Verdict: A sweet, steamy second-chance romance between a movie star and the dog trainer she left behind, held back by a reunion that comes too easily and side plots that never pay off.
Best for: Readers who want a low-drama, high-heat Hollywood reunion with a guaranteed HEA, and who’d rather feel cosy than tense.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5: billed as high steam, and readers say the scenes are plentiful)
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.3/5: a 3.78 Goodreads average, with StoryGraph much lower at 2.78)
Tropes: Second chance, childhood sweethearts, movie star and commoner, hidden past, small town roots, celebrity romance, dog-related meet-again, found family, no cheating, standalone HEA.
Choices is Tessa Vidal’s 2019 debut, the first book in her self-published Cherished Choices line and a 206-page contemporary second chance romance: Caro and Shell grew up together in a Mississippi trailer park and were torn apart eleven years ago, and now Caro is Hollywood royalty with a buried past while Shell is the most sought-after dog behaviorist in town.
It sits at 3.78 on Goodreads across 83 ratings and 13 written reviews, 4.4 stars on Amazon across 138 ratings, and 2.78 on StoryGraph from nine reviewers. That spread is wider than usual. Readers who liked it found it sweet and happy, and readers who didn’t found it flat, and very few landed in between.
What Is Choices About?
This is a contemporary lesbian romance built on the celebrity reunion: one woman got famous and left, the other stayed true to who she is, and the book asks whether first love can survive fame, money and pride. The Los Angeles setting means red carpets and private investigators, but the emotional core is two women from the same poor background who made different choices.
Caro has reinvented herself so thoroughly that her past is a secret she’d pay to keep. Shell won’t hide where she came from, and her life has its own complications, including a twin brother in serious trouble. The two meet again over Caro’s newly adopted dog, and from there the book is mostly about whether they’ll let themselves go back to each other.
What Makes This Sapphic Second-Chance Romance Work
- The sweetness: The readers who loved it use words like sweet, cute and cuddly. One left with a big goofy grin, and that’s the mood the book is going for.
- Low drama: A 3-star reader calls it a love story with no major drama or complicated plots, which is a complaint for some and the whole appeal for others.
- The heat: The description promises high steam and a 5-star reader says the sexy bits deliver. Even the harshest review agrees the scenes are plentiful.
- Grown-up heroines: One reviewer praises the grown-up characters and strong women who can’t let go of their first love.
- A clean promise: The book states there’s no cheating and no cliffhanger, and the HEA arrives as promised.
Book Synopsis
Eleven years ago, Caro and Shell were each other’s whole world, two girls with nothing much except each other. Then life split them up. Caro went west and became a movie star, the kind who’s polished in every photo and never talks about where she grew up. Shell stayed herself.
Now Shell is in demand in Los Angeles too, as the dog behaviorist people call when nobody else can help. When Caro adopts a dog named Dickens, the two women end up in the same room for the first time in over a decade, and the feelings they buried turn out to be very close to the surface.
But Caro’s carefully built image has cracks, and someone has noticed. Shell’s twin brother Ryder is in trouble of his own, the kind that brings federal agents. And both women have to decide whether pride and ego will win again, or whether they’re ready to choose each other this time.
My Review
The appeal of Choices is easy to see. Two women who loved each other as kids, one who sold out a little and one who didn’t, reunited by a badly behaved dog. That’s a good premise for a comfort read, and the book knows it.
When it works, it works because it’s kind. Nobody is cruel, the stakes stay human-sized, and the heroines are adults who know what they want. The readers who rated it four and five stars mostly say the same thing: it made them happy. I don’t think that’s nothing.
The trouble is tension, and this is the complaint that recurs across the low reviews. The most detailed one, a 1-star, says there’s no build-up to the relationship and the small conflict the author adds is too easy to overcome. A 2-star reader says the two get back together almost as soon as they meet again. If you want a second-chance romance to make you wait, this one doesn’t.
The side plots are the second problem. Ryder’s FBI trouble promises action and then fizzles, and that same 1-star review notes that the blackmail threat against Caro is never revisited. Even a friendly 4-star reader wanted more resolution on Ryder. A 5-star reviewer admits it gets a bit repetitious. And the harsh review finds the celebrity side unconvincing, saying Caro reads as boring rather than glamorous.
So reset the expectation. If you were hoping for angst, a long road back and a plot that ties every thread, you’ll feel short-changed. If you want a warm, steamy reunion where you never worry about the ending, that’s exactly what you get.
My honest note: A pleasant debut with real heat and very little tension, and loose threads it never ties. Read it as a cosy weekend book and it does the job.
| Element | In Choices |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Caro & Shell: movie star and dog behaviorist, childhood sweethearts reunited after eleven years |
| Core tropes | Second chance, celebrity romance, hidden past, childhood sweethearts |
| Setting | Los Angeles, with roots in a Mississippi trailer park |
| Heat level | 4/5: high steam, frequent open-door scenes |
| Series | Cherished Choices #1, a standalone with an HEA, no cheating and no cliffhanger |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content, blackmail, a sibling in trouble with the law, poverty in backstory |
How Spicy Is Choices?
