Updated on October 8, 2026
Verdict: A witch-and-vampire romantasy set in Edinburgh with unusually rich representation and a resurrection plot that works — and takes so much of the book that the romance ends up in the background.
Best for: Readers who want fantasy with real weight, who value masc/femme dynamics and South Asian and plus-size representation on the page, and who do not need the romance to be the engine.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — no romance.io entry; derived from the publisher’s spicy billing and reader reports of explicit content)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.9/5 — a 4.11 Goodreads average with a real marketing-versus-reality gap on how central the romance is)
Tropes: Enemies to lovers, witch and vampire, resurrection quest, grief, masc/femme dynamic, urban fantasy, found partnership, Edinburgh setting, series opener, dark humour.
Will It Hurt? is book one of Lily X’s Bitten By Magick series, a self-published sapphic witch and vampire romantasy published in July 2025, in which a wytch prone to chaos and a grieving, murderous vampyre have to work together on a spell that can bring someone back from the dead.
It holds a 4.11 average across 838 Goodreads ratings and 156 written reviews. The review-to-rating ratio here is high, which usually means an engaged readership rather than a passive one — and the reviews are detailed, specific and split along a line that has nothing to do with quality. Both halves of that split are worth understanding before you start.
What Is Will It Hurt? About?
The premise is a partnership forced by grief. A resurrection spell — the retraction spell, in the book’s own terms — is the object both women need, and the vampyre’s reason for needing it is the loss she is carrying. That gives the plot a real engine rather than a MacGuffin, and it is why the fantasy half of this book is as substantial as it is.
The setting is Edinburgh, and readers single it out. Urban fantasy usually defaults to American cities; putting witches and vampires into a city with that much actual gothic architecture gives the atmosphere something to work with, and reviewers describe the worldbuilding and the flow of the writing pulling them in together.
What Makes This Sapphic Witch and Vampire Romantasy Work
- Representation with specifics: Two women of colour as leads, plus masc/femme dynamics, South Asian representation and plus-size representation — a reader lists all four and calls it great representation across identities.
- Edinburgh: The worldbuilding is named as fantastic, and the atmosphere is credited alongside the prose rather than instead of it.
- It is funny: Surprisingly funny is a reader’s own verdict, on a book about raising the dead. The comedy is a genuine and unadvertised strength.
- Angst that lands: Readers report reading it in a day and single out the angst as the reason they could not stop.
- A grief-driven plot: The resurrection spell gives the fantasy half real motivation, which is why it takes over the book.
Book Synopsis
Edinburgh has always looked like a city where something could go wrong at any moment, and in this version of it something regularly does. Witches work here, vampires feed here, and the two communities have arrangements that mostly hold. Mostly.
The wytch at the centre of the book is chaos-prone in the way that people are when rules feel like suggestions. The vampyre is grieving, and grief has made her murderous rather than sad — a distinction the book takes seriously. They do not like each other, and the dislike is mutual, immediate and reasonably well founded on both sides.
What forces them together is the retraction spell: magic that can bring a person back from the dead, which is exactly the sort of thing a grieving vampyre will do anything to obtain and exactly the sort of thing a chaotic wytch might be able to cast. The work is long, dangerous and technical, and it requires them to be in each other’s company for the length of a book. The question is not whether hate turns to heat — the title is not subtle — but what raising the dead actually costs, and whether either of them is prepared to pay it.
My Review
The representation here is the most specific I have seen in this run and it deserves naming properly rather than as a bullet point. A reader lists it out: two women of colour as the main characters, masc/femme dynamics, South Asian representation, plus-size representation. That is four separate things a great many books in this genre do not do at all, done together, and done without the book becoming about doing them. In a category dominated by interchangeable pale protagonists, it is a genuine differentiator.
The second strength is atmosphere, and the Edinburgh setting is doing real work. Readers pair the worldbuilding with the flow of the writing when they praise it, which suggests the city is not scenery — it is shaping the prose. There is also a comic register that nobody advertises: surprisingly funny is a reader’s verdict on a book whose plot is about resurrecting a corpse, and that tonal range is harder to pull off than either mode alone.
The dominant criticism is a marketing-versus-reality gap, and the sharpest version of it comes from a reader who backed the author’s Kickstarter for early access — someone maximally predisposed to like this. Their objection is precise: although the book is marketed as romantasy, it leans much more into the fantasy side, because the retraction spell takes centre stage and the romance ends up feeling like a background element. That is not a complaint about the book being bad. It is a complaint about the book being sold as one thing and being another.
