This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A cosy, well-liked snowed-in butch/femme Christmas novella with an ice-queen surgeon and a golden-retriever carpenter, held back by a length that moves the romance faster than at least one reader could follow and a reader record too thin to prove much beyond “people enjoyed it.”
Best for: Readers who want a one-sitting holiday romance with a tattooed butch who fixes things and a guarded femme doctor who thaws, and who are happy to trade slow-burn development for warmth, heat and a guaranteed happy ending.
Heat level: ★★★★☆ (4/5 — derived from the author’s “steamy” billing and reader reports; romance.io has no steam band for it yet)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.9/5 — a 4.35 Goodreads average across 174 ratings, resting on only five written reviews)
Tropes: Butch/femme, snowed in, forced proximity, ice queen/golden retriever, opposites attract, city doctor meets small-town local, one unexpected night, Christmas romance, novella, guaranteed happy ending.
Fire and Frost by Emily Hayes is the third title in her self-published A Very Sapphic Christmas Collection, a 110-page contemporary lesbian romance set in the snowbound mountain town of Hawthorne Lake — and the collision at its centre is Dr. Nia South, a guarded city surgeon who came for one big operation and planned to leave again immediately, running into Soren Stevenson, the tattooed butch carpenter a blizzard leaves her stuck with.
It holds a 4.35 average across 174 Goodreads ratings and 4.5 stars across 277 Amazon ratings, it is the best-rated of the collection’s four books on Goodreads, and it also ships inside Hayes’s 13-story Naughty and Nice Christmas box set. What it does not have is much written discourse: five Goodreads reviews, a handful of short Amazon ones, and no blog coverage I could find. That gap between numbers and words is worth understanding before you start.
What Is Fire and Frost About?
Fire and Frost is a small-town holiday novella built on the oldest winter-romance machine there is: weather closes the roads, weather closes the airport, and two women who would otherwise have passed each other in a week are made to share the same four walls. Goodreads readers shelve it as lesbian romance, contemporary, Christmas and forced proximity, and that is exactly what it is.
Nia is defined by what she has shut down. The author’s own copy calls her heartbroken and icy, a woman whose life fell apart and who has not wanted anyone since; she arrives in Hawthorne Lake intending to operate, avoid her feelings and go home. Soren is defined by what she gives away — a local who repairs everything and everyone, and who meets the ice queen with an open, golden-retriever warmth. Reviewers don’t say much about how the point of view is handled, so what the book buys you here is the dynamic rather than the structure: frost meeting fire, as the title promises.
What Makes This Butch/Femme Holiday Romance Work
- The opposites-attract pairing: One reader sums Nia and Soren up as opposites in almost every way, and reviewers agree the sparks between them are the point. The ice-queen/golden-retriever billing is what the book delivers.
- Butch/femme on purpose: The book is sold as butch/femme, and at least one reviewer calls it plainly a butch/femme holiday story. It sits comfortably on our butch/femme reading list.
- Heat with heart: “Heat and heart” is how one reader sums it up, and others independently mention a good amount of heat alongside emotional depth. The steam is present without swallowing the story.
- Easy, warm reading: Reviewers call it easy and heartwarming, a lazy-afternoon book. One says she smiled through much of it.
- The collection’s best numbers: At 4.35 on Goodreads it edges out all three of its siblings, which range from 4.2 to 4.3.
Book Synopsis
Nia South does not do small towns, and she does not do feelings. She is a surgeon from the city, brought to Hawthorne Lake for a single major operation, and her plan is simple: do the work, keep her head down, and be gone before anyone in this snow-globe mountain town can get close enough to ask how she is. Whatever broke her life apart is not up for discussion, least of all with herself.
The weather has other ideas. A storm rolls in hard enough to close the roads and ground the flights, and Nia finds herself stuck in a cosy local bar with no exit and no schedule to hide behind. Also stuck there is Soren Stevenson — tattooed, easy-smiling, the carpenter half the town calls when anything breaks. Soren is everything Nia has taught herself not to trust: open, cheerful, entirely unbothered by an ice queen’s frost, and very good with her hands.
As the snow keeps falling, what begins as forced company turns into conversation, and conversation turns into something warmer than Nia has allowed herself in a long time. One unplanned night is enough to prove that she can still want someone. The harder question is what happens when the roads reopen — whether a woman who came to Hawthorne Lake to fix one patient and leave can let herself be fixed in return, and whether a storm romance can survive the thaw.
My Review
The pairing is what works, and it works because it is so clean. An icy surgeon who has closed herself off and a warm butch who repairs things for a living is a dynamic that needs no explanation, and Hayes leans into it without apology. One reviewer puts it as two women who are opposites in almost every way, with sparks flying between them — and that is exactly what the cover copy promised.
