Verdict: A light, likeable Cinderella retelling with a butch firefighter heroine and a small-town arson mystery, undercut by an instant romance and a plot most readers saw coming.
Best for: Readers who want a quick, cosy fairy tale twist with a firefighter lead and a dash of mystery, and who don’t mind a love story that’s settled early.
Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5: romance.io’s open door band)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.5/5: a 3.86 Goodreads average across 734 ratings, with StoryGraph cooler at 3.55)
Tropes: Cinderella retelling, butch firefighter, class difference, childhood crush, evil stepmother, small town, arson mystery, insta-love, mystery subplot, happy ending.
Cinders is Cara Malone’s 2018 retelling of the Grimm brothers’ Cinderella and the second novel in her Sapphic Fairy Tales series (Goodreads counts it third), a contemporary lesbian romance set in the small town of Grimm Falls, where firefighter Cynthia “Cyn” Robinson, still chasing her cold stepmother’s approval, finally catches the eye of Marigold, the town’s golden girl and her longtime crush, just as someone starts setting fires.
Goodreads has it at 3.86 from 734 ratings and 109 written reviews, StoryGraph at 3.55 from 135, and romance.io at 4.06 from only eight. It was reissued in 2025 under the Lisbon Press name, and the audiobook has been out since 2020. Readers mostly enjoy it and mostly agree on its flaws, which makes this one of the easier books to call. The question is how much you mind the speed of the romance.
What Is Cinders About?
It’s a small-town fairy tale retelling played straight in the present day, with no magic. The Cinderella beats are there in modern form: the stepfamily, the class gap, the girl nobody expects to get the happy ending. The firehouse replaces the hearth, which is a nice touch. The Lesbrary’s reviewer liked that Cyn’s job plays on how Cinderella got her name in the original story, sleeping in the cinders.
Cyn is a butch firefighter who joined the department partly because it was the last thing her stepmother wanted for her. Marigold comes from the kind of family that runs a small town. The story leans on that class difference and on Cyn’s need for a family that never quite accepts her. On top of the romance sits a serial arsonist plot, which is why 76% of StoryGraph readers tag it mysterious.
What Makes This Sapphic Cinderella Retelling Work
- The firefighter twist: A butch firefighter Cinderella is the hook, and it’s the thing readers praise most. The Lesbian Review called it the perfect choice, and the Lesbrary’s reviewer singled it out too.
- The nods to the original: The Lesbian Review says part of the fun is spotting clues from the old tale. The book also includes the original Grimm story at the end, which one two-star reviewer still said she appreciated.
- The tone: “Fun,” “light” and “cute” come up again and again. Readers who rated it four stars mostly describe a quick, cheerful read.
- The mystery: The arson plot gives the book a second engine, and several readers enjoyed trying to work out who was behind it.
- The couple: Readers who liked it call Cyn and Mari an adorable pair, and the family drama is pitched as “just enough” by one four-star reviewer.
Book Synopsis
Cyn Robinson has spent her whole life wanting three things. She wants to save lives as a firefighter, she wants her stepmother to look at her with something like approval, and she wants Marigold, the girl she’s had a crush on since they were kids. Only the first one has ever looked possible. Her stepmother has made it clear what she thinks of a stepdaughter who’d rather wear turnout gear than fit in, and Marigold belongs to a world Cyn only sees from the outside.
Then a fire brings them together. Cyn puts out the blaze, and in the middle of the smoke and the aftermath, Marigold finally notices her. The spark between them is real and fast, and for the first time it looks like Cyn’s dream girl might actually be within reach. But Grimm Falls is a small town with a long memory, and Cyn’s family has its own ideas about where she belongs and who she should be.
The fires don’t stop. Someone in town is setting them on purpose, and Cyn’s crew keeps getting called out. Cyn has to work out who wants to see Grimm Falls burn while holding on to a relationship that her stepfamily would happily tear apart. The question that pulls you through is whether a firefighter who’s always been told she’s not enough can claim her happy ending before it all goes up in flames.
My Review
The concept is great, and I wish more retellings were this playful with their source. Making Cinderella a butch firefighter is a joke that keeps paying off: the cinders, the soot, the girl everyone overlooks turning out to be the one running into burning buildings. Cyn is easy to root for from the first page, and the setup gives her a reason to be underestimated that feels earned.
