Carol (The Price of Salt) Review | Patricia Highsmith | Is It Worth Reading?

This post contains affiliate links, including Amazon and Libro.fm. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Verdict: The novel that broke the punishment ending for lesbian fiction, written in prose almost nobody has matched since, undercut by a heroine who is acted upon for three hundred pages.

Best for: Readers who want mid-century atmosphere, yearning carried entirely by restraint, and a piece of publishing history they can feel working, and who do not need the couple to be equals on the page.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5 — romance.io’s “glimpses and kisses”)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5 — a 4.02 Goodreads average across 88,746 ratings, with a dissent that is remarkably specific)

Tropes: Age difference, class difference, queer awakening, secret relationship, road trip, Christmas meeting, cold heroine, shy heroine, forbidden love, hopeful open ending.

The Price of Salt is Patricia Highsmith’s second novel, a standalone published in 1952 by Coward-McCann under the pseudonym Claire Morgan and reissued as Carol in 1990 under her own name, set between a Manhattan department store at Christmas and a long drive west through the Midwest, and built on the collision between Therese Belivet — nineteen, engaged to a man she does not want, working a toy counter she cannot stand — and Carol Aird, an elegant woman in her thirties who is mid-divorce and buys a doll.

It holds a 4.02 average across 88,746 Goodreads ratings and a 3.96 across 18,822 StoryGraph reviews, and its 1953 pulp paperback sold close to a million copies. The averages sit on top of a split that is unusually well articulated: readers either find the restraint devastating or find it inert, and the argument almost always lands on the same two characters. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.

What Is The Price of Salt About?

This is mid-century historical literary fiction now, though it was contemporary fiction when it was written, and that distinction matters more here than in almost any other book on this list. Highsmith was not reconstructing 1952 — she was living in it, publishing under a false name because she did not want to be labelled a lesbian novelist, in a market where the genre convention required the queer character to die, go mad, or marry a man. Everything the novel does with silence, indirection and legal threat is reportage rather than period colour.

Therese is introduced by absence: no family to speak of, a boyfriend she cannot make herself want, an ambition she has not started, and no vocabulary at all for what happens to her across a shop counter. Carol is introduced by what she assumes — that she can manage this, that she has time, that her lawyer and her husband will behave. The novel runs in close third person on Therese and never leaves her, and that single restricted viewpoint is the source of both its power and its most common complaint: you never once get inside Carol.

What Makes This Mid-Century Sapphic Classic Work

• The prose: The most-praised element by a distance and the one thing no reviewer on any side disputes. Readers describe it as cold water; Highsmith writes sensation with the precision she usually reserved for menace.
• The withholding: The erotic charge is carried almost entirely by gaze and proximity. romance.io rates the heat at 1/5 and the book is still one of the most charged on this list, which is a genuine technical achievement.
• The stakes are legal, not emotional: A private detective, a recording device and a custody hearing do the work that a jealous rival would do in a lesser novel. It is why the middle third feels like surveillance.
• 1950s New York: 83% of StoryGraph readers mark the book emotional and 56% reflective, and much of that is atmosphere — the store, the apartment, the diners on the way west.
• The ending, in context: Highsmith’s own 1989 afterword says plainly that before this book queer characters in American novels had to pay for it. Readers who know that history report the last twenty pages hitting far harder.

Book Synopsis

Therese Belivet is nineteen, temping through Christmas on the toy floor of a Manhattan department store, and quietly certain that her life has not started. She has a boyfriend, Richard, who wants to take her to Europe and marry her. She has an ambition to design sets that she has told almost nobody about. Mostly she has the counter, the crowds and the noise.

Then a woman in a fur coat comes to buy a doll for her daughter, gives her name and address for the delivery, and leaves. Therese sends her a Christmas card. Carol Aird writes back. What starts as lunch becomes an afternoon, then a weekend at a house in New Jersey, then an arrangement neither of them describes out loud — while Carol’s divorce grinds on and her husband’s lawyers make it very clear what kind of mother they intend to prove she is.