The second strength is tone. This is a comfort read, and the reviews say so repeatedly: easy, sweet, heartwarming, a lazy-afternoon book with likeable leads and very little angst. One reader calls Hayes a wordsmith and the book very well written; another calls it one of Emily’s better stories, which, from a reader who clearly knows the backlist, is worth more than a generic five stars. The heat is folded into that warmth rather than sitting on top of it, and “heat and heart” is the phrase that best captures what reviewers liked.
Where it struggles is scale, and the honest version of that is: we don’t have much to go on. At 110 pages, the book has to move a guarded woman from frost to fire across a single storm, and the only critical review on Goodreads — a two-star — says the relationship moved forward too quickly. That is one voice, not a theme, but it is the complaint the format predicts, and the 13% of Goodreads ratings parked at three stars suggest a quieter group who found it pleasant rather than memorable. The bigger limitation is evidence. Most of the written reviews run two or three sentences, StoryGraph has no community reviews at all, and romance.io has two ratings and no steam band. A 4.35 on 174 ratings is a solid number, but it is a number without much of an argument behind it.
One expectation to reset: the “heartbroken” surgeon in the blurb might suggest a grief-heavy book. Readers do mention emotional depth, but they also say there is very little angst and not too many complications. If heavy backstory is what drew you, calibrate; if you wanted a gentle, warm storm romance, relax.
My honest note: A well-made holiday comfort novella that does exactly what its title promises and very little it doesn’t. If you need a romance to earn every step, the length will leave you short. If you want an ice queen thawing in front of a butch who fixes things, this is a satisfying evening.
| Element | In Fire and Frost |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Soren Stevenson & Dr. Nia South — butch small-town carpenter and femme city surgeon, opposites attract |
| Core tropes | Butch/femme, snowed in, forced proximity, ice queen/golden retriever, city meets small town, Christmas |
| Setting | Hawthorne Lake — a snowbound mountain town cut off by a blizzard at Christmas |
| Heat level | 4/5 — steamy, derived from author billing and reader reports (no romance.io band) |
| Series | A Very Sapphic Christmas Collection book 3 of 4 — standalone couple; also in the Naughty and Nice box set |
| Content notes | Explicit sexual content, the heroine’s unspecified past heartbreak, a severe winter storm; no crowd-sourced warnings exist yet on StoryGraph |
How Spicy Is Fire and Frost?
I’m calling it a 4/5, and I want to be clear about where that number comes from. romance.io lists the book but has not assigned it a steam band yet — it carries just two ratings there — so this is derived rather than quoted. The author bills it as a “steamy” romance full of high-spark winter heat, the box set it appears in promises “super steamy” stories, and readers corroborate that: one mentions “a good amount of heat,” another “some steamy moments,” a third frames the whole book as heat and heart. That puts it in the open-door range, with the one unexpected night the blurb advertises at its centre.
The caveat worth knowing is not about content but about proportion. One reviewer calls the book sweet overall with steamy moments, which suggests the heat is a feature rather than the engine. No reviewer I found flags any specific kink or consent concern. For butch-led contemporary romance in the same heat band, Touch the Sky and Stud Like Her sit at 4/5 too.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want a butch/femme romance you can finish in one sitting, you love the ice-queen-meets-golden-retriever dynamic, you want real heat in your holiday reading, and you value a cosy, low-angst story with a guaranteed happy ending.
You may want to skip it if: you need a slow burn to believe in a couple, you want a book with deep, sustained emotional stakes, you prefer closed-door holiday romance, or you like to see a lot of reader discussion before you commit to a title.
In short: a warm, steamy storm romance that delivers its premise cleanly and asks you to accept that the thaw happens fast.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
There is no viral moment behind this book and no critical coverage — I found no blog, trade or review-site write-ups for it at all. What it has is steady, quiet approval from Emily Hayes’s existing readership. It was published on 16 December 2025 as the third of four books in the collection, and it also went into the 13-story Naughty and Nice box set, which carries a 4.6 on Amazon across 77 ratings — a second route in for readers who bought the bundle rather than the single. Since then it has gathered 174 Goodreads ratings and 277 on Amazon. The distribution is strongly positive: 82% of Goodreads ratings are four or five stars, 13% sit at three and only eight readers went lower. On Amazon, 89% rate it four or five. But only five people wrote a Goodreads review, and StoryGraph shows no community reviews on either of its two entries, so everything below comes from a small pool of short reviews. Treat the themes as indications, not consensus.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The characters, first — “likable” and “well liked” both turn up, and several readers say they loved the pair. Second, the combination of heat and warmth: reviewers mention a good amount of heat and emotional depth in the same breath, and one sums the whole book up as heat and heart. Third, the ease of it. “Easy” comes up repeatedly — an easy Christmas read, easy to read without too many complications — and readers mean it as praise. One reviewer credits Hayes as a genuinely good writer, and another, clearly a regular, ranks it among the author’s better stories.