The expectation to reset follows directly. If you are choosing this because you want a romance with fantasy around it, calibrate hard — on our romance-weight scale this sits closer to fantasy-first than to balanced, and the enemies-to-lovers arc is the part most likely to feel underserved. If the fantasy is what you actually came for, relax: the plot has motivation, the city has texture, and 390 pages go somewhere.
My honest note: A good fantasy novel with a romance in it, sold as a romantasy. If you read the label literally you will be disappointed in a book that does not deserve it.
| Element | In Will It Hurt? |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | A chaotic wytch and a grieving, murderous vampyre — enemies forced into a working partnership |
| Core tropes | Enemies to lovers, witch and vampire, resurrection quest, grief, masc/femme dynamic, forced partnership |
| Setting | Edinburgh, with witch and vampire communities operating underneath it |
| Heat level | 4/5 — no romance.io entry; billed as spicy and reported explicit by readers |
| Series | Bitten By Magick book 1 — a series opener funded partly through Kickstarter; book two is Choke On My Name |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content, grief and bereavement, violence and killing, necromancy, blood |
How Spicy Is Will It Hurt?
A 4/5, and the sourcing is worth being explicit about. romance.io has no entry for this title, so there is no catalogued band to quote — which is itself informative, since it means the book is not being filed as mainstream adult romance. The publisher bills it as a spicy sapphic romantasy, readers confirm the explicit content is present and on the page, and nobody reports it as constant. Four is the honest read.
The thing worth flagging is proportion rather than content. Because the resurrection plot dominates, the intimate scenes arrive further apart than the marketing implies. Readers who want a high-frequency spice read will find the gaps long. For the same pairing at a higher and steadier heat, Green-Eyed Monster is the direct comparison, and Her Spell That Binds Me runs witches at top-band explicitness in a tighter setting.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want fantasy that actually has a plot, representation across identity matters to you, you like an atmospheric non-American urban fantasy setting, and you enjoy a book that can be funny about grim material.
You may want to skip it if: you need the romance to be the centre, you want the enemies-to-lovers arc to be the main event, high-frequency spice is the priority, or you dislike quest-shaped plots.
In short: a strong fantasy novel with excellent representation, mislabelled as a romance-first read.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
This book has an unusually engaged readership for its size: 156 written reviews against 838 ratings is close to one in five, where most indie titles run one in ten or worse. Part of that is how it was made — Lily X ran a Kickstarter for early access, which produces backers who feel invested and write about it, and there was an ARC round before the July 2025 release. There is no trade coverage, no Reddit footprint and no audiobook on Libro.fm. What the book has instead is a small readership that engaged with it seriously, which is why the reviews are more analytical than enthusiastic.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Representation, named with unusual specificity — two women of colour as leads, masc/femme dynamics, South Asian representation, plus-size representation, all listed together by a reader as great representation across identities. Second, Edinburgh: the worldbuilding is called fantastic and credited alongside the atmosphere and the flow of the writing, which is the sign of a setting doing structural work. Third, the angst, which readers say kept them reading in a single sitting. Fourth, and unadvertised, the humour — surprisingly funny is a direct quote about a book concerning necromancy, and the tonal range gets noticed. An ARC reader also singles out a small craft detail as the thing that hooked them: a crossword the characters are doing in the opening chapters.
What readers argue about and complain about: The genre label, above everything. The most detailed critical review comes from someone who backed the Kickstarter to get it early — about as invested as a reader can be — and their objection is that although it is marketed as romantasy it leans far more into fantasy, with the retraction spell taking centre stage and the romance reduced to a background element. They add that the enemies-to-lovers arc did not land for them either. That is a structural criticism, not a taste one, and it is echoed in softer form elsewhere. Second, pacing of the relationship: because the quest dominates, readers report the couple developing in the gaps rather than at the centre. The genuine split is over what the reader wanted. Readers who came for a fantasy novel with a sapphic relationship in it rate this highly. Readers who came for a romance rate it lower, and both are right about the book in front of them.
The series question everyone should ask first: Bitten By Magick is a new series and this is book one, from an author whose first book this appears to be for most of her readership. Nobody in the reviews reports a cliffhanger, and the resurrection plot resolves within the volume. The open question is continuation — a Kickstarter-funded debut series carries more delivery risk than a backlist author’s, and while book two is titled Choke On My Name, no release date for it has been confirmed. Borrow it as a complete fantasy novel rather than as an investment in a series.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Will It Hurt? more fantasy than romance?
