Evil Dead Center Review: Is It Worth Reading?

Verdict: A grounded, angry 1990s mystery with an Ojibwe lesbian sleuth, a strong sense of place and a case that exposes real harm done to Native children, held back by a slow start and a plot that leans on obvious villains.

Best for: Readers who want a crime novel by and about a Two-Spirit Ojibwe woman, who care about setting and politics more than twists, and who can handle a dark subject treated without sensationalism.

Heat level: ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5: an established couple in the background, by reader reports)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.5/5: a 3.67 Goodreads average across about 60 ratings, a small readership that praises Renee and the setting and splits on the pacing)

Tropes: Amateur sleuth, established lesbian couple, ex-girlfriend returns, reservation mystery, suspicious death ruled an accident, small-town corruption, blizzard climax, series book 2.

Evil Dead Center is the second and final Renee LaRoche mystery by Carole laFavor, first published by Firebrand Books in 1997 and reissued by the University of Minnesota Press in 2017: a lesbian crime novel set on and around the fictional Red Earth Reservation in northern Minnesota, where an Ojibwe schoolteacher who helps out the tribal police is pulled into a young Native woman’s death because her ex-girlfriend refuses to believe it was an accident.

It’s a small book in reader terms: a 3.67 Goodreads average across roughly 60 ratings, with 13 written reviews, and a 3.78 on StoryGraph from 17. Its weight comes from elsewhere. laFavor (1948 to 2011) was a Two-Spirit Ojibwe novelist and activist who served on the President’s Advisory Council on HIV/AIDS, and the 2017 reissue, with a foreword by scholar Lisa Tatonetti, put her two mysteries back in print as early landmarks of Native lesbian fiction. Readers who find it now mostly love Renee. The ones who don’t usually stop early.

What Is Evil Dead Center About?

It’s a traditional amateur-sleuth mystery, closer to a cozy in structure than to noir, though nothing about the subject is cozy. One reviewer points out that it doesn’t read like hard-boiled crime by white American writers at all: the land, Ojibwe practice and the community’s relationship to outside institutions carry as much of the story as the clues. It also turns into something closer to a thriller as it goes, ending in deep woods in a blizzard.

Renee LaRoche teaches part time at an elementary school and helps the Red Earth tribal police without any official badge. She lives with her girlfriend Samantha, a Chinook writer, and the book opens on a settled, happy life about a year after the events of Along the Journey River. Then Caroline, Renee’s first girlfriend from their activist days, calls with a death she says was murder. Renee narrates, and her calm, reflective voice is the thing reviewers come back to.

What Makes This Indigenous Lesbian Mystery Work

  • Renee herself: The most praised element in the reviews. Readers call her characterization “fantastic” and single out how reflective she is, and how she faces horror through stillness and story.
  • Sense of place: Northern Minnesota, the reservation and the winter woods are vivid, and reviewers say the landscape matters to how Renee thinks.
  • Ojibwe culture on its own terms: Cultural and spiritual practice is part of the plot, not decoration, and one reader enjoyed learning Ojibwe words of wisdom along the way.
  • A case with real-world teeth: The mystery exposes racism in how Native deaths are investigated and how Native foster children are placed. An academic review of the reissue praises it for using fiction to highlight crises that hit tribal communities hard.
  • A queer relationship that’s just there: Renee and Samantha are a stable couple, and the ex who comes back stirs things up without blowing them apart.

Book Synopsis

A year after she helped solve a murder on her reservation, Renee LaRoche has settled into something like peace. She teaches, she lends the tribal police a hand when they ask, and she comes home to Samantha. Winter is coming on and life is quiet, the way she likes it.

Then Caroline calls. They were together almost twenty years ago, back in their movement days, and Caroline hasn’t been part of Renee’s life for a long time. A young Ojibwe woman Caroline knew has been found dead on the edge of the reservation, and the coroner has written it off as exposure, the kind of drunken accident officials expect from Native people. Caroline doesn’t believe it. She wants Renee to look.

The deeper Renee digs, the uglier it gets. The dead woman’s story leads to Native children placed in white foster homes off the reservation, and to people in positions of trust who have every reason to keep things buried. Renee has to work without a badge, around authorities who don’t take her seriously, while old memories of her own childhood rise up and her past with Caroline sits awkwardly at her kitchen table. The question isn’t only who killed a young woman. It’s how far the harm goes, and who has been allowed to look away.

My Review

The best thing in the book is Renee’s voice. She’s thoughtful, patient and quietly furious, and laFavor lets her process terrible things the way a real person might, slowly and with help from the people around her. It’s a different temperature from most crime fiction, and it suits the material.

