This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A fast, genuinely unsettling YA cult thriller with a tender sapphic thread running through it, held back by a twist many readers see coming and an ending that stops short of the reckoning it sets up.
Best for: Teen and adult readers who want a quick, dark book about how a predator builds a family around vulnerable girls, and who are happy for the romance to be a lifeline rather than the main event.
Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — closed door; a 12-and-up YA novel not indexed by romance.io)
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.4/5 — a 3.58 Goodreads average across 383 ratings, with “reads young” the most repeated complaint)
Tropes: Cult survival, found family gone wrong, forbidden love, sapphic first love, dual POV, dual timeline, loyalty trials, isolated rural setting, the new girl who changes everything.
Where Lost Girls Go by Kody Keplinger is a standalone young adult thriller from Scholastic Press, published on 7 July 2026 and set in a cabin in the Kentucky mountains, where a man called Sol has gathered a household of runaway girls who call each other sisters — and where Iris, the most loyal of them, starts falling for the newest arrival, Rose, at exactly the moment Sol begins demanding proof that she belongs to him. It belongs on the sapphic suspense shelf rather than the romance one.
It holds a 3.58 average across 383 Goodreads ratings, a 3.69 on StoryGraph with only 1% of readers marking it did-not-finish, and a full set of trade reviews — Publishers Weekly, Kirkus, School Library Journal and the Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books all covered it. Readers finish it; they disagree on who it was written for. Both halves of that argument are worth understanding before you start.
What Is Where Lost Girls Go About?
Where Lost Girls Go is a YA psychological thriller first and a queer coming-of-age story second. Goodreads readers shelve it as young adult, thriller, mystery, LGBT and cults, in roughly that order, and Amazon lists it for ages 12 and up, grades seven to nine. The Appalachian setting does real work: a remote cabin, no phones, no neighbours, and a closed world whose rules are written by the one adult in it.
Iris has lived with Sol for about a year. She has a past she does not talk about, a new flower name he chose for her, and a debt she believes she can never repay. What she lacks is anyone to compare notes with honestly, until Rose arrives. Sol, meanwhile, assumes loyalty is his by right and designs trials to test it. The book alternates Iris’s present-tense chapters with a second, past-tense storyline following Caela, a girl whose life comes apart after her father’s death — and the question of how those two threads meet is the engine of the whole book.
What Makes This Sapphic YA Cult Thriller Work
- The manipulation feels real: Readers repeatedly call Sol’s grooming chilling and realistic. Kirkus singles out the girls’ reactions to a cult-leader father figure as the book’s strongest material, and StoryGraph readers tag it dark by a huge margin.
- Caela’s chapters: The second POV is the part several reviewers name as heartbreaking — a clear, step-by-step account of how a loved, bright girl ends up with nowhere to go.
- Iris and Rose: The forbidden love thread is small, but readers describe it as sweet and say it gives Iris the strength to see what is in front of her.
- Pace: “Page-turner” is the recurring word. Half of StoryGraph readers rate the pace fast, and the 1% did-not-finish rate says people get to the end.
- A finished story: It is a standalone. Whatever you think of the last chapter, there is no sequel to wait for.
Book Synopsis
Nobody at the cabin asks where anyone came from. That is the first rule Iris learned when Sol brought her up the mountain, and after a year she has come to love it. The girls share chores and beds and flower names, and in return for keeping them safe Sol asks for only one thing: that they never doubt him. Iris has never been happier, or she has told herself so often enough that it feels the same.
Then Sol brings home someone new. He names her Rose, the sisters fold her into the household, and Iris finds herself drawn to her in a way she has no words for. Rose asks questions the others stopped asking a long time ago. She notices things. And when Sol sees how close the two of them have become, he decides it is time for Iris to prove her devotion — through a series of trials that grow harder each time she hesitates.
Running alongside Iris’s story is Caela’s. After her father dies suddenly, she is sent to live with a mother who never wanted the job and a stepfather who wants her gone even more. Lonely and desperate to keep the only friend she has left, Caela starts making choices that close doors behind her one by one. As Iris’s trials escalate and the cabin’s secrets start to surface, the question is not only what Sol really wants from his girls, but what happened to the ones who came before — and how far Iris will go to protect the family she chose.
My Review
What Keplinger gets right, she gets very right. Sol is not a cartoon. He is patient, generous when it suits him, and precise about which fear to press on, and the book shows his control working through gifts, new names and the language of family rather than through chains. That is the hard part of a cult story, and the book understands that the girls stay because staying feels like love.
The second strength is Caela. Her chapters are fewer, but they carry most of the book’s emotional weight: a grieving teenager sliding, choice by small choice, from a home that does not want her to a stranger who says he does. Several reviewers say her thread moved them more than the cabin scenes, and I think that is because it answers the question every cult story raises — how does anyone end up there? — without condescending to the girl asking it.
