loved was the low-angst, high-communication register; and Here We Go Again for a romance that takes the family material even further. More in Contemporary Lesbian Romance and across our Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding set out to use a fake-engagement reality show as cover for a woman finally telling her mother the truth, and three things carry it: two Black sapphic leads written with obvious affection, a couple who communicate instead of manufacturing conflict, and a coming-out arc that refuses to be resolved with a hug. Three things hold it back: reality-television logistics that fall apart under any scrutiny, stakes that dissolve every time they are raised, and a romance that arrives faster than the page count earns. If you want warmth, heat and no third-act breakup, it delivers all three. Check D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

We rank D’Vaughn and Kris Plan a Wedding at 3.7/5 — a warm, fast, genuinely kind romance built on a premise that does not survive being looked at.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

• ✓ 3.96 average across 8,450 Goodreads ratings
• ✓ Named to the New York Times best romance list for 2022
• ✓ 3.99 on StoryGraph across 5,747 reviews
• ✓ No award recognition despite the mainstream notice

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ No third-act breakup and no manufactured miscommunication
• ✓ Butch-femme dynamic written with real specificity
• ✓ The coming-out arc gives the romance an actual spine
• ✓ Falling in love is asserted faster than it is built

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

• ✓ 93% of StoryGraph readers call the cast loveable
• ✓ D’Vaughn’s anger at her mother is never minimised
• ✓ Family and community given real texture
• ✓ 14% say there is no strong character development

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

• ✓ 73% of StoryGraph readers mark it funny
• ✓ The Jitter Cam interstitials work as structure and as joke
• ✓ Dual first-person present tense keeps the pace up
• ✓ Reality-show continuity errors flagged by reviewers

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

• ✓ 85% of StoryGraph readers mark it lighthearted
• ✓ The mother storyline carries genuine weight
• ✓ 55% still mark it emotional despite the comic frame
• ✓ Every obstacle resolves before it can hurt

Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ romance.io files it as explicit open door
• ✓ StoryGraph puts sexual content at the top of the graphic tier
• ✓ Hot throughout rather than saved for one scene
• ✓ Body-image backstory surfaces without being explored

Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ Full HEA with an epilogue set one year later
• ✓ The coming-out thread resolves without false comfort
• ✓ The epilogue answers the doubt the book raises late
• ✓ D’Vaughn’s uncertainty runs to roughly the 90% mark

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

• ✓ Short and fast enough to reread in a sitting
• ✓ Comfort reread with no unpleasant surprises
• ✓ The Jitter Cam sections stay funny
• ✓ The premise holds up less well the second time

Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.