Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Updated on October 8, 2026

Verdict: A cosy sapphic Halloween-town rom-com with the most likeable setting I have read this year, undercut by a central romance that runs from strangers to soulmates inside a week.

Best for: Readers who choose books by season rather than by plot, and who want the autumn-cafe-and-witches atmosphere more than they want a love story that convinces.

Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — “Explicit open door”, in romance.io’s phrasing)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.5/5 — a 3.74 Goodreads average across 11,320 ratings, with a rushed romance as the single most repeated complaint)

Tropes: Small-town paranormal, dead ex-girlfriend as matchmaker, new girl in town, witch and human, dual first-person POV, cosy murder mystery, found family, forced proximity, opposites attract, seasonal romance.

Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist by Ali K. Mulford and K. Elle Morrison is the first book in the Maple Hollow series, a self-published cosy sapphic paranormal rom-com set in a small town where Halloween is not a decoration but a census, and where apothecary witch Jordyn gets drunk enough to conjure the ghost of her dead ex-girlfriend and then has to fall for somebody new with that ghost watching.

It carries a 3.74 average across 11,320 Goodreads ratings and 2,188 written reviews, which makes it roughly twelve times bigger than anything else Ali K. Mulford has published under that name — and, at the same time, the lowest-rated title in that catalogue. Those two facts sit next to each other for a reason, and the reviews split much harder than a 3.74 suggests: 60% of ratings are four or five stars, 37% are three or below, and the two camps are not arguing about the same book.

What Is Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist About?

This is a cosy paranormal romance first and a murder mystery second, and the ratio matters because a good number of readers arrive expecting the reverse. Maple Hollow is a permanent-autumn town in which witches, vampires, ghosts and ordinary humans share a high street, a cafe called the Witches Brew, and an apothecary. The magic is atmospheric rather than systematised — there are no rules to learn, no power hierarchy to track, and the book is not interested in supplying any.

The structure is dual first-person POV, alternating between Jordyn, who has spent three years not dealing with her ex-girlfriend’s death, and Harlow, who has moved to town to work in her sister’s cafe and assumed the spooky branding was a marketing gimmick. Lou, the conjured ghost, is the third leg of the book and the reason it works at all: she is snarky, she is not leaving, and she has decided that Jordyn dating again is her unfinished business. StoryGraph readers file the moods as lighthearted (81%) and funny (61%) before mysterious (53%), which is an accurate reading of what the book is actually doing.

What Makes This Cosy Sapphic Paranormal Romance Work

  • The town does the heavy lifting: “cozy” turns up in 712 Goodreads reviews and “vibes” in 430, and Maple Hollow is the thing readers name before they name either lead.
  • The pitch lands exactly as sold: the authors describe the book as “Stars Hollow meets Halloweentown”, and readers independently reach for those references — 175 reviews say Halloweentown, 108 say Gilmore.
  • Lou is the standout: the ghost ex is named in 138 reviews, and several readers say plainly that they cared more about her and the side cast than about the couple.
  • It is short and it moves: 280 pages, 58% of StoryGraph readers call the pace fast, and only 3% did not finish — unusually low, and the clearest evidence that even the unimpressed got to the end.
  • The characters are easy to like: 84% of StoryGraph readers answer yes to “loveable characters”, against 5% no, which is a wider margin than the overall rating would predict.

Book Synopsis

Jordyn runs the apothecary in Maple Hollow and has been quietly not coping since her girlfriend Lou died. Three years on, a night of heavy drinking and unsupervised magic produces a result she did not plan: Lou, fully present, fully audible, and entirely unwilling to move on until Jordyn does. The haunting is affectionate and relentless. Lou wants Jordyn dating, and Lou intends to supervise.

Harlow arrives in town the same week to take a job at her sister’s cafe. She expects a themed tourist trap. She finds vampires with opinions, a barista who levitates the milk, and a customer base that treats magic as infrastructure. Within days she has offended most of the town’s supernatural population, spilled something on someone important, and started planning her exit.