Evil Dead Center by Carole laFavor book cover

The second strength is what the case is really about. It’s easy for a mystery to treat a social problem as set dressing. This one builds the whole plot on it: the coroner’s assumption about Native drinking, the foster system pulling children off the reservation, officials who protect each other. Readers who rated it highly say it handles difficult topics realistically, and one who read it for a class recommends checking content warnings first, which is good advice.

Where it struggles is pacing, and the low-star reviews are short and to the point. One reader couldn’t finish it because it “took forever to get to the point.” Another found it fine but no more than “okay.” A third, otherwise positive, felt the white male characters were stereotyped as obvious villains, which drains some of the suspense. These come from a handful of readers in a small pool, so I’d call them tendencies rather than themes. Still, about 12% of its Goodreads ratings are one or two stars, and they point the same way: the opening is slow and the solution isn’t hard to see.

It also helps to know what kind of book this is. The cover and the title (which, as one reviewer dryly notes, has nothing to do with the Evil Dead films) might suggest horror. It’s a mystery that becomes a thriller, rooted in community and grief. If you came for a puzzle box, you may be underwhelmed. If you came for a voice and a place you don’t often get in crime fiction, it’s worth your time.

My honest note: A quietly powerful mystery from an important Ojibwe lesbian writer, more memorable for Renee and Red Earth than for its plot. Give it fifty pages, and go in braced for what the case turns out to be.

ElementIn Evil Dead Center
Central relationshipRenee LaRoche and her girlfriend Samantha, with Renee’s first girlfriend Caroline back in the picture
Core tropesAmateur sleuth, reservation mystery, suspicious death, ex-girlfriend returns, local corruption
SettingThe fictional Red Earth Reservation and northern Minnesota in winter, 1990s
Heat level1/5: established couple, no explicit content in reviews
SeriesRenee LaRoche book 2 of 2; the case resolves; the series ended with this book
Content notesA child exploitation ring targeting Native foster children (not graphic, per reviewers), child abuse, racism, death of a young woman, memories of childhood trauma; StoryGraph lists no warnings yet

How Spicy Is Evil Dead Center?

A 1/5. This is a mystery, and romance.io doesn’t index it (I couldn’t reach romance.io from here anyway). Renee and Samantha are a loving established couple, and Caroline’s return adds some old feelings, but none of the reviews I read mention sex scenes, and the book’s attention is on the case.

The thing to know in advance is the subject. The crime at the center involves the exploitation of Native children in foster care, and the investigation touches on child abuse and on Renee’s own childhood memories. Reviewers who mention it say it’s handled seriously and isn’t graphic, but one recommends reading content warnings before starting. For a lesbian mystery of the same era and region with a lighter touch, Hallowed Murder is set in Minneapolis and starts Ellen Hart’s long-running series.

Who Should Read This Book?

You’ll likely love it if: you want Indigenous crime fiction by a Native author, you read mysteries for character and setting, you like an established lesbian couple at the center, you’re interested in queer literary history.

You may want to skip it if: you need a fast, twisty plot, crimes involving children are a hard line, villains without much shading bother you, you want romance to be part of the story.

In short: A voice-and-place mystery with a heavy subject, more important than it is thrilling.

What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)

This book reaches readers through classrooms and the 2017 University of Minnesota Press reissue rather than through any buzz. At least one Goodreads reviewer read it for a class, and the reissue drew an academic review in the journal Transmotion in 2019, which argues the book uses fiction to highlight real crises affecting tribal communities and notes how it shifts from mystery into thriller. Publishers Weekly reviewed the original 1997 Firebrand edition. Beyond that the footprint is small: about 60 Goodreads ratings, 17 on StoryGraph, no trade reviews of the reissue that I could find, and I couldn’t reach Reddit from here.

Why readers love it (according to the discourse): Renee, first. Readers call her characterization fantastic and love her relationships with Samantha and with family. Second, the Ojibwe setting and culture, which reviewers describe as central to the plot rather than flavor. Third, the realism: one reader praises how many hard topics it covers (prejudice, child abuse, a same-sex relationship) while still telling “a really good story,” and adds it would make a great TV series. StoryGraph’s small sample marks it mysterious and adventurous.

What readers argue about and complain about: First, pace. The one DNF says it took too long to get going, and the 2-star review calls it only okay. Second, the villains: a positive reviewer still felt the white male antagonists were stereotyped. Third, one dismissive review calls it “cop propaganda,” though Renee works without official status and the book is pointed about how institutions fail Native people, so that reading is very much a minority. With a pool this small, none of these is a firm consensus.

