This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A short, cosy and quietly steamy seaside romance between a Black detective inspector in her late forties, laid up with a broken leg, and the flirtatious senior colleague who has just retired at 56 — a warm end to the Leicester Trilogy that loses a little steam in a late argument.
Best for: Readers who want women in their late forties and fifties, a week away by the sea, a long-simmering workplace flirtation finally acted on, and a book they can finish in an evening.
Heat level: Not rated (romance.io has no steam rating; two reviewers give it 3/5 flames)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.1/5 — a 4.27 Goodreads average across 51 ratings)
Tropes: Colleagues to lovers, forced proximity, seaside cottage, age gap, injured heroine, late-forties and fifties leads, series finale, epilogue.
Mending Bones is Merlina Garance’s 2023 self-published contemporary lesbian romance and the third and final book in her Leicester Trilogy. Claire Atkins, a detective inspector in her late forties, has worked alongside Estelle for years and has always brushed off Estelle’s flirting as meaningless. Then Claire breaks her leg, discovers that Estelle is retiring from the police at only 56, and — before she can ask why — finds herself whisked off to Estelle’s seaside cottage in Devon for a week.
It holds a 4.27 average across 51 Goodreads ratings, with 82% of them four or five stars, and 4.1 stars across 40 Amazon ratings. It is a small book with a small, devoted readership, largely made up of readers who followed the whole trilogy.
What Is Mending Bones About?
This is a colleagues-to-lovers romance with a simple, appealing premise: two women who have circled each other for years are suddenly given a week with nothing to do but eat, drink wine, walk the coast and talk. Claire has spent her career working twice as hard as everyone around her, and being forced to stop is almost harder than the broken leg. Estelle, glamorous and impulsive, has been flirting with her for about seven years and has finally decided to be clear about what she wants.
Under the cosy surface there is more going on. Estelle’s early retirement is not quite what it seems, and the book touches on corruption inside the police and on what it has cost Claire to be one of very few Black women in her profession. Readers describe it as gentle and steamy, but not weightless.
What Makes This Cosy Sapphic Romance Work
- Claire finally takes the lead: Readers of the trilogy loved Claire as a supporting character in the first two books, and many say this was the story they had been waiting for.
- Older heroines: Reviewers welcome leads in their late forties and fifties, which they rarely find in sapphic romance.
- Estelle: Flirty, beautiful and impulsive, but with darker moods underneath. One reviewer liked that she is not a relentless ray of sunshine; another declared her the love of their life.
- The setting: A seaside cottage, lazy mornings, good food and wine. One reviewer called the book a love letter to a slower, more restful life.
- Communication: Claire and Estelle disagree about serious things, but readers say they talk them through rather than retreating into silence.
Book Synopsis
Claire, a detective inspector in her late forties, has known and worked with Estelle for many years. Ever since they met, it has felt as though there could be something more between them. Estelle’s gentle flirting and compliments have been a constant in Claire’s life, but her self-confidence never let her believe Estelle meant anything by it.
Then Claire breaks her leg, and soon afterwards learns that Estelle has decided to retire from the police at only 56. Something about it does not feel right, but before Claire can start asking questions, Estelle offers to take her away to her seaside cottage for a week. With Claire on sick leave and Estelle retired, they both have the time.
Surely a week of lazy mornings, too much food and wine, and walks through the countryside is not enough to make Claire fall, when she has resisted for so long?
My Review
The pleasure of this book is its premise, and Garance does not overcomplicate it. Two grown women, a small house by the sea, a week with no work: it is forced proximity at its most civilised. The romance moves quickly once they arrive — one reviewer called it a quick-burn rather than a slow one — because the attraction has been there for years. What the week provides is the time to finally say so.
Claire is the reason it lands. She is proud, stubborn and exhausted from a career in which she has had to prove herself over and over as a Black queer woman, and she does not know how to rest or how to believe someone wants her. Readers who share some of that experience say her anxieties and stubbornness ring true. Estelle is her opposite: carefree on the surface, with real sadness and anger she keeps hidden, and one of the book’s pleasures is watching Claire realise she does not know Estelle nearly as well as she thought.
The criticism is about the last act. One reviewer found the fight between Claire and Estelle near the end juvenile for women their age, felt it existed mainly to move the plot, and thought the ending rushed as a result — they would also have liked more of Stu, Claire’s best friend from the previous book, instead of a brief epilogue. Another reader rated it three stars, saying it was cute and low-stakes but that they read it at the wrong time. A reviewer who read the whole trilogy noticed that each book follows a similar pattern, with a serious outside problem and a period where one heroine needs to think alone.
It is also worth being clear about the evidence base: 51 Goodreads ratings, 14 written reviews, 14 on StoryGraph and two ratings on romance.io. Almost all of those come from readers who already loved the author, several of them from advance copies.
My honest note: If you want a short, warm, grown-up romance with a sea view and some heat, especially if you have read the earlier Leicester books, this is a lovely way to spend an evening. If late-book arguments bother you, the final stretch may frustrate you.
| Element | In Mending Bones |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Claire Atkins & Estelle — detective inspector and newly retired senior officer, colleagues to lovers |
| Core tropes | Colleagues to lovers, forced proximity, seaside cottage, age gap, injured heroine |
| Setting | Leicester and a seaside cottage in Devon |
| Heat level | Not rated — no romance.io steam rating; reviewers give it 3/5 flames |
| Series | Leicester Trilogy #3 — reads as a standalone, happy resolution with an epilogue |
| Content notes | Police corruption, a broken leg and recovery, racism and homophobia in the heroines’ pasts, sexual content |
How Spicy Is Mending Bones?