What readers argue about and complain about: Pace, and only just. The sole critical Goodreads review, at two stars, says the relationship moves forward too quickly, which is the complaint a 110-page romance built around a single storm invites. That is one reader, not a pattern, and no one else echoes it in writing. Beyond that there is simply no argument on record: nobody disputes the ending, the heat or the characterisation, and no one flags a content problem.
The standalone question worth asking first: Fire and Frost stands alone. It is book three of A Very Sapphic Christmas Collection, but the first book, a fake-dating CEO romance, follows a different couple entirely, and nothing here requires the others. Nia and Soren get their happy ending: the Naughty and Nice box set that includes this story promises guaranteed happy endings, and readers confirm this one lands. If you want more, the numbers make the collection a fair next step rather than a courtesy: The Christmas CEO (book 2) averages 4.3 across 175 Goodreads ratings, Her Holiday Arrangement (book 1) 4.2 across 403, and Christmas with the Ice Queen (book 4) 4.2 across 110. This one edges all three.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Fire and Frost a butch/femme romance?
Yes. The author markets it as butch/femme: Soren is a butch carpenter and Nia a femme surgeon. At least one reviewer describes it the same way, and it sits on our butch/femme list for that reason.
Does Fire and Frost have a happy ending?
Yes. The box set that includes it promises guaranteed happy endings, and readers confirm a satisfying, happy close for Nia and Soren. There is no cliffhanger.
How spicy is Fire and Frost?
About a 4/5. romance.io has not assigned it a steam band yet, but the author bills it as steamy and readers report a good amount of heat. It is warm first and spicy second.
Do I need to read the rest of A Very Sapphic Christmas Collection first?
No. The collection’s first book follows a different couple, and Fire and Frost reads as a standalone. It is also included in the Naughty and Nice box set if you want the other stories too.
How long is Fire and Frost?
It is a novella of about 110 pages on Kindle and 108 in paperback.
Is there an audiobook?
Not that I could find. Libro.fm does not stock one, and I found no audio edition of this title.
If You Loved Fire and Frost, Read These Next
For another butch/femme Christmas romance, Season of Love is the closest match in setting and mood, with a gentler, closed-door approach to the heat. If Emily Hayes’s voice is what worked for you, The Princess’s Bodyguard is another short, warm Hayes comfort read, with even more heat. And if the surgeon was your favourite half of the pair, Hayes’s Surgeon is a fast hospital romance built around one.
For more in this register, browse our butch/femme lesbian romance guide or the full Book Reviews collection.
The Bottom Line
Fire and Frost is a small holiday book that knows exactly what it is. The ice-queen-and-golden-retriever pairing is clean and charged, the butch/femme dynamic is deliberate, and the heat and warmth sit comfortably together. It is also short enough that the thaw happens fast, light on sustained emotional stakes, and backed by more ratings than reasons. Whether that trade works depends on what you want from a Christmas novella — but if you want a snowed-in butch/femme romance with real warmth and a guaranteed happy ending, it is worth the evening. Check Fire and Frost on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Fire and Frost ranks as a warm, steamy indie butch/femme holiday novella — cleanly executed and well liked, limited by its length and a thin review record, and best approached for the ice-queen thaw rather than for a slow-built romance arc.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ 4.35 average across 174 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 4.5 stars across 277 Amazon ratings
- ✓ Highest-rated of the four-book collection
- ✓ Only five written Goodreads reviews
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Ice queen/golden retriever sparks deliver
- ✓ Butch/femme dynamic written deliberately
- ✓ Sparks praised as delicious by one reader
- ✓ One reader found it moved too fast
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Likable leads, per several reviews
- ✓ Soren’s warmth anchors the book
- ✓ Nia’s thaw is the emotional arc
- ✓ Novella length limits supporting cast
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ One reader calls Hayes a wordsmith
- ✓ “Easy to read” recurs as praise
- ✓ Ranked among her better stories
- ✓ Too few reviews to judge craft deeply
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ Readers mention real emotional depth
- ✓ Heartbroken heroine gives it weight
- ✓ Called cute and heartwarming
- ✓ Very little angst, by readers’ account
Heat Level ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Billed as steamy by the author
- ✓ “A good amount of heat” per readers
- ✓ Blurb centres one unexpected night
- ✓ Derived — romance.io has no steam band
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Guaranteed happy ending delivered
- ✓ Standalone couple, no cliffhanger
- ✓ Called a satisfying holiday romance
- ✓ Storm-length arc resolves quickly
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ One-sitting length suits a yearly revisit
- ✓ One reader would read it any time of year
- ✓ Three sibling novellas share the season
- ✓ No audiobook for a second pass
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.