Updated on October 8, 2026
Verdict: A gorgeously atmospheric folkloric murder mystery with the best prose on this shelf and a genuine rivals-to-lovers romance — attached to a political ending a substantial minority of readers found indefensible. Best for: Plot-first readers who want fantasy and mystery carrying real weight alongside the romance, and who are prepared for a closed-door book and a contested resolution. Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5 — behind closed doors) Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.48 Goodreads average across 20,570 ratings, with a political objection driving the loudest reviews) Tropes: Academic rivals to lovers, murder mystery, expedition, folkloric fantasy, grumpy ice queen, forced proximity, dark academia, slow burn, standalone. A Dark and Drowning Tide by Allison Saft is a standalone sapphic fantasy published by Del Rey in September 2024, in which Lorelei Kaskel — a sharp-tongued folklorist from the kingdom’s persecuted Yevani minority — is forced to solve her mentor’s murder alongside Sylvia von Wolff, the aristocratic academic rival she cannot stand, on an expedition to find the mythical source of all magic. It has a 3.48 average across 20,044 Goodreads ratings, a 3.56 across 9,705 StoryGraph reviews, a starred Library Journal review and a Goodreads Choice Award nomination for Romantasy. It also has one-star reviews with hundreds of likes making an argument the trade reviews never touch. Both halves are worth understanding.What Is A Dark and Drowning Tide About?
This is fantasy and mystery first, romance third, and the ordering is the whole point of recommending it. StoryGraph readers mark it 86% adventurous, 70% mysterious and 55% dark, with only 12% calling it character-driven — an unusually plot-weighted profile for a book that appears on romantasy lists. The setting is Brunnestaad, a kingdom closely modelled on imperial Germany, with folklore that functions as a working magic system rather than decoration. Lorelei is the outsider: Yevani in a country that despises them, brilliant, abrasive, and dependent on royal favour she resents needing. Sylvia is everything she is not — aristocratic, beloved, effortless. The murder of their shared mentor forces them into partnership on an expedition already full of people with motives, and the book is narrated close to Lorelei, which means you spend it inside someone who is frequently unkind and knows it.What Makes This Sapphic Folkloric Fantasy Work
- The prose: the most consistent praise in the reviews by a distance. Saft writes atmosphere — drowned forests, enchanted water, folkloric dread — better than almost anyone on this shelf.
- The rivalry: academic rivals-to-lovers with genuine intellectual friction, not just sniping. The banter between Lorelei and Sylvia is what readers quote.
- Lorelei’s Yevani identity: readers, including Jewish reviewers, repeatedly name the coded representation as the book’s most ambitious element — even where they argue about how it lands.
- The mystery has structure: a closed circle of suspects on an expedition, each with motive. StoryGraph’s 70% mysterious rating is earned.
- Institutional backing: a starred Library Journal review, a national bestseller listing, and a Goodreads Choice Award nomination in Romantasy.
Book Synopsis
Lorelei Kaskel has clawed her way into a position no Yevani is supposed to occupy. She is a folklorist in the service of a king whose country would rather she did not exist, and the work is the only leverage she has — for herself and for her people. The expedition should have been the making of her. Six of the kingdom’s finest set out to find the Ursprung, the mythical spring from which all magic flows, under the leadership of the mentor who gave Lorelei her chance. Then the mentor is found dead, and the killer is one of the five people remaining. Chief among the suspects, and now Lorelei’s unwanted partner in the investigation, is Sylvia von Wolff — aristocratic, infuriating, and the rival Lorelei has spent years measuring herself against. Neither can complete the expedition alone and neither can afford for it to fail. What neither expects is how quickly proximity turns the thing between them into something harder to name than dislike, or how much each will have to concede about the world she thought she understood before they reach the water.My Review
Saft can write, and it is not a close call. The atmosphere here — drowned forests, folkloric dread, water that will not behave — is the best prose on this site’s fantasy shelf, and it is the thing nearly every reader agrees on regardless of what they thought of the rest. The rivalry works too: Lorelei and Sylvia argue like two people who have read each other’s papers, and the intellectual friction gives the slow burn something to burn against.
The structural ambition deserves credit as well. Lorelei is Yevani, a coded Jewish minority in a country that alternates between using and despising her, and Saft builds the book’s stakes out of that rather than around it. Readers keep naming this as the most serious thing the novel attempts — including the readers who think it fails.
Because that is where the argument is. The dominant criticism of this book is not about craft, it is about politics: a substantial group of readers argue the plot resolves by having its persecuted protagonist side with the imperial power oppressing her, and that the ending frames collaboration with an imperialist king as the reasonable choice. The two most-liked one-star reviews make this case at length and drew hundreds of likes and comments between them. At least five independent reviewers raise it. Not one of the trade reviews mentions it — Library Journal starred the book without a reservation. When professional criticism and reader criticism diverge that completely, the divergence is itself the story.