When Carol proposes a drive west with no particular destination, it reads like escape. The question the novel spends its second half on is who is really travelling with them, what it will cost Carol to keep going, and whether a nineteen-year-old who has never chosen anything can survive being chosen.

My Review

Sentence for sentence this is the best-written book on our sapphic fiction list, and it is not close. Highsmith brings the same instrument she used for suspense — the flat, exact registration of physical detail — and points it at wanting somebody. The famous scene is not a sex scene; it is a woman at a counter noticing a coat. That the novel generates that much heat at a 1/5 rating on romance.io tells you how much of the erotic work is being done by withholding.

The second strength is that the threat is procedural. Most novels about a love affair under pressure supply a villain; this one supplies a lawyer. The detective in the next motel room, the recording made through a wall, the custody arrangement waiting at the end of it — that is what closes around these two women, and it is far more frightening than any confrontation because there is nothing to argue with. StoryGraph’s readers register it: stalking sits in the graphic tier of the community content warnings, above anything sexual.

Where it struggles is Therese, and this is the dominant complaint rather than my own impatience. Readers describe her as passive, immature, and closer to fixated than in love, and the mechanism is structural: the novel is locked to her viewpoint at the exact age when she has no interiority to spare, so for long stretches she is receiving a relationship rather than participating in one. That feeds a second problem the three-star reviews return to — because we never enter Carol, her withholding reads to a lot of readers as coldness rather than mystique, and Smart Bitches put it precisely when it called the book constrained by Carol’s enigmatic quality. Stack the road trip’s deliberate slowness on top (42% of StoryGraph readers call the pace slow against 7% who call it fast) and you have the shape of nearly every critical review.

The expectation worth resetting is the film. Todd Haynes’s 2015 Carol gives Cate Blanchett’s Carol a visible interior and rebalances the two women into something like equals; the novel deliberately does not. If you arrived from the film expecting that dynamic, calibrate — the book is one woman watching another and guessing. If you have heard this described as the first lesbian novel with a happy ending, calibrate slightly the other way too: it ends with a reunion, not a resolution, and readers regularly note that it is more open than its reputation suggests.

My honest note: A landmark that is also genuinely great prose, carried by a narrator who spends most of the book being carried. If you read for interiority and control, Therese will frustrate you; if you read for atmosphere, restraint and the exact texture of wanting something you have not been given words for, very little else compares.

Element	In The Price of Salt
Central relationship	Therese Belivet & Carol Aird — a nineteen-year-old shopgirl and a woman in her thirties mid-divorce
Core tropes	Age difference, class difference, queer awakening, secret relationship, road trip, forbidden love
Setting	Manhattan and suburban New Jersey at Christmas, then a drive west through the Midwest, early 1950s
Heat level	1/5 — romance.io’s “glimpses and kisses”
Series	Standalone — complete, nothing further required
Content notes	Period homophobia and lesbophobia, surveillance and stalking, custody threatened on grounds of sexuality, coercive divorce proceedings, heavy drinking, suicidal ideation, a significant age and power imbalance

How Spicy Is The Price of Salt?

A 1/5. romance.io catalogues it as “glimpses and kisses”, and StoryGraph’s community warnings put sexual content in the minor tier, below alcohol and well below stalking. There is one consummation and it is handled in a few restrained sentences — the 1953 paperback carried a New York Times line praising the book for handling explosive material with sincerity and good taste, which was accurate then and is still the best description of the ration now.

The element worth flagging in advance is the age gap. Therese is nineteen and Carol is in her thirties, with money, a car and a marriage behind her, and StoryGraph readers log an adult/minor relationship tag at the minor tier that reflects how unevenly matched the two are rather than anything illegal. No reviewer flags anything beyond that. For the same restrained band on this site, This Is How You Lose the Time War and The Jasmine Throne sit at the same 1/5 — different genres entirely, same principle, where the charge is all anticipation.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you read for prose above plot, you want mid-century atmosphere rendered by someone who was there, you find restraint more erotic than description, and you are interested in the book as a hinge in publishing history.

