Verdict: A warm, slow-burning paranormal fake relationship between a fox-shifter and the human spying on her, and one of Jae’s best-received books, held back by the fact that it’s only the first half of the love story.
Best for: Readers who love a very slow burn, found family and shifter politics, and who are happy to read two books to get one romance.
Heat level: ★★☆☆☆ (1.5/5: a slow burn, with readers saying the heat arrives in book two)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.2/5: a 4.53 Goodreads average across 472 ratings, discounted for an ending that leaves the romance unfinished)
Tropes: Enemies-to-lovers, fake relationship, only one bed, fake mates, slow burn, shape-shifters, single mom, spy in the house, found family, prejudice between species.
Enemies by Nature is Jae’s 2025 paranormal lesbian romance from Ylva Publishing, listed by the publisher as book seven of the Shape-Shifter series but written to be read on its own, and it’s a slow burn built on a political stunt: the shape-shifting Wrasa need better press, so their council pairs aloof fox-shifter Tala Peterson with Faith MacAllister, the human daughter of their loudest enemy, in a very public fake relationship.
Readers love it. It holds 4.53 on Goodreads across 472 ratings and 4.33 on StoryGraph across 71 reviews, and fewer than 2% of its Goodreads ratings sit below three stars. The thing almost everyone brings up is that it’s the first of two books, and the romance isn’t finished when this one ends. That’s the part worth understanding before you start.
What Is Enemies by Nature About?
This is shifter romance in Jae’s established world, where shape-shifters have revealed themselves and tension with humans runs high. That means politics, prejudice and pack life are always in the room, and the book uses them seriously. One reader on the publisher’s site says it touches on the experience of LGBTQ+ people and other minorities who’ve been vilified for being different, and the allegory isn’t subtle, nor does it try to be.
Tala is a fox-shifter raised by a wolf pack, prickly and proud and in no mood to pretend. Faith is a single mother with a young daughter she’s determined to keep out of it, and she has her own reason for agreeing: she’s reporting back to her father. Each thinks the other is the enemy. The dual point of view lets you see both of them lying, which is half the fun.
What Makes This Paranormal Fake-Relationship Romance Work
- The slow burn: Reviewers say it’s a true slow burn and call it the Jae way. Trust comes first, then feeling, and readers who like that pace love it here.
- Fake dating done right: One reader sums it up as fake dating done right, with an emotional arc that feels believable and chemistry that creeps up before it hits.
- Tala’s pack: The wolf pack that raised Tala is a favourite. Readers say it’s a lot of fun to spend time with them, and one names a late-night talk between Faith and Tala’s mother as a highlight.
- The real stakes: The human and shifter conflict isn’t wallpaper. Readers call the story thought-provoking and say the opposing beliefs give the enemies-to-lovers setup real bite.
- Character work: Every StoryGraph reviewer who answered says the characters develop strongly, and 94% call them lovable.
Book Synopsis
Ever since shape-shifters stepped out into the open, humans and the Wrasa have been circling each other. The Wrasa council wants to change the story, and they’ve come up with a bold idea: a staged romance between one of their own and a human, preferably one whose family can’t stand them.
Faith MacAllister fits that description perfectly. Her father is the Wrasa’s most vocal critic, and she agrees to the arrangement on one condition, that her six-year-old daughter stays out of it. Tala Peterson is the shifter picked to play her mate, and she’s furious about it. She doesn’t trust Faith, and she’s right not to, because Faith is quietly passing information back to her father. The lab-made mate scent that’s meant to sell the act doesn’t help, since Tala finds it annoyingly hard to ignore.
Then the wolf pack that raised Tala insists on meeting her new mate. Now the two fake lovers have to share a home, and a bed, and face a family who has every reason to be suspicious. Faith starts to see the Wrasa up close, and she has to choose between the father she grew up with and the people she was sent to spy on.
My Review
The setup is clever, and it does more than produce romance. A fake relationship as a public relations stunt between two species who don’t trust each other gives the book a political engine, and the spying gives it suspense. Every tender moment has a lie underneath it, and Jae plays that well.
