Meeting Millie Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Meeting Millie by Clare Ashton book cover book cover

Verdict: A beloved, deeply felt friends-to-lovers slow burn set in Oxford: a geeky lesbian lawyer and the charismatic straight best friend she lost at university meet again ten years later. Many readers call it the friends-to-lovers book they measure all others against; others found the one-sided pining exhausting and the chemistry unconvincing. Best for: Readers … Read more

Every Step She Takes Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Every Step She Takes by Alison Cochrun book cover book cover

Verdict: A warm, funny and heartfelt late coming-out romance on Portugal’s Camino de Santiago, with a hilarious opening and a vivid, found-family walking tour. Most readers loved it; a sizeable minority felt the romance lacked spark next to Cochrun’s earlier books, or tired of the confident-lesbian-teaches-baby-gay setup. Best for: Readers who love travel romances and … Read more

Astrid Parker Doesn’t Fail Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Astrid Parker Doesn't Fail by Ashley Herring Blake book cover book cover

Verdict: A hugely popular, often funny and tender bisexual-awakening romcom: uptight designer Astrid Parker and reluctant carpenter Jordan Everwood clash over a televised inn renovation and fall for each other. Fans love finally getting inside Astrid’s head; plenty of readers, especially fans of book one, found the chemistry thin and the plot underpowered. Best for: … Read more

Underwater Vibes Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Underwater Vibes by Mickey Brent book cover book cover

Verdict: An unusual, introspective debut about a woman’s late awakening in the swimming pool — refreshing to readers tired of formula, but most found the writing hard to warm to, the romance thin and the ending premature. Best for: Readers who want a quiet, literary-leaning self-discovery story with a European setting. Heat level: Low Rating: … Read more

Learning to Fall Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Learning to Fall by Peach Morris book cover

Verdict: A warm, heartfelt coming-of-age debut about a young carer finding herself — and a found family — in roller derby. Readers love the representation and emotional honesty; many warn it is not the sapphic romance it is marketed as. Best for: Readers who want a queer found-family story with a sports setting and a … Read more

All’s Fair in Love and Field Hockey Review: Is It Worth Reading?

All’s Fair in Love and Field Hockey by Kit Rosewater book cover

Verdict: A YA rivals-to-lovers romance with a strong emotional core about grief and a mother’s legacy, but it splits readers sharply. Fans cried and loved the coming-of-age arc; critics found the romance rushed, the field hockey thin and several elements underdeveloped. Best for: YA readers who want a queer awakening story wrapped in grief and … Read more

Running Home to You Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Running Home to You by Samantha Saldivar book cover

Verdict: An ambitious, deeply emotional softball love story spanning a decade, and one of the most passionately reviewed books we have covered. Readers call it remarkable and beautifully written; some found it too heavy, too long, or more character study than romance. Best for: Readers who want sweeping, yearning, messy sapphic angst with a hard-won … Read more

Finding a Keeper Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Finding a Keeper by Nicole Pyland book cover

Verdict: A tender, emotional best-friends-to-lovers slow burn set on a college soccer team, with some of the most convincing football writing in sapphic romance and a real weight of grief underneath. Readers love Sloan and Marley; the main quibble is an ending some found less than fully satisfying. Best for: Readers who want a new-adult … Read more

On Her Terms Review: Is It Worth Reading?

On Her Terms by Amy Spalding book cover

Is On Her Terms by Amy Spalding worth reading? Our review of the funny LA fake-dating romance with a 36-year-old bisexual heroine — and the love interest readers argue about.

When Dreams Change Review: Is It Worth Reading?

When Dreams Change by Violet Morley book cover

Is When Dreams Change by Violet Morley worth reading? Our review of the cosy Sitka softball-coach romance with a newly separated boss — low angst, big cast, thin plot.