Updated on October 7, 2026
Verdict: An extremely dark sapphic captive thriller built on a Stockholm-syndrome bond between a grieving young woman and the killer who takes her — devastating for the readers it works on, undercut by writing and editing problems that drive many others to quit.
Best for: Experienced dark-romance readers who want graphic content, kink and an emotionally brutal captor-captive story, and who can forgive rough prose for intensity.
Heat level: ★★★★★ (5/5 — romance.io: explicit and plentiful)
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.2/5 — a 4.12 Goodreads average across 1,760 ratings that hides a deeply split reception: 13% of readers give it one or two stars, almost always for the writing)
Tropes: Captor and captive, Stockholm syndrome, abduction, vengeance, morally grey heroine, age gap, BDSM and primal play, tortured heroine, criminal heroine, dual POV.
Collateral Damage is Shassii’s self-published 2025 dark sapphic romance, billed by its author as a sapphic erotic thriller, in which Alora — whose life has been destroyed by a murder — ends up held by Hays, a killer who calls her Puppet, and the two are drawn into a bond that the book itself describes as heavy Stockholm syndrome with no guaranteed happy ending.
It has 1,760 Goodreads ratings averaging 4.12 and 498 written reviews, 841 Amazon ratings averaging 4.6, and a 4.38 from 13 romance.io readers. Those averages look comfortable, but the distribution does not: 57% of Goodreads ratings are five stars and 13% are one or two. Among the thirty reviews Goodreads shows first, fourteen are three stars or below and several are DNFs. Few books on this site divide readers this sharply.
What Is Collateral Damage About?
It is a captive thriller first and a romance second, and the author is explicit about that: the description warns of graphic and disturbing scenes, directs readers to content warnings, and promises Stockholm syndrome rather than a conventional love story. Romance.io readers tag it with abduction, vengeance, BDSM, primal play, daddy kink and a tortured heroine, which gives a fair picture of the book’s range.
Alora is the one who has lost everything — the description opens on a life taken from her in cold blood and a girl reduced to a shell. Hays is the captor, a “Clown” with an act for everything and, in Alora’s words, a hollow heart. The book is told from both points of view, which is what lets readers who love it describe watching the two heal each other, and what lets readers who hate it describe a relationship they cannot accept. At 538 pages, it is a long read.
What Makes This Dark Sapphic Thriller Work
- Emotional devastation: The five-star reviews read like aftermath — readers say they are in shambles, sobbing, thinking about Alora and Hays every morning. For its audience, the emotional impact is the whole point.
- Dual POV: Fans like that both points of view are equally engaging, and that the book shows the two women changing each other.
- Uncompromising darkness: The author warns readers properly, and the readers who wanted a truly dark sapphic book say it delivered rather than softening at the last minute.
- Crossover appeal: At least one five-star reader says they do not normally read dark romance and need a traditional happy ending, and still could not stop thinking about it.
- The heat: Romance.io places it in the top band, and the kink content is a deliberate part of the book rather than an add-on.
Book Synopsis
Alora’s world ends in a single act of violence. The life she loved is taken from her in cold blood, and what is left of her is grief and fear. Then she is taken — by Hays, a killer with a performer’s mask and a name for her that tells Alora exactly what she has become: Puppet.
Held against her will, Alora has every reason to hate her captor and every reason to fear what Hays will do next. Hays has her own reasons for keeping Alora close, and the book takes its time revealing them. As captivity stretches on, the line between survival and attachment starts to blur, and both women discover that the cruelty each expected from the other is not the whole story.
The book’s question is not whether these two should love each other — it tells you plainly that they should not — but what happens when they do anyway, and whether anything good can be built from that much damage. The author does not promise a happy answer.
My Review
The intensity is real, and it is why the book has the readership it does. Shassii commits completely to the premise: there is no softening of the captor, no convenient misunderstanding to make the abduction less than it is, and the emotional payoff, for the readers it reaches, is enormous. The five-star reviews are some of the most shaken we have read for any book on this site.
The second strength is the way the book uses its two points of view. Readers who love it say they watched Alora and Hays grow and heal each other, and that both voices hold their attention. For a book this dark, that sense of transformation is what turns it from a horror story into something its fans experience as a love story.