You may want to skip it if: a passive protagonist frustrates you, you need both halves of a couple to be legible, slow middles lose you, or you want the equal partnership the 2015 film supplies and the novel does not.

In short: the most beautifully written book on this list, told by its least assertive narrator.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (August 2026)

Seventy-four years after publication this book has two distinct readerships arguing past each other, and it is worth knowing which one you are joining. The first arrived through Todd Haynes’s 2015 film — six Academy Award nominations and no wins, famously passed over for Best Picture, with the Queer Palm and a shared Best Actress prize at Cannes — and reads the novel expecting Blanchett’s Carol. The second arrived through queer literary history and reads it as the book that refused the punishment ending. There is no current viral moment, no anniversary push and no new adaptation; what drives the 88,746 Goodreads ratings is a steady stream of readers working through canon lists, and the reviews split accordingly.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The prose comes first and comes up most, described as clean, cold and exact, and it is the one thing even the one-star reviews concede. Second is atmosphere, with readers using words like dreamlike and claustrophobic for the same pages. Third is the yearning specifically — readers single out the accuracy of uncertainty, jealousy and not-knowing rather than any romantic beat. Fourth is the historical weight: Highsmith’s own afterword, in which she lists the wrist-cutting and the swimming pools that queer characters were required to end in, converts a lot of readers who were lukewarm until they understood what the ending was refusing. Fifth is the final twenty pages, which come up again and again as the moment the book pays out. The minority view that cuts against the main complaint is worth naming: a real contingent argues Therese’s passivity is the entire subject, that a nineteen-year-old with no language for herself would not be a match for Carol, and that reading her as a weak character is reading the novel as if it were about two adults.

What readers argue about and complain about: Therese, above everything. The specific charge is not that she is unlikeable but that she is inert — devoted rather than active, and fixated on a woman she barely knows — and it shows up in review after review. The second theme is Carol, and it interacts with the first: because the novel never enters her viewpoint, her withholding reads to many as selfishness, and a substantial number of readers finish the book unconvinced she was worth it. StoryGraph puts a number on that discomfort — only 47% call the characters loveable, with 36% choosing complicated, the lowest loveability score of any historical title on our list bar one. Third is pacing, concentrated in the road trip, where the external plot goes quiet and the novel becomes travelogue; 42% of StoryGraph readers call it slow. Fourth, and sharper than the others: emotional flatness. Readers who came expecting the heat of mid-century pulp report finding none of it, and the complaint is that the restraint tips into coldness. Fifth, least common but relevant if you have been sold on the ending: several readers describe it as ambiguous rather than happy. The genuine split is over whether the restraint is the achievement or the limitation, and there is no reconciling those two readings — the same pages produce both.

The standalone question worth asking first: It is a complete standalone and needs nothing else, and the edition question matters more than the sequel question here. The Price of Salt and Carol are the same novel; the 1990 Bloomsbury reissue put Highsmith’s name on it for the first time and added her afterword, which is worth having and is not in every edition. If it works for you, be careful about treating it as a doorway into Highsmith generally — her better-known books are the Ripley novels and Strangers on a Train, which share the prose and none of the tenderness, and readers who go straight from this to those regularly report whiplash.

The audiobook is narrated by Cassandra Campbell and runs 10 hours 37 minutes from Blackstone, published under the title Carol, and her flat, unhurried delivery suits a narrator who is not letting herself feel things out loud.

Prefer audio? Listen to Carol on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does The Price of Salt have a happy ending?

Hopeful rather than resolved. Carol loses custody of her daughter rather than give Therese up, and the final scene is a reunion across a restaurant rather than a settled future — which in 1952 was itself the radical act.

Are The Price of Salt and Carol the same book?

Yes. It was published as The Price of Salt in 1952 under the pseudonym Claire Morgan, and reissued as Carol by Bloomsbury in 1990 under Patricia Highsmith’s own name, with a new afterword by her.

