This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A warm, funny butch/femme “cuffing season” romance with real chemistry, a scene-stealing five-year-old and co-writing so seamless readers can’t find the join, held back by a late-book breakup built on a secret that many readers found contrived.
Best for: Readers who love a relationship-of-convenience setup, a butch single mom and a kid who matters to the plot, and who can forgive one familiar third-act miscommunication and a lot of closed doors.
Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5 — derived: romance.io lists the book without a steam rating, and readers repeatedly say most love scenes fade to black)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5 — a 4.16 Goodreads average across 539 ratings, pulled down by the most repeated complaint in the reviews: a contrived late-book breakup)
Tropes: Relationship of convenience, fake dating with real feelings, butch/femme, single parent, holiday season romance, rules that get broken, found family, workplace pressure, third-act breakup, HEA.
A Convenient Arrangement by Aurora Rey and Jaime Clevenger is the first Mile High City Romance, a 2021 Bold Strokes Books contemporary lesbian romance set in Denver between the first cold snap and Valentine’s Day — and its collision is Jess Archer, a lifestyle journalist assigned to date someone for a season and write about it, meeting Cody Dawson, a tenure-track professor and single mom who needs a plus-one and has no intention of letting anyone near her son for keeps.
It holds a 4.16 average across 539 Goodreads ratings, 4.03 across 117 StoryGraph reviews and 4.7 stars from 218 Amazon ratings — a rare co-write between a Bold Strokes author and a Bella Books author that readers overwhelmingly say reads like one voice. Four in five Goodreads ratings are four or five stars. But underneath that friendly spread, two complaints recur almost word for word, and both are worth understanding before you start.
What Is A Convenient Arrangement About?
This is a contemporary fake-dating romance with a twist that almost every reviewer stops to explain: “cuffing,” the habit of pairing up for the cold months and splitting by spring. It isn’t a fauxmance in the usual sense — the two women really do date, with ground rules and an expiry date — which means the romance is less about hiding a lie from the world than about two people pretending to themselves that the end date will hold.
Jess is the sunny one: good with people, great with kids, and tired of writing fluff for an online lesbian magazine. Cody is the guarded one — divorced, raising five-year-old Ben largely alone, and quietly told by colleagues that a partner on her arm would not hurt her tenure case. Readers describe her as a butch mom; several call her a “hot butch,” and one says both authors specialise in emotionally vulnerable butches opposite strong femmes. romance.io’s tags list dual point of view, so both women’s doubts are on the page.
What Makes This Butch/Femme Fake-Dating Romance Work
- The cuffing premise: The most discussed thing in the reviews. Most readers had never heard the term, and several say it gives a tired relationship-of-convenience setup a genuinely fresh angle.
- Chemistry and banter: Readers across every star rating say the spark is there from the first meeting, and the dialogue is repeatedly singled out as natural, funny and easy.
- Ben: Cody’s son is praised by more reviewers than any other character. Watching Jess bond with him is, for many, the best part.
- Seamless co-writing: At least seven Goodreads reviewers say they could not tell where one author stopped and the other started — the most common compliment after chemistry.
- A butch single mom: One reader who came from Clevenger’s Three Reasons to Say Yes says they got another hot butch mom here, another loves butch women who are strong and maternal at once, and a third calls Cody a dreamboat.
Book Synopsis
Jess Archer’s editor at an online lesbian magazine wants a series on cuffing season, written from the inside. Jess is not convinced she is the cuffing type, but the assignment is a chance to write something with more weight than her usual fluff, and she can’t write it alone. She needs a partner willing to date her from autumn to Valentine’s Day, knowing every date may end up, suitably disguised, in her column.
Cody Dawson has her own reasons to answer the call. She is a professor on the tenure track, her life organised around her five-year-old son, and she has picked up the unwelcome message that the people deciding her future would be happier to see her settled. A woman who is fun, interesting and guaranteed to leave by spring sounds ideal. The two meet, like each other at once and write the rules down: plus-ones for work events, no pressure about sex, no drifting past the end date, and Ben told only that Jess is a friend.
The rules last about as long as you would expect. Jess turns out to be wonderful with Ben, the social calendar pushes them into more time together, and the interruptions of single parenthood keep getting between them at exactly the wrong moment. Holidays arrive, families get involved, and the column keeps coming out. As the season turns and the deadline they agreed to gets closer, both women have to decide whether this arrangement is still convenient at all — and whether either one is brave enough to say so first.
My Review
The premise is the best thing here, and the authors use it well. Cuffing gives a fake-dating romance a built-in clock, and it lets Rey and Clevenger skip the usual contortions: nobody is lying to a family or a boss, the relationship is real from the start, and the tension is entirely about whether the end date means anything. That is a cleaner engine than most fauxmances run on, and readers notice: again and again they call it a new spin on a trope they thought they knew.