The second strength is the pack. Found family is easy to do badly, and here it’s the thing readers single out. Tala’s wolves are funny and warm, and Faith meeting them is where the book loosens up. The scene readers remember most is a quiet one, Faith talking to Tala’s mother in the middle of the night. That tells you what kind of book this is.
The main complaint is the ending, and it isn’t a quibble. On the first page of Goodreads reviews, more than half bring up the sequel, the cliffhanger or the wait. One 3-star reader says plainly that it feels unfinished. Another held her rating at 3.5 until she could read the second book. Even fans say it ends with a bit of a cliffhanger, and the publisher is upfront that the romance runs across two novels. Book one takes Tala and Faith from enemies to allies. It doesn’t get them to the finish line.
The other complaint is smaller. One reader says it’s not really enemies-to-lovers, more like mild disagreement to romance, and I can see the point. These two distrust each other, but nobody is cruel. If the word “enemies” on the cover made you expect hatred, this is gentler than that.
So set your expectations. If you want a complete romance in one book with an HEA, wait and read both together. If the slow build is what you’re here for, this is about as good as it gets, and the second book is already out.
My honest note: A lovely, thoughtful first half of a romance, with a great supporting cast and a slow burn that earns every inch. Buy both books at once and you’ll have no complaints.
| Element | In Enemies by Nature |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Tala Peterson & Faith MacAllister: fox-shifter and human single mom, enemies to allies in a fake relationship |
| Core tropes | Fake relationship, fake mates, only one bed, slow burn, spy in the house, found family |
| Setting | Jae’s Shape-Shifter world, including the wolf pack that raised Tala, whose ritual ground is in Shenandoah National Park |
| Heat level | 1.5/5: slow burn, heat held for book two |
| Series | Part one of a two-book romance that ends in Shifting Nature; can be read without the earlier Shape-Shifter books |
| Content notes | Prejudice and hostility toward shifters, a bigoted parent, spying and deception, family pressure |
How Spicy Is Enemies by Nature?
Not very. I couldn’t find a romance.io rating for it, and the reviews describe a slow burn in which trust has to come before anything else. The clearest evidence is a reader who says the second book picks up the pace and the heat by several notches, which tells you how low it runs here. I’d put it at 1.5/5.
Nobody flags any consent concerns, though the lab-made mate scent is part of the plot, and Tala resents the attraction it causes and blames it on chemistry. If you want Jae with more on the page, Second Nature has one explicit scene late on (2/5), and Damage Control is a contemporary Jae with an open door (3/5).
Who Should Read This Book?
You’ll likely love it if: you love a very slow burn, found family and pack dynamics make you happy, you like romance with a political edge, and you’re happy to read two books for one love story.
You may want to skip it if: you need an HEA in every book, you want real hostility in your enemies-to-lovers, you’re after spice, and shifter worlds aren’t your thing.
In short: a tender, clever opening act that only feels complete once you add the second book.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (November 2026)
Jae has a loyal readership, and that’s what’s carrying this book: nearly 500 Goodreads ratings and a Goodreads distribution with only a single 1-star and six 2-stars. I couldn’t get into Reddit to check the sapphic subs, but there’s outside coverage. The Paranormal Romance Guild reviewed it for Queer Romance Ink, and there are reader reviews on the publisher’s own site. The audiobook is the other route in: Abby Craden narrates for Tantor Media, it runs 9 hours and 15 minutes, and it came out on 20 January 2026. Audible reviewers praise her work on the series. I couldn’t confirm a Libro.fm listing, so the Libro.fm button below goes to a search.
Why readers love it (according to the discourse): The slow burn, which comes up in review after review, often with an affectionate nod to Jae’s style. Then the pack and the found-family warmth. Then the fake relationship itself, with readers praising how believable the emotional arc feels. A long StoryGraph review says the tension between Tala and Faith crackles from the first page, and readers who know the series enjoy seeing Tala again after her appearance in True Nature.
What readers argue about and complain about: The ending, above everything. Readers keep saying it ends with a cliffhanger or feels unfinished, and several reviews written before the sequel’s release are about the wait. The second, quieter point is the enemies label: one reader says the hostility is closer to mild disagreement. A few readers also note how slow it is, but most of them mean it as praise.