The second strength is the mood. This is a light book even with an arsonist in it, and that’s a deliberate choice. Cyn’s work gives her somewhere she’s good at what she does, which balances out a home where she never is, and the arson plot adds just enough tension to keep things moving between romantic scenes. At around 250 pages it reads quickly, and “quick” is a word plenty of readers use.
Where it struggles is the romance itself, and this is the complaint the critical reviews share most. “Insta-love” is the phrase that keeps coming up. One three-star reader said the couple gets together after barely interacting, another said it felt even more rushed than the first book in the series, and a two-star reviewer noted the relationship is basically settled by the one-third mark, which leaves the rest of the book with little romantic tension. The mystery draws a similar charge. Several readers found it predictable, one found the solution dragged and was full of holes, and one more found the dialogue oddly formal and the characters one-dimensional.
The expectation to reset is the word “retelling.” If you’re hoping for a close, clever mirror of the fairy tale, calibrate: readers call it a loose, modern take, and a couple wanted it to follow the source more tightly. If you were worried it would be twee, relax. There’s no magic, and the firefighting is the real centre of Cyn’s life.
I’d have liked more of Marigold, too. She’s the prize in the fairy tale and the love interest in the romance, and that double role leaves her a little flat. Readers say plenty about Cyn and almost nothing about Mari beyond her family’s standing, which tells you where the book’s attention goes. The stepmother fares better as a character, if not as a person. She’s cold in a way that feels specific rather than cartoonish, and the stepfamily scenes are where the book’s emotional stakes really live. One reader was bothered that a major choice Cyn makes late on carries no consequences, and I can see why that would stick if you’re paying close attention. Most readers aren’t reading it that way, though. They’re reading it for the warmth, and the warmth is there.
My honest note: A charming idea with a romance that skips the slow part. If insta-love is a dealbreaker, this will frustrate you. If you want a breezy, sweet-natured Cinderella with a butch lead and a bit of mystery, it’s an easy afternoon.
| Element | In Cinders |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Cynthia “Cyn” Robinson and Marigold: butch firefighter and her childhood crush from the town’s leading family |
| Core tropes | Cinderella retelling, butch firefighter, class difference, evil stepmother, small town, arson mystery |
| Setting | The present-day small town of Grimm Falls |
| Heat level | 3/5: open door |
| Series | Sapphic Fairy Tales: a standalone couple, no cliffhanger |
| Content notes | Fire and fire injury, an emotionally cold and controlling stepmother, some sexual content |
How Spicy Is Cinders?
Middle of the road. Romance.io puts it at 3 out of 5, its “open door” band, though only eight people have rated it there. That matches what readers say. One four-star reviewer rated the heat three out of five fire emojis, and the reviews mostly talk about sweetness and fun rather than steam. There are on-page scenes, but they aren’t the focus, and the Lesbian Review described the book as sweet and gentle.
No reviewer I read flags anything extreme or a consent issue. If you want a firefighter romance with more heat, All Fired Up sits a notch higher, and so does Firestorm. For a Cinderella with barely any heat, the young adult Cinderella Is Dead goes the other way.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: a butch heroine makes you happy, you like fairy tale retellings that take liberties, a short cosy read with a mystery thread sounds perfect, and you’re fine with a couple that clicks right away.
You may want to skip it if: insta-love ruins a romance for you, you want a mystery you can’t solve early, you prefer close retellings of the source, or you need a lot of depth in your side characters.
In short: a fun idea that trades slow-burn tension for speed and sweetness.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
This is a small indie book with a modest, steady readership. It came out in September 2018, picked up 734 Goodreads ratings over eight years, and has no viral moment that I could find. I couldn’t get into Reddit to check the sapphic subs, and there are no trade reviews. It did get real blog coverage, though, which is more than many indie retellings manage. The Lesbian Review called it a charming retelling and recommended it alongside Seeing Red, and the Lesbrary ran a positive review in January 2020. The audiobook came from Tantor in May 2020, narrated by Emily Beresford and running a little over five hours. I couldn’t confirm a Libro.fm listing, so the Libro.fm button below goes to a search, and the Audible button goes to an Audible search.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The firefighter Cinderella, first and by a distance. Readers love the idea of a butch lead running into fires instead of sweeping up after them. Next is the tone, which the four-star reviews keep calling fun and light. Then the retelling itself: some readers enjoy hunting for nods to the original, and one called it a well-done reworking with a lesfic twist. A few also enjoyed the arson mystery as a change of pace from pure romance, and the couple gets called adorable more than once.