The second strength is the family at the centre of it. Ben is not a plot device; the book is honest about how much a five-year-old rearranges an adult’s life, and Jess earns her place with him before she earns it with Cody. The co-writing is genuinely impressive too. Two authors from two publishers produced a book readers keep saying feels like one voice, with light, funny dialogue.
Where it struggles is the last stretch. This is not my personal gripe — it is the single most repeated criticism in the Goodreads reviews, raised by roughly a quarter of the thirty most visible reviewers. Two women who have communicated well for three quarters of the book suddenly stop, one withholds something she has no clear reason to hide, and a breakup follows around the 80–85% mark. Readers call it contrived, predictable and frustrating in characters in their thirties; the consolation, two say, is that it doesn’t last long. The second theme is heat, and it is the gap readers most want flagged.
That is the expectation to reset. Both authors are known for steam, and readers came in expecting it — five of the thirty reviews say the love scenes are mostly faded out, cut short or underwhelming, and others say the parenting interruptions are constant. If Rey and Clevenger’s names made you expect a scorcher, calibrate. If the kid made you worry about an explicit book with a child at its centre, relax: the closed doors are doing that work.
My honest note: A four-star premise and a four-star family, dragged toward three and a half by a black moment you can see coming. If contrived third-act miscommunication ruins a book for you, you’ll feel it here. If you can ride it out, this is one of the warmer holiday-season butch/femme romances around.
| Element | In A Convenient Arrangement |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Jess Archer & Cody Dawson — upbeat femme journalist and butch single-mom professor, as readers describe them; a seasonal arrangement turned serious |
| Core tropes | Relationship of convenience, fake dating with real feelings, butch/femme, single parent, holiday romance, third-act breakup |
| Setting | Denver, from autumn through the winter holidays to Valentine’s Day — a university campus, Jess’s family Thanksgiving and a lot of kid-friendly dates |
| Heat level | 3/5 — derived; love scenes happen, but readers say most fade to black |
| Series | Mile High City Romance book 1 — complete couple with an HEA; Love, Accidentally follows their friends |
| Content notes | Sexual content, abandonment, emotional abuse (past and present, per reader content warnings), injury, an absent ex-wife resurfacing |
How Spicy Is A Convenient Arrangement?
A 3/5, and it is a derived number. romance.io lists the book with seven ratings but no steam rating of its own, so the band comes from readers — and they are unusually specific. The two women do sleep together, and one audiobook reviewer says the book captures the butch/femme sexual dynamic both authors are known for. But five Goodreads reviewers say the scenes are mostly faded out, cut short or underwhelming, and several compare it unfavourably with Clevenger’s usual heat. A 2022 companion short story, Cuffed for Valentine’s Day, is billed by its own description as adding a little kink.
Nothing in the heat needs a warning. No reviewer I found flags consent questions, and the thing most likely to frustrate you is the opposite problem: the number of moments cut short by Ben. For contemporary romances in the same band, Butch Girls Can Fix Anything and Wooing the Farmer sit at the same 3/5.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you enjoy fake dating or a relationship with an end date, you want a butch mom and a child who is a real character, you like banter and low-key holiday warmth, and you’re curious what two favourite authors sound like writing together.
You may want to skip it if: a third-act breakup built on a withheld secret makes you throw books, you want the romance with fewer interruptions from a child, you came to these authors for explicit heat, or you need a plot that surprises you.
In short: a sweet, funny seasonal romance whose first three quarters are better than its black moment.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
There is no viral moment and nothing new pushing this book in 2026. Its readership came in at release through a NetGalley advance-copy push — a large share of the visible Goodreads reviews say they read an ARC from Bold Strokes — and through the authors’ existing fan bases, with several reviewers saying they requested it because they already read one author or both. I found no trade reviews, the Amazon editorial block carries only the authors’ biographies, and neither The Lesbian Review nor the Lesbrary reviewed it that I could find; Brian’s Book Blog reviewed the audiobook and gave it five stars. That audiobook is the other steady route in: Bold Strokes released it narrated by Kira Omans, running 9 hours 35 minutes, and one reviewer who listened says her voices were distinct and the performance improved the story.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The chemistry, first and most consistently — “chemistry” is the recurring word in the positive reviews, usually paired with praise for the dialogue. Then Ben: readers call him cute, adorable and the one who steals the show, and one parent of two five-year-olds says the interruptions and hesitations felt exactly right. Third, the collaboration — reviewer after reviewer says they couldn’t spot the seams. Brian’s Book Blog calls it “a really cute story about two driven women who made each other better,” and says the ending left him in happy tears. A strong friend group and Jess’s warm, noisy family round it out.