Where it struggles is register, and this is not one reader’s quibble — it is the most repeated criticism across the three- and two-star reviews. Readers call it juvenile, simplistic, closer to middle grade than YA; one reviewer says she figured out what was happening by the second chapter. Around that sit the structural complaints. The sisters blur together, with only Iris and Rose getting real development, so the “family” is thinner than it needs to be for its loss to hurt. Several readers wanted more reason to believe these girls would follow Sol at all. The pacing is slow through the middle and then sprints, and the ending is open — bittersweet to some, short on justice to others.
One expectation to reset: the jacket copy pitches this as The Girls meets The Scammer, which sets up an adult-literary expectation the book never intends to meet. It is a 12-and-up thriller from a children’s publisher, and it reads like one. The romance, too, is a subplot: tender and important to Iris’s arc, but minimal by design. If you came for a sapphic love story, calibrate. If you came for a younger reader, or you want a dark book that will not tip into anything graphic, relax — this is exactly that.
My honest note: A sharp, credible portrait of coercive control wrapped in a thriller that is easier to solve than it should be. If you need your twists to land cold, this will disappoint you. If you want a fast, humane book about why girls stay, it earns its afternoon.
| Element | In Where Lost Girls Go |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Iris & Rose — the most loyal girl in the house and the newcomer who questions everything; a sapphic first-love subplot |
| Core tropes | Cult survival, found family gone wrong, forbidden love, loyalty trials, dual POV, dual timeline |
| Setting | A remote cabin in the Kentucky mountains, run by a man called Sol |
| Heat level | 1/5 — closed door; not indexed by romance.io |
| Series | Standalone — resolves, with an open, bittersweet final chapter |
| Content notes | Death of a parent, fire and fire injury, toxic and emotionally abusive relationships, confinement, death, homophobia and homophobic bullying, child abuse, homelessness, police encounters |
How Dark and Spicy Is Where Lost Girls Go?
Not spicy at all: a 1/5. romance.io has no entry for it, which is normal for young adult fiction and tells you the book is not being catalogued as romance in the first place. Amazon’s 12-and-up reading age and the reader reviews agree — the relationship between Iris and Rose stays at feelings, closeness and kisses, and several reviewers say the subtlety suits a story about a predatory man.
Dark is the real question, and the answer is: emotionally, yes; graphically, no. StoryGraph readers tag it dark (86%), emotional and tense, and its user-submitted warnings flag parental death, fire injury and a toxic, abusive relationship as the heaviest content. One reader who called it dark still said it never edges too far. If you want a sapphic YA thriller at the same heat, The Girls I’ve Been and Where Echoes Die both sit at 1/5.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want a thriller you can finish in a sitting, you are interested in how coercive control actually works, you like a quiet sapphic thread that matters to the plot, and you are buying for — or reading like — a younger teen.
You may want to skip it if: you guess twists early and resent it, you want a full romance with the relationship at the centre, you need a large cast with distinct voices, or you want an ending that delivers consequences rather than an open door.
In short: an honest, affecting cult story for teens, with a mystery adults will likely solve first.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
This is a trade launch, not a viral one. Where Lost Girls Go arrived from Scholastic Press on 7 July 2026 after an early review push — the earliest Goodreads reviews date from November 2025, many readers credit NetGalley or a Scholastic UK proof, and 130 written reviews against 383 ratings is the profile of an ARC-driven book rather than a word-of-mouth one. Four trade outlets reviewed it, and Goodreads lists an Audible audio edition from Scholastic Audio released the same day as the hardcover. I could not confirm a narrator or runtime: Audible would not load from here, and the audiobook is not stocked on Libro.fm. Reddit and TikTok could not be checked from here, so I am not reporting a social footprint either way.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The cult psychology first — “chilling” and “realistic” are the recurring words, and readers praise how clearly the book shows grooming turning vulnerability into dependence. Then the speed: several call it a page-turner they finished in a day, and one compares the vibe to Yellowjackets. Caela’s chapters draw the most emotional responses. The romance gets gentle, consistent approval — “cute together,” a subplot that “carries this for me” — even from readers who wanted more of it. At least one reader who did not see the twist coming calls it the highlight.
What readers argue about and complain about: Register, above everything. A cluster of three-star reviewers describe it as reading young, simple or juvenile, and both substantive two-star reviews say the same, one calling it more middle grade than YA. The trade reviews, notably, do not raise this at all — Kirkus pegs it at ages 12 to 16, which is the whole explanation, but the jacket’s adult comparison titles set other readers up for something else. Second: predictability, with multiple readers saying the dual POVs telegraph the reveal. Third: the ending — abrupt or open-ended for several readers, one wanting more justice for Sol, another more resolution for the girls. Beyond that, the sisters blending together, thin backstories, and a slow middle that turns rushed at the end. Opinion genuinely splits on the romance: some wanted more, others say its restraint is exactly right for the setting.
