Verdict: A warm, sapphic, Métis-centered retelling of The Secret Garden that fixes the original’s blind spots and gives Mary a first love, held back by a young-feeling voice, a predictable path and less time in the garden than the title promises.
Best for: Teen and adult readers who loved The Secret Garden as children and want it reimagined with Indigenous characters and a gentle sapphic romance, and who don’t mind a story that skews young.
Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: YA, a sweet first romance)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.6/5: a 3.73 Goodreads average across about 1,140 ratings, a starred Kirkus review and a Governor General’s Award shortlisting, and readers who wanted more depth)
Tropes: Classic retelling, orphan sent to a remote house, girl in the attic, first love, wicked stepmother, found family, healing through nature, Métis community, coming of age, standalone.
Into the Bright Open: A Secret Garden Remix is Cherie Dimaline’s entry in the Remixed Classics series from Feiwel & Friends, published in September 2023: a historical YA retelling that moves Frances Hodgson Burnett’s story to 1901 Ontario, centers Métis characters and lets a lonely orphan fall for a local girl while rescuing a cousin hidden away in the attic.
It sits at 3.73 on Goodreads across roughly 1,140 ratings and 3.85 on StoryGraph across about 630 reviews. Kirkus gave it a starred review, BCCB praised the prose, and it was a finalist for the Governor General’s Literary Award for young people’s literature. Readers love what Dimaline changed. Some wish she had gone further. Both halves are worth understanding before you start.
What Is Into the Bright Open About?
This is a YA historical retelling with a gothic edge. The bones of The Secret Garden are all here: an orphaned girl, a cold relative’s house, a locked garden and a hidden child. Dimaline moves it to the Georgian Bay region of Ontario at the turn of the century, adds a white stepmother as the villain, and builds the household around Métis characters the original would have ignored or caricatured.
Mary Lennox is older than Burnett’s Mary, a teenager who’s spoiled, prickly and alone after her parents die. She lands at her uncle’s house with no idea how to be kind. Sophie is a Métis girl from the community nearby, and she’s the one who shows Mary the land and, slowly, a different way to live. Olive, Mary’s cousin, takes the place of the original’s hidden Colin. The book stays close to Mary, so you watch her soften one stubborn step at a time.
What Makes This Sapphic Retelling Work
- The Métis setting: The most praised change. Readers love the relocation to Canada and the Indigenous community at its center, and several say it made the story feel new rather than borrowed.
- Mary and Sophie: Their slow, sweet romance is the other big draw. The Lesbrary called the way they grow toward each other very cute, and readers keep using the same word.
- Fixing the original: Reviewers point out that the book confronts the racism of the source directly, with one noting that the original could never.
- A real villain: The stepmother is a hated figure in the reviews, and her treatment of Olive gives the book a sharper, darker engine than Burnett’s.
- Warmth: StoryGraph readers tag it emotional (70%) and hopeful (57%), and 80% call the characters loveable.
Book Synopsis
Mary Lennox has never had to think about anyone else. Then her parents die, and she’s packed off to Georgian Bay to live with an uncle she’s never met in a big, gloomy house at the edge of the wilderness. She arrives rude, frightened and determined to hate it.
The house is full of rules and silences. Her uncle is barely there. His new wife runs everything with a tight smile. The staff seem to know things Mary doesn’t, and at night she hears crying from somewhere upstairs. Outside, there’s a walled garden no one will talk about, and a girl named Sophie from the nearby Métis community who isn’t impressed by Mary at all.
Mary starts sneaking out. With Sophie’s help she finds the garden, and then she finds the source of the crying: a cousin named Olive, kept out of sight and told she’s too ill to leave her room. The more Mary learns, the less Olive looks sick and the more the house looks like a trap. Mary has to decide whether she’s brave enough to stand up to the adults who control her life, and what she’s willing to risk for the two girls who are changing it.
My Review
The best thing Dimaline does is make the place matter. Georgian Bay, the water, the land and the Métis families who belong to it aren’t scenery. They’re what Mary is being healed by, which is a smarter version of the original’s idea that a garden can save a child. It’s the part readers praise most and the part that makes the book feel like Dimaline’s rather than Burnett’s.
Mary and Sophie are the second strength. It’s a first love written gently, with Sophie unimpressed and Mary slowly earning her. One reviewer’s whole review was basically excited shouting about the girls, and it’s hard to blame them. The romance stays sweet and innocent, which fits the story.
Where it struggles, the complaints are consistent. The most common is that it reads young. One reader who quit early felt it was written as though teens need things simplified, and another said it felt closer to middle grade than YA, especially given how sheltered both girls are. The second complaint is the garden itself: a couple of readers expected far more time there and got more time in the house. Third, a few readers found it predictable, which is partly the cost of retelling a famous book, and one felt aging Mary up made her less fun than the original’s spoiled child.
The expectation to reset is the tone. The cover and the word “remix” might suggest something edgy. It’s warmer and simpler than that, with a dark streak in how Olive is treated. If you want a sophisticated adult retelling, calibrate. If you want a sweet sapphic version of a childhood classic, you’re in the right place.
My honest note: A kind, thoughtful update of an old favorite, with a first romance worth rooting for. Read it for Sophie and the setting, and don’t expect depth beyond its age range.
| Element | In Into the Bright Open |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Mary Lennox, a newly orphaned girl, and Sophie, a Métis girl from the nearby community, first love |
| Core tropes | Classic retelling, orphan in a remote house, girl in the attic, wicked stepmother, healing through nature |
| Setting | Georgian Bay, Ontario, in 1901, at Mary’s uncle’s house and the surrounding Métis community |
| Heat level | 1/5: YA, a sweet first romance |
| Series | Remixed Classics #8: standalone; each book in the series is a different author and story |
| Content notes | Child abuse, racism and confinement; death of a parent, racial slurs and grief; minor panic attacks, colonisation and classism (StoryGraph reader warnings) |
How Spicy Is Into the Bright Open?
Not at all. It’s YA for ages 13 and up, romance.io doesn’t catalog it, and by every reader account the romance is a sweet, chaste first love. One reader felt it was closer to middle grade in tone. I’d call it a 1.
The thing to flag is the abuse plot. StoryGraph readers list child abuse and confinement as graphic, and one reader stopped reading because of how heavy those parts became. If you want a YA sapphic book with a similar mix of plants, family secrets and a dark house, This Poison Heart is a strong match.
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: The Secret Garden was a childhood favorite, you want Indigenous characters at the center of a classic, a gentle first sapphic romance appeals, and you like stories about healing through land and community.
You may want to skip it if: you want YA with an older, sharper voice, you’re hoping for lots of time in the garden itself, predictability bothers you, or child abuse is a hard limit.
In short: A sweet, meaningful remix that plays it a little young and a little safe.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
This is a recent, award-noticed YA book with a modest readership: about 1,140 Goodreads ratings and 247 written reviews, and around 630 on StoryGraph. It reaches readers through the Remixed Classics series, which a lot of reviewers say they’re reading through in order, and through Dimaline’s reputation from The Marrow Thieves. Kirkus starred it, BCCB and The Lesbrary reviewed it well, and it was a Governor General’s Award finalist.
The audiobook from Macmillan Audio is narrated by Brefny Caribou and runs 7 hours 21 minutes.
Prefer audio? Listen to Into the Bright Open on Libro.fm, the audiobook shop that supports independent bookstores.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The setting and the representation, first. Readers praise the Canadian relocation and the Métis characters constantly, and several call the result a whole new story with only traces of the original. Second, the sapphic romance, with “sweet” and “cute” doing a lot of work in the reviews. Third, the way the book takes on the original’s racism. And readers who had never read Burnett’s novel say it works fine on its own.
What readers argue about and complain about: The young voice, above everything. Several readers say it reads younger than YA, and one quit early because it felt simplified. Second: the garden, which gets less page time than readers expected. Third: predictability, with a few readers saying they always knew where it was heading. Fourth, a single but sharp point: aging Mary up loses some of the original’s charm for readers who loved her as a bratty little girl. The real split is the remix itself. Some readers wanted it to stay closer to Burnett; others wanted it to go further away.
The standalone question worth asking first: It stands alone. The story resolves in this book with no sequel. It’s part of the Remixed Classics series, but each entry is a different classic and a different author, so you can read them in any order. Dimaline’s The Marrow Thieves is her best-known YA novel and a much darker read.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Into the Bright Open a sapphic book?
Yes. Mary Lennox falls for Sophie, a Métis girl from the nearby community. It’s a sweet, chaste first romance inside a retelling of The Secret Garden.
How spicy is Into the Bright Open?
It’s a 1/5. It’s YA for ages 13 and up, and the romance is innocent. Some readers felt it was close to middle grade in tone.
Do I need to read The Secret Garden first?
No. Several readers who hadn’t read the original say it works on its own, though fans of Burnett’s book will spot the changes.
Is Into the Bright Open a standalone?
Yes. It’s part of the Remixed Classics series, but each book is independent and this one is complete.
Is there an audiobook?
Yes. Macmillan Audio published it, narrated by Brefny Caribou, with a runtime of 7 hours 21 minutes. It’s available on Libro.fm and Audible.
If You Loved Into the Bright Open, Read These Next
For plants, family secrets and a sapphic YA heroine, This Poison Heart is the closest match in feel. If you like your retellings with a darker edge, Girl, Serpent, Thorn reworks a fairy tale with a girl who’s dangerous to touch. And for a YA coming-of-age about a girl pushing back against adults who want to control her, The Miseducation of Cameron Post is a heavier, contemporary classic. For more, browse our Indigenous sapphic books guide or the full book reviews archive.
The Bottom Line
Into the Bright Open set out to reclaim a beloved classic for the people it left out, and it does that with warmth. The Métis setting is the heart of the book, Mary and Sophie are lovely together, and the darker stepmother plot gives it bite. It reads young, it’s predictable, and the garden gets less attention than it deserves. It’s worth it for readers who want a gentle sapphic retelling of a childhood favorite and value representation over complexity. Check Into the Bright Open on Amazon
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Into the Bright Open ranks as a heartfelt sapphic YA retelling. It’s strongest on setting and representation and weakest on depth and surprise. Read it for Sophie and Georgian Bay rather than for a twisty plot.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 3.6/5
- ✓ 3.73 average across 1,140 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ 3.85 on StoryGraph across 628 reviews
- ✓ Kirkus starred, Governor General’s finalist
- ✓ Reads young for many readers
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Sweet, slow first love
- ✓ Sophie earns praise as a love interest
- ✓ Readers call it cute again and again
- ✓ Gentle and secondary to the rescue plot
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ 80% of StoryGraph readers find them loveable
- ✓ Mary softens believably
- ✓ The stepmother a hated villain
- ✓ Aged-up Mary loses some charm for fans
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ BCCB praised the subtle prose
- ✓ Strong sense of place
- ✓ Clear, accessible voice
- ✓ Some felt it was simplified
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 70% tag it emotional
- ✓ Healing through land and community
- ✓ Olive’s plight lands hard
- ✓ Predictable beats soften the payoff
Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
- ✓ YA for ages 13 and up
- ✓ Chaste first romance
- ✓ Not catalogued as romance
- ✓ Close to middle grade in tone for some
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Complete standalone
- ✓ Hopeful resolution
- ✓ Villain gets her due
- ✓ Readers saw it coming
Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.3/5
- ✓ Comfort retelling of a classic
- ✓ 7 hour 21 minute audiobook
- ✓ Remix series invites more reading
- ✓ Simple plot limits a reread
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

1 thought on “Into the Bright Open Review: Is It Worth Reading?”