Then Jordyn asks her out. What follows is a courtship conducted under supervision — a witch who has not let herself want anything in three years, a newcomer who cannot decide whether to stay, and a dead woman narrating from the corner of the room. Meanwhile a death in Maple Hollow turns out not to have been an accident, and the town’s tidy autumn surface starts to show its seams.

My Review

The setting is the reason this book has 11,320 ratings, and it earns them. Maple Hollow is specific in a way cosy fantasy towns often are not: the cafe has a menu, the apothecary has stock, the vampires have jobs and grievances, and the seasonal furniture — pumpkin picking, spiced drinks, a town that runs on Halloween the way other towns run on tourism — is laid on thickly and without apology. Lou is the best thing in it. Making the dead ex a live, funny, interfering presence rather than a source of solemn flashback is the one genuinely clever structural decision here, and it is the decision readers respond to.

Pumpkin Spice and Poltergeist by Mulford and Morrison book cover

The second strength is control of length. At 280 pages and just under six hours on audio, this is a book you finish in two sittings, and the craft reason is that the authors do not stop for worldbuilding they have not earned. Nothing is explained. The magic simply operates, the mystery proceeds, and the reader is trusted to keep up. That is why StoryGraph’s did-not-finish rate is 3% — low enough to be worth stating, because plenty of books rated higher than this one lose more readers in the middle. It also explains why “editing” returns zero results in a search of all 2,188 Goodreads reviews. Whatever else is wrong here, the sentences are clean and the book was properly proofed, which is not the default for self-published sapphic romance.

Where it struggles is the romance, and this is not my objection — it is the dominant reader complaint by a distance. “Rushed” appears in 91 reviews, “cringey” in 73 and “cringe” in another 24, “cheesy” in 51, “chemistry” in 66, most of those noting its absence. The mechanism is simple: Jordyn and Harlow meet, and within what the text presents as about a week they are declaring permanent love, with no intervening period in which either of them is uncertain. Because the book is short and the mystery takes up a third of it, the relationship gets perhaps sixty pages of actual development, and readers who came for a romance notice. StoryGraph is blunter still: only 61% say the character development is strong, and 22% say outright that it is not, which is a heavy no-vote for a book where 84% like the characters. People like these two women. They do not believe them as a couple.

The expectation to reset is what “cosy mystery” means here. The murder plot is real, it occupies a serious share of the page count, and it is the weakest element: multiple readers describe it as half-baked, complain that the resolution is unearned, and note that motive and mechanism are never properly laid out. The book is marketed as a rom-com with a mystery in it and reads as a rom-com interrupted by one. If you are here for the atmosphere and the ghost, treat the murder as connective tissue and you will have a good time. If you read cosy mysteries as mysteries — clues, suspects, a fair solution — this will annoy you by the last third, and you should skip it rather than argue with it.

My honest note: A five-star setting and a two-star love story, averaged out by a ghost who deserves her own book. If you buy paranormal romance for the vibe, this is one of the better autumn purchases on the sapphic shelf; if you buy it for the couple, spend the money elsewhere.

ElementIn Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist
Central relationshipJordyn & Harlow — apothecary witch and human newcomer, chaperoned by Jordyn’s dead ex-girlfriend Lou
Core tropesSmall-town paranormal, dead ex as matchmaker, new girl in town, witch and human, dual first-person POV, cosy murder mystery
SettingMaple Hollow — a permanent-autumn town where witches, vampires, ghosts and humans share a high street
Heat level4/5 — “Explicit open door” per romance.io; a small number of scenes, weighted to the back half
SeriesMaple Hollow book 1 — complete arc, HEA, two epilogues; books 2 and 3 follow new couples
Content notesGraphic sexual content, death and murder; moderate car accident, grief and violence; minor alcohol, alcoholism and cursing (StoryGraph community warnings)

How Spicy Is Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist?

A 4/5. romance.io places it in its “Explicit open door” band, one below the top rung it reserves for books where the sex is both graphic and constant, and readers corroborate that placement without much argument — “spicy” turns up in 93 Goodreads reviews, “fade to black” in none, and several readers use the phrase “decent spice” as a consolation in otherwise negative reviews. The scenes are on the page, described directly, and written for heat rather than for comedy.