What readers argue about and complain about: The late conflict, above everything. Around eight of thirty visible Goodreads reviews call the breakup contrived, manufactured or signalled from a mile away, and at least one reviewer knocked off a full star for it specifically; the recurring frustration is that two grown women who communicated well suddenly stop. The heat is the second theme: five readers say too many scenes fade to black or fall flat, and several wanted more one-on-one time. Third: Ben divides readers more than the average suggests. Most love him, but three or four say he is too needy, too polished or too mature for five, and that the interruptions wore thin. Beyond that, a couple of readers found the middle slow, one found the plot predictable from page one, and one argues the column’s disguise would never have fooled the people it describes.
The standalone question worth asking first: It reads as a standalone. Jess and Cody’s story is complete, ends in an HEA with no cliffhanger, and a 2022 companion short story, Cuffed for Valentine’s Day (4.51 across 43 ratings), finds them together in a snowy cabin. The follow-up novel, Love, Accidentally (2021, Bella Books), switches to their friends Finn and Amelia, who are introduced here; it sits at 4.03 across 648 ratings — slightly lower on average but more widely read, so if the friend group was your favourite part, it is the natural next step.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is A Convenient Arrangement a butch/femme romance?
Readers read it that way. Several Goodreads reviewers call Cody a hot butch mom and describe the pairing as butch/femme, and one notes that both authors are known for vulnerable butches and strong femmes. The publisher’s description doesn’t use the labels itself.
How spicy is A Convenient Arrangement?
A 3/5 by our estimate. romance.io has no steam rating for it; the leads do sleep together, but five reviewers say the love scenes are mostly faded out, cut short or underwhelming, which surprised fans of both authors.
Does A Convenient Arrangement have a happy ending?
Yes. There is a late breakup around the 80–85% mark, but Jess and Cody end together with an HEA and no cliffhanger, and a companion short story shows them still together on Valentine’s Day.
Do I need to read it before Love, Accidentally?
No, but it helps. Love, Accidentally follows Finn and Amelia, who are introduced here as friends of the leads, and reviewers say each book can stand alone.
Is there an audiobook?
Yes. Bold Strokes Books released an audio edition narrated by Kira Omans, running 9 hours 35 minutes. Listeners mostly praise it, though one found the voicing of the less femme characters too masculine.
If You Loved A Convenient Arrangement, Read These Next
For another Clevenger butch/femme romance with a mom and her kids at the centre, Three Reasons to Say Yes is the closest match and runs hotter. If Rey’s half of the partnership is what you want more of, Summer’s Cove pairs a soft butch with a single-mom chef and an eight-year-old who steals every scene. And for a warm butch/femme romance at the same 3/5 heat about a single mother learning to let someone in, Butch Girls Can Fix Anything hits the same kind-hearted register.
For more in this register, browse our butch/femme lesbian romance guide or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
A Convenient Arrangement sets out to give fake dating a new clock, and for most of its length it runs beautifully. The chemistry is real, Ben makes the family feel lived-in rather than decorative, and two authors write as one. It also leans on a third-act secret a lot of readers saw through, closes more bedroom doors than its authors’ fans expected, and lets a five-year-old interrupt more than some readers could stand. If you want a cosy, funny holiday-season butch/femme romance and can forgive one familiar wobble near the end, it is worth the season. Check A Convenient Arrangement on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, A Convenient Arrangement ranks as a warm, well-made Bold Strokes holiday fauxmance — charming and genuinely funny, held back by a contrived black moment and muted heat, and best approached for the chemistry and the family rather than the steam or the plot.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 4.16 average across 539 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4.03 across 117 StoryGraph reviews
- ✓ 4.7 stars from 218 Amazon ratings
- ✓ Late breakup is the dominant complaint
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Chemistry praised across every star rating
- ✓ Cuffing gives the fauxmance a real clock
- ✓ Early ground rules and good communication
- ✓ Breakup at 80–85% feels contrived
Characters ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Ben is the most-loved character
- ✓ Cody read as a butch mom dreamboat
- ✓ Loveable characters: 100% on StoryGraph
- ✓ Some find Ben too mature for five
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Two authors, no visible seams
- ✓ Natural, funny dialogue repeatedly praised
- ✓ Lighthearted and funny moods lead StoryGraph
- ✓ Slow in places, two readers say
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Single parenthood rings true to parents
- ✓ Jess and Ben’s bond lands
- ✓ Ending moved one reviewer to tears
- ✓ Black moment signalled well in advance
Heat Level ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Intimacy becomes part of the arrangement
- ✓ Sexual tension readers call palpable
- ✓ Companion story promises a little kink
- ✓ Five readers flag fade-to-black or flat scenes
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ HEA for Jess and Cody
- ✓ No cliffhanger; complete couple arc
- ✓ Breakup is short-lived, readers say
- ✓ Reached via a withheld-secret miscommunication
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 9h35m Kira Omans audiobook
- ✓ Seasonal read for the winter holidays
- ✓ Companion novel and short story extend it
- ✓ Predictable plot limits the second pass
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.