What readers argue about and complain about: Insta-love, above everything. It’s the most repeated criticism in the three- and two-star reviews, and at least one reader thinks it’s a habit across the series. Second is the plot. Several readers found the mystery predictable, and one argued the second half drags and ignores obvious holes, like a town that apparently has no security cameras. Third is depth. Readers describe the characters as one-note and the book as too short to develop them, and one found the dialogue stiff. There’s also a split over the retelling. Some like how loose and modern it is, and others wanted it closer to the Grimm original. Even a fan who’d read 15 of Malone’s books called this one her rare miss.
The standalone question worth asking first: Each Sapphic Fairy Tales book follows its own couple, so you can start here. It resolves without a cliffhanger. Readers comparing the series are split: one StoryGraph reviewer liked Cinders more than Fairest, while a Goodreads reader found it thinner than Seeing Red. All three are collected in a complete series edition. If you like Malone’s voice and want something with more room to breathe, our review of The Rules of Love covers one of her full-length contemporaries.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cinders a standalone?
Yes. It’s part of Cara Malone’s Sapphic Fairy Tales series, but each book has its own couple and Cinders resolves fully on its own.
How spicy is Cinders by Cara Malone?
A 3 out of 5. Romance.io lists it as open door, and readers describe it as sweet and fun more than steamy.
Is Cinders a close retelling of Cinderella?
Not very. It’s a loose, modern version of the Grimm tale with no magic, built around a firefighter heroine, a stepmother and a class gap. The original Grimm story is included at the end.
Is there an audiobook of Cinders?
Yes. Emily Beresford narrates the 2020 Tantor edition, which runs a little over five hours.
Is there insta-love in Cinders?
Yes, and it’s the most common complaint. The couple gets together quickly, and much of the later tension comes from the arson plot and Cyn’s family rather than the romance.
If You Loved Cinders, Read These Next
For another Cinderella with a queer heart and much higher stakes, try Ash, a quieter, more literary young adult take. If it’s the firefighter you liked, All Fired Up is funnier and hotter, and Truly Enough keeps the cosy feeling with a firefighter lead. For more books like this, see our lesbian firefighter romance books, or browse all our book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Cinders wants to be a fun, modern Cinderella with a butch hero in turnout gear, and that part works. The concept is clever, the tone is warm, and the arson plot keeps it moving. But the romance arrives almost instantly, the mystery is easy to solve, and the characters don’t get much room to grow. It’s worth it if you want a quick, sweet retelling and don’t need a slow burn. If insta-love is a dealbreaker, look elsewhere. Check Cinders on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Cinders ranks as a light indie fairy tale romance. It’s carried by a great butch firefighter premise and a cheerful tone, held back by insta-love and a predictable mystery, and best read for the concept rather than the slow build.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ 3.86 average across 734 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ StoryGraph cooler at 3.55 from 135
- ✓ Covered by the Lesbian Review and the Lesbrary
- ✓ Five of 30 sampled reviews at two stars
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ Childhood crush finally noticed
- ✓ Readers call the couple adorable
- ✓ Class gap adds some friction
- ✓ Insta-love is the top complaint
Characters ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Cyn is a butch lead worth rooting for
- ✓ Stepmother gives her something to push against
- ✓ Marigold gets less to do
- ✓ Called one-note in several reviews
Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Quick, light, readable prose
- ✓ Playful nods to the Grimm tale
- ✓ Original Grimm story included at the end
- ✓ One reader found the dialogue stiff
Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5
- ✓ Stepfamily rejection gives real stakes
- ✓ Arson plot adds tension
- ✓ 76% of StoryGraph readers say mysterious
- ✓ Little time for feelings to build
Heat Level ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Romance.io open door band
- ✓ Only eight romance.io ratings so far
- ✓ Readers stress sweet over steamy
- ✓ Scenes are present but not the focus
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Standalone couple, no cliffhanger
- ✓ Fairy tale happy ending delivered
- ✓ Arson plot gets resolved
- ✓ Mystery solution predictable for many
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Short enough for an afternoon
- ✓ Emily Beresford audio from Tantor
- ✓ Part of a three-book complete set
- ✓ Predictable mystery dulls a second read
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