The thing worth flagging in advance is frequency rather than explicitness. There are only a handful of scenes and they cluster in the back half, which is why a second heat tracker, Swooon, scores the same book 2/5 and describes it as staying on the tamer side. Both readings are defensible: when this book is explicit it is genuinely explicit, but you are getting a couple of encounters in 280 pages, not a spice-forward romance. Calibrate for a cosy first, a heat read second.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you read seasonally and want a Halloween book that commits, you want a paranormal small town with actual texture, you like a scene-stealing third character more than a slow burn, and you want something you can finish in a weekend.

You may want to skip it if: instalove ruins a romance for you, you need a mystery with a solution you could have reached yourself, you find quippy millennial dialogue and puns actively unpleasant, or you want a magic system with rules.

In short: an excellent setting and an unconvincing couple, sold in the same book at the same price.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)

There is no viral moment here, and the absences are the story. TikTok is named in three of 2,188 Goodreads reviews and I found no organic BookTok trend despite packaging built for one; there are no trade reviews; Jude in the Stars, LezReviewBooks and Bookish Sapphic have not covered it. What exists is a cluster of small ARC blogs publishing within weeks of each other, an I Heart SapphFic listing and author interview from October 2024, and one substantive specialist review — The Lesbrary, where Liv gave it four stars and called it “the cozy mystery/paranormal romance that I pictured”. That is an author-driven footprint, not a groundswell, which makes the 11,320 ratings worth explaining — the sequel has 2,606, and these authors’ other sapphic rom-coms sit between 187 and 850. Two things did it. Ali K. Mulford also writes as A.K. Mulford, whose Five Crowns of Okrith carries over 30,000 ratings on book one alone. And the title: The Pumpkin Spice Café reached 610,164 ratings and TikTok Shop Book of the Year, building a seasonal search term this book dropped straight into in July 2024, in Kindle Unlimited, with cover art in the same idiom. One two-star reviewer says she downloaded this by mistake instead of the Gilmore. The breakout is a distribution story, not a quality one.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The town, first and by a wide margin — “cozy” and “vibes” are the recurring words, appearing in 712 and 430 reviews respectively. Then Lou, named in 138 reviews and frequently described as the best character. Then the banter, praised in 73. The humour divides but has defenders, and StoryGraph’s 61% funny rating backs them. Cast diversity draws consistent credit at 75% yes, and Harlow’s ADHD representation is named by 14 reviewers, positively by most.

What readers argue about and complain about: The pace of the romance is the loudest complaint, and the mechanism is compression — a mystery subplot eats a third of a 280-page book, so the couple declare permanent love roughly a week after meeting, and 91 reviews call the result rushed. Second is tone: “cringey” returns 73 reviews, “cringe” another 24 and “cheesy” 51, aimed at the pun density and the quippy dialogue register, with one reviewer coining “millennialcore” for it. Third is the mystery, where the objection is structural rather than tonal — the solution arrives without the clues that would let a reader anticipate it. Fourth and quieter, the co-authorship: one reader notes the prose does not change between the two POVs, the only place the collaboration shows. Notably absent: editing complaints, zero hits across 2,188 reviews.

The series question everyone should ask first: nothing here to fear. Book one resolves completely — the murder is solved, Jordyn and Harlow get an HEA, and the book closes with two epilogues, which at least one reviewer thought was one too many. No review in the set mentions a cliffhanger. Maple Hollow is a standalone-first series: Curses & Cold Brew (September 2025, 3.94 across 2,606 ratings) follows Iris and Ramona, and Lycans & Lattes arrived in 2026 with another new pair. Cliffhanger-averse readers can stop after book one with nothing left dangling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist end on a cliffhanger?

No. The murder plot resolves, Jordyn and Harlow get a happily-ever-after, and the book closes with two epilogues. No reviewer in the sample I read mentions being left hanging, and the sequels follow different couples entirely.

How spicy is Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist?

A 4/5. romance.io rates it “Explicit open door”, and 93 Goodreads reviews use the word spicy while none mention a fade to black. The scenes are explicit but there are only a few, concentrated in the second half.

