Books Like First Kill: 10 Sapphic Vampire and Monster-Hunter Reads

First Kill had a premise that sells itself. Juliette, a teenage vampire from an old Savannah family, has to make her first kill and picks Calliope, the new girl at school, who turns out to come from a family of monster hunters. Netflix released eight episodes in June 2022 and cancelled the show that August. V.E. Schwab adapted it from her own short story in the 2020 anthology Vampires Never Get Old. It is a short story, so there is no novel to go to next.

The exact combination barely exists in books. A YA romance where a vampire girl and a hunter girl fall for each other across a family feud is a shelf of almost nothing. We went through every sapphic vampire title we have reviewed, and the YA ones are mysteries first, with closed-door romances that readers often say never quite catch.

So this list splits the show into its parts: the hunter-and-vampire pairing, the teenage supernatural town, the monster families, and a Black heroine at the centre. Each pick has a “How it differs” note, because no single book gives you all of it.

If you want the romance turned up, you will have to go adult. The first and last picks here are adult, and one of them is extremely explicit.

Some links below are affiliate links; if you buy through them we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you. Related: sapphic shows on Netflix · best sapphic vampire romance books.

All 10 Books at a Glance

Heat ratings from our reviews (1 = closed door, 5 = very explicit).
TitleVampires?Hunter vs monster?Age groupRomance central?Heat
First Kill (the show)YesYesTeenYesLow
The Book of Blood and RosesYesYesAdultYes3/5
Bite MeYesYes (slayer)YANo1/5
The Coldest TouchYesNoYAPartly1/5
This Ravenous FateYesPartlyYANo1/5
The Midnight GirlsMonster girlsNoYAYes2/5
These Witches Don’t BurnNo (witches)NoYAPartly1/5
The ScapegracersNo (witches)NoYANo1/5
The Dead and the DarkNo (ghosts)NoYANo1/5
Carmilla and LauraYesNoAdultYes3/5
Better Off RedYesNoAdultYes5/5

1. The Book of Blood and Roses by Annie Summerlee

The Book of Blood and Roses by Annie Summerlee book cover

The opener of the Callisto Chronicles, from Del Rey: an adult sapphic paranormal romance set at a moody academy in the Scottish Highlands, where the central pairing is a hunter and a vampire with real danger between them. The leads are already comfortable being queer, so the conflict is loyalty and species, not coming out.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: It is the closest thing on this list to the show’s core setup: a girl raised to kill vampires and a vampire she should not want, with families and institutions pulling them apart. Unlike most books here, the romance is the main event.

How it differs: It is adult, not YA, and has real heat (3/5). The campus is a Gothic Scottish academy, not Savannah, and readers say the final act rushes.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

2. Bite Me by Jennifer Dugan, illustrated by Kit Seaton

Bite Me by Jennifer Dugan, illustrated by Kit Seaton book cover

A 240-page YA graphic novel. High-school senior Poe Parker is turned into a vampire on the same night her crush, Jolie Prescott, turns out to be a slayer and drives a stake through her chest. Poe survives, wakes up hungry and furious, and plots revenge.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: It is First Kill with the roles flipped: the vampire girl is the one who gets ambushed, and the hunter is the girl she liked. Kit Seaton’s art is the most praised thing about it.

How it differs: The romance barely gets page time, and the second half runs out of room. It is pitched at readers 12 and up, so it is gentler than the show.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

3. The Coldest Touch by Isabel Sterling

The Coldest Touch by Isabel Sterling book cover

A YA paranormal mystery in which vampires answer to a secret governing body. Elise Beaumont sees how people will die the moment she touches them, and she is assigned a vampire named Claire Montgomery, forever seventeen, to teach her how to use the curse. Then the murders start.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: A teenage girl and a teenage-looking vampire, a hidden supernatural bureaucracy and a ticking clock. If what you liked was the “secret world under an ordinary town” feel, this has it.

How it differs: No hunter families and no Romeo-and-Juliet feud. It is closed-door (1/5 heat), and many readers say they never felt the romance.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

4. This Ravenous Fate by Hayley Dennings

This Ravenous Fate by Hayley Dennings book cover

A Black sapphic vampire mystery set in Harlem in 1926: speakeasies, Prohibition crime and a city with a monster problem, told as a YA historical paranormal with the romance in second place.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: Calliope was the show’s heart for many viewers, and this is one of very few vampire books led by a Black sapphic heroine. The family-business-of-monsters angle is here too.

