No Strings Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A cosy, steamy small-town romance about a sheriff in exile and the forest ranger she makes a no-strings deal with, held back by a thin police plot and a middle that coasts on charm.

Best for: Readers who want banter, mountain scenery and an open-door friends-with-benefits romance, and who don’t need much happening outside the bedroom to stay happy.

Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5: explicit and frequent, by reader consensus)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5: a 4.09 Goodreads average, with the same two complaints turning up in most of the lower ratings)

Tropes: Friends with benefits, small town, one year only, cop and forest ranger, only lesbian in town, slow emotional burn, banter, found community, a very good dog.

No Strings is a 2009 standalone from Bella Books by Gerri Hill, a small-town lesbian romance set in Lake City, Colorado, where a police chief demoted to county sheriff for one year and a forest ranger who has made peace with being the only lesbian in town agree to sleep together all winter on the strict understanding that it means nothing.

On Goodreads it holds a 4.09 average across about 2,455 ratings and 137 written reviews, and it has a second life on audio thanks to Abby Craden’s 2019 recording for Tantor. The love is real, but the complaints are consistent too, and they mostly come from Hill’s own fans. Both halves are worth knowing before you start.

What Is No Strings About?

This is contemporary lesbian romance of the comfortable kind. It’s set in a tiny mountain town where everyone knows everyone, the weather is a character, and the plot is mostly about two women discovering that the arrangement they set up to avoid feelings is the thing producing them. The sheriff job gives the book a little procedural texture, but it’s a romance first and a cop story a distant second.

Reese Daniels is the outsider. She made a bad call back in Winter Park, she’s here as punishment, and she tells anyone who’ll listen that she’s leaving the moment her year is up. M. Z. Morgan is the local: settled, funny, outdoorsy, a little lonely, and smart enough to know that falling for someone with a departure date is a terrible idea. The story stays close to both women, so you get Reese’s restlessness and Morgan’s caution side by side, which is exactly what makes the bargain feel fragile from the first night.

What Makes This Sapphic Friends With Benefits Romance Work

  • The banter: Reader after reader names the dialogue first. The back and forth between Reese and Morgan is playful and quick, and several reviewers say the teasing is what sold them on the couple before the bedroom did.
  • The chemistry: The attraction is there from their first meeting, and the reviews that rate it highest describe a bond forming that neither woman wanted. That’s the whole engine of a friends-with-benefits romance, and Hill gets it right.
  • The setting: Hill’s love of the outdoors shows. The high country, the long winter and the quirky townspeople come up again and again, and one of the early reviews quoted on Bella’s own page singles out the town’s atmosphere.
  • Low angst: Audible listeners keep using words like sweet, cosy and gentle. There’s drama, but nobody is put through the wringer, and for a lot of readers that’s the appeal.
  • It hasn’t aged: One longtime Hill reader went back to it a decade on and said there wasn’t even a tech reference that dated it. For a 2009 romance, that’s a real compliment.

Book Synopsis

Reese Daniels used to run the police department in Winter Park, a busy resort town with plenty to do and plenty of women to do it with. Then one mistake, the kind that gets talked about, gets her shipped off to Lake City for a year as the county sheriff. The town is small, the winters are long, and the most exciting call she can expect is probably a bear in somebody’s trash.

Morgan has lived in Lake City long enough to count as a local. She works as a forest ranger, has a circle of friends who feel like family, and has more or less accepted that the dating pool consists of nobody. So when a good-looking, broody sheriff moves to town, Morgan notices. She also notices that Reese mentions her departure date in nearly every conversation. Friendship is easy. Anything more seems pointless.

Then Reese makes an offer. As the snow comes in and the nights get longer, why not keep each other warm, with no expectations and no promises, and a clean goodbye when the year is up? Morgan says yes. The sex turns out to be the best either of them has had, the friendship deepens, and the winter keeps going. The question the rest of the book asks is a simple one: how long can two people pretend something is temporary when it so clearly isn’t?

My Review

What I liked most is how relaxed this book is. Hill sets up the premise in a few chapters and then lets the two women just be together, joking, arguing, going out on calls, and sleeping together. It’s a hangout book with heat, and the hangout part is good. Reese and Morgan are fun to be around, and the town is full of people you’d happily have a beer with.

