The Christmas Murder Game Review: Is It Worth Reading?
Alexandra Benedict’s snowbound Christmas puzzle mystery has a bisexual heroine and a clever twelve-day game, but almost no romance and a killer most readers guess early.
Alexandra Benedict’s snowbound Christmas puzzle mystery has a bisexual heroine and a clever twelve-day game, but almost no romance and a killer most readers guess early.
Verdict: A cosy, well-liked snowed-in butch/femme Christmas novella with an ice-queen surgeon and a golden-retriever carpenter, held back by a length that moves the romance faster than at least one reader could follow and a reader record too thin to prove much beyond “people enjoyed it.” Best for: Readers who want a one-sitting holiday romance … Read more
Verdict: A gentle, closed-door butch/femme short story about a newly out band mom and a butch orchestra director snowed in at a music competition, warm and easy to love but held back by a length that leaves readers wanting a whole book. Best for: Readers who want a low-angst romance between two women in their … Read more
Updated on October 8, 2026 Verdict: A snowed-in Minnesota romance with the most carefully handled grief writing on the sapphic contemporary shelf this year, let down by a third-act conflict a lot of readers found manufactured. Best for: Readers who want a widow’s story told properly inside a warm romance, who like forced proximity where … Read more
Updated on October 9, 2026 Verdict: A tense, well-researched hostage thriller with a slow-burn romance between a wounded police officer and the doctor who walks into danger to save her, held back by a romance that gets less room than the peril and trauma that heals suspiciously fast. Best for: Readers who want sapphic romantic … Read more
Updated on October 8, 2026 Verdict: A quiet, warm winter romance between a lonely novelist who has just turned forty and the newly divorced neighbour who moves in across the road, with real heat and a thoughtful coming-out story, held back by a plot so gentle that some readers find nothing happens at all. Best … Read more
Verdict: A snowed-in sapphic rom-com that is genuinely, repeatedly funny, held back by a romance its own readers barely mention. Best for: Readers who want a short, low-angst comfort read with a scene-stealing cat, and who can accept that the conflict stays gentle and the spice stays moderate. Heat level: ★★★★☆ (3.5/5 — the book’s … Read more