How it differs: It is historical, mystery first and romance second, with 1/5 heat. Readers love the premise and say the prose needed another edit.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

5. The Midnight Girls by Alicia Jasinska

The Midnight Girls by Alicia Jasinska book cover

Two monster girls whose work is stealing hearts, set against each other in a wintry, Polish-folklore city. Rivals to lovers with villainous heroines.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: The draw is two dangerous girls on opposite sides who are not supposed to want each other, which is First Kill’s whole engine.

How it differs: Both leads are monsters; nobody is a hunter. It is fantasy, not contemporary, the first act is slow and some readers find the romance cold.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

6. These Witches Don’t Burn by Isabel Sterling

These Witches Don't Burn by Isabel Sterling book cover

A Salem witch mystery with an already-out lesbian heroine, a coven with rules and a toxic ex who is still around.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: Small-town supernatural families with secrets, and a teen heroine who is out from page one. A good bridge if you want the high-school-plus-monsters mix without vampires.

How it differs: Witches, not vampires, and no hunter-and-monster romance. The romance barely gets built and the mystery is easy to guess.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

7. The Scapegracers by H. A. Clarke

The Scapegracers by H. A. Clarke book cover

A feral, funny witch-coven debut with a loud lesbian narrator and a friendship ensemble readers adore. First of a completed trilogy.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: The tone: teenage, irreverent and a bit gory, like the show at its most fun. The trilogy is finished, which after First Kill’s cancellation is worth something.

How it differs: No vampires and very little romance; this is a friendship story first. The plot is slippery and the prose style is not for everyone.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

8. The Dead and the Dark by Courtney Gould

The Dead and the Dark by Courtney Gould book cover

A creepy small-town ghost mystery with a strong father-daughter story and a sharp eye for how a community turns on queer people.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: A town hiding something, a family at the centre of it and a sapphic subplot between two girls who should not get along.

How it differs: Ghosts, not vampires, and the romance is thin. Many readers felt the ending was rushed.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

9. Carmilla and Laura by S.D. Simper

Carmilla and Laura by S.D. Simper book cover

A short, warm rewrite of Sheridan Le Fanu’s 1872 Carmilla, the story that invented the lesbian vampire, built so that this time the women survive.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: If you want vampire romance where the vampire girl is allowed a happy ending, this answers the oldest version of the question.

How it differs: It is adult, historical and gentle on horror. No hunters and no high school.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

10. Better Off Red by Rebekah Weatherspoon

Better Off Red by Rebekah Weatherspoon book cover

The first book of the Vampire Sorority Sisters trilogy (Bold Strokes, 2011): a college student pledges a sorority that turns out to be run by vampires. Warm, funny and very explicit.

Why a First Kill fan wants it: It is where sapphic vampire romance as a genre really starts, and the vampire-household dynamics are a lot of fun.

How it differs: Read this part before you buy. You will be recommended this, and it is not YA: it is 5/5 heat, college-age, and has almost no plot. Read it as the adult version of the daydream, not as a First Kill substitute.

The Amazon link above is an affiliate link. If you buy through it we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

If You Only Read One

For the hunter-and-vampire romance: The Book of Blood and Roses.

For the teen version, in one sitting: Bite Me.

For a Black sapphic lead in a vampire story: This Ravenous Fate.

For a finished series after a cancelled one: The Scapegracers trilogy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is First Kill based on a book?

First Kill is based on a short story of the same name by V.E. Schwab, published in the 2020 anthology Vampires Never Get Old: Tales with Fresh Bite. There is no full-length First Kill novel.

Will there be a First Kill season 2?

No. Netflix cancelled First Kill in August 2022 after one season of eight episodes.

What is the best book like First Kill?

For the vampire-and-hunter romance, The Book of Blood and Roses by Annie Summerlee is the closest match, though it is adult. For a YA version, try the graphic novel Bite Me by Jennifer Dugan and Kit Seaton.

Are there YA sapphic vampire books?

Yes, including Bite Me, The Coldest Touch by Isabel Sterling and This Ravenous Fate by Hayley Dennings. All three are closed-door, and the romance plays second fiddle to the mystery.

Where can I find more books-like guides?

Our Books Like directory collects every read-alike guide we have published, from Carmilla to Heated Rivalry.

More read-alike guides: browse the Books Like directory, or try sapphic books like Carmilla and sapphic vampire novels.

Leave a Comment