Do I need to read the Maple Hollow books in order?

No. Each book takes a new couple, so Curses & Cold Brew and Lycans & Lattes work without book one. Reading in order gets you the town and the recurring side cast in the right sequence, which is most of the pleasure of the series.

Is there an audiobook, and is it any good?

Yes — Nikki Grey, Bridget Bordeaux and Jake Bordeaux narrate, running roughly 5 hours 56 minutes, self-published through Rogue Fables and released in September 2024. Reviewers like the duet format but around ten of them flag inconsistent recording levels between narrators, with one voice noticeably quieter than the other.

Prefer audio? Listen to Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist on Libro.fm — the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.

Is it a romance or a cosy mystery?

A romance, decisively, with a mystery subplot that takes up more room than it earns. Readers who came for a whodunnit are the most disappointed group in the reviews, and the mystery’s resolution is the most criticised single element in the book.

If You Loved Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist, Read These Next

If the accidental-summoning engine is what worked, our spicy sapphic romantasy guide covers the open-door end of that shelf with heat rated separately from darkness. If you want the coffee-shop-and-vampires small-town texture with the paranormal played straight rather than for laughs, She Came for Blood keeps the found family and adds real stakes. And if the seasonal packaging is what pulled you in, The Pumpkin Spice Café by Laurie Gilmore is the book that created this market segment — it is a male-female romance, and it draws the identical complaint about a relationship that moves too fast. More in paranormal and fantasy lesbian romance and our book reviews.

The Bottom Line

Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist wants to be the sapphic Halloweentown rom-com the shelf did not have, and it half succeeds. The town is textured, the ghost is the best-written character in the book, and the 280 pages move fast enough that almost nobody puts it down. It is also built on a romance that skips its own middle, a mystery that resolves without earning it, and a joke register that a substantial minority of readers find actively grating. Whether that trade works depends entirely on what you are buying — and the reader who wants a fortnight of autumn atmosphere more than a convincing love story will get exactly what they came for. Check Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist on Amazon →

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Pumpkin Spice & Poltergeist ranks as a seasonal cosy sapphic paranormal — atmospheric, funny and genuinely easy to finish, held back by a romance that never earns its declaration, and best approached for the town and the ghost rather than the couple or the mystery.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ 3.74 average across 11,320 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ StoryGraph agrees at 3.69 from 4,188
  • ✓ Only 3% did-not-finish, unusually low
  • ✓ 37% of ratings are three stars or below

Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Lou as chaperone is a smart device
  • ✓ Early banter between the leads works
  • ✓ Open-door payoff satisfies most readers
  • ✓ 91 reviews call the romance rushed

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ 84% of StoryGraph readers found them loveable
  • ✓ Lou named in 138 Goodreads reviews
  • ✓ Harlow’s ADHD praised by 14 reviewers
  • ✓ 22% say character development is not strong

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Zero editing complaints across 2,188 reviews
  • ✓ Banter singled out in 73 reviews
  • ✓ Setting detail is concrete, not generic
  • ✓ Cringey in 73 reviews, cringe in 24

Emotional Impact ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5

  • ✓ Grief premise gives it a real spine
  • ✓ 63% say character flaws are central
  • ✓ Lou’s unfinished business genuinely lands
  • ✓ Only 33% register the book as emotional

Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5

  • ✓ romance.io band is “Explicit open door”
  • ✓ Spicy named in 93 Goodreads reviews
  • ✓ No reviewer reports a fade to black
  • ✓ Few scenes, clustered in the back half

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.9/5

  • ✓ Complete arc, HEA, no cliffhanger
  • ✓ Two epilogues close every thread
  • ✓ Sequels follow new couples entirely
  • ✓ Mystery solution is the most criticised element

Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Seasonal reread appeal every autumn
  • ✓ 280 pages, under six hours on audio
  • ✓ 12,946 readers still have it shelved
  • ✓ Audio levels uneven across three narrators

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Next read: find another witch romance between women, filtered by heat, mood and ending.

Leave a Comment