The standalone question worth asking first: it is a standalone and requires nothing further; the arc closes, but the final chapter leaves room rather than tying every thread. If you want more Keplinger, know that her solo YA novels sit in a tight band on Goodreads — The DUFF at 3.79 across nearly 197,000 ratings, That’s Not What Happened at 3.75, Run at 3.70 — and this one, at 3.58, lands at the bottom of it. Her middle-grade Lila and Hadley (3.97) and the anthology she edited, All Out (3.92), are her highest-rated books.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Where Lost Girls Go a romance?
Not primarily. It is a YA cult thriller with a sapphic subplot between Iris and Rose that readers describe as subtle, sweet and important to Iris’s arc. If you want the relationship at the centre, this is not that book.
How spicy is Where Lost Girls Go?
A 1/5. It is a closed-door young adult novel for ages 12 and up, and romance.io does not index it. The relationship stays at feelings and kisses.
What age is Where Lost Girls Go for?
Amazon lists it for ages 12 and up, grades seven to nine, and Kirkus reviewed it for ages 12 to 16. Many adult readers say it reads young, so set expectations accordingly.
Does Where Lost Girls Go have a sequel or a cliffhanger?
No. It is a standalone and the main arc resolves. Several readers found the ending abrupt or more open than they wanted, but nothing is held back for a sequel.
Is there an audiobook of Where Lost Girls Go?
Yes. Goodreads lists an Audible edition from Scholastic Audio released on 7 July 2026. It is not currently available on Libro.fm.
What are the content warnings for Where Lost Girls Go?
Readers flag the death of a parent, fire and fire injury, a toxic and emotionally abusive relationship, confinement, homophobia and bullying, and child abuse. Kirkus also notes homelessness and police encounters.
If You Loved Where Lost Girls Go, Read These Next
Readers who want another YA thriller about girls outlasting a dangerous man should go straight to The Girls I’ve Been, which runs the same survival engine with a sharper heist and a bigger readership behind it. If the dual timeline was the draw, Far From You braids past and present around a grieving girl and a mystery in the same way. And for small-town dread with a sapphic pair at its centre, The Dead and the Dark adds a supernatural edge to the same closed-community menace.
For more like this, browse our lesbian YA books guide, the sapphic mystery and thriller list, or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
Where Lost Girls Go sets out to show how a man turns lost girls into a family he owns, and on that it succeeds. Sol’s manipulation is credible, Caela’s slide is genuinely moving, and the Iris-and-Rose thread gives the book a warm pulse in a cold house. It is also simpler than its comparison titles promise, easier to solve than a thriller should be, and thin on everyone outside its two leads, with an ending that opens a door where some readers wanted a reckoning. For a teen reader, or anyone who wants a fast, dark, closed-door story about why people stay, it is worth it. Check Where Lost Girls Go on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Where Lost Girls Go ranks as a solid, teen-pitched sapphic cult thriller — credible on coercion and quietly tender, held back by a guessable twist and a young register, and best approached for Sol, Caela and the psychology rather than the mystery.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ 3.58 average across 383 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Only 1% did-not-finish on StoryGraph
- ✓ Four trade outlets reviewed it
- ✓ “Reads young” is the loudest complaint
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ Readers call Iris and Rose sweet
- ✓ Relationship drives Iris’s awakening
- ✓ Restraint suits the predatory setting
- ✓ A subplot, minimal by design
Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Sol is credible, not a cartoon
- ✓ Caela’s arc hits hardest
- ✓ 78% say character flaws drive it
- ✓ The sisters blur together
Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Propulsive, page-turning prose
- ✓ PW calls it “a propulsive thriller”
- ✓ Clean present/past POV split
- ✓ Many readers find it simplistic
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Tagged dark by 86% on StoryGraph
- ✓ Grooming portrayed as chilling
- ✓ Caela’s grief and exile land
- ✓ Thin backstories blunt the stakes
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ Closed door throughout
- ✓ Ages 12 and up per Amazon
- ✓ Not indexed by romance.io
- ✓ Descriptive, not a quality mark
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ True standalone, no sequel needed
- ✓ Bittersweet close some readers loved
- ✓ Reveal surprises a minority
- ✓ Abrupt and open for several
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Short enough to finish in a day
- ✓ Dual timeline rewards a second look
- ✓ Scholastic Audio edition exists
- ✓ Twist-dependent, less on repeat
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.