We have not scored the heat, because romance.io has no steam rating for Mending Bones — only two readers have rated it there — and StoryGraph has no content data on sexual content. What we do have is two reviewers who scored the spice themselves, and both gave it three flames out of five. Readers describe the book as “both gentle and steamy”, with quiet intimacy and a clear sexual attraction between the leads. That suggests on-page scenes in the middle of the heat range, but it is a reader estimate rather than a rating.
StoryGraph has no content warnings submitted. From reader reviews and our own cozy lesbian romance list, the things to know are police corruption, Claire’s injury and recovery, and the racism and homophobia implied in Claire’s past as a Black queer woman in the police.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you want heroines in their late forties and fifties, you like colleagues to lovers and forced proximity, you want a cosy seaside setting, and you have enjoyed the earlier Leicester Trilogy books. It sits on our mature lesbian romance and cozy lesbian romance lists.
You may want to skip it if: you dislike late-book fights, you want a long slow burn, or you need a confirmed heat level.
In short: A cosy, grown-up week by the sea with a couple readers have waited three books to see together.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (September 2026)
This is a self-published series finale with a small, loyal readership, and a web search surfaced no Reddit threads. On Goodreads the split is 47% five stars, 35% four and 15% three, with a single two-star rating; StoryGraph shows 3.88 across 14 reviews, with readers most often tagging it hopeful and lighthearted. It was not in Kindle Unlimited when I checked, and I found no audiobook edition.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Claire getting her own story first. Second, the older heroines. Third, Estelle. Fourth, the seaside setting and the slower pace of life it celebrates. One reader singles out the book’s dedication and its message that everyone deserves love and joy, whoever they are and however old.
What readers argue about and complain about: The late fight, above everything — one detailed review found it immature and plot-driven. Second, an ending that felt rushed to the same reader. Third, a sense of pattern across the trilogy. None of these complaints is common, but the reviews are few.
The series question worth asking first: Mending Bones works as a standalone and closes on a happy ending, but it is the last book of a trilogy that begins with The Flourishing and continues with Just Stu. At least one reviewer enjoyed it enough to go back to book one, and trilogy fans say it means more if you already love Claire when she arrives.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you need to read the Leicester Trilogy in order?
No. Mending Bones is the third book, after The Flourishing and Just Stu, and it has a new couple, so it can be read on its own. Claire is a much-loved supporting character in the first two books, though, and readers who met her there got more out of seeing her finally take the lead.
How old are Claire and Estelle?
Claire is a detective inspector in her late forties — one reviewer puts her at 46 — and Estelle has just retired at 56, so there is an age gap of about a decade.
How spicy is Mending Bones?
romance.io has no steam rating for it, so we have not given it a score. Two reviewers who rated the spice themselves each gave it three out of five, and readers describe the book as both gentle and steamy.
Does Mending Bones have a happy ending?
Yes. Claire and Estelle end up together, and an epilogue shows them established as a couple. One reader called the ending bittersweet and another said it made their eyes wet, so expect some emotion on the way.
Is there an audiobook of Mending Bones?
I could not find one. Libro.fm has no listing. It is available as a Kindle ebook and a paperback.
If You Loved Mending Bones, Read These Next
For another romance with a woman in uniform past fifty, try Gold Star Chance. Honey in the Marrow is a slower, more emotional romance between two women in their fifties and sixties. And if it was the seaside you loved, Summer’s Cove is also reviewed on this site. For more, browse our women over 40 list, the mature lesbian romance hub, cozy lesbian romance, or the full Book Reviews archive.
The Bottom Line
Mending Bones sets out to give a beloved supporting character her own love story, and it largely succeeds: the seaside week is cosy, Claire is complex and real, Estelle is a delight, and the heat is there without taking over. What holds it back is a late argument that at least one reader found out of character and an ending that feels a little rushed. For readers who want a short, warm romance with women in their late forties and fifties, it is worth it. Check Mending Bones on Amazon →
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Mending Bones ranks as a very good, cosy mature sapphic romance — warm in setting and rich in its heroine, held back by a rushed final act and a small evidence base.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ 4.27 average across 51 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 82% of Goodreads ratings are four or five stars
- ✓ 4.1 stars across 40 Amazon ratings
- ✓ Small evidence base
Romance ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Years of flirtation finally acted on
- ✓ Forced proximity at a seaside cottage
- ✓ A quick burn once they arrive
- ✓ Late fight felt juvenile to one reader
Characters ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ Claire a fan favourite from the trilogy
- ✓ Estelle charming with hidden depths
- ✓ Leads in their late forties and fifties
- ✓ Wanted more of Stu
Writing ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Easy, quick read
- ✓ Cosy sense of place
- ✓ Serious themes under the surface
- ✓ Pattern repeats across the trilogy
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Claire’s exhaustion and self-doubt ring true
- ✓ Serious workplace themes addressed
- ✓ Ending moved at least one reader to tears
- ✓ Low stakes for some
Heat Level — not rated
- ✓ No romance.io steam rating
- ✓ Two reviewers give it 3/5 flames
- ✓ Described as gentle and steamy
- ✓ On-page intimacy
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Happy resolution for Claire and Estelle
- ✓ Epilogue shows them as a couple
- ✓ HEA vs HFN not specified
- ✓ Felt rushed to one reader
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 3.9/5
- ✓ Short enough for an evening
- ✓ Rewarding with the whole trilogy
- ✓ Cosy setting to return to
- ✓ No audiobook edition
Affiliate disclosure: Lesbian Romance Reads is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through the link below we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.