No Strings by Gerri Hill book cover

The second strength is the chemistry, and it’s built on talk rather than looks. The banter does a lot of work here. By the time they make their deal, you already believe these two enjoy each other, so the arrangement reads as a natural next step and not a contrivance. Gaby at LezReviewBooks put the chemistry down to clever dialogue and situations, and I’d agree.

Where it struggles is plot, and that’s not just me. The most common complaint, and it comes mostly from readers who love Hill, is that the police and ranger material is thin. Lex Kent, who gave it 3.5 stars, said to read it for the romance and not for exciting cop or ranger scenes, and another longtime fan noted it moves slower than Hill’s usual books. A second, smaller complaint is about the start. A couple of readers felt the hookup came too fast and too conveniently, without the yearning that makes this kind of story land. One also flagged an early encounter Morgan has with another woman that read badly to her, plus a random ex and some subplots that go nowhere.

The expectation to reset is the title itself. “No strings” sounds like a slow burn that breaks at the end, and this isn’t that. One Audible listener said it jumps right into the spice and is definitely not a slow burn. The burn here is emotional, not physical. If you came for mounting tension and a first kiss at 60 percent, recalibrate. If you came for two women who are already sleeping together slowly figuring out they’re in love, you’re in the right place.

My honest note: A warm, sexy, low-stakes Gerri Hill that does the romance well and the rest of the story lightly. If you want suspense with your sheriff, you’ll be bored; if you want a winter in the mountains with good company, it’s a lovely way to spend a weekend.

ElementIn No Strings
Central relationshipReese Daniels and M. Z. Morgan: a sheriff on a one-year exile and a settled local forest ranger
Core tropesFriends with benefits, small town, one year only, cop and ranger, emotional slow burn
SettingLake City, Colorado, through a long mountain winter
Heat level4/5: explicit and frequent
SeriesStandalone; the couple turns up again as secondary characters in Hill’s Snow Falls, according to an Audible listener
Content notesExplicit sexual content; StoryGraph readers flag gore, blood and a car accident, plus animal death, death and minor biphobia

How Spicy Is No Strings?

I’d put it at 4 out of 5. I couldn’t get a romance.io reading for this one, so the number comes from what readers say, and they’re consistent: it’s explicit, it’s frequent, and it starts early. One reviewer called it the steamiest Gerri Hill she’d read, another tagged it as explicit, and Audible listeners joke about needing an ice bucket. The sex is also part of the story rather than a break from it, because the whole premise is that these two keep sleeping together while telling themselves it’s casual.

The one thing worth flagging in advance is that early encounter between Morgan and another woman, which one reader found uncomfortable to read. Nobody else raises it, and no reviewer names anything darker on the page. If you want a similar heat level, Hunter’s Way, another Gerri Hill, sits in the same explicit open-door band, and A Little Kissing Between Friends runs a friends-with-benefits setup at a similar temperature.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you like your romance cosy and low angst, banter is your favourite part of any love story, a snowy small town with nosy neighbours sounds perfect, and you want open-door scenes that start early.

You may want to skip it if: you need a strong outside plot, you want a slow physical burn with a payoff, you get impatient with an easy middle, or a cop heroine with no real cases sounds pointless.

In short: a feel-good winter romance that’s all about the couple, for better and for worse.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This is a 2009 book, so there’s no launch buzz to report and no viral moment. I couldn’t reach Reddit to check for threads, and I didn’t find any TikTok attention worth naming. What it does have is a steady backlist life and a strong audio edition. The Lesbian Review praised Craden’s performance in glowing terms, Tantor’s own page leads with that line, and LezReviewBooks gave the audio 4.5 stars: four for the story, five for the narration. That reviewer had read the book years earlier and found it just okay, then loved it on audio. That’s a useful tip if the page version doesn’t grab you. StoryGraph has it at 3.82 across 285 reviews, and its readers tag it lighthearted far more than anything else.

Abby Craden narrates the Tantor edition, which runs 5 hours and 42 minutes and came out at the end of 2019.

Prefer audio? Listen to No Strings on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The banter is the thing people name most, followed closely by the chemistry and the setting. “Small town” and “low angst” keep coming up, and so does the narration: a large share of the recent reviews are from listeners, and almost all of them mention Craden by name. Several readers liked that it’s a Gerri Hill without much danger, just two likeable women and a cute dog. On Goodreads, 76 percent of ratings are four or five stars, and only 4 percent are one or two.