The series question everyone should ask first: This is part one of Tala and Faith’s story, and the romance concludes in Shifting Nature, which is already out and rates even higher, at around 4.6 on Goodreads. A reader on the publisher’s site says she read the two back to back and was glad she could. That’s my advice too: if cliffhangers bother you, start only when you have both. You don’t need to have read the earlier Shape-Shifter books, though True Nature is where Tala first appears.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Enemies by Nature end on a cliffhanger?
Yes, more or less. Readers describe a bit of a cliffhanger, and the romance isn’t resolved until the second book, Shifting Nature.
Do I need to read the other Shape-Shifter books first?
No. The publisher says the two-book story can be read on its own, though Tala first appears in True Nature.
How spicy is Enemies by Nature?
Low, about 1.5/5. It’s a slow burn, and readers say the heat picks up in Shifting Nature.
Is there an Enemies by Nature audiobook?
Yes. Abby Craden narrates the Tantor Media audiobook, which runs 9 hours and 15 minutes and came out in January 2026.
Is Enemies by Nature an only one bed book?
Yes. Jae lists only one bed among its tropes, and the pack visit forces the fake couple to share a bed.
If You Loved Enemies by Nature, Read These Next
The obvious next read is Shifting Nature, which finishes the story. After that, go back to where the world began with Second Nature, the first Shape-Shifter book. If you want Jae without the fur, Damage Control is a contemporary with more heat. For more shared beds, see our lesbian only one bed books, browse more paranormal and fantasy lesbian romance, or look through all our book reviews.
The Bottom Line
Enemies by Nature sets out to make a fake relationship carry real political weight, and it does. The slow burn is patient, the pack is a joy and the human and shifter conflict gives the romance stakes. The catch is that this is half a story, the enemies are gentler than the title promises, and there’s very little heat. If you like slow, warm romance and you’re happy to buy two books, this is an easy recommendation. Check Enemies by Nature on Amazon
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, Enemies by Nature ranks as a top-tier slow-burn paranormal fake relationship. It’s carried by Tala’s pack and its patient emotional arc, held back by an unfinished ending, and best read back to back with Shifting Nature rather than on its own.
The Evidence Scorecard
Overall ★★★★☆ 4.2/5
- ✓ 4.53 average across 472 Goodreads ratings
- ✓ StoryGraph close behind at 4.33
- ✓ Only one 1-star rating on Goodreads
- ✓ Romance unresolved until book two
Romance ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Fake dating called done right
- ✓ Chemistry creeps up, then lands
- ✓ Faith spying keeps the tension honest
- ✓ Enemies closer to mild disagreement
Characters ★★★★★ 4.5/5
- ✓ 100% of StoryGraph voters cite strong growth
- ✓ 94% call the characters lovable
- ✓ Tala pack a reader favourite
- ✓ Both leads get their own point of view
Writing ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- ✓ Meticulously crafted, says one reader
- ✓ Emotional moods lead on StoryGraph
- ✓ Political themes handled with weight
- ✓ Slow pacing will test some readers
Emotional Impact ★★★★☆ 4.1/5
- ✓ Prejudice theme lands for readers
- ✓ Quiet pack scenes are the highlights
- ✓ Faith torn between father and Wrasa
- ✓ Biggest payoffs held for book two
Heat Level ★★☆☆☆ 1.5/5
- ✓ Very slow burn
- ✓ Heat rises in Shifting Nature
- ✓ No romance.io rating found
- ✓ Lab-made mate scent is a plot point
Ending ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ Ends with a bit of a cliffhanger
- ✓ Called unfinished by one reader
- ✓ Shifting Nature already out
- ✓ Sequel rates even higher, around 4.6
Re-read Value ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Abby Craden audiobook, 9h 15m
- ✓ Pack scenes reward a return
- ✓ Best reread as a two-book set
- ✓ Length and pace ask for patience
Find it on AmazonListen on Libro.fmListen with AudibleBuy at Bookshop.org
The store links on this page are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