Where it struggles is the writing, and that is not a matter of taste; it is the overwhelming theme of the negative reviews. Of the fourteen reviews rated three stars or below among the thirty Goodreads shows first, the large majority are about the prose: readers describe awkward sentences, run-ons, spelling and grammatical mistakes, overlong inner monologues and a story that is hard to follow, and several compare it unfavourably to fan fiction. Six or more of those readers did not finish, some within the first fifty pages. Length is the second complaint — one reader who did finish says it is far too long — and a third reader liked the plot but found it confusing.
The expectation to reset is the gap between the hype and the reading experience. One DNF reader asks outright why everyone is talking about this book, and that tension runs through the reviews: the average is high because the readers who connect rate it five stars almost without exception, not because the book is broadly polished. If you are drawn by the reputation, sample the opening chapters before you commit. If the prose works for you there, it will probably work for you all the way through.
And it is worth saying plainly what this book is. The author calls it heavy Stockholm syndrome with no guaranteed happy ending, and romance.io readers tag abduction, BDSM, primal play and a tortured heroine. That is not a criticism — the warnings are clear and honest — but it is not a book for readers who want dark romance with the edges sanded off.
My honest note: A book that wrecks the readers it reaches and loses many others in the first few chapters. If you are a seasoned dark-romance reader who forgives rough editing for raw emotion, try it; if clumsy prose pulls you out of a story, this one will.
| Element | In Collateral Damage |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Alora (“Puppet”) & Hays (“Clown”) — a grieving captive and the killer who holds her |
| Core tropes | Captor and captive, Stockholm syndrome, abduction, vengeance, age gap, BDSM and primal play, dual POV |
| Setting | Contemporary — a world of violence and captivity |
| Heat level | 5/5 — explicit and plentiful (romance.io) |
| Series | Standalone; the author does not guarantee a happy ending |
| Content notes | Abduction, murder, graphic violence, Stockholm syndrome, BDSM and kink including primal and daddy dynamics, grief, abuse — see the author’s own content warnings |
How Dark and Spicy Is Collateral Damage?
As spicy as this site’s scale goes. Romance.io’s main entry rates it five of five, “explicit and plentiful,” from 13 ratings (a second, smaller entry has it at four), and its readers tag BDSM, primal play, daddy kink and fem-dom. The sex is explicit and frequent, and much of it is entangled with the captivity dynamic rather than separate from it.
It is also as dark as the site’s scale goes. The author’s own description warns of graphic and disturbing scenes and directs readers to content warnings before they start, and the consent questions are built into the premise. If that is the draw, nothing here will feel softened. For other sapphic books at the extreme end, see our reviews of Her Wrath and La Viuda’s Underworld.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you read extreme dark romance by choice, you want a captive dynamic with no apologies, you value emotional devastation over polish, and you are comfortable with explicit kink.
You may want to skip it if: editing errors and awkward prose pull you out of a story, consent violations are a hard limit, you need a guaranteed happy ending, or you want a tight, fast thriller.
In short: a cult dark read with a devoted audience and a craft problem.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
This is a word-of-mouth dark-romance phenomenon in a small niche. It was released on Valentine’s Day 2025, and in under two years it has built up 1,760 Goodreads ratings and nearly 500 written reviews — far more than most indie sapphic dark romances. The reviews show how: readers say they picked it up because of the buzz and because of recommendations from other readers, and one asks pointedly why everyone is talking about it. It is in Kindle Unlimited, which lowers the cost of trying it, and there are hardcover and paperback editions but no audiobook. The Goodreads distribution is 57% five stars, 18% four, 12% three, 7% two and 6% one — a shape that says love-it-or-hate-it.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The emotional hit, first and above all. The five-star reviews are full of grief, heartache and readers saying they need time to process, and several say they still think about Alora and Hays days later. The second draw is the relationship’s arc: fans describe watching two broken women heal each other, and they enjoy the dual point of view. The third is that the book means what it says — readers who wanted genuinely dark sapphic fiction feel they got it. Notably, even a reader who usually needs a traditional happy ending and low angst rated it five stars.
What readers argue about and complain about: The writing, above everything. Low reviews describe awkward prose, spelling and grammar mistakes, run-on sentences, overlong inner monologue and a plot that is hard to follow; several compare it to fan fiction, and at least six of the visible low reviews are DNFs, some at 12% or within 35 pages. Length is the second theme: one reader who finished calls it too long, and at 538 pages it is a big commitment for a book with this many complaints about pace. The third is plain disbelief at the average — readers who disliked it say they do not understand the high rating. The genuine split is between readers who will forgive almost anything for emotional intensity and readers who cannot get past the sentences.
The standalone question worth asking first: Collateral Damage is a standalone, and the author is clear that there is no guaranteed happy ending. Readers who loved it describe an ending that left them with grief and a kind of peace, which is about as much as we can say without spoilers. If you need a clear HEA before you start, this is not the book to gamble on.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Collateral Damage have a happy ending?
Not guaranteed. The author describes it as heavy Stockholm syndrome with no guaranteed HEA, and readers describe an ending that leaves them with grief as well as a sense of peace.
How spicy is Collateral Damage?
A 5/5. Romance.io rates it explicit and plentiful, with BDSM, primal play and daddy-kink tags.
Is Collateral Damage a romance or a thriller?
The author calls it a sapphic erotic thriller rather than a conventional romance. It centres on a captor-captive relationship, and the romance develops inside that dynamic.
Why do so many readers DNF Collateral Damage?
Almost always because of the writing. Low reviews cite awkward prose, spelling and grammar errors and a confusing plot, and several readers stopped within the first quarter.
Is Collateral Damage on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes. As of October 2026 the Kindle edition is included with Kindle Unlimited.
If You Loved Collateral Damage, Read These Next
For another sapphic book at the darkest end of the scale, try Her Wrath, built around a ruthless older matriarch and a long list of content warnings. For dark sapphic crime with a more conventional romance arc, La Viuda’s Underworld. For more books like this one, browse our books like Tryst Six Venom list, the possessive and obsessive sapphic romance roundup and our guide to dark sapphic romance, or every title in Book Reviews.
The Bottom Line
Collateral Damage sets out to be as dark and as devastating as sapphic fiction gets, and for its fans it is exactly that. It works on emotional intensity, on a dual-POV transformation and on an honesty about what it is. It struggles on prose, on editing and on a 538-page length that many readers could not get through. For seasoned dark-romance readers who prize feeling over polish, it is worth a try on Kindle Unlimited; for everyone else, the sample will tell you quickly. Check Collateral Damage on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Collateral Damage ranks as a polarising indie dark sapphic thriller — emotionally overwhelming for its audience, held back by unpolished writing, and best approached by dark-romance veterans for the intensity rather than the craft.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ 4.12 average across 1,760 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4.6 from 841 Amazon ratings
- ✓ 57% five stars, 13% one or two
- ✓ 14 of 30 visible reviews at three or below
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Fans see two women healing each other
- ✓ Bond built inside captivity
- ✓ Readers still thinking about the pair days later
- ✓ Stockholm dynamic by design, not a love story for all
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Both POVs called equally engaging
- ✓ Alora’s grief and change at the centre
- ✓ Fans say each brings the other back to life
- ✓ Critics call the characters poorly drawn
Writing ★★☆☆☆ 2.3/5
- ✓ Raw intensity carries fans through
- ✓ Author’s warnings clear and honest
- ✓ Spelling and grammar errors widely reported
- ✓ Awkward prose the main reason for DNFs
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Five-star reviews describe devastation
- ✓ Grief and heartache, then a sense of peace
- ✓ Even non-dark readers moved
- ✓ Impact lost on readers who quit early
Heat Level ★★★★★ 5/5
- ✓ romance.io: 5 of 5, explicit and plentiful
- ✓ BDSM, primal play and daddy-kink tags
- ✓ Heat integral to the captive dynamic
- ✓ Consent questions built into the premise
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Standalone, nothing to wait for
- ✓ Fans find it cathartic
- ✓ Author is honest about no guaranteed HEA
- ✓ Not a clear happy ending
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Fans say it lives in their heads
- ✓ In Kindle Unlimited
- ✓ No audiobook for a second pass
- ✓ 538 pages of dense, heavy material
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

4 thoughts on “Collateral Damage Review: Is It Worth Reading?”