Yes, and it is the most repeated criticism. A reader who backed the author’s Kickstarter says that although it is marketed as romantasy it leans far more into fantasy, with the resurrection spell taking centre stage and the romance becoming a background element. Read it as fantasy-first.
How spicy is Will It Hurt?
A 4/5. There is no romance.io entry to quote, so this comes from the publisher’s spicy billing and reader reports. The explicit content is present and on the page, but the quest plot means the scenes arrive further apart than the marketing implies.
Does Will It Hurt? have good representation?
Unusually so. Readers list two women of colour as leads, masc/femme dynamics, South Asian representation and plus-size representation — four things together that most books in this genre do not attempt at all.
Where is Will It Hurt? set?
Edinburgh, and readers single the setting out. The worldbuilding is described as fantastic and gets credited alongside the atmosphere and the prose rather than as background.
Does Will It Hurt? end on a cliffhanger?
No reader reports one, and the resurrection plot resolves within the book. It is book one of the Bitten By Magick series, so the world continues, but you get a complete story in a single borrow.
Is Will It Hurt? on Kindle Unlimited?
Yes. It carried the Kindle Unlimited badge on its Amazon listing when we checked in August 2026. Availability changes without notice, so confirm the badge before you borrow.
If You Loved Will It Hurt?, Read These Next
Three land closest. Her Spell That Binds Me by Luna Oblonsky runs witches at a higher heat with the romance firmly at the centre, which is the direct answer if the balance here disappointed you. Green-Eyed Monster by Rawnie Sabor pairs a witch with a demon across 573 pages and keeps the relationship central throughout. And Providence Girls by Morgan Dante is where to go if the literary register and the grief were what worked for you. For more in the same band, browse our sapphic romantasy on Kindle Unlimited guide or the full run of book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Will It Hurt? is a better book than its label. The Edinburgh setting does real structural work, the representation is specific and layered in a way this genre rarely manages, the grief driving the resurrection plot gives the fantasy genuine motivation, and it is funnier than a book about raising the dead has any right to be. Against that: it is marketed as romantasy and reads as fantasy-first, the enemies-to-lovers arc gets less room than the spell does, and readers who came for a romance say so. Worth borrowing if you want the fantasy half to be real. Check Will It Hurt? on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Will It Hurt? ranks as a strong indie sapphic urban fantasy — atmospheric, well represented and genuinely plotted, held back by a romance the marketing oversells, and best approached as a fantasy novel with a relationship in it.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ 4.11 average across 838 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ One in five readers wrote a review
- ✓ Marketed as romantasy, reads as fantasy-first
Romance ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5
- ✓ Enemies-to-lovers premise cleanly set up
- ✓ Grief gives the vampyre real motivation
- ✓ Hate-to-heat arc delivers on the title
- ✓ Romance sits in the background of the quest
Characters ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Two women of colour as leads
- ✓ Masc/femme dynamic written with specificity
- ✓ South Asian and plus-size representation on the page
- ✓ Relationship develops in the gaps between plot
Writing ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Edinburgh worldbuilding called fantastic
- ✓ Atmosphere and prose flow praised together
- ✓ Surprisingly funny about grim material
- ✓ Balance between quest and romance mishandled
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Grief drives the whole plot rather than decorating it
- ✓ Angst kept readers up in one sitting
- ✓ Resurrection stakes are personal, not abstract
- ✓ Emotional payoff attaches to the spell, not the couple
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Billed as spicy and confirmed explicit by readers
- ✓ Scenes on the page when they arrive
- ✓ No romance.io entry to corroborate a band
- ✓ Long gaps between scenes because of the quest
Ending ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Resurrection plot resolves inside the book
- ✓ No cliffhanger reported by readers
- ✓ Complete story in a single borrow
- ✓ Series continuation unproven for a new author
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Edinburgh atmosphere rewards a return
- ✓ Humour lands again on a second pass
- ✓ Kindle Unlimited makes re-borrowing free
- ✓ No audio edition for a second format
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
More like this: browse every sapphic witch romance we have verified, from cozy small-town witches to dark covens, with heat and endings labelled.
Find more like it: this book is on our list of sapphic urban fantasy books.
3 thoughts on “Will It Hurt? Review: Is It Worth Reading?”