The series question everyone should ask first: This is the second Renee LaRoche mystery, and it was the last; laFavor didn’t write a third before her death in 2011. The case here resolves fully, and while the book refers back to Along the Journey River, the readers I saw who started here don’t mention being lost. One reviewer who began with this book says she wants to go back and read the first. Both were reissued together in 2017, so they’re easy to read in order if you prefer.

I couldn’t find an audiobook edition, on Libro.fm or elsewhere.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Evil Dead Center a lesbian book?

Yes. Renee LaRoche, the Ojibwe sleuth and narrator, lives with her girlfriend Samantha, and her first girlfriend Caroline brings her the case. The book is a mystery, not a romance.

Do I need to read Along the Journey River first?

No. Evil Dead Center is the second Renee LaRoche mystery and refers to the first, but the case stands alone. Reading in order gives you more of Renee’s backstory.

Is Evil Dead Center related to the Evil Dead movies?

No. It’s a crime novel set on a fictional Ojibwe reservation in Minnesota, and one reviewer jokes about exactly this mix-up.

How dark is Evil Dead Center?

Fairly dark in subject. The case involves the exploitation of Native foster children and child abuse, though reviewers say it isn’t graphic.

Who was Carole laFavor?

A Two-Spirit Ojibwe novelist and activist (1948 to 2011) who served on the President’s Advisory Council on HIV/AIDS. Her two Renee LaRoche mysteries were reissued by the University of Minnesota Press in 2017.

If You Loved Evil Dead Center, Read These Next

Hallowed Murder is the natural next stop: a lesbian amateur-sleuth mystery from the same era, also set in Minnesota. For a contemporary Indigenous author writing a sapphic story, Into the Bright Open by Métis writer Cherie Dimaline is gentler and younger in tone. And if it’s the outsider investigator you liked, Magic for Liars follows a private eye who doesn’t fit into the community she’s investigating. There’s more on our Indigenous sapphic books list, and the full archive is under Book Reviews.

The Bottom Line

Evil Dead Center sets out to tell a mystery that’s really about how a community’s children are failed, through the eyes of an Ojibwe lesbian who won’t look away. Renee is wonderful, Red Earth feels real, and the anger behind the book is earned. The start is slow, the villains are easy to spot and the plot is less surprising than the setting. For readers who want a voice and a world rarely given space in crime fiction, it’s well worth reading, with care. Check Evil Dead Center on Amazon.

The Eikna Overall Ranking

On the Eikna scale, Evil Dead Center ranks as an important small-press lesbian mystery. It’s carried by its narrator and its setting, held back by pacing and thin villains. Read it for Renee and Red Earth rather than for the puzzle.

The Evidence Scorecard

Overall ★★★★☆ 3.5/5

  • ✓ 3.67 average across about 60 Goodreads ratings
  • ✓ 3.78 on StoryGraph from 17 ratings
  • ✓ Reissued by University of Minnesota Press
  • ✓ One DNF and an “okay” cite slow pacing

Romance ★★★☆☆ 2.8/5

  • ✓ Stable couple at the center
  • ✓ Ex-girlfriend adds old tension
  • ✓ Queer life shown as ordinary
  • ✓ Relationship stays in the background

Characters ★★★★☆ 3.8/5

  • ✓ Renee is the most praised element
  • ✓ Reflective, patient narrator
  • ✓ Strong family and community ties
  • ✓ Villains read as stereotyped to one reader

Writing ★★★☆☆ 3.4/5

  • ✓ Dialogue praised by reviewers
  • ✓ Vivid northern Minnesota setting
  • ✓ Ojibwe words and practice woven in
  • ✓ Slow opening, per low-star reviews

Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 3.7/5

  • ✓ Real-world harm at the heart of the case
  • ✓ Renee faces old childhood memories
  • ✓ Handled seriously, reviewers say
  • ✓ Obvious culprits soften the tension

Heat Level ★☆☆☆☆ 1/5

  • ✓ Established couple
  • ✓ No sex scenes mentioned in reviews
  • ✓ Focus stays on the case
  • ✓ Descriptive score, not a criticism

Ending ★★★★☆ 3.6/5

  • ✓ Case resolves fully
  • ✓ Blizzard finale turns it into a thriller
  • ✓ Series ends here
  • ✓ Solution is not hard to guess

Re-read Value ★★★☆☆ 3.2/5

  • ✓ Renee rewards a return visit
  • ✓ Pairs well with book 1
  • ✓ Useful for queer literary history
  • ✓ Heavy subject discourages rereading

Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org

The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

1 thought on “Evil Dead Center Review: Is It Worth Reading?”

Leave a Comment