There’s no romance.io entry for Choices, so I’m going by the book’s own label and the reviews. The description calls it high steam, and readers agree on frequency even when they disagree on quality: one calls the sexy bits a highlight, while the 1-star reviewer calls the sex scenes plentiful, overdramatic and unrealistic. That puts it at 4/5.
No reviewer flags consent issues or specific kinks. If you want the same heat with more story behind it, Boss of Her also sits at 4/5, and Tempted by the Actress offers a celebrity romance at a lower 3/5.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want a cosy second-chance story, you like your romance steamy, you don’t need much conflict, and a guaranteed HEA is non-negotiable.
You may want to skip it if: you want a long, angsty road back, frequent sex scenes bore you, you need every subplot resolved, and you expect Hollywood to feel glamorous on the page.
In short: a feel-good, high-heat reunion that trades tension for comfort.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
There isn’t much conversation around Choices. It came out in January 2019, has 83 ratings on Goodreads, and I couldn’t find trade reviews, blog coverage or an audiobook edition. I couldn’t reach Reddit, so I can’t speak for the sapphic subs. The Amazon number is the healthiest at 4.4, and as usual Amazon runs high: StoryGraph’s smaller group gives it 2.78, which is more than a full star lower.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): “Sweet” is the recurring word. Readers like that it’s an easy, happy read with grown-up heroines and a love that never really went away. The heat is a draw for this group, and the dog helps. Several fans want more from this world, and one wished for a Hollywood follow-up with the same cast.
What readers argue about and complain about: Tension, above everything. The detailed negative reviews say the reunion happens too fast and the obstacles fold too easily, so the romance feels anticlimactic. Second, the subplots: Ryder’s run from the FBI and the private investigator’s blackmail both raise stakes that the book doesn’t follow through on, and a friendly reviewer noticed that too. Third, repetition, which even a 5-star reader mentions. Then there’s the real split, on the sex scenes: one camp counts them as a highlight, and the other finds them overdone.
The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone, with no cliffhanger and an HEA, so you won’t need anything else to finish the story. A reader calls it a good start for a first book and looks forward to more, and Tessa Vidal has gone on to write a run of sapphic romances since. If you liked the heat but wanted more plot, that later work is the place to look.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Choices by Tessa Vidal a standalone?
Yes. It’s the first Cherished Choices book, but the description says it has no cliffhanger, and it ends with an HEA.
Does Choices have cheating?
No. The description says there’s no cheating, and no reviewer reports any.
How spicy is Choices?
About 4/5. It’s billed as high steam, and readers on both sides agree there are plenty of open-door scenes.
Is there a Choices audiobook?
Not that I could find. Libro.fm doesn’t list one and I couldn’t find an Audible edition, so the audio buttons below go to searches.
Is Choices a slow burn?
No. The most common complaint is the opposite: Caro and Shell get back together quickly, with little build-up.
If You Loved Choices, Read These Next
If the celebrity angle is what hooked you, Tempted by the Actress gives you an actress romance with a little less heat, and Fake For Fame puts fame at the centre of the plot. For more reunions, our second chance romance reviews are the place to browse. For more books with the same no-cheating promise, see our lesbian romance books with no cheating, or browse all our book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Choices wants to be a warm, steamy reunion, and on those terms it mostly succeeds. The heroines are likeable, the heat is frequent and the ending is safe. It also rushes the reconciliation, leaves its subplots hanging and never makes Hollywood feel real. If a cosy, spicy second-chance story is what you’re after, it’s a fair pick. If you want tension, look elsewhere. Check Choices on Amazon
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Choices ranks as a light, high-heat indie second-chance romance. It’s sweet and generous with its spice, held back by thin conflict and dropped subplots, and best read for comfort rather than angst.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ 3.78 average across 83 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ Amazon higher at 4.4 across 138 ratings
- ✓ StoryGraph lowest at 2.78
- ✓ Readers split hard, few in the middle
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ Childhood sweethearts reunited
- ✓ Sweet and cuddly, say the fans
- ✓ Little build-up before they reunite
- ✓ Conflict folds too easily
Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Grown-up heroines praised
- ✓ Shell stays true to her roots
- ✓ Caro called boring by one reader
- ✓ Ryder left unresolved
Writing ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Easy, quick read at 206 pages
- ✓ A debut, and readers note it
- ✓ Repetitive in places
- ✓ No editing complaints recorded
Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 2.9/5
- ✓ Eleven years apart sets the stakes
- ✓ Pride and money as obstacles
- ✓ Called anticlimactic in detail
- ✓ Blackmail threat never revisited
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Billed as high steam
- ✓ Plenty of open-door scenes
- ✓ Overdramatic to one reader
- ✓ No romance.io entry to confirm
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ HEA as promised
- ✓ No cheating, no cliffhanger
- ✓ Ryder subplot left hanging
- ✓ Blackmail never resolved
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 2.9/5
- ✓ Short and comfortable
- ✓ Fans want more of this world
- ✓ Little tension to revisit
- ✓ No audiobook found
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