How explicit is it?

A 1/5. romance.io files it under “glimpses and kisses” and StoryGraph logs sexual content only at the minor tier. There is one consummation, handled in a few sentences.

How close is the 2015 film to the book?

Close on plot, different in balance. Todd Haynes gives Carol an interior the novel withholds, which makes the film feel like a story about two women and the book feel like a story about one woman watching another. The film took six Oscar nominations and won none.

Is it based on a true story?

Partly. Highsmith worked a department-store Christmas job at Bloomingdale’s in 1948 and served a customer in a fur coat who became the seed for Carol; the plot around the divorce and the detective is invented.

Is there an audiobook?

Yes. Cassandra Campbell narrates the Blackstone edition at 10 hours 37 minutes, listed under the title Carol.

If You Loved The Price of Salt, Read These Next

Try Last Night at the Telegraph Club for the same decade from the other coast and the other side of the class line, with the same surveillance pressure; Fingersmith for a period romance where the obstacle is again legal machinery rather than feeling, at a higher heat; and Under the Udala Trees for a much later novel that ends on the same question — whether a partnership that has to stay quiet counts as freedom. More in Historical Lesbian Romance and across our Book Reviews.

Why It Made Our Lists

The Price of Salt is featured on our Best Lesbian Romance Books guide.

The Bottom Line

The Price of Salt set out to write a love affair between two women that did not end in a punishment, and three things carry it: prose of a precision almost nobody has matched in the genre since, a threat that is procedural rather than melodramatic, and an ending whose significance grows the more you know about what it was refusing. Three things hold it back: a narrator who is acted upon far more than she acts, a love interest kept so opaque that many readers finish unconvinced by her, and a middle third that goes deliberately quiet at the point most readers want acceleration. If you want the book that made the rest of this list possible, and you can read a heroine who is still becoming a person, it is essential. Check The Price of Salt on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

We rank The Price of Salt at 3.8/5 — a foundational novel and a superb piece of writing, told through the least assertive narrator on this list.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

• ✓ 4.02 average across 88,746 Goodreads ratings
• ✓ First major lesbian novel to refuse the punishment ending
• ✓ 1953 paperback sold close to a million copies
• ✓ 3.96 on StoryGraph, below its Goodreads average

Romance ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

• ✓ Yearning rendered with unusual accuracy
• ✓ The relationship is the plot, not a subplot
• ✓ Reunion ending was genre-breaking in 1952
• ✓ Smart Bitches calls it constrained by Carol’s opacity

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

• ✓ 75% of StoryGraph readers report strong development
• ✓ Therese’s uncertainty is period-accurate and specific
• ✓ Carol’s control is convincing from the outside
• ✓ Only 47% find the cast loveable, 36% say complicated

Writing ★★★★★ 4.5/5

• ✓ The single most-praised element in every review set
• ✓ Suspense-writer precision aimed at desire
• ✓ 1950s New York rendered from inside it
• ✓ Some readers find the restraint tips into coldness

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ 83% of StoryGraph readers mark it emotional
• ✓ Final twenty pages are the most-cited payoff
• ✓ Highsmith’s afterword reframes the whole book
• ✓ Recurring complaint of emotional flatness

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

• ✓ romance.io files it as glimpses and kisses
• ✓ StoryGraph logs sexual content at minor tier only
• ✓ One consummation, handled in a few sentences
• ✓ Charge is entirely anticipation, not description

Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5

• ✓ Both women alive, free and moving toward each other
• ✓ Carol pays a real, named price for it
• ✓ Historically decisive for the whole genre
• ✓ More open-ended than its reputation suggests

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

• ✓ Prose rewards rereading more than plot does
• ✓ A fixture on queer literary history syllabi
• ✓ Carol reads differently once you know the ending
• ✓ The road trip is slow going a second time

Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads participates in the Amazon Associates Program and the Libro.fm affiliate program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.