The craft complaints sit underneath. Several readers describe the worldbuilding as imperial Germany with the names changed rather than genuinely built. The murder mystery, which is the book’s engine, is repeatedly described as resolving too quickly and too neatly for the setup it earned. And Lorelei divides people hard — StoryGraph readers split 51% loveable, 30% “complicated,” 17% not, which is the weakest character-likeability profile I have recorded here, and the Amazon reviews reach for words like cruel and toxic about the central dynamic.
One expectation to reset, and it is the practical one: this is a closed-door book. romance.io rates it 2/5, “behind closed doors,” and StoryGraph files sexual content under minor. It appears on spicy sapphic romantasy lists constantly and it does not belong there. If heat is why you came, this is the wrong book — and if you have been complaining that romantasy stopped bothering with plot, it is very much the right one.
My honest note: The best-written book on this shelf and the most argued-about, which is not a coincidence. Read it for the prose, the folklore and the rivalry; go in knowing the ending is contested and that a lot of thoughtful readers came out of it angry.
| Element | In A Dark and Drowning Tide |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Lorelei Kaskel & Sylvia von Wolff — outsider folklorist and aristocratic rival, forced into partnership |
| Core tropes | Academic rivals to lovers, murder mystery, expedition, forced proximity, grumpy ice queen, slow burn |
| Setting | Brunnestaad, a kingdom modelled on imperial Germany, on an expedition to find the Ursprung |
| Heat level | 2/5 — behind closed doors; StoryGraph files sexual content as minor |
| Series | Standalone — complete arc, romantic resolution, no sequel |
| Content notes | Graphic antisemitism, death and murder; violence, war and blood; colonisation, panic attacks and brief sexual content in the background |
How Spicy Is A Dark and Drowning Tide?
A 2/5, and this needs saying loudly because the book is routinely recommended to people looking for spice. romance.io rates the steam level “behind closed doors,” and StoryGraph’s crowd-sourced warnings place sexual content in the minor tier — the lowest they use. The romance is built on tension, restraint and intellectual friction, and the payoff is emotional rather than explicit. Nothing else needs flagging beyond the content notes above, though those are heavier than the heat rating implies — antisemitism, death and murder all sit in the graphic tier. If you want sapphic fantasy at this heat level deliberately, This Is How You Lose the Time War sits a band lower at 1/5 and Portrait of a Lady on Fire matches it at 2/5.Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want prose you can sink into, you read fantasy for folklore and atmosphere, you like a murder mystery with a closed circle of suspects, and a closed-door romance is a feature rather than a limitation. You may want to skip it if: you want explicit heat, you need a likeable narrator, you will not forgive a mystery that resolves too fast, or a fantasy ending that reads as siding with empire is something you would rather not spend 384 pages arriving at. In short: beautifully written, seriously ambitious, and the most divisive ending on this site’s shelf.What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
Two years on, this is the best-credentialed and most-contested book on this shelf at once. Library Journal gave it a starred review, calling it a fraught enemies-to-lovers fantasy in the register of the Emily Wilde books with political intrigue layered on. It was a national bestseller and a Goodreads Choice Award nominee for Romantasy in 2024. What it does not have is the rest of the trade set — I could find no Kirkus, no Publishers Weekly and no Booklist review, and Amazon’s editorial block carries only author blurbs, from Ava Reid, Rachel Gillig, Hannah Whitten, India Holton and others. BookTok engaged heavily and organically, though largely with the cover and the dark-academia aesthetic rather than the argument inside the book. Reddit is oddly quiet for a title this size. And there is one practical warning worth passing on that has nothing to do with the writing: Amazon’s own review summary flags a printing defect in some physical copies, with readers reporting the final chapters bound at the front and the first twenty-five pages missing. Check your copy before you start. Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The prose, first and almost unanimously — atmospheric, folkloric, immersive are the recurring words, and even one-star reviewers concede it. Then the rivalry: readers praise Lorelei and Sylvia’s dynamic specifically for having intellectual content rather than just hostility. The Yevani representation draws serious engagement from readers who found it moving and thoughtfully built. The folkloric magic system gets credit for functioning rather than decorating. And a meaningful contingent are simply here for a fantasy that remembered to have a plot — this is the book named when someone complains romantasy has become all spice and no structure. What readers argue about and complain about: The politics, above everything. At least five independent reviewers, including the two most-liked negative reviews on the book, argue that the resolution has its persecuted protagonist ally with the imperial power oppressing her and frames that as the sensible choice — one describes the cast as helping the imperialist subjugating them. This is a reading, not a settled fact, and other readers reject it entirely; what is not in dispute is that it dominates the critical conversation. Second: the worldbuilding, which several describe as imperial Germany lightly renamed, with continuity slips. Third: the mystery, widely reported as resolving too quickly and too neatly to justify its own setup. Fourth: Lorelei herself, whom a real share of readers found needlessly cruel — StoryGraph’s likeability split is the weakest on this site. Some Jewish and non-Jewish readers alike also found the antisemitism allegory handled more shallowly than its prominence warranted. And a notable proportion of the one-star reviews are outright did-not-finishes, most citing the slow first third. The standalone question worth asking first: this is a true standalone with a complete arc and a romantic resolution, and nothing further is required. Saft is prolific and uneven by the numbers — A Far Wilder Magic sits at 3.81, A Fragile Enchantment at 3.47, and her 2025 Disney Fairies novel Wings of Starlight at 4.14 across more than 50,000 ratings, her most-read book by a wide margin. Her 2026 novel Immortal Game is the one currently pulling readers back through the backlist.Frequently Asked Questions
How spicy is A Dark and Drowning Tide?
A 2/5. romance.io rates it “behind closed doors” and StoryGraph’s crowd-sourced warnings place sexual content in the minor tier. Despite frequently appearing on spicy sapphic romantasy lists, this is a closed-door book built on tension rather than explicit content.Is A Dark and Drowning Tide a standalone?
Yes. It resolves completely with a romantic resolution for Lorelei and Sylvia and has no sequel. Allison Saft’s other novels are separate stories, not continuations.Why is A Dark and Drowning Tide controversial?
A substantial group of readers argue the ending has its persecuted Yevani protagonist side with the imperial power oppressing her, and frames that collaboration as the reasonable choice. The two most-liked critical reviews make this case and drew hundreds of likes. Other readers reject the reading entirely, and no trade review mentions it.Is the murder mystery in A Dark and Drowning Tide satisfying?
The setup is — a closed circle of suspects on an expedition, with StoryGraph readers rating the book 70% mysterious. The resolution is the recurring complaint: multiple readers describe it as arriving too quickly and too neatly for the structure it built.Is there an audiobook of A Dark and Drowning Tide?
Yes — narrated by Saskia Maarleveld for Random House Audio, running twelve hours and thirteen minutes. No narration-specific complaints appear in the reviews.If You Loved A Dark and Drowning Tide, Read These Next
If it was the academic rivalry and the dark-academia atmosphere, An Education in Malice runs the same engine with vampires and considerably more heat. If it was plot-first queer fantasy where the romance is real but not the point, Gideon the Ninth is the more extreme version of that trade. And if the magical rivalry is what you want with the spice turned all the way up, Her Spell That Binds Me is the opposite end of the same idea. For more in this register, browse our guide to sapphic romantasy books or the full Book Reviews collection.The Bottom Line
A Dark and Drowning Tide is the best-written book on this site’s fantasy shelf and the one I would most hesitate to hand over without a caveat. The prose is genuinely lovely, the folklore functions, the rivalry has intellectual weight, and Library Journal starred it for good reason. It is also built on worldbuilding several readers find thin, resolves its mystery faster than it earned, and ends in a way a serious contingent of readers experienced as a political betrayal of its own protagonist. Read it for the writing and the atmosphere — but read the argument about it too, because you will probably have an opinion. Check A Dark and Drowning Tide on Amazon →The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, A Dark and Drowning Tide ranks as a prestige sapphic folkloric fantasy — beautifully written, structurally ambitious and trade-starred, undone for many readers by an ending they read as siding with empire, and best approached for the prose and the mystery rather than for heat or comfort.The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ 3.48 average across 20,044 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Starred Library Journal review
- ✓ Goodreads Choice Award nominee, Romantasy
- ✓ Political objection dominates the critical reviews
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Rivalry has genuine intellectual friction
- ✓ Slow burn earns its restraint
- ✓ Banter widely quoted by readers
- ✓ Central dynamic called toxic by some
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Lorelei carries real outsider stakes
- ✓ Yevani identity work is seriously attempted
- ✓ Sylvia more than an aristocratic foil
- ✓ Weakest likeability split recorded here
Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Atmosphere is the near-universal praise
- ✓ Folkloric dread genuinely well built
- ✓ Even critics concede the prose
- ✓ Worldbuilding called Germany renamed
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ 41% of readers mark it emotional
- ✓ Persecution stakes are concrete
- ✓ 55% of readers found it dark
- ✓ Allegory called shallow by some readers
Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 2/5
- ✓ romance.io rates it behind closed doors
- ✓ StoryGraph files sexual content as minor
- ✓ Tension carried by restraint
- ✓ Routinely mis-recommended as spicy
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Romance reaches a real resolution
- ✓ Expedition arc closes completely
- ✓ Standalone with no sequel needed
- ✓ Mystery and politics resolve too neatly
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Prose rewards a slower second pass
- ✓ Twelve-hour audiobook is a clean revisit
- ✓ Folklore layers repay attention
- ✓ Contested ending discourages returning
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
2 thoughts on “A Dark and Drowning Tide Review: Is It Worth Reading?”