Verdict: A warm, funny Christmas office romance with one of Jae’s best grumpy bosses and a lot of real chemistry, held back by a workplace conflict some readers find thin and a family subplot that never gets fixed.
Best for: Readers who love an ice queen thawing slowly for a sunny, stubborn heroine, who like their holiday romance more cosy than Christmassy, and who are fine with a secret-identity setup that runs a while.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5: romance.io’s “explicit open door” band)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5: a 4.16 Goodreads average across 5,072 ratings, with StoryGraph a touch cooler at 3.93)
Tropes: Boss and employee, grumpy sunshine, ice queen, hidden identity, workplace romance, Christmas romance, slow burn, meet-cute accident, dual POV, class difference.
Under a Falling Star is Jae’s 2014 Ylva novel and the first book in her loose Unexpected Love series, a contemporary lesbian romance set at a games company in Portland, Oregon, where new secretary Austen Brooks knocks a star-shaped tree topper onto the head of the company’s feared second-in-command, Dee Saunders, without having any idea who she is.
It’s one of Jae’s most-read books. Goodreads has it at 4.16 from 5,072 ratings and 368 written reviews, StoryGraph at 3.93 from 818, and romance.io at 4.14. A 2021 audiobook with Abby Craden gave it a second wind, and a lot of the recent reviews come from listeners. The praise is steady and the criticism is narrow but pointed, and it’s worth knowing what that criticism is before you start.
What Is Under a Falling Star About?
This is a slow burn workplace romance with a Christmas frame, and the workplace part does more work than the Christmas part. The company setting means hierarchy, office gossip and the question of who’s allowed to date whom. The holiday mostly supplies the opening accident and a bit of seasonal glow. A LibraryThing reviewer expected more Christmas from the blurb than the book delivers, and I’d agree with that.
Austen is new to the company and quick with her mouth, a secretary who isn’t interested in being anyone’s doormat. Dee is the COO, a workaholic everyone calls Attila behind her back, raised in a family that never thought much of women in charge. The story switches between them in third person, so we get both halves of the misunderstanding. Austen thinks Dee is a fellow employee. Dee knows exactly who Austen is and says nothing. That’s the engine.
What Makes This Sapphic Ice Queen Boss Romance Work
- The ice queen: Dee is the reason most people pick this up and the reason they rate it highly. Readers who love a grumpy, guarded heroine who melts for one person say Jae does this type as well as anyone.
- The chemistry: “Chemistry” comes up in eight of the 30 Goodreads reviews I read closely, nearly always as praise. LezReviewBooks says Jae builds the attraction scene by scene until the tension is thick enough to keep you turning pages.
- The banter: Austen doesn’t defer, and the sparring between a nobody and the boss is where a lot of the humour comes from. StoryGraph readers tag it funny almost as often as emotional.
- The pace of the romance: Readers like that nobody says “I love you” too early. One Goodreads reviewer called the pacing realistic for exactly that reason.
- The audiobook: Abby Craden’s 2021 recording is praised again and again, and one listener said it lifted a book she’d liked into one she loved.
Book Synopsis
Austen Brooks needs her new job. It’s a secretarial post at an international games company, and on her first day she volunteers for the task nobody else in her department wants: decorating the big Christmas tree in the lobby. It’s supposed to be a chance to make a good impression. Instead the star on top comes loose and lands on a woman walking underneath, who ends up in the ER with stitches in her forehead.
The injured woman is Danielle “Dee” Saunders, the company’s chief operating officer and the person half the building is afraid of. Austen doesn’t know that. She’s heard gossip about a boss called Attila and has never seen her face, so she treats Dee like any other annoyed colleague, which means she argues with her. Dee, who is not used to anyone arguing with her, finds that she doesn’t mind. She blames the sudden attraction on the head wound and decides to keep quiet about her job title for now.
Keeping quiet gets harder the more time they spend together. Austen is warm and funny and plainly drawn to the woman she thinks is just a stressed coworker. Dee has spent her life proving to a dismissive family that she belongs at the top, and she’s got rules about mixing work and her private life for good reason. Every day the truth stays hidden it gets more expensive. The question pulling you through is what happens when Austen finds out who Dee really is, and whether either of them can risk a relationship that crosses the line between boss and staff.
My Review
Dee is the best thing in this book, and she’s a great version of a character type I’m always happy to read. She’s cold at work for reasons the book takes seriously. She’s surrounded by men who think she shouldn’t be where she is, and she’s built armour to match. Watching that armour come off for one person, slowly and a little against her will, is the whole pleasure, and Jae doesn’t rush it.
The second strength is that Austen isn’t a pushover. A lot of boss romances pair the ice queen with someone timid, and the imbalance can feel uncomfortable. Austen pushes back from the very first scene, and because she doesn’t know who she’s talking to, the early conversations have a freedom most office romances can’t manage. That’s the clever part of the secret identity setup. It lets the two women meet as equals before the job titles get in the way.
Where it struggles is the same setup, once it’s done its job. The criticism I saw most often in the cooler reviews is the workplace obstacle. One reader called the “we can’t date because we work together” worry plainly silly, another wanted more fireworks than the book delivered, and that same reader got tired of hearing the characters repeat that Dee is the boss. The other recurring complaint is Dee’s family. Her family, brothers included, is openly sexist toward her, and two separate reviewers were bothered that this never gets resolved or even pushed back on in a satisfying way. The harshest review I read, a two-star reread from someone who had first given it five, was mostly about that family.
The expectation to reset is the Christmas tag. If you want a full holiday romance with snow, markets and carols on every page, calibrate: the season frames the story rather than filling it. If a boss romance worried you because of power games, relax a little. Dee’s rank creates tension rather than leverage, and none of the reviewers I read describe the power gap as uncomfortable.
My honest note: A four-star office romance with a five-star ice queen. If an unresolved toxic family subplot will nag at you, know it’s coming. If you want a grumpy boss melting for a sunny employee, this is one of the good ones.
| Element | In Under a Falling Star |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Austen Brooks and Dee Saunders: new secretary and the company’s COO |
| Core tropes | Boss and employee, grumpy sunshine, ice queen, hidden identity, workplace romance, Christmas |
| Setting | An international games company in Portland, Oregon, at Christmas |
| Heat level | 4/5: explicit open door |
| Series | Unexpected Love book 1: complete on its own, with a short story sequel (Partners) |
| Content notes | Sexual content, emotional abuse and sexism within a family, death of a parent, homophobia, grief, brief mentions of rape and sexual assault |
How Spicy Is Under a Falling Star?
Romance.io puts it at 4 out of 5, its “explicit open door” band, and that’s what I’d call it too. Because this is a slow burn, the heat arrives late, but when it does it’s on the page. One five-star reader described it as just the right amount of steamy, which fits. Another said a late-night scene at the office had real potential to be sexier than it was, so the book is more generous with tension than with frequency.
No reviewer I read flags a consent problem, and the boss dynamic doesn’t spill into anything coercive. If you want something at a similar level with a workplace engine, Boss of Her sits in the same band. Jae’s own Something in the Wine is a notch milder.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: an ice queen boss is your favourite kind of heroine, you like banter more than angst, you want a slow burn with an explicit payoff, and you read Jae for steady, reliable romance.
You may want to skip it if: a sexist family that never faces consequences will spoil it for you, you find “we work together” conflicts flimsy, you want wall-to-wall Christmas, or you want the sex early.
In short: a great grumpy boss romance with one subplot that never quite pays off.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
There’s no viral moment here, and that’s normal for a 2014 lesfic novel. What there is, is a long tail. The ratings have kept building for twelve years, and Goodreads status updates show a fresh wave of readers picking it up each autumn, which makes sense for a book with a tree on the cover. I couldn’t get into Reddit for this one, and I found no trade reviews. Blog coverage is solid for a backlist sapphic title: LezReviewBooks gave the audiobook five stars and Curve has a short, positive write-up. The big development is audio. Ylva and Tantor released a new recording in December 2021, narrated by Abby Craden and running 8 hours and 5 minutes, replacing an earlier version with a different narrator. A lot of the newer reviews are from people who found the book that way.
Prefer audio? Listen to Under a Falling Star on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Dee comes first. Readers who love an ice queen describe her as the misunderstood boss done right, and “grumpy” turns up in a big share of the reviews I read. Next is the chemistry and the pacing. The attraction builds without anyone declaring love too early, and several readers call the relationship believable. Then the humour, which is why StoryGraph’s crowd tags it lighthearted (80%) and funny (56%). Last is the narration. LezReviewBooks says Craden made both women feel natural, and Audible listeners keep naming her as the reason they loved it.
What readers argue about and complain about: The workplace obstacle is the main one. Some readers buy Dee’s reasons for keeping her distance and some think they’re flimsy, and the reviewer who hated the “we work together” conflict hated it a lot. Second is Dee’s family. Two separate reviewers objected that the sexism and disrespect she gets at home is never resolved, and for the two-star reviewer it soured the whole book on a reread. Third, and smaller: the Christmas promise is lighter than the cover suggests, and one reader simply wanted more heat and more fireworks. There’s also a comparison worth knowing about. One lesfic blog argued the setup closely mirrors Melissa Good’s Tropical Storm, a boss and employee story from the uber fanfic era. That’s one voice, but if you’ve read that book you’ll see the resemblance.
The standalone question worth asking first: It works as a standalone and resolves fully. Austen and Dee come back in a short story, Partners, and make an appearance in Wrong Number, Right Woman. Austen’s best friend also links the book to Jae’s Portland Police Bureau series, but you don’t need any of it. If you want to keep going with Jae, see our full Jae reading order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Under a Falling Star a standalone?
Yes. It’s book one of Jae’s Unexpected Love series, but the series is loose and this book resolves fully on its own. A short story sequel, Partners, revisits the couple.
How spicy is Under a Falling Star?
A 4 out of 5. Romance.io places it in the “explicit open door” band, and the explicit scenes come late because it’s a slow burn.
Is Under a Falling Star a Christmas book?
Partly. It opens at Christmas with the tree topper accident, but readers say the holiday frames the story rather than filling it, so it reads well at any time of year.
Is there an audiobook of Under a Falling Star?
Yes. Abby Craden narrates the 2021 edition, which runs 8 hours and 5 minutes and is widely praised. It’s on Libro.fm and Audible.
Does Austen know Dee is her boss?
Not at first. Austen doesn’t know who Dee is when they meet, and Dee chooses not to tell her, which drives the first half of the book.
If You Loved Under a Falling Star, Read These Next
For another boss romance at the same heat with a sharper power dynamic, try Boss of Her. If it’s Jae’s steady, warm style you’re after, Something in the Wine is a gentler road trip of a romance, and Wrong Number, Right Woman lets you catch up with Austen and Dee. For more books like this, see our lesbian boss employee romance books, or browse all our book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Under a Falling Star sets out to be a funny, slow-burning office romance with a Christmas spark, and it gets there. Dee is a terrific ice queen, Austen is a match for her, and the chemistry builds the way it should. But the workplace obstacle is thinner than the book thinks it is, Dee’s family is left unpunished, and the Christmas is mostly on the cover. It’s worth it for anyone who loves a grumpy boss melting for one person, and the audiobook is the best way in. Check Under a Falling Star on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Under a Falling Star ranks as a strong, dependable lesfic boss romance. It’s carried by a standout ice queen and real chemistry, held back by a flimsy workplace conflict and an unresolved family subplot, and best read for Dee rather than for the holiday.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ 4.16 average across 5,072 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ StoryGraph a touch cooler at 3.93 from 818
- ✓ Romance.io at 4.14
- ✓ Family subplot sours a minority of readers
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ Chemistry praised in eight of 30 reviews
- ✓ No rushed declarations of love
- ✓ Secret identity lets them meet as equals
- ✓ Workplace obstacle feels flimsy to some
Characters ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Dee is the most praised element
- ✓ Austen pushes back from scene one
- ✓ Dual POV covers both sides
- ✓ Dee’s family stays one-note
Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Steady, readable Jae prose
- ✓ Banter carries a lot of humour
- ✓ Third person dual POV handled cleanly
- ✓ One reader says the prose sometimes doesn’t flow
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Dee’s armour comes off slowly
- ✓ Sexism at home gives her real stakes
- ✓ 80% of StoryGraph readers say lighthearted
- ✓ Family conflict never gets a payoff
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Romance.io explicit open door band
- ✓ Scenes arrive late in the slow burn
- ✓ Readers call the amount just right
- ✓ More tension than frequency
Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Complete standalone resolution
- ✓ Short story sequel for more
- ✓ No reviewer reports a cliffhanger
- ✓ Family threads left hanging
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ Holiday frame invites a December reread
- ✓ Abby Craden audio widely praised
- ✓ New narrator gives a second way in
- ✓ One reader liked it less on reread
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