What readers argue about and complain about: First, the plot outside the romance. A sheriff and a forest ranger in the mountains sounds like a setup for action, and readers who expected some were let down; the cases are minor and slow. Second, the start of the arrangement. Readers who like a long build felt the hookup happens before you’ve had time to want it, which takes some yearning out of the story. Third, loose threads: one reviewer listed an ex who appears and vanishes and subplots that lead nowhere, and another thought the drama late on could have been solved with one honest conversation. The real split is about pace. Some call it a perfect gentle read; a few say they skimmed.

The standalone question worth asking first: It’s a complete standalone with a happy ending, and you don’t need anything else to enjoy it. If you like Hill’s outdoorsy small-town mode, Hunter’s Way is a good next stop, and listeners point out that Reese and Morgan return as secondary characters in Snow Falls.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is No Strings a standalone?

Yes. It’s a complete standalone with a happy ending. Reese and Morgan reportedly appear again as side characters in Gerri Hill’s Snow Falls, but you don’t need it.

How spicy is No Strings?

About a 4 out of 5. Readers describe it as explicit, frequent and early, and one calls it the steamiest Gerri Hill she has read.

Is No Strings a slow burn?

Not physically. The two women start sleeping together early in the book, and the slow part is the emotional side, as they figure out the arrangement means more than either admits.

Is there an audiobook of No Strings?

Yes. Abby Craden narrates the Tantor edition, which runs 5 hours and 42 minutes. Many readers say the audio is the best way to experience it.

Is there much police action in No Strings?

Not much. This is the most common complaint in the reviews: the sheriff and ranger jobs give the book texture, but the cases are minor and the focus stays on the romance.

If You Loved No Strings, Read These Next

For more Gerri Hill in the same mountain mood, try Hunter’s Way, which pairs an outdoors setting with a stronger mystery thread. If it’s the casual-that-isn’t setup you love, A Little Kissing Between Friends runs the same trope at similar heat. And if you liked the forced closeness more than the sex, The Roommate Arrangement is a gentler, lower-heat take on two women sharing space. There’s more on our friends with benefits lesbian romance books list, and every review we’ve written lives under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

No Strings sets out to be a warm winter romance about two women who swear they won’t fall in love, and it mostly succeeds. The banter is lively, the chemistry is real, and the mountain town is a lovely place to spend a few hundred pages. The police plot is thin, the hookup comes before the longing, and a few loose ends never get tied up. It’s worth it if you want comfort, heat and good company, and especially worth it on audio. Check No Strings on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, No Strings ranks as a classic Bella-era small-town romance. It’s warm, funny and genuinely sexy, held back by a plot that barely exists outside the couple. Read it for the banter and the winter, not for the badge.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ 4.09 average across about 2,455 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 76% of ratings are four or five stars
  • ✓ StoryGraph lands lower at 3.82
  • ✓ Hill fans call the plot thin

Romance ★★★★☆ 4.1/5

  • ✓ Banter builds the bond before the bed
  • ✓ A bond forms that neither wanted
  • ✓ Emotional slow burn under a fast start
  • ✓ Some missed yearning before the hookup

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Reese and Morgan are easy to like
  • ✓ Townspeople praised as warm and quirky
  • ✓ A very good dog, per the publisher
  • ✓ Ex and subplots left underused

Writing ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

  • ✓ Dialogue flows naturally, per reviewers
  • ✓ Nature writing is a Hill strength
  • ✓ Reads as current despite 2009 date
  • ✓ Middle coasts and some skimmed

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ Low angst is the point for many
  • ✓ Fear of the end date gives stakes
  • ✓ Late drama solvable by one conversation
  • ✓ Few readers call it moving

Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Readers call it explicit and frequent
  • ✓ Steamiest Hill for at least one fan
  • ✓ Starts early, not a slow burn
  • ✓ One early encounter read badly

Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Happy ending, by reader consensus
  • ✓ Standalone with nothing left hanging
  • ✓ Couple returns in Snow Falls
  • ✓ Resolution comes easily

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ Comfort read for a winter weekend
  • ✓ Abby Craden audio rewards a relisten
  • ✓ Several reviewers have reread it
  • ✓ Light